What do you think?
Rate this book
'Here Are Your Gods!': Faithful Discipleship in Idolatrous Times
How should Christians be faithful disciples in the political turbulence of Trump and Brexit?
Christopher J H Wright unpacks the Biblical theme of idolatry and connects it to discipleship in today’s world. As Christians, we desperately need to name and expose the false gods and idols that we are tempted to bow down to – ‘Here are your gods!’
The Bible challenges the idols of political power and nationalism. The Biblical story is filled with hope that the kingdom of God will ultimately triumph over all human empires. How then should we live as followers of Jesus, the Messiah, Saviour, Lord and King?
Part One is adapted from chapter 5 of Wright’s The Mission of God, ‘The Living God Confronts Idolatry’. Parts Two and Three bring the Bible to bear on contemporary politics in the UK and USA, and for all Christians seeking to make sense of the changing world we live in.
Christopher J H Wright unpacks the Biblical theme of idolatry and connects it to discipleship in today’s world. As Christians, we desperately need to name and expose the false gods and idols that we are tempted to bow down to – ‘Here are your gods!’
The Bible challenges the idols of political power and nationalism. The Biblical story is filled with hope that the kingdom of God will ultimately triumph over all human empires. How then should we live as followers of Jesus, the Messiah, Saviour, Lord and King?
Part One is adapted from chapter 5 of Wright’s The Mission of God, ‘The Living God Confronts Idolatry’. Parts Two and Three bring the Bible to bear on contemporary politics in the UK and USA, and for all Christians seeking to make sense of the changing world we live in.
176 pages, Paperback
Published September 29, 2020
42 people are currently reading
626 people want to read
About the author
Christopher J.H. Wright
102 books207 followersChristopher J.H. Wright, (born 1947) is a Anglican clergyman and an Old Testament scholar. He is currently the director of Langham Partnership International. He was the principal of All Nations Christian College. He is an honorary member of the All Souls Church, Langham Place in London, UK.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 70 reviews
November 21, 2020
I have a love-hate relationship with some books. I find them feeding my understanding, bringing me to reflect, and arousing my prayers. But I argue and dispute with them most of the way through, sometimes shoving them aside for a time so I can cool off. This was one of those books. Christopher J. H. Wright, international ministries director of the Langham Partnership, Old Testament scholar, prolific author, and lecturer, has pulled together an in-depth examination on idolatry in his newly published, 176-page softback “Here Are Your Gods: Faithful Discipleship in Idolatrous Times”. Part of it will sound familiar to those who have read his chapter on idolatry in “The Mission of God”. But Wright takes that material, fleshes it out more fully and goes into places that get painfully close to home – thus my love-hate relationship with it. The volume is scholarly, but also approachable for all studiers of the Scriptures.
In the first part, Wright addresses what idolatry really is. He begins by unpacking, and then refuting, those academics who see the history of Israel as an evolving, developing growth from polytheism, to henotheism, to monotheism. Instead, he promotes that Israel’s monotheism was from ground-zero, and that Yahweh was not seen as in some generic glass of “god” but is The God. He further tackles the question about the reality or unreality of other gods. He concludes that they “are nothing in relation to Yahweh; they are something in relation to their worshippers” (7). The author develops what this means, by showing how most idols and gods were deified parts of creation, or sacralized works of human hands, or the divinized State, and on occasion, demonic powers. More often than not, we are the makers of our own gods, and history “is the graveyard of the gods” (31). Therefore, idolatry is the dethronement of Yahweh, and the enthronement of creation. Ofttimes, we regularly apotheosize the things that entice us, things we fear, things we trust and need (35-42). Thus, idolatry is radical self-harm (43). These first four chapters were very insightful, and his analysis deeply useful in challenging our own hearts. “It is God’s people who need the most warning against the dangers of idolatry and to be made aware of what they have been delivered from and should not go back to” (62).
I imagine that the second and third parts are where many will find the author going from preaching to meddling, and others will decry it as not going far enough. Wright takes on political idolatry, first by showing how God is not trapped within historical development, nor can God be identified with it (76). But rather, Yahweh orchestrates the rise and fall of nations, using other nations at critical moments. According to the author, the signs that a nation is approaching this critical moment of God’s judgment are when there is a legacy of historic and systemic violence, increasing poverty and inequality, dangerous forms of populism and nationalism, sexual confusion, family breakdown, ecological devastation, and war on truth (79-87). But what God desires for nations is modesty, integrity, and justice, from the leadership especially, but also in the led. Therefore, as he asserts, Yahweh will expose national idolatry, specifically the worship of prosperity, national pride, and self-exaltation. Then Wright announces, one major way God brings judgment on an idolatrous nation: “You get the government that mirrors the gods you worship” (108). In the final section of the book, the author lays out what Christians can and should do in an idolatrous environment. This section was the least satisfying to me.
I found “Here Are Your Gods” a richly beneficial read at so many levels. Wright’s exploration into idolatry, what it is, and the way it works into societies and social networks was enlightening. Even the portions I hated reading caused me to engage – even if argumentatively – the material and spend time questioning. Questioning not only the author, but my own heart, and our present geopolitical and national condition. I am haunted by his statement that “you get the government that mirrors the gods you worship.” Good God have mercy on us!
“Here Are Your Gods” should be in the hands of every pastor and Christian leader. It should be taken up, read, argued with, and prayed through by every Christian who dares to peruse its pages. It will challenge you, disappoint social activists and revolutionaries, anger nationalists, repulse the self-satisfied, but it will not leave you unchanged. I recommend the book.
My thanks to IVP Academic. I requested a copy of the book used in this review, and they sent it gladly, making no stipulations on me. Therefore, this evaluation was made freely, without any duress or hostage-taking.
In the first part, Wright addresses what idolatry really is. He begins by unpacking, and then refuting, those academics who see the history of Israel as an evolving, developing growth from polytheism, to henotheism, to monotheism. Instead, he promotes that Israel’s monotheism was from ground-zero, and that Yahweh was not seen as in some generic glass of “god” but is The God. He further tackles the question about the reality or unreality of other gods. He concludes that they “are nothing in relation to Yahweh; they are something in relation to their worshippers” (7). The author develops what this means, by showing how most idols and gods were deified parts of creation, or sacralized works of human hands, or the divinized State, and on occasion, demonic powers. More often than not, we are the makers of our own gods, and history “is the graveyard of the gods” (31). Therefore, idolatry is the dethronement of Yahweh, and the enthronement of creation. Ofttimes, we regularly apotheosize the things that entice us, things we fear, things we trust and need (35-42). Thus, idolatry is radical self-harm (43). These first four chapters were very insightful, and his analysis deeply useful in challenging our own hearts. “It is God’s people who need the most warning against the dangers of idolatry and to be made aware of what they have been delivered from and should not go back to” (62).
I imagine that the second and third parts are where many will find the author going from preaching to meddling, and others will decry it as not going far enough. Wright takes on political idolatry, first by showing how God is not trapped within historical development, nor can God be identified with it (76). But rather, Yahweh orchestrates the rise and fall of nations, using other nations at critical moments. According to the author, the signs that a nation is approaching this critical moment of God’s judgment are when there is a legacy of historic and systemic violence, increasing poverty and inequality, dangerous forms of populism and nationalism, sexual confusion, family breakdown, ecological devastation, and war on truth (79-87). But what God desires for nations is modesty, integrity, and justice, from the leadership especially, but also in the led. Therefore, as he asserts, Yahweh will expose national idolatry, specifically the worship of prosperity, national pride, and self-exaltation. Then Wright announces, one major way God brings judgment on an idolatrous nation: “You get the government that mirrors the gods you worship” (108). In the final section of the book, the author lays out what Christians can and should do in an idolatrous environment. This section was the least satisfying to me.
