Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Submission is an addiction she thought she’d left behind, but who can say no to him?

Best friends are always supposed to be there for each other, but walking into a place like The Punishment Pit was above and
beyond.

Now Master Lukus is holding her captive, intent on punishing Tiffany for her mistakes, and instead of saving Brianna, she’s trapped with a man from her darkest fantasies.

She’s in way over her head. Falling too hard, too fast. And the dangerously dominant owner of the club is pushing all her buttons, waking up every naughty desire she’s ever had — and more.

But his life isn’t simple, and neither is hers, and nothing is easy when hearts are involved. Everyone has decisions to make, but when every choice is hard, can any of them really have it all?

Warning: Having it All is book three in the binge-worthy Punishment Pit series. This book has naughty BDSM punishments, dominance and submission, and delicious power exchange. If that’s not your cup of tea, don’t swing by The Punishment Pit.

260 pages, Kindle Edition

First published April 21, 2015

60 people are currently reading
622 people want to read

About the author

Livia Grant

53 books1,345 followers
USA Today bestselling author Livia Grant lives in Chicago with her husband and furry rescue dog named Max. She is fortunate to have been able to travel extensively and as much as she loves to visit places around the globe, the Midwest and its changing seasons will always be home. Livia's readers appreciate her riveting stories filled with deep, character driven plots, often spiced with elements of BDSM.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
146 (61%)
4 stars
64 (26%)
3 stars
18 (7%)
2 stars
8 (3%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews
Profile Image for Louise H's Book Thoughts.
2,024 reviews315 followers
October 23, 2020
After reading the first two books, and being on the fence with the series, and having indulged in purchasing a KU membership, I decided to see where the story went in these books.

I got more into the flow of this one, particularly the Lukas and Tiffany scenes, which were very steamy, consensual and totally had me captivated. I really enjoyed seeing their developing relationship and the compromises Lukas was prepared to make. It was also good to see Tiffany retaining her independence and strength of character.

Markus learns the truth about an event in book #1, I can't say I was a fan of his response, it still seemed a lot of "about him" rather than how was his wife coping. And I still didn't find her reaction very realistic. The emotional turmoil and stress Brianna had gone through in a very short period of time would surely have resulted in some sort of break down, at some point. I just failed all round to connect or really believe in this couple.

However Tiffany and Lukas carried the story for me, so I didn't mind too much. And that cliffhanger ending really had me on edge!
Profile Image for Dennis.
931 reviews26 followers
September 10, 2021
Terrific BDSM novel

Oh wow this book is mostly about Lukus and Tiffany and I think it is awesome there is a good amount of steamy scenes and punishment scenes, of particular note is that the dialogue between the characters is truly outstanding. I really loved the descriptions of the characters and the dialogue between the characters and this is the main reason I love this writer, she is so very good with her dialogue and I love her characters. Note that this book ends in a huge cliffhanger, but I am sure that you will want to read this story and of course the next one too.

This book is part of the The Punishment Pit series and I advise you to start with the first book as the books are not exactly stand alone.
Profile Image for Kelly_Reads_Books.
2,115 reviews188 followers
September 19, 2020
Such a tantalizing story!
I am loving the continuation of Brianna and Markus's story. This couple has been through so much and seem to be on a path to finding each other again.
But Tiffany and Lukus, wow, such a hot and heavy start to their relationship. I need a cold shower after their first night together!
This series is perfectly scrumptious!
Profile Image for Donna Louise.
797 reviews12 followers
September 22, 2020

Donna L
5.0 out of 5 stars Deliciously Rich
Reviewed in the United States on September 22, 2020
Ms Grant is not only an exceptional storyteller, but she is well versed
in the BDSM lifestyle.She has a gift at reaching right into the souls of
her characters and bringing them to life.

In this book, the focus is not only on reuniting Marcus and Brianna's
crumbling marriage, but we are privileged to be able witness the birth
of Lukus and Tiffany's tumultuous relationship.

