There are some books that you read because you pine for the old days. Sports nostalgia books really do that for many people. After all, how many young boys fondly remember their old baseball heroes like Joe DiMaggio or Babe Ruth. It always amazed me how few books have been written about the world of professional football during the era of the 1920s to the 1950s, versus how many have been written about professional baseball. There seems to be so much more longing for the olden days of baseball than football. Perhaps unwittingly, Jim Dent gives us a glimpse about why the "good old days" of the NFL were not as good as the good old days of baseball.
In this book, Dent gives us a good look at "The Bronk", the legendary Chicago Bears linebacker Bronko Nigurski who played professional football for an astounding 20 years from the 1920s to the 1940s. He played for George Halas, the legendary founder of the Chicago Bears and one of the founders of the NFL. But in this book, Dent gives us a shallow portrayal of "The Bronk". In this book, we get the idea that Nagurski was a modern Paul Bunyan, a giant of a man who brought down real pain upon his opponents on the gridiron. But after reading this book, what do we really know about Nagurski? The fact is, what should one really care about him other than his size?
The NFL of Bronko Nagurski was a very different league than the NFL today, and not at all better than its modern descendent. The modern NFL is more like the world of college football in Nagurski's time. In that game, coaches regularly came up with innovative plays, passes were common along with the "flea flicker" and other risky ways to gain yardage. But such was not the NFL. This is why it was common in those days for college football coaches to regularly advise their best players not to become professional football players when they graduated from college ball. The NFL was what professional wrestling is today. It was a forum where men would pack the stands to see large men pound each other into the turf for every yard. Passes were rare and plays consisted mostly of the largest player barrelling down the field into a sea of defenders, so that the fans could wonder who would be left standing when the yard or two of gain was acknowledged. This is how the NFL was, because this is what the fans wanted. It would be this way from the founding of the league in 1920 all the way until the 1960s, when the league finally changed to draw in fans who had less of a stomach for the pounding torture of every play.
The title of this story, which implies that the book is about the 1943 NFL championship that the Bears won against all odds, is really only a small part of the book. This book is really about Bronko Nagurski, a mountain of a man who lived his last days in constant pain because of the years of torture that he put his body through. It's not an uplifting story, but it's a fitting story about the way that the NFL really was in those days. This is a great book for hard core football fans, but others really will get nothing out of it.