I found “Here Are Your Gods” a richly beneficial read at so many levels. Wright’s exploration into idolatry, what it is, and the way it works into societies and social networks was enlightening. Even the portions I hated reading caused me to engage – even if argumentatively – the material and spend time questioning. Questioning not only the author, but my own heart, and our present geopolitical and national condition. I am haunted by his statement that “you get the government that mirrors the gods you worship.” Good God have mercy on us!
“Here Are Your Gods” should be in the hands of every pastor and Christian leader. It should be taken up, read, argued with, and prayed through by every Christian who dares to peruse its pages. It will challenge you, disappoint social activists and revolutionaries, anger nationalists, repulse the self-satisfied, but it will not leave you unchanged. I recommend the book.
My thanks to IVP Academic. I requested a copy of the book used in this review, and they sent it gladly, making no stipulations on me. Therefore, this evaluation was made freely, without any duress or hostage-taking.
June 7, 2023
Definitely a popular level book by Wright. First section of the book is 5 star worthy since he is well within his field of OT scholarship. Second section is 2 stars. He predicts the downfall of the west and the rise of China. Granted he says he is merely speculating and it was a transcript from a talk he gave, but still. Last section and especially the epilogue are fantastic 5 stars.
Best part about this book is his leanings toward Christian’s refraining from politics and calling our obsession with guns and flags “idolatry”.
If you want a quick understanding of Israel’s understanding of idolatry and what it means for us today ESPECIALLY as it relates to politics, this is your book.
Best part about this book is his leanings toward Christian’s refraining from politics and calling our obsession with guns and flags “idolatry”.
If you want a quick understanding of Israel’s understanding of idolatry and what it means for us today ESPECIALLY as it relates to politics, this is your book.
April 8, 2025
Such a timely book. Wright does a great job exploring how idols and gods have always been present in culture, including what they are (and aren't, which I really enjoyed, as he answered a lot of questions I’ve had). The second half of the book talks about the christian response to idolatry and the role christians play in either participating in it or rejecting it.
LOVED this book. I listened to it on audio, read by Derek Perkins, and it was fantastic.
LOVED this book. I listened to it on audio, read by Derek Perkins, and it was fantastic.
July 11, 2023
Amazing, thought-provoking book. Christopher J.H. Wright is a great OT author, but this one gets a bit more personal while covering the whole Bible and our contemporary world. Very interesting reading.
October 15, 2021
Profound and timely work. Must read.
May 24, 2021
There are a lot of things to like about Wright's discussion of modern day idolatry. When Wright sticks to a discussion of idolatry he excels; when he talks politics, he occasionally gets sidetracked. The concepts of fear as an idol, nations as idols, syncretistic Christianity, and idolatry as the cause of kingdom failures were all outstanding discussions.
In fairness to Wright, when he speaks politically, he points out the faults of all political parties. While he writes in general terms, pointing out general issues/evils in society (which cannot be generally denied), I doubt that I would agree with his solutions or specific definitions of the problems were he to get more precise. For example, Wright hints that Trump was the the greater of two evils in the 2016 election (a point which is rather arbitrary and debatable but does disclose his political leanings) and that the wealthiest .1% of the human population should distribute their wealth to alleviate the poverty of 50% of humanity. While it is true that the wealthy should look to alleviate poverty, I'm not sure that redistribution of wealth (a.k.a socialism - this seems to be what he hints at) is the answer. However, Wright does speak in general terms and therefor should be considered in general terms.
The most glaring issue is in chapter seven where Wright clarifies that he is not trying to advocate for Christians withdrawing from the political realm or from voting. I find it odd that he spends the entire book speaking about the evils and idolatry of government, how Western governments are doomed to fail like all governments throughout history, how Christians must be "in the world but not of the world", and how Christians must not compromise or engage in/support evil/idolatry, and yet then tells Christians to engage in politics and voting by choosing the "lesser of two evils." How can a Christian NOT compromise their faith while choosing the "lesser of two evils"? Can a Christian support idolatry and evil in a small way without being guilty of those sins? Is it okay to compromise with evil for the sake of the greater good (situational ethics)? Must we continue in sin that grace may abound? He tries to correct the issue by arguing that once a person chooses the lesser of two evils they must proceed to speak out against the evils of their choice. Why not speak out against the evils from the get go and never support them in any way? Why not be "salt and light" in a community without engaging in corrupt human politics? Why not simply be a member of the Kingdom of Heaven, trying to win souls to the Lord (and thus affecting significant societal change through the gospel) rather than attempting to reform a corrupt system? Why is it that neither Jesus nor the apostles engaged in "choosing the lesser evil" and trying to enact societal change through the legislative process?
Clearly I disagree with Wright's approach to and encouragement of political activism. Yet, I would stress again the helpful nature of his discussion on idolatry. All in all "Here are your Gods" is a bit of a mixed bag, but the overall discussion of idolatry makes the book worthwhile.
In fairness to Wright, when he speaks politically, he points out the faults of all political parties. While he writes in general terms, pointing out general issues/evils in society (which cannot be generally denied), I doubt that I would agree with his solutions or specific definitions of the problems were he to get more precise. For example, Wright hints that Trump was the the greater of two evils in the 2016 election (a point which is rather arbitrary and debatable but does disclose his political leanings) and that the wealthiest .1% of the human population should distribute their wealth to alleviate the poverty of 50% of humanity. While it is true that the wealthy should look to alleviate poverty, I'm not sure that redistribution of wealth (a.k.a socialism - this seems to be what he hints at) is the answer. However, Wright does speak in general terms and therefor should be considered in general terms.
The most glaring issue is in chapter seven where Wright clarifies that he is not trying to advocate for Christians withdrawing from the political realm or from voting. I find it odd that he spends the entire book speaking about the evils and idolatry of government, how Western governments are doomed to fail like all governments throughout history, how Christians must be "in the world but not of the world", and how Christians must not compromise or engage in/support evil/idolatry, and yet then tells Christians to engage in politics and voting by choosing the "lesser of two evils." How can a Christian NOT compromise their faith while choosing the "lesser of two evils"? Can a Christian support idolatry and evil in a small way without being guilty of those sins? Is it okay to compromise with evil for the sake of the greater good (situational ethics)? Must we continue in sin that grace may abound? He tries to correct the issue by arguing that once a person chooses the lesser of two evils they must proceed to speak out against the evils of their choice. Why not speak out against the evils from the get go and never support them in any way? Why not be "salt and light" in a community without engaging in corrupt human politics? Why not simply be a member of the Kingdom of Heaven, trying to win souls to the Lord (and thus affecting significant societal change through the gospel) rather than attempting to reform a corrupt system? Why is it that neither Jesus nor the apostles engaged in "choosing the lesser evil" and trying to enact societal change through the legislative process?
Clearly I disagree with Wright's approach to and encouragement of political activism. Yet, I would stress again the helpful nature of his discussion on idolatry. All in all "Here are your Gods" is a bit of a mixed bag, but the overall discussion of idolatry makes the book worthwhile.
November 14, 2020
This is timely book. It is perhaps the most incisive critique of Christianity's engagement with the larger culture that I've seen. It's noteworthy that Wright is British. He comes from a culture where evangelicals are not quite as uniformly married to the trappings of political power as here in the U.S. As an outsider (at least in the American context), he is a potent prophet in the midst of tenuous time for American evangelicalism - a moment where the moral integrity of the movement finds itself strained under the weight of its own hypocrisy.
Wright here offers a concise summary of biblical idolatry - equal parts learned and winsome. This first part of the book is easily worth the price of admission. However, when Wright moves on to apply his theology of idolatry to our present moment, it truly shines.