Lukus was fighting a losing battle.He was at war with himself.Finding
Tiffany was unexpected.One side of him wanted to send her away,but
the other side wanted to bind her to him forever .Foreign emotions
were running a marathon within him.Teenage memories, and a deep
seated curiosity with submission reignighted when Tiffany met Lukus.
Talk about hot !! Lukus had an instant affect on Tiffany's equilibrium,
could she learn to submit to him.Was he the man of her dreams, or
would he turn her dreams into nightmares.Layers upon layers of
emotions were stripped bare, uncovering a deep seated yearning that
Tiffany was no longer able to deny.

Marcus was determined not to make the same mistakes with Brianna as
he did with is first wife.He hid his dominant personality so well that even
a hardcore submissive like Brianna did not suspect it.I do feel that it would
take more than one night of harsh punishment for Brianna to be able to
redeem herself.This couple now have to navigate their future together as
husband and wife.Dominant and submissive.

This book was delicious and smooth,just like good chocolate. The author
never shies away from difficult situations, but she attacks them head on.
I am totally in lust with Lukus, and very jealous of Tiffany.How pathetic is
that.I don't have much empathy for Brianna, but everyone deserves a
Profile Image for Jacqueline Chappell.
1,444 reviews19 followers
September 17, 2020
I liked this one so much. I love that Tiff is getting a chance to explore the lifestyle with a good dom who’s looking for more than a good time. Lukus is strong, deeply dominant and yet doesn’t want a 24/7 relationship. They will fit each other to a T once they get past the cliffhanger. I love that Markus and Brianna have worked things out and now have a chance at an honest and fulfilling relationship. So much going on and can’t wait for the next one.
Profile Image for Shane Starrett.
Author 15 books830 followers
January 24, 2021
It’s all too easy to hide from the things you fear, even if confronting those fears may lead to the greatest passion of your life. Ms. Grant shows what can happen if you think taking the path of least resistance is your best choice, and the incredibly sexy route available if you just make that leap of faith with your heart instead of listening to the fears in your head instead. Five stars—do NOT miss this journey!
Profile Image for Badh.
3,311 reviews65 followers
October 1, 2020
We have the continuing saga of Brianna and Markus, and Lukus and Tiffany. We're getting more of Lukus and Tiffany in this one, which is nice. I'm glad that we aren't completely losing Brianna and Markus, because without them, we wouldn't be anywhere, but Lukus and Tiffany are such a huge part of Brianna and Markus' story that it works really well.

I really like Tiffany and Lukus. I think it's going to be interesting to see their relationship grow because it's a new thing for both of them, and there are going to be interesting growing pains going on.

