What a fun adventurous read! I really enjoyed this book, and it settles in my being after the read as a really fun romp, with certain moments still simmering trying to tell further stories themselves in my mind. That is the mark of a good book and time well spent reading. Recommended.
This is the first book I've read in this series "The Faery Rehistory," and it can be read as a standalone. In the advanced reader copy I received from NetGalley, the book opens with a glossary, and I think this is the first book I've read where I poured through every single entry of a glossary *before* beginning the main text, because every single entry sparked colorful story thoughts behind the entry, fascinating! And I do know much Icelandic and Celtic lore, so this was surprising! Unless you are up on the words and lore, I recommend not skipping the glossary. Yes, it's a bit of an info dump, but I considered it sort of like receiving a map before entering a land, and it leaves itself as general Celtic and Icelandic knowledge enhancement after the quick read.
The prologue could become a book itself as well, and I still find myself mulling over in my mind that life that is only discussed briefly in the prologue, really just a set up of a life to come and the main character life framing. An entire life is only teased at, and I'm left salivating and hoping and wondering, ...and then we're directed to the actual story,....
The book itself has a pacing that begins slow covering the span of only a day or so, and then moves perhaps too fast through the rest of the book, as so much happens so quickly, I found myself wishing for a longer book. I understand the publishing drive and ROI need to trim pages and present stories more concisely, but the feeling arc in this telling becomes more a feeling hard turn, perhaps partly for brevity's sake, yet nevertheless remains interesting and captivating.
The story is so captivating that I staying up very late finishing it. We have villains and nature consciousness and different types of fae and lords and ladies, we have steampunk elements and a great goddess (I would have loved the story from the goddess POV!), we have poetry and ancient lore brought fresh, we have a bit of mystery and of course sizzling hot romance. (Explicit sex scenes included.) It's all there and it's a full delicious meal.
If I could make changes as a reader, I'd draw out the timeline just a bit to feel more believable. I cannot think of a human I know that made such a hard turn in feeling and judgement so swiftly. That small plot moment leaves the reader a bit pulled away, but this is myth and myth can do such things as move with lightning speed, and so I voided out my human expectation and continued on. Honestly, the turn was expected anyway, just a bit slower burn to ride the wave upward was what I thought coming. If timeline could not be altered, I'd at least make the feeling tone arc move at a decent crescendo instead of hard turns, but it might be difficult to do in this tight storytelling. The book remains very enjoyable if we suspend that expectation.
This book is told in dual POV (with the exception of prologue), and that has benefits and costs as most probably know. Here, we know what is happening in the minds of two characters; but we slightly loose the very deep emotional bond that can come with one POV / first person done well, where we travel a feeling-train hand in hand with one and only one being, and we become the champion of that character, (with good writing) knowing their deepest pain *and feeling it deeply ourselves.* Here, with dual POV and this going back and forth, that incredible depth potential is sacrificed.
This ends up feeling like a really fun romp and adventure, and we're left curious for more, yet without the deep bond that can tie us inexorably to a character's future imagined well-being and success. The meal becomes satisfying but not earth-shattering or belief amending.
Multiple POV is a trend it seems, and it leads to a different outcome, certainly more egalitarian. That is the benefit. I have this perspective that diving into books is like a reincarnation, and we can grow from a life lived in the mind only, and here we have two.
There are steampunk elements that are interesting but could have been done another way, with magic and beings and nature instead of devices. It does add a novel twist on fae lore indeed. But the many plot moves and twists are very well crafted, devices or no. It is tight and moves along with increasing speed and becomes quite the ride.
There are no glaring holes, and the way the author writes is wonderful to read for a book like this, the words step out of the way of the story and the reader is carried smoothly through buildup and high-action moments. I really enjoy and appreciate this author's way with words, a finely tuned vehicle for visionary travel indeed.
4 stars for an invigorating story thick with fae and Celtic-Icelandic lore, thank you Sharon Lynn Fisher! And thank you NetGalley and Blackstone Publishing for the ARC.
----------
My star ratings:
5 stars: Incredible read, cannot get it out of my mind, will read again and again, perhaps has effect on self identity or belief
4 stars: Very enjoyable, no glaring plot or writing issues, added to my idea or knowledge or lore bank, glad to have read
3 stars: Enjoyable on some level but something was missing or in the way - a writing style, plot holes, pacing or emotional connection
2 stars: At some point I was probably screaming at the book and wondering where was the editorial team, or was there a helping team at all
1 star: probably DNF unless I felt obligated, will forget it existed sadly, the idea kernel squandered