My only qualm is that I would be interested in hearing Wright further develop his thoughts on how societies fall under the weight of their own idolatry. While I am open to his, I feel like his explanation lends itself to a narrative that's a little too linear. Historically speaking, the fall of a nation is a complex event, never reducible to a single cause. And while I believe that Wright would agree with this assessment, he fails to give the appropriate nuance here. Of course, this is a minor issue with an otherwise exceptional work.
Wright here offers a concise summary of biblical idolatry - equal parts learned and winsome. This first part of the book is easily worth the price of admission. However, when Wright moves on to apply his theology of idolatry to our present moment, it truly shines.
My only qualm is that I would be interested in hearing Wright further develop his thoughts on how societies fall under the weight of their own idolatry. While I am open to his, I feel like his explanation lends itself to a narrative that's a little too linear. Historically speaking, the fall of a nation is a complex event, never reducible to a single cause. And while I believe that Wright would agree with this assessment, he fails to give the appropriate nuance here. Of course, this is a minor issue with an otherwise exceptional work.
October 26, 2020
Chris Wright's excellent analysis of the place of idols in the Bible and contemporary culture. His analysis of the of what constitutes idols as 4 categories (Things that entice you, things you need, things that you trust, things that you fear) was helpful.
Also his analysis of Paul's 4 fold teaching regarding idols, theological, evangelistic, pastoral and prophetic showed how different responses may be required depending on the situation was helpful.
His call on believers to examine their own idols is needed. Whether that the idol of country, the idol of politics. And the call to speak kingdom truth to power. His final analysis of praying for and against the authorities was fascinating and also the call to lament, love and hope needed.
I would have liked to have seen a deeper analysis on helping believers reflect on their own idols. But a great book on a neglected subject. And as the very last verse of the first letter of John reminds us. 'Dear children, keep yourself from idols."
Also his analysis of Paul's 4 fold teaching regarding idols, theological, evangelistic, pastoral and prophetic showed how different responses may be required depending on the situation was helpful.
His call on believers to examine their own idols is needed. Whether that the idol of country, the idol of politics. And the call to speak kingdom truth to power. His final analysis of praying for and against the authorities was fascinating and also the call to lament, love and hope needed.
I would have liked to have seen a deeper analysis on helping believers reflect on their own idols. But a great book on a neglected subject. And as the very last verse of the first letter of John reminds us. 'Dear children, keep yourself from idols."
November 5, 2023
This work by Wright is a courageous foray into the intersect of biblical spirituality, the mission of God and the believer’s life in the public square. The narrative is so well written that it exudes a near lyrical quality. That said, this is not a light-hearted writing. There is a brawny undertone to this book as it boldly confronts some pressing matters that need a response from today’s church.
Wright calls for a thoughtful approach to issues of nationalism (as opposed to kingdom-centric thinking), economic injustice and xenophobia. The book’s inspiration was a series of lectures he delivered in South Carolina. Taking the overarching concept of the mission of God from his opus, he was then asked to apply this worldview to the political and social arenas.
There are select points where I diverge from some of his passionate arguments, yet I am grateful for such an erudite and empathetic perspective on how to live in the public square as a disciple. It has impacted my thinking in many ways.
Wright calls for a thoughtful approach to issues of nationalism (as opposed to kingdom-centric thinking), economic injustice and xenophobia. The book’s inspiration was a series of lectures he delivered in South Carolina. Taking the overarching concept of the mission of God from his opus, he was then asked to apply this worldview to the political and social arenas.
There are select points where I diverge from some of his passionate arguments, yet I am grateful for such an erudite and empathetic perspective on how to live in the public square as a disciple. It has impacted my thinking in many ways.
September 12, 2022
Very challenging (sometimes uncomfortable) perspective on modern idolatry from a non-American standpoint.
I learned a lot in the first part about WHY Israel in the Old Testament was attracted to idolatry. That had never made sense to me before. The author gives rich insight to ancient customs and traditions, and the reasoning behind the lure of idolatry. Great comparisons to today. Not your typical, “back then they liked to worship golden calves, today we like to worship success, money, things, etc.” although that was addressed.
I didn’t necessarily agree with the author on every detail, but he definitely gave the reader much to consider.
I learned a lot in the first part about WHY Israel in the Old Testament was attracted to idolatry. That had never made sense to me before. The author gives rich insight to ancient customs and traditions, and the reasoning behind the lure of idolatry. Great comparisons to today. Not your typical, “back then they liked to worship golden calves, today we like to worship success, money, things, etc.” although that was addressed.
I didn’t necessarily agree with the author on every detail, but he definitely gave the reader much to consider.
March 22, 2024
This book is covering topics that are sorely needed today - modern idolatries, political turbulence, and how to be faithful disciples in the midst of both. I would highly recommend this book!
December 26, 2020
If you have to read one book in 2021. Make it this one- it will bear fruit in our practical lives- which affect our voting habits, our honest appraisal of our self-interests, and our honest peer into the lives we are living (practically. Not idealized) as Christians in the west (America and UK)
August 4, 2020
Stunning.
March 30, 2021
Idols/gods: the one who makes it, trusts in his own creation.
If the gods of a nation are in fact the human construct of that nation’s pride, the glory of a god is identical to the glory of its nation. To glorify a nations god usually meant praising a nation’s military might. To praise Yahweh is significant (Psalm 115:1). To give glory to Yahweh is to give praise for distinct character and not just about self-congratulation. It can be confusing and seductive among modern nations who sloganize a pious sounding “God bless America” in blatant political speeches. We often create ourselves as gods as self-made people, in the pride of our hearts.
In Eden after taking the fruit, Humans have not become gods, but chosen to act as though they were: defining for themselves what is good and evil. Therein lies the root of all forms of idolatry, we deify our own capacities and make gods of ourselves, our choices and all their implications. God then shrinks in horror from immortality in such a fallen state, and refuses access to the tree of life. Idolatry dethrones god and enthrones creation.
Psalm 96:5-6; the gods worshipped by the nations are personifications of all that impresses us, splendor, majesty, strength, glory, we look for such magnificence and power, and worship these things wherever they inspire awe, in stadiums of great triumph or lives of pampered heroes, in battalions of soldiers, or on the stage of rock concerts, or tv/movie celebrity, on the pinnacles of corporate towers of greed.
Fear the Lord you saints, and you will have nothing else to fear. (Psalm 34)
Divine jealousy is an essential function of divine love. It’s precisely because he wills our good that he hates the harm that idolatry generates. God’s conflict with the gods is for our own good and His glory. It’s not that idolatry steals God’s glory, but that it thwarts God’s love.
We will not win the battle for God. The emphasis of the Bible is that we wait for god to defeat his enemies, and we’ll celebrate God’s victory. God fights for us, not we for him.
Our societies in the west have enriched themselves through institutionalized and politically sanctioned of 3 of the 10 commandments, the ones forbidden murder, theft, and coveting. There are centuries of blood on our hands.
in recent years, we seem to be living in a war on truth. The ease with which lies are told by those in power or seeking power, then shrugged off when the falsehood is exposed with almost no accountability or consequences is genuinely frightening of its implications for the survival of civic political stability and trust in government.
Seeking to make a great name for themselves is idolatry, the original sin of Babel. One form of political idolatry is the obsession os political security and hero worship of military, amounts spent on military defense, boastful display of military hardware, it’s the willingness of Christian churches to sanctify national pride and military virulence of the state that I find syncrentistic. To display flags and military emblems alongside the communion table. I do not reject legitimate patriotism within biblical limits, but what message is conveyed by imperial symbols of war alongside the sacrifice of the prince of peace? What are we to make of this conflation? It’s ironic at least in the constitutional separation of church and state. It seems hard to imagine Paul and disciples worshipping around the roman eagle and regimental symbols.