I really like Tiffany and her sassiness. I think that she's going to keep Lukus on his toes, in the best possible way. Of course, he's going to turn around and do the same thing to her, so there's that. LOL.
Profile Image for Jo-Ann Forrest.
2,905 reviews22 followers
September 21, 2020
The story continues to unfolds between Markus and Briana, they are getting on track for a new normal that they will explore. Meanwhile, her BFF Tiffany is drawn like a magnet towards Lukus and so is he. He soon realizes that she is the missing piece he was looking to get out of his boredom. She is smart, sassy,sexy and she might be his perfect match! However, she is a virgin to the lifestyle and he is a Master's Master. Will this woman bring him down to his knees or will they find something in between? Can she live by the strict code and listen to her Dom? Doesn't she know what curiosity did to the cat? As their story unfolds before our eyes, you will be pulled into their dynamic and their drama. I volunteered to review this story.
Profile Image for Kay Parker.
Author 44 books972 followers
September 29, 2020
Things are full steam ahead back at the Punishment Pit, with Markus and Brianna reacquainting themselves as a D/s couple. For me personally, I still haven't quite warmed up to Markus and I can't explain why. There is a scene toward the end of the book where I don't feel quite as disconnected to him, so I hope that will continue in book 4. I'd like to love him as much as I love Lukas, but I think there's a bit of work to do there.
Lukas and Tiff, however, have been the highlight of Having It All. I've loved Lukas from the first, and Tiff is becoming a fast favorite. I can't wait to see what happens after that interesting little cliffhanger.
Profile Image for Anna.
790 reviews
September 27, 2020
AHHH.... This book has gotten us to a more balanced place with Markus and Brianna (although still so sizzling). In fact, there is a TON of sexy times in this book between both couples. *cue the fan now* Now Lukus and Tiffany’s relationship is brand new and in a much shakier place. I loved the vulnerability they both showed, especially Lukus. And their intense HEAT... I mean I cannot say enough about it! Whew!! The entire book takes place in a week, which normally is not my preference. However, it was definitely realistic... the chemistry, intense attraction. Relationships definitely happen that quickly, so it felt real. I do wish it did not end the place it did, and I am so glad the next book is just around the corner. I definitely recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Profile Image for Kathy Heare Watts.
6,896 reviews175 followers
April 28, 2015
INTENSE.....RAW.....EMOTIONAL.....EROTIC
Wow, these stories just suck you in and hold you hostage! I love that it kept me captivated and on the edge of my seat with the twist and turns in the plot. Lukus Mitchell and Tiffany O'Sullivan have been on an emotional, but erotic roller-coaster trying to work out their relationship. Him being Master of Masters of The Punishment Pit and a Dominate man. Tiffany is more reserved, she enjoyed seeing the BDSM scene but has only been a voyeur, stepping into a new role is suspenseful and giving complete and total trust and relinquishing control isn't easy. Danger is out there, Jake Davenport has both Tiffany and Brianna in his sights, but Markus and Lukus are not willing to let him win, he is going down......but they have to catch him first. The scenes are so well described you can hear and feel the tension, the paddle hitting skin, the screams of pain....but the erotic moments are just as intense with the moans of ecstasy. I can't wait to see what happens next in this intense, edgy, erotic tale.
Profile Image for Laurel.
505 reviews8 followers
April 23, 2015

I absolutely love Livia Grant's books and this is the third book in the passion series. I'm again meeting old friends from books 1 and 2 and now the story of Lukus and Tiffany. Tiff is new to the BDSM but wants to explore it with Lukus. Tiffany's best friend, Brianna and her husband Markus help guide her in her exploration. An old enemy Jake, has Lukus and Markus doing their best to protect their women. The writtng is fast paced and so well done that from the first page which grabbed me, I couldn't put it down until the wee hours of night. The plot is intense with all the elements of a great novel with danger, violence, amazing hot sex and discipline, romance and love. I will be waiting with baited breath for book 4. This was an awesome read.
Profile Image for SH.
807 reviews13 followers
April 23, 2015
I. Love. This. Series. I adored book one and two, and was so happy and excited to read book three. It met my expectations and more. Ms. Grant has certainly created something special. It was wonderful to reconnect with characters from the previous book and to now experience the romance between Lukus and Tiffany. This book offers a detailed plot with suspense, danger, HOT sexy stuff, romance and love and it literally kept me turning page after page! If you haven't read this series, what are you waiting for? I can't wait for book four!!
Profile Image for cKw.
12 reviews
April 25, 2015
Hot/Steamy/Excitingly Delicious

This has to be one of the best series I have read in a long time! I absolutely love all the characters - Lucus and Markus are beyond Hot!
A must read!
Waiting patiently for book four....
Profile Image for Julia Butterfield - Stevens.
901 reviews9 followers
September 24, 2020
Told again in multiple povs, this continues the story of Markus, Brianna, Tiffany and Lukas and follows straight after the events in book two, Securing It All, which must be read before.

The book focused mainly on Lukas and Tiffany's fledgling relationship. There was a lot of sex, these two had fiery hot chemistry, but Lukas has been quietly changed by Tiffany and perhaps she has finally found the man strong enough to release her hidden desires. There was a lot of depth to their conversations as Lukas started to draw out truths and desires Tiffany had been afraid of, particularly regarding bdsm.  I loved that there was so much about the dynamics of a d/s relationship in this, but they still have a way to go! Tiffany with her sass and vulnerability and dominant Lukas who realises he wants more than just sex, make an intriguing, passionate pair.

