There are mainly three names that always pop up in the recommended books when looking at the harem genre on Goodreads - Logan Jacobs, Eric Vall, and Dante King. I have read multiple entries from the first two, but not Dante King, so I figured I'd finally give him a shot. Honestly, I'd say this was... ok, compared to the rest of the field. A solid 2, maybe even 2.25. It has a shocking amount of worldbuilding - not that it had a lot, or even necessarily good worldbuilding, but it had an amount. Although, to be fair, I am coming off of Scholomance, which steals so many things from Harry Potter that it has a negative amount of worldbuilding of its own. So perhaps I'm giving this book a little too much credit in that department. But it feels like actual effort was put into fleshing out the world, at least for the tiny bit that it