We are people shaped by the word of God, sharing in the mission of God, living in the kingdom of God.
Many Christians try to fit the Bible into their world, their life. Our life is not the center of reality. We apply our lives to the scriptures, not the other way around. We should ask, How can I apply my life to the story of the Bible, to participate in what God is doing?
I’m not questioning Christian involvement in politics, but the seeking of supremacy in such arenas to advance the kingdom by political means, especially with sacrificing integrity, “getting our man in the white house”. He holds prayer meetings int he oval office, what if Jeroboam did too? What matter is not prayers but practice.
We should do some thinking about the Bible’s ethical priorities, rather than assuming that the moral issues we are passionate about are identical to what the bible or Jesus prioritize. it’s too easy for our moral hotspots to hide moral blindspots.
John Stott, If meat goes rotten when left out, there’s no point in blaming the meat, that’s what happen in natural state, bacterial putrefaction sets in, the question to ask is, where was the salt? if a room goes dark in the evening, don’t blame the room. The question is, Where is the lamp?
In “Our Father in heaven” we acknowledge a higher throne, the ruler of the kings of the earth. Prayer is a political act.
I see no contradiction is praying for and against our leaders. They are sinners in need of God’s love and mercy, we pray that God will give them wisdom and success in politics that are for the good of society. I pray against them when they pursue what is out of line with what God’s standards and human wellbeing, when they’re actions are driven by party advantage, ruthless ambition, than by truth, justice, common good. When wickedness thrives, the poor/marginalized sink into destitution, shouldn’t we protest to God that such things are scandalous, destructive, evil?
If the gods of a nation are in fact the human construct of that nation’s pride, the glory of a god is identical to the glory of its nation. To glorify a nations god usually meant praising a nation’s military might. To praise Yahweh is significant (Psalm 115:1). To give glory to Yahweh is to give praise for distinct character and not just about self-congratulation. It can be confusing and seductive among modern nations who sloganize a pious sounding “God bless America” in blatant political speeches. We often create ourselves as gods as self-made people, in the pride of our hearts.
In Eden after taking the fruit, Humans have not become gods, but chosen to act as though they were: defining for themselves what is good and evil. Therein lies the root of all forms of idolatry, we deify our own capacities and make gods of ourselves, our choices and all their implications. God then shrinks in horror from immortality in such a fallen state, and refuses access to the tree of life. Idolatry dethrones god and enthrones creation.
Psalm 96:5-6; the gods worshipped by the nations are personifications of all that impresses us, splendor, majesty, strength, glory, we look for such magnificence and power, and worship these things wherever they inspire awe, in stadiums of great triumph or lives of pampered heroes, in battalions of soldiers, or on the stage of rock concerts, or tv/movie celebrity, on the pinnacles of corporate towers of greed.
Fear the Lord you saints, and you will have nothing else to fear. (Psalm 34)
Divine jealousy is an essential function of divine love. It’s precisely because he wills our good that he hates the harm that idolatry generates. God’s conflict with the gods is for our own good and His glory. It’s not that idolatry steals God’s glory, but that it thwarts God’s love.
We will not win the battle for God. The emphasis of the Bible is that we wait for god to defeat his enemies, and we’ll celebrate God’s victory. God fights for us, not we for him.
Our societies in the west have enriched themselves through institutionalized and politically sanctioned of 3 of the 10 commandments, the ones forbidden murder, theft, and coveting. There are centuries of blood on our hands.
in recent years, we seem to be living in a war on truth. The ease with which lies are told by those in power or seeking power, then shrugged off when the falsehood is exposed with almost no accountability or consequences is genuinely frightening of its implications for the survival of civic political stability and trust in government.
Seeking to make a great name for themselves is idolatry, the original sin of Babel. One form of political idolatry is the obsession os political security and hero worship of military, amounts spent on military defense, boastful display of military hardware, it’s the willingness of Christian churches to sanctify national pride and military virulence of the state that I find syncrentistic. To display flags and military emblems alongside the communion table. I do not reject legitimate patriotism within biblical limits, but what message is conveyed by imperial symbols of war alongside the sacrifice of the prince of peace? What are we to make of this conflation? It’s ironic at least in the constitutional separation of church and state. It seems hard to imagine Paul and disciples worshipping around the roman eagle and regimental symbols.
We are people shaped by the word of God, sharing in the mission of God, living in the kingdom of God.
Many Christians try to fit the Bible into their world, their life. Our life is not the center of reality. We apply our lives to the scriptures, not the other way around. We should ask, How can I apply my life to the story of the Bible, to participate in what God is doing?
I’m not questioning Christian involvement in politics, but the seeking of supremacy in such arenas to advance the kingdom by political means, especially with sacrificing integrity, “getting our man in the white house”. He holds prayer meetings int he oval office, what if Jeroboam did too? What matter is not prayers but practice.
We should do some thinking about the Bible’s ethical priorities, rather than assuming that the moral issues we are passionate about are identical to what the bible or Jesus prioritize. it’s too easy for our moral hotspots to hide moral blindspots.
John Stott, If meat goes rotten when left out, there’s no point in blaming the meat, that’s what happen in natural state, bacterial putrefaction sets in, the question to ask is, where was the salt? if a room goes dark in the evening, don’t blame the room. The question is, Where is the lamp?
In “Our Father in heaven” we acknowledge a higher throne, the ruler of the kings of the earth. Prayer is a political act.
I see no contradiction is praying for and against our leaders. They are sinners in need of God’s love and mercy, we pray that God will give them wisdom and success in politics that are for the good of society. I pray against them when they pursue what is out of line with what God’s standards and human wellbeing, when they’re actions are driven by party advantage, ruthless ambition, than by truth, justice, common good. When wickedness thrives, the poor/marginalized sink into destitution, shouldn’t we protest to God that such things are scandalous, destructive, evil?
October 17, 2020
"One of the horrendous blasphemies of the modern West has been the ease of using the name of God in association with national aggrandization." So writes Christopher Wright in his illuminating and uncomfortable book "Here Are Your Gods." Anytime someone begins to name idols, be they personal or cultural, if you don't get a little uncomfortable, you're probably blind to your own idols because we all have them, not the least of which is "using the name of God in association with national aggrandization."
Mr. Wright was born in Belfast, Northern Ireland, and attends All Souls Church, Langham Place (I've had the privilege of attending services there, great church), but is very well acquainted with the culture of the United States and indeed brings an outsiders perspective which is all too often lacking—or ignored—by those who swim in the cultural waters of the States but seem blind to their danger. Here is a good example of Mr. Wright's frank observation as an outsider: "To outside observers like me, the gun is surely in the Olympian superleague of American gods. It reigns over all its opponents and defeats every attempt to restrict its sovereignty. The gun-god exacts the most horrific sacrifices of human lifeblood—child sacrifice no less—and shrugs off every wave of revulsion that follows such events."
Ouch! Rarely are you going to hear an American theologian write in such terms, more less a pastor preach in such a way, but surely the outsiders have a better perception of our idols and gods, than we do, especially when it comes to guns. I've heard all the arguments (I used to live in gun country), but it takes a particular blindness not to see the frightening damage that guns have done again and again in our country, and the American solution is to buy more and more guns! It's a form of insanity. I've been to Japan and you can walk the streets there past midnight and feel perfectly safe. Try doing that in your average American city. This is the legacy of the gun-gods that we Americans worship. Surely Mr. Wright is more perceptive than we are here.
Here is another example: "The worship of Baal is alive and well in Western culture—with our idolizing of sex and money. As the Canaanites (and Israel after them) worshiped fertility in its broadest sense, so we worship its modern equivalents. We must have an abundance of everything. Consumerism as an ideology feeds the economy, which in turn depends on creating insatiable consumer demand and unpayable consumer debt."