I loved that finally Markus and Brianna are repairing their marriage with honest, forthright communication. They both made mistakes and kept so many secrets and finally it seems they are becoming true to themselves and each other. I'm sure we haven't seen the back of the despicable Jake yet though especially now Bri has revealed all to her husband.

There wasn't so much hardcore bdsm in this, but it's still The Punishment Pit and Tiff pushes all of Lukas's buttons and vice versa!

It ends on a cliffhanger, so I'm glad there's not long to wait to find out what comes next for these four. All I know, it won't be plain sailing, or should I say.......paddling 😉
Profile Image for Hanan .
1,992 reviews20 followers
September 24, 2020
This book is focusing on Lukus and Tiffany.
I love the chemistry and dynamics they have.
It’s sexy and sizzling hot.
But I also love that Lukus demands her full honesty.
He wants Tiffany to be open and talk things through with him.
To ask questions and to discuss not only her desires.
But the things that scare her.
He wants an open dialogue and no hiding any issues.
He’s seen first hand the consequences of not having an open truthful communication between partners can lead to.
I liked that Tiffany and Lukus are willing to take a chance on this budding relationship.
Even though both are in uncharted territory.
Tiffany being a newbie in the BDSM world.
And Lukus never having a one on one relationship with anyone.
I love Tiffany’s sassiness and her comebacks.
And how she didn’t want to change who she was.
But wanted to explore to feel more complete.
Lukus is one sexy observant dom.
I liked how attuned he was with Tiffany.
How he studied her body language and facial expressions.
And knew immediately when something changed within her.
Ms. Grant also gives us more of Marcus and Brianna’s “new” relationship.
Marcus is self reflecting and vows never to make the same mistakes he made in his previous marriage.
I liked that he owned up to his wrong doings.
Brianna is also learning from her mistakes.
And she’s communicating her wants and needs.
Looking forward to reading Balancing it All.

Profile Image for Maria (Ri).
5,137 reviews14 followers
September 22, 2020
I have to be honest. I was a little gunshy about going into this book because of how I felt after the last book. There were some residual feelings that didn't sit right with me in the last book and I worried that it would carry over on how, or even if, I would enjoy this book. I need not have worried because this book left me in a better headspace than the last book.

I enjoyed watching Tiffany and Lukus explore their dynamic as they discovered more about themselves, each other, and their connection. It was intense. I also enjoyed getting the chance to see Brianna and Markus slowly build on the love they had for each other as well as build on what this experience has taught them. I liked that further explanation was given into the BDSM lifestyle and that this author has given a lot of time and detail into what that entails for the participants. That was one of my biggest complaints with the previous books, is that it had lost a huge component of that lifestyle and that was honesty and communication wich severely broke my trust.

Looking forward to where the author takes this next.
Profile Image for Jennifer Bolin.
50 reviews
September 22, 2020
so we still see bits of Brianna & Markus & how they're making the new dynamics of their marriage work after Markus finds out how much into pain & BDSM Brianna is.. BUUUUUUT we now are reading about Master Luke & Tiffany, Brianna's best friend & co-partner in their salon... Tiffany has always been a bystander in the BDSM world & has been happy to just be a voyeur, but now after meeting Luke, she's starts questioning whether she can be woman & submissive enough for the elusive Master of Masters who could have his pick of the litter of literally the hundreds of submissive women who walk through his club's doors.. Lukus has fallen head over heels over this fiery sassy vixen that came originally to "save" her best friend without realizing that she wasn't in any real harm & is enjoying being her first to BDSM experiences as well as trying to be in a "normal" relationship.. great book from beginning to end.. cant wait to see what happens next!!!! <3
Profile Image for Rhonda Hicks.
4,572 reviews82 followers
September 24, 2020
They've both been keeping secrets from each other. Brianna wanting and needing Marcus to dominate her in the bedroom and punish her when she's done something wrong. Marcus had to admit, not only to himself but to Bri, he had not only been a neglectful husband to his first wife but a bad Dom to her as well. Does it put them on the road to recovery as far as their relationship and marriage are concerned? And if you've been following the series up to now, then you know Lukus and Tiffany were dealing with the friend side of the fallout. There's a chemistry between them but is Tiffany brave enough to actually dip her toes into a BDSM relationship? Is Lukus, Master of Masters, flexible enough for a fearful newbie? And Jake? Are there consequences to or from him? This is such an exciting, adrenaline-filled story it just doesn't let go, even when I reach the last page. I can't wait for the next one!!
Profile Image for Sharon.
1,812 reviews41 followers
September 24, 2020
I might be in the minority but I was so excited for Lukus and Tiffany and was a bit disappointed that the book started with Brianna and Markus. Don’t get me wrong because overall I enjoyed the book, but I wanted to jump in with both feet to see how Lukus could convince Tiffany to give him a chance and explore the world he was a Master of. I enjoyed how Lukus approached what he wanted to explore with her. That being said, these books must be read in order and you will be left wanting the conclusion of Lukus and Tiffany’s story which is releasing in a couple of weeks.

