Well glad that’s over. Unlikeable fMC, too many sappy endearments , poor editing throughout, and a horrible Morgan Matriarch (whose earlier awfulness is never actually resolved or confronted, it’s just overlooked by the end and not mentioned again.)
But Maggie truly makes this book difficult to like. Five years ago, she and Ben had a one-night stand before he left for CA and she left for Princeton. 2 months later, Maggie returns to AZ pregnant.
Fast forward five years and Ben is returning to his hometown for some R&R (doctor’s orders). Maggie has been living, working on Ben’s family farm, and raising their 4yo daughter, Emma, this whole time, never breathing a word about Ben being the father to anyone other than Ned (Maggie’s dad who retired to help with Emma). Why Ben at 27yo wanted to sleep with Maggie at 18yo, I do not know, except lust I guess, annd according to the author’s timeline, that’s their initial ages. So they are 23 and 32 now.
Ben has never been told he’s a father. His huge family of 5 siblings and parents who own a farm/ranch have never been told, despite the fact Maggie works for them and they all live in a small town where everyone knows everyone else’s business. Plus they say Emma is the spitting image of Ben.
So now that Ben is in town, Maggie is freaking out and debating telling him. Her own father tells her Ben has a right to know, and Maggie agrees, but says she’ll tell him when she has a chance. Oh and she’ll have plenty of chances but does she tell him? Nope!! When she finally, finally gets around to telling Ben that Emma is his, after how many play dates, and Maggie and Ben having sex repeatedly even though she keeps telling herself to stay away from Ben 🙄, Maggie finally tells him.
And you know what, Ben is rightfully upset. He never got a chance to be there. And so he asks for time and space to process this life-altering news. And what does Maggie do, get offended and annoyed and mad at Ben.
So Ben repeatedly has been showing he loves Emma and Maggie, but immature Maggie just keeps holding onto the idea that Ben is going to leave again. Does she communicate with Ben, of course not, she just assumes and thus does inane things to distance herself from him.
Ben, the sucker for punishment that he is, still continues to make changes to his life in CA so he can move back to be with Maggie, Emma and the rest of his family. He continues to try to be with them even as Maggie rebuffs him. I mean at one point, Maggie takes her fears out on him by crying and shouting at him about how he wasn’t there when Emma was a baby and I about wanted to slap the woman because whose fault was that!?
Then you have the not-so-lovely Leonora, mother of Ben who wants to set her son up with a woman of their standing, not some “stable hand” and “harlot” as she refers to Maggie, repeatedly. And Leonora conspires to set her son up and tells Maggie lies. At the end, there’s no mention of her awfulness it’s just, ok she’s grandma and on board with Ben and Maggie.
The “my beloved” and “my darling” etc etc in this book made me want to roll my eyes so much. It was too sappy and not romantic at all.
And then the editing. There were moments throughout, and it’s just annoying to have typos and mentions that don’t make sense. For example, towards the end, Emma goes down for a nap on the picnic blanket outside in the yard, Maggie cover her with her sweater, then pulls Ben into the remodeled house to have sex🙄, where she proceeds to take off her sweater. The same sweater she just covered her child with.
The book idea had promise but the story went downhill fast and was just ended up feeling too long. Will definitely not continue the series and would not recommend to anyone either.