Again, ouch! Who among us can claim that they've never fallen prey to consumerism? Never bought something they really didn't need, just happened to want a lot.
As perhaps has become obvious, Mr. Wright is not afraid to name names, or call out gods and idols and hold them up in front of us, which is what makes the book disturbing, no one likes to have their idols pointed out, yet point Mr. Wright does. However, his purpose is not to throw stones, but to call us to become faithful disciples of Jesus Christ in a time when idols and false gods hold more and more sway over even faithful Christians. This will require laying down our gods and purposing to follow only the true God. Mr. Wright calls us to do this.
Mr. Wright is also harsh on the syncretism that somehow wraps God up in the national flag as if the two were the same thing: "Those who defend this god seem characteristically to be devoted worshipers of the god of national greatness also, symbolized by the flag. Frequently both (guns and patriotism, along with the Second Amendment) are harnessed to the name of God, in a form of syncretism that I find virtually blasphemous." Anyone who has been paying attention to the political landscape in America will have noticed the easy syncretism that allows Christians to act as if the 2nd Amendment—the right to keep and bear arms—were a sort of God-given, inalienable right. It is not.
There is much more to the book and Mr. Wright is actually much more positive than I've made him out to be. Yes, he calls out our idols and gods, but he also calls us to faithfulness to God alone, and lays out the biblical framework for discipleship in an age in which idols seem to reign supreme. It is possible and worth pursuing, and Mr. Wright gives us a solid foundation to do so.
Nevertheless, he does write like an Old Testament prophet and I will leave the final word to him: "Indeed, I believe that one reason for the slow but accelerating collapse of Western civilization is the profoundly syncretistic and idolatrous nature of Western Christianity, combined with the idolatry of the culture that surrounds us. We, God’s people, like Israel of old, are in uncritical collusion with the false gods of our ambient cultures."
Mr. Wright was born in Belfast, Northern Ireland, and attends All Souls Church, Langham Place (I've had the privilege of attending services there, great church), but is very well acquainted with the culture of the United States and indeed brings an outsiders perspective which is all too often lacking—or ignored—by those who swim in the cultural waters of the States but seem blind to their danger. Here is a good example of Mr. Wright's frank observation as an outsider: "To outside observers like me, the gun is surely in the Olympian superleague of American gods. It reigns over all its opponents and defeats every attempt to restrict its sovereignty. The gun-god exacts the most horrific sacrifices of human lifeblood—child sacrifice no less—and shrugs off every wave of revulsion that follows such events."
Ouch! Rarely are you going to hear an American theologian write in such terms, more less a pastor preach in such a way, but surely the outsiders have a better perception of our idols and gods, than we do, especially when it comes to guns. I've heard all the arguments (I used to live in gun country), but it takes a particular blindness not to see the frightening damage that guns have done again and again in our country, and the American solution is to buy more and more guns! It's a form of insanity. I've been to Japan and you can walk the streets there past midnight and feel perfectly safe. Try doing that in your average American city. This is the legacy of the gun-gods that we Americans worship. Surely Mr. Wright is more perceptive than we are here.
Here is another example: "The worship of Baal is alive and well in Western culture—with our idolizing of sex and money. As the Canaanites (and Israel after them) worshiped fertility in its broadest sense, so we worship its modern equivalents. We must have an abundance of everything. Consumerism as an ideology feeds the economy, which in turn depends on creating insatiable consumer demand and unpayable consumer debt."
Again, ouch! Who among us can claim that they've never fallen prey to consumerism? Never bought something they really didn't need, just happened to want a lot.
As perhaps has become obvious, Mr. Wright is not afraid to name names, or call out gods and idols and hold them up in front of us, which is what makes the book disturbing, no one likes to have their idols pointed out, yet point Mr. Wright does. However, his purpose is not to throw stones, but to call us to become faithful disciples of Jesus Christ in a time when idols and false gods hold more and more sway over even faithful Christians. This will require laying down our gods and purposing to follow only the true God. Mr. Wright calls us to do this.
Mr. Wright is also harsh on the syncretism that somehow wraps God up in the national flag as if the two were the same thing: "Those who defend this god seem characteristically to be devoted worshipers of the god of national greatness also, symbolized by the flag. Frequently both (guns and patriotism, along with the Second Amendment) are harnessed to the name of God, in a form of syncretism that I find virtually blasphemous." Anyone who has been paying attention to the political landscape in America will have noticed the easy syncretism that allows Christians to act as if the 2nd Amendment—the right to keep and bear arms—were a sort of God-given, inalienable right. It is not.
There is much more to the book and Mr. Wright is actually much more positive than I've made him out to be. Yes, he calls out our idols and gods, but he also calls us to faithfulness to God alone, and lays out the biblical framework for discipleship in an age in which idols seem to reign supreme. It is possible and worth pursuing, and Mr. Wright gives us a solid foundation to do so.
Nevertheless, he does write like an Old Testament prophet and I will leave the final word to him: "Indeed, I believe that one reason for the slow but accelerating collapse of Western civilization is the profoundly syncretistic and idolatrous nature of Western Christianity, combined with the idolatry of the culture that surrounds us. We, God’s people, like Israel of old, are in uncritical collusion with the false gods of our ambient cultures."
January 15, 2024
Like "The Kingdom, The Power and The Glory" which I also read recently, Christopher Wright's "Here Are Your Gods" aims squarely at the enmeshment of the American and British churches with politics--usually right-wing politics--in both countries. Wright is a Brit, though clearly knowledgeable of the American church and politics.
The strength of the book is its clarion identification of politics (as pursued today in much of the church) as an idol. That some, many, have chased an objective of advancing the kingdom of Christ through political means, they have fallen prey to idolatry and Wright does well to point this out. He begins his book with a long discussion of Biblical "gods", what they are, how to discern them, and how they interfere with the mission of God on earth. Wright builds a necessary and good foundation for his argument, but as a discussion of idols in Scripture, it is very useful on its own, even without reference to political idols.
From that beginning, Wright advances his work with a discussion of political idolatry both in the past and now, then ends with two chapters on his view of how we should live as kingdom people in a politically turbulent world.
Wright's argument is commendable and serious Christians ought to wrestle with it. His expression of what the Bible requires of kings in a political context was interesting and the book might have been strengthened by the author spending more space on exploring that subject.
In my own wrestling with his work, I saw two weaknesses that detracted from the soundness of his views:
First, in laying out the idols to which the modern west have fallen, he loses the careful connection of that idolatry to the church. In the end of the chapter entitled "A People Shaped by the Living God," one could conclude he is criticizing national America and Britain for following after the idolatry of national Israel. The solution to that problem would, of course, be to "reclaim the nation for God," the very kind of idolatry he criticizes earlier in the book. A clearer connection to how the church is succumbing to those idols and how the church should respond would have made his argument more sound.
Second, Wright has a particular political bent which is not difficult to glean from his writing. That bent shows up in his book in places that, again, undermine his argument. He is harshly critical of Brexit. I must admit to only mild and passing understanding of the arguments for and against Brexit, but it never occurred to me that wanting more national and local control of ones affairs would be idolatrous while desiring to be ruled by a multi-national bureaucracy like the EU would not be. It seems to me that's a normal political question upon which solid Christians could come down on either side without jeopardizing their relationship with God. Also, in the first paragraph of his epilogue, Wright says, "The days immediately following the general election in the United Kingdom in December 2019 found me depressed and angry...My anger was directed not only at the blatant corruption and industrial-scale mendacity of our politics but also at our God...And it seems there will be no respite in such policies of years to come, with the same government now with an increased parliamentary majority. How does God tolerate it?" Does Wright believe those elected in 2019 were not appointed to those positions by God? Is he reluctant to trust God for justice and righteousness despite who is leading his government? The temptation to idolatry exists on both sides of the aisle and Wright's epilogue somewhat undermined the rest of the book.