Again, I don’t think the cover matched the darker punishment elements of the story and again there were definitely inconsistencies in the flow of the story.

I am intrigued by Lukus and Tiffany and can’t wait to get the end of their story in the next book, Balancing It All.
#MSBB
Profile Image for JigsawGirl.
4,084 reviews
September 24, 2020
This book shifted to focusing more on Lukus and Tiffany. OMG! What was Tiffany thinking. She is determined to drive Lukus to drink. And here I was waiting for Jake to make a reappearance to try and screw up Markus and Bri. We still hear from Bri and Markus, but they are in a pretty sweet spot right now.

I like the way Lukus insists on honesty and frequent communication with Tiffany. Not only because she is new to the lifestyle, but because it's necessary in relationships in general. I think they have great chemistry. They really manage to ratchet up the sexual tension tension. I also like seeing Lukus' vulnerability. Many books focus on the female's vulnerability, but often don't let the males shine through.

I can't wait to see how Tiffany is going to get out of the mess she finds herself in now.

I voluntarily read and reviewed the Advanced Reader Copy of this book.
Profile Image for Mom2three.
2,026 reviews16 followers
October 2, 2020
I fall more in love with this story the longer it goes on. The nice twist with this one is that it focuses on Lukus and Tiffany more than Markus and Brianna. The chemistry between Lukus and Tiffany is incredible! I actually like their dynamic more than Markus and Brianna. They seem to have learned from watching Bri and Markus flounder, and are determined to not fall into the same trap of dishonesty and secrets. Tiffany isn't just going to submit easily, though, and it's going to take all of Lukus's patience to tame her.
Along with the love stories, there is still the issue of Jake and the danger he poses to Brianna. This gives the added suspense and tension, and moves the story along at a fast and exciting pace. Overall, this is a great read that is full of heat, passion, love, and suspense, and I loved it.
144 reviews1 follower
September 22, 2020
The series continues with Marcus, Brianna, Lukus and Tiffany, focusing more on the latter couple and was an absolute delight! The contrast of the experienced Dom Lukus versus a relatively untried Tiffany is a delicious combination. I liked how real the chemistry was between them, but also the hesitance on her part to jump into this new lifestyle and the patience and understanding shown by Lukus to make her feel comfortable. This book highlights the importance of transparency in your communication. Meanwhile Marcus and Brianna continue to navigate their new reality....both couples bring the heat, be assured of plenty of steam and D/s dynamics. Can’t wait for the next book!
I was given an ARC of this book and am leaving my honest opinion.
Profile Image for April Symes.
5,013 reviews448 followers
September 23, 2020
Having It All is Book 3 in "The Punishment Pit " series by Livia Grant. The series continues with Markus, Brianna, Master Lukus and Tiffany. We get more Lukus and Tiffany this go around in book 3. We get to read how Markus and Brianna finally get on the right page together, their relationship issues working out better than ever. The chemistry between them is hot !! Then you add Master Lukus and Brianna's BFF Tiffany. Ohhh yasss!! They have a red-hot start going to their romance and the sparks fly!! The pages just sizzle with the insta-lust of their relationship. I like watching Lukus and Tiffany feel out where they want to see their relationship go... the book ends on a epic cliffhanger. I can't wait for book 4!!!

