I would like to thank Netgalley and HQ for an advance copy of A Fatal Affair, the sixth novel to feature PC Trudy Loveday and Coroner Clement Ryder, set in Oxford, 1961.
When the May Queen of Middle Fenton, Iris Carmody, is found dead, wrapped around the maypole by its ribbons the village is in shock. When her boyfriend, David Finch, is found a few days later hanging in a barn, the villagers are quick to draw conclusions. His father, Superintendent Finch isn’t and asks Ryder and Loveday to take a closer look.
I thoroughly enjoyed A Fatal Affair, which is an engrossing mystery with plenty of suspects and a captivating protagonist in Trudy Loveday. I found the plot absorbing as it contains little to no forensics and consists mainly of human interactions and deductions. Yes, these characters are mostly stereotypes, like Iris the loose moraled, money grubbing gold digger or the smart but naive David Finch, but it hardly matters as they fit the narrative nicely and the reader “knows” them, or their type. The plot itself is clever as I had no idea of the killer’s identity until the denouement, although the motive was slightly clearer, tied as it is to Iris’s personality.
The novel is told from various points of view, mostly Ryder and Loveday, giving the reader a wider perspective and more characters to suspect, as many of them, outside the investigators, have secrets and dark thoughts that raise alarm bells with the reader. Fortunately there are no musings from the unnamed killer, a current trend that I loathe.
I love the relationship between the crusty, sophisticated Ryder and the young, naïve Trudy. He looks on her as a daughter and she, in turn respects and learns from him. They are a formidable team and improving with every outing.
A Fatal Affair is a good read that I have no hesitation in recommending.