Still, it's an important book and well worth the time.
The strength of the book is its clarion identification of politics (as pursued today in much of the church) as an idol. That some, many, have chased an objective of advancing the kingdom of Christ through political means, they have fallen prey to idolatry and Wright does well to point this out. He begins his book with a long discussion of Biblical "gods", what they are, how to discern them, and how they interfere with the mission of God on earth. Wright builds a necessary and good foundation for his argument, but as a discussion of idols in Scripture, it is very useful on its own, even without reference to political idols.
From that beginning, Wright advances his work with a discussion of political idolatry both in the past and now, then ends with two chapters on his view of how we should live as kingdom people in a politically turbulent world.
Wright's argument is commendable and serious Christians ought to wrestle with it. His expression of what the Bible requires of kings in a political context was interesting and the book might have been strengthened by the author spending more space on exploring that subject.
In my own wrestling with his work, I saw two weaknesses that detracted from the soundness of his views:
First, in laying out the idols to which the modern west have fallen, he loses the careful connection of that idolatry to the church. In the end of the chapter entitled "A People Shaped by the Living God," one could conclude he is criticizing national America and Britain for following after the idolatry of national Israel. The solution to that problem would, of course, be to "reclaim the nation for God," the very kind of idolatry he criticizes earlier in the book. A clearer connection to how the church is succumbing to those idols and how the church should respond would have made his argument more sound.
Second, Wright has a particular political bent which is not difficult to glean from his writing. That bent shows up in his book in places that, again, undermine his argument. He is harshly critical of Brexit. I must admit to only mild and passing understanding of the arguments for and against Brexit, but it never occurred to me that wanting more national and local control of ones affairs would be idolatrous while desiring to be ruled by a multi-national bureaucracy like the EU would not be. It seems to me that's a normal political question upon which solid Christians could come down on either side without jeopardizing their relationship with God. Also, in the first paragraph of his epilogue, Wright says, "The days immediately following the general election in the United Kingdom in December 2019 found me depressed and angry...My anger was directed not only at the blatant corruption and industrial-scale mendacity of our politics but also at our God...And it seems there will be no respite in such policies of years to come, with the same government now with an increased parliamentary majority. How does God tolerate it?" Does Wright believe those elected in 2019 were not appointed to those positions by God? Is he reluctant to trust God for justice and righteousness despite who is leading his government? The temptation to idolatry exists on both sides of the aisle and Wright's epilogue somewhat undermined the rest of the book.
Still, it's an important book and well worth the time.
July 20, 2021
I heard a quote from Bridgetown Pastor Tyler Staton about 6 months back who said “in order to minister to Brooklyn I need to rid myself of the idols of Brooklyn” and it has rattled in my head ever since. This book colored in the image that quote created in my head.
In this book, Christopher Wright spends the first half outlining what idols and false gods were in the Old Testament and how they affected the Israelite people. He argues that turning to the idols of their culture led to the Israelite downfall. When the Israelites would turn from Yahweh and practice idolatry, their community suffered and sin flourished. Yahweh would then bring judgement to the Israelites, whether by just turning them over to their sin or through the conquering of their land.
He then spends the second half of the book arguing that this hasn’t changed and this is still the case for Christians today. For our Western world he outlined 3 “Idols” that we can worship. 1- the idol of prosperity, success, and money or “mammon.” “The worship of Baal is alive and well in Western culture- through the idolizing of sex and money(Wright).” He argues we see this most prominently in our consumerism and in our worship of celebrity. 2- the idol of nationalism. “Our particular form of this idolatry of national greatness takes is this obsession with military security (as we see in the reign of Solomon and subsequent kings) and the worship of the military itself(Wright).” He goes on to condemn both English and American churches for our syncretism between Christnianity and nationalism and note “it’s hard to imagine early Christians gathering around symbols of the Roman Empire(Wright).” 3- the idol of self-exaltation. We tell each other to “believe in yourself” and “follow your heart” where the ancient prophets were clear that would always lead to national ruin if we did that. This idol is clear path to pride and arrogance and directly leads to a lack of care for the oppressed.
Leviticus 19:4
Do not turn to idols or make for yourselves any gods of cast metal: I am the Lord your God.
1 Corinthians 10:14
Therefore, my beloved, flee from idolatry.
Scripture is so clear, flee from idolatry and false gods! But in the American church we see that as an ancient thing or something for countries “over there.” There’s a real conversation that needs to be had about “America’s false gods.” We (rightly I think) encourage those who convert from other religions to flee worship of those other gods, but do we do the same for ourselves when we leave the gods of the West/America?
If our culture’s idols and false gods are mammon, self-exaltation, and nationalism what are the rituals that surround that? Black Friday? Bachelor/bachelorette? Super Bowl? Presidential elections? And how is our engagement different because we worship Yahweh?
“Here Are Your Gods” is one of the most important books I’ve read in the last 2 years. It has convicted me tremendously and given me language to better minister to those around me.
In this book, Christopher Wright spends the first half outlining what idols and false gods were in the Old Testament and how they affected the Israelite people. He argues that turning to the idols of their culture led to the Israelite downfall. When the Israelites would turn from Yahweh and practice idolatry, their community suffered and sin flourished. Yahweh would then bring judgement to the Israelites, whether by just turning them over to their sin or through the conquering of their land.
He then spends the second half of the book arguing that this hasn’t changed and this is still the case for Christians today. For our Western world he outlined 3 “Idols” that we can worship. 1- the idol of prosperity, success, and money or “mammon.” “The worship of Baal is alive and well in Western culture- through the idolizing of sex and money(Wright).” He argues we see this most prominently in our consumerism and in our worship of celebrity. 2- the idol of nationalism. “Our particular form of this idolatry of national greatness takes is this obsession with military security (as we see in the reign of Solomon and subsequent kings) and the worship of the military itself(Wright).” He goes on to condemn both English and American churches for our syncretism between Christnianity and nationalism and note “it’s hard to imagine early Christians gathering around symbols of the Roman Empire(Wright).” 3- the idol of self-exaltation. We tell each other to “believe in yourself” and “follow your heart” where the ancient prophets were clear that would always lead to national ruin if we did that. This idol is clear path to pride and arrogance and directly leads to a lack of care for the oppressed.
Leviticus 19:4
Do not turn to idols or make for yourselves any gods of cast metal: I am the Lord your God.
1 Corinthians 10:14
Therefore, my beloved, flee from idolatry.
Scripture is so clear, flee from idolatry and false gods! But in the American church we see that as an ancient thing or something for countries “over there.” There’s a real conversation that needs to be had about “America’s false gods.” We (rightly I think) encourage those who convert from other religions to flee worship of those other gods, but do we do the same for ourselves when we leave the gods of the West/America?
If our culture’s idols and false gods are mammon, self-exaltation, and nationalism what are the rituals that surround that? Black Friday? Bachelor/bachelorette? Super Bowl? Presidential elections? And how is our engagement different because we worship Yahweh?
“Here Are Your Gods” is one of the most important books I’ve read in the last 2 years. It has convicted me tremendously and given me language to better minister to those around me.
November 10, 2020
Are idols still an immediate hindrance to discipleship today? Have politics become so important that they have become our idols? In “Here are Your Gods,” Christopher Wright helps us have faithful discipleship in idolatrous times.
Monotheism and Mission
In just over 150 pages, Wright walks us through a theology of idolatry. He examines the “gods” of the Bible, and explains how monotheism and mission is a massive Biblical teaching. He categorizes idols and gods as objects within the visible creation, demons, and the product of human hands.