My Rating: 4.5 stars ********
1,862 reviews9 followers
September 24, 2020
Absolutely loving this series!
I couldn’t wait to read this next installment! The feel good vibes coming off Marcus and Brianna as they discover their new relationship is heartwarming. With the discovery of what Marcus missed while Brianna was with her ex, ensures he will have Lukus look into the man. Lukus and Tiffany start to feel each other out as Tiffany surprises Lukus with her skill on the court and Lukus’ surprising skills to read Tiffany’s inner thoughts. But with Tiffany being relatively new to the lifestyle, will she be enough for Lukus? You have to read to find out and it definitely ends on a cliffhanger that will leave you counting the days to the next book! Hurry Livia, I need to know now.
2,171 reviews14 followers
September 24, 2020
Ms. Grant takes us on one hell of an emotional journey in Having It All. We get the full gamut of the emotional experience with Markus and Brianna trying to fix what's broken as well as Lukus and Tiffany's intense relationship. Ms. Grant really is an exceptional storyteller! The way that she weaves the emotions into the words on the page so that we feel their impact is incredible, truly fabulous! I don't want to say anymore and spoil this for anyone else but you really need to read this book and experience their journeys for yourself. I can't wait to read the next book in this series as I know it's going to be great since every book in the series has been better than the last. I was given an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Heather  Chaotic Creatives.
1,136 reviews52 followers
September 19, 2020
Ok I want to start off by saying I really have enjoyed reading these books. I love hot alpha men who take control of their women. I love sassy as hell women who give their doms a run for their money. I really enjoy reading books in a series. I enjoyed getting to see Bri and Markus working on their relationship, and I flove the fact that Tiffany has opened Lukus's eyes to something more.
The reason for the 4 stars is how the story ends on yet another cliffhanger... I am not an author by no means, BUT I am not a patient person and I need to know what is going to happen next. I will say Livia Grant knows how to dangle that carrot just out of reach to have us craving more.
1,886 reviews
September 19, 2020
I love this series and devour every book as it comes out. I like that although the women are submissives, they’re strong and recognized as strong by their Doms. Marcus and Brianna are resolving outstanding issues and behaving like newlyweds but this story focuses on Tiffany and Lukus and it is encouraging to know that although Lukus is a master’s master he is still unsure of how to proceed with Tiffany just as she is with him although Tiffany is in danger of sabotaging the relationship through insecurity before it starts. There is some very hot sex and some very loving moments and it was a joy to read but there is a cliffhanger.
Profile Image for Carolyn Spence.
1,873 reviews17 followers
September 21, 2020
"This isn't a game." Lukus says to Tiffany. Two new characters get more spotlight in this book. We still see the continuing healing for Brianna and Markus, but the dynamics are changing and expanding in this chapter. Tiffany is making a big step in staying to learn more about the lifestyle with Lukus, "but walking away is not an option". Communication, communication, communication is key. I loved how each are not sure of themselves when they are normally very confident in other aspects of their lives. Pins and needles to see where this is going, can't wait for the next chapter.

I voluntarily reviewed this book.
3,015 reviews17 followers
September 21, 2020
Another Scintillating Episode!!

Our main couple Markus & Brianna are newly back together and re-establishing their relationship. But the star of the show the whole series for me has been Lukas. He helped “punish” Brianna, realized her submissive needs and gave Markus the info needed to save their marriage.

Now Lukas is turning his attention to Brianna’s best friend Tiffany. Once again super sizzling and fabulous… can this experienced Dom find what he needs with a newbie? Truly is all about the relationship and the building of trust. Whew!

**I am voluntarily leaving my honest review of this book**
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.