Without hesitation, he shows how modern idols may be things that entice us, things we fear, things we trust, and things we need. These false gods will fail us, and Christians are to join God in the missional battle against idolatry for the goal of the glory of God.
Political Idolatry
For the purpose of Wright’s book and giving the background of our modern context, this theology of idolatry prominently plays out in the realm of politics. I was most interested to see how God sets his story across generations, in the setting of the rise and fall of nations. I was moved to see the sovereignty of God and the primacy of his Kingdom.
In regards to politics, the idols of prosperity, national pride, and self-exaltation are specifically identified by Wright. And when the world gives in to these idols, God’s judgment looms overhead.
Salt and Light
So the Christian must be living by the story of God, by his mission, and submitting to his reign. It was especially helpful to me how Wright framed how we must think – we are not living in the world’s story, but we are living out God’s story that he has written in his Word.
In the closing pages, Wright reminds us to be salt and light. And with a book on idolatry, it is fitting that he would exhort us to the regular worship of God alone. Fixing our gaze on God will help us combat cynicism and confront a downcast soul. The truths of the Gospel ring true in 2020. And our God is a consuming fire.
I received a media copy of “Here Are Your Gods” and this is my honest review.
Monotheism and Mission
In just over 150 pages, Wright walks us through a theology of idolatry. He examines the “gods” of the Bible, and explains how monotheism and mission is a massive Biblical teaching. He categorizes idols and gods as objects within the visible creation, demons, and the product of human hands.
Without hesitation, he shows how modern idols may be things that entice us, things we fear, things we trust, and things we need. These false gods will fail us, and Christians are to join God in the missional battle against idolatry for the goal of the glory of God.
Political Idolatry
For the purpose of Wright’s book and giving the background of our modern context, this theology of idolatry prominently plays out in the realm of politics. I was most interested to see how God sets his story across generations, in the setting of the rise and fall of nations. I was moved to see the sovereignty of God and the primacy of his Kingdom.
In regards to politics, the idols of prosperity, national pride, and self-exaltation are specifically identified by Wright. And when the world gives in to these idols, God’s judgment looms overhead.
Salt and Light
So the Christian must be living by the story of God, by his mission, and submitting to his reign. It was especially helpful to me how Wright framed how we must think – we are not living in the world’s story, but we are living out God’s story that he has written in his Word.
In the closing pages, Wright reminds us to be salt and light. And with a book on idolatry, it is fitting that he would exhort us to the regular worship of God alone. Fixing our gaze on God will help us combat cynicism and confront a downcast soul. The truths of the Gospel ring true in 2020. And our God is a consuming fire.
I received a media copy of “Here Are Your Gods” and this is my honest review.
February 11, 2021
When you read the title of this book you might think that it is the typical book where idolatry is approached in a superficial way and somewhat distant from our reality, however, Prof. Wright does a splendid job in this work.
I want to briefly mention what you can find in this book and what benefit you can get from reading it.
This book is composed of eight chapters divided into three parts, the first part shows us what the Scripture says about God and the gods, how this is seen particularly in the Old Testament. I found very helpful the chapter in which the author develops the theme "What are the gods?", and that helps as a frame of reference for the development of the book. We could say that this part is the theological foundation of the writing.
The second part may be sensitive to some readers, however it is an important issue. Here, the author develops how idolatrous principles permeate politics. On how empires and their gods fall, because as Wright points out, gods do not fail to fail.
The last part helps us answer the question, how are Christians to live in a world prone to idolatry? Here the author shows us how Christians are part of a transcendental call in Christ Jesus and called to be light in the midst of the darkness of idolatry.
Everything I have said about this book has been in broad strokes, but I must tell you that it is a very useful read, both for its broad theological and biblical development, as well as for its practical contributions. You may not agree on the author's political tendency, however his contribution to a crucial issue is of great importance.
What makes this book different from others that talk about idolatry is its contemporaneity, it places the reader before reality and how those principles are applied.
Lastly, I must say that this is one of the best books I read in 2020.
I want to briefly mention what you can find in this book and what benefit you can get from reading it.
This book is composed of eight chapters divided into three parts, the first part shows us what the Scripture says about God and the gods, how this is seen particularly in the Old Testament. I found very helpful the chapter in which the author develops the theme "What are the gods?", and that helps as a frame of reference for the development of the book. We could say that this part is the theological foundation of the writing.
The second part may be sensitive to some readers, however it is an important issue. Here, the author develops how idolatrous principles permeate politics. On how empires and their gods fall, because as Wright points out, gods do not fail to fail.
The last part helps us answer the question, how are Christians to live in a world prone to idolatry? Here the author shows us how Christians are part of a transcendental call in Christ Jesus and called to be light in the midst of the darkness of idolatry.
Everything I have said about this book has been in broad strokes, but I must tell you that it is a very useful read, both for its broad theological and biblical development, as well as for its practical contributions. You may not agree on the author's political tendency, however his contribution to a crucial issue is of great importance.
What makes this book different from others that talk about idolatry is its contemporaneity, it places the reader before reality and how those principles are applied.
Lastly, I must say that this is one of the best books I read in 2020.
June 22, 2022
An excellent appraisal of modern idolatry (particularly political idolatry) elucidated through a well-balanced and well-informed theological worldview. Wright has a knack for sharing insight in a way that is eloquent, succinct, and contagiously impassioned. His expertise in the Hebrew Scriptures is most helpful, and it is obviously integral to the discussion at hand. I found his comparison of the rule of Jeroboam II to contemporary political/religious syncretism to be particularly astute.
While this book shrewdly diagnoses the problem of political idolatry that is utterly endemic to the West—and does so in a way that admirably upholds and appeals to biblical wisdom—it should not be mistaken for a detailed guide to Christian political engagement. The solutions Wright offers to these problems are not merely political or legislative, but rather theological; they are aimed at reversing the corrosive effects of idolatry by providing a way of life that informs not only our political engagement, but the whole of our existence. Obviously, this will have ramifications in the political arena, but Wright’s vision is much broader in scope.
In any case, this is a timely and much-needed book for the modern Church. Wright begins by helpfully delineating the nature of idolatry as it is presented in the Scriptures; and from there, he surveys both ancient and modern instances of political idolatry, and discusses appropriate responses for the people of God. Wright insists on orienting ourselves around God’s story, rather than orienting God around ours. By locating our present state of affairs within the story of God as outlined in Scripture, we can identify the trajectory of His story, and thus better discern His will for our present involvement in it.
Highly recommended.
While this book shrewdly diagnoses the problem of political idolatry that is utterly endemic to the West—and does so in a way that admirably upholds and appeals to biblical wisdom—it should not be mistaken for a detailed guide to Christian political engagement. The solutions Wright offers to these problems are not merely political or legislative, but rather theological; they are aimed at reversing the corrosive effects of idolatry by providing a way of life that informs not only our political engagement, but the whole of our existence. Obviously, this will have ramifications in the political arena, but Wright’s vision is much broader in scope.
In any case, this is a timely and much-needed book for the modern Church. Wright begins by helpfully delineating the nature of idolatry as it is presented in the Scriptures; and from there, he surveys both ancient and modern instances of political idolatry, and discusses appropriate responses for the people of God. Wright insists on orienting ourselves around God’s story, rather than orienting God around ours. By locating our present state of affairs within the story of God as outlined in Scripture, we can identify the trajectory of His story, and thus better discern His will for our present involvement in it.
Highly recommended.
October 31, 2021
This book could have easily been five stars! I totally agree with Chris’s explanation of idols in scripture (80% of the book), but where I disagree is with his heavy handed portrayal of conservative issues as being linked to idolatry and his neglect at ever mentioning the idols on the other side of the aisle. It’s as almost as if he is saying, “Stop following the idols of capitalism and nationalism and instead bow to liberal ideas of big government” without even realize he is saying it.
Don’t get me wrong…all of those can be dangerous idols. I think the image of Trump looms so large in Dr Wright’s mind that he can’t get past it and see the idolatry that the other side also includes.
Very telling us the epilogue of the book where he laments that the Conservative party won the 2019 election in the UK. He repeatedly laments for the poor who have been victimized and will continue in their plight because of the election. Are we to assume all of their problems would be over if the other party had won and thus aleve his lamenting? Is that not political idolatry at its finest? Maybe both capitalism and government make horrible gods?
I still love this author and his other works. Would probably still recommend this book as it still has a lot of good points to make!
Don’t get me wrong…all of those can be dangerous idols. I think the image of Trump looms so large in Dr Wright’s mind that he can’t get past it and see the idolatry that the other side also includes.
Very telling us the epilogue of the book where he laments that the Conservative party won the 2019 election in the UK. He repeatedly laments for the poor who have been victimized and will continue in their plight because of the election. Are we to assume all of their problems would be over if the other party had won and thus aleve his lamenting? Is that not political idolatry at its finest? Maybe both capitalism and government make horrible gods?
I still love this author and his other works. Would probably still recommend this book as it still has a lot of good points to make!
December 27, 2024
Finished reading Christopher Wright’s book, “’Here Are Your Gods’: Faithful Discipleship In Idolatrous Times.” I found it challenging; at time, uncomfortable; always thoughtful.
Christopher Write does not mince his words. He looks at the idols in the Old Testament and then he looks at our modern times and asks if we have not made idols which we worship; idols, in his words, made from things that entice us, things we fear, things we trust, things we need. The problem with these idols, as the author says it, “deprive God of his proper glory.”
If we are to follow Jesus in these turbulent times, our lives must be different. He says, “Penetrating distinctiveness is the Christian calling in the world, as salt and light.” We must be distinctive people. We must also be praying people. “As the book of Revelation alerts us, Babylon is still the world we live in. It is a world of post-truth, fake news, contradictions and denials, then denials of denials; a world of utter confusion of sexual morals….”
Christopher Write concludes in the Epilogue of the book to dwell on the importance of lament, the power of a life of love, and the reality of hope.
A lot to think about. So, if you don’t want to be challenged, don’t read this book. But I hope you do.
Christopher Write does not mince his words. He looks at the idols in the Old Testament and then he looks at our modern times and asks if we have not made idols which we worship; idols, in his words, made from things that entice us, things we fear, things we trust, things we need. The problem with these idols, as the author says it, “deprive God of his proper glory.”
If we are to follow Jesus in these turbulent times, our lives must be different. He says, “Penetrating distinctiveness is the Christian calling in the world, as salt and light.” We must be distinctive people. We must also be praying people. “As the book of Revelation alerts us, Babylon is still the world we live in. It is a world of post-truth, fake news, contradictions and denials, then denials of denials; a world of utter confusion of sexual morals….”
Christopher Write concludes in the Epilogue of the book to dwell on the importance of lament, the power of a life of love, and the reality of hope.
A lot to think about. So, if you don’t want to be challenged, don’t read this book. But I hope you do.
Read
October 30, 2020"We live in an age that has built an idol out of politics. You don’t need to be a Political Scientist to see this fact. We divide ourselves into political factions and then demonize the other side, forgetting that the point of division is not the line of truth established by the Gospel but is instead a line between two parties entirely entrenched in the fallen and temporary concerns of the state. This division becomes more important to us than any other concerns, to the point where we feel more united to those on our side of the political line than to those who confess the same faith. In his new book Here are your gods, Christopher Wright has called us out on our idolatry, and shows us the Biblical path to repentance."
Read the rest here: https://www.patheos.com/blogs/schaeff...
Read the rest here: https://www.patheos.com/blogs/schaeff...
February 23, 2021
The book starts with a deep dive into the concept of idols in the Old Testament. I think the average reader may be put off by the academic nature of those first few chapters. Still, those chapters provide a solid foundation for which the author later examines today's political and cultural environment in the UK and the United States. I imagine that some readers will disagree with his political views, but I think the author highlights the moral and social failures that both Republican and Democratic parties ignore. He provides a middle-way for Christians to engage in the world while avoiding the temptation to adhere to a Christian nationalistic perspective or to avoid politics. Informative, provocative, challenging, and Christ-affirming, the book effectively links the concept of idols to today's post-modern idols.
November 14, 2023
I always enjoy the writings of Christopher J H Wright. In particular, he has greatly helped me in my understanding of the Old Testament of the Bible. This book is divided into 3 sections: The Lord God and other gods in the Bible, Political idolatry then and now and God’s people in idolatrous world. The book felt a little uneven with the first section being considerably more academic than the other 2. This can easily be understood when we learn that the first section is adapted from chapter 5 of the same author’s well known and greatly appreciated book ‘The Mission of God’. The 2 other sections are more personal as he exposes false gods and idols we are tempted to bow down to, with a particular focus on contemporary politics in the US and the UK. You may not agree with all the author’s conclusions but the book will certainly stimulate your thinking on this very important subject.
March 23, 2021
Great book. Christopher Wright does good work showing how the Church has become quite consumed by idolatry, especially in the political realm. Wright then guides readers to look at those in political leadership and their platforms to question their character, motives and policies. Wright proposes that it is not good to pursue what has been called the “Benedict Option” or to be the modern equivalent of Zealots but to hear Jesus’ command to be “salt and light”. To be salt and light, according to Wright, means fo live lives that penetrate society with virtue yet remain distinct from the broader culture. As Daniel prayed for and served Babylon so should modern Christians do the same in their “Babylon”.
May 23, 2021
Read it once and then immediately began it again to reread. Written just before the pandemic and before the insurrection of January 6, this book anticipates it due to the idolatry of the west and in the US and UK in particular. Specifically, the dominant idols of consumerism, nationalism, self-sufficiency, guns, and strongmen are identified - all of which continue to plague our nations. Wright shows what an idol is in both the old and new testaments, and also how we are to live in light of the turmoil of our age. Drawing from OT ethics, his missionary focus charts a path for those thirsting for righteousness in their lands. Excellent book.
September 16, 2022
I've heard it said that a good book should disturb you. This one accomplished that task. I will have to reread this multiple times before concluding, but I can't entirely agree with about 25% of the author's findings. He has a politically liberal slant, but I'm not ready to discount his views. I was tempted to immediately discard some of the issues that he raised until the Holy Ghost's convicting power whispered, "Is he wrong?" I will be chewing this one over for some time. I recommend reading the book regardless of its political implications. There is still much good, but you may have to eat the meat and spit out the bones.
April 14, 2025
This small book packs a big punch. The first half provides a taxonomy of idolatry, and provides a way to think about idolatry through the lens of missions — after all, if missions is about drawing people to God, mustn’t it involve freeing people from idol worship? The second half details national and political idolatry, and briefly offers a model for remaining faithful in a faithless era. Among other things, I feel better qualified to speak wisely and discerning about the causes and symptoms of divine judgment in America, and to be clear-eyed about the Bible’s witness against empires. But I am also emboldened as I think about God’s mission calling idolatrous people to himself.
November 28, 2020
A good portion of this book is a reprint of “The Mission of God” by the same author. Highly academic, I found it difficult to stay engaged and apply to my individual life. The tagline “faithful discipleship in idolatrous times,“ Felt a bit misleading. Discipleship to me denotes practical application, insight in guidance for the common and ordinary. While the author did make a few mentions to modern day political events, I left feeling over educated without clear direction on how to apply this to my personal life or my community.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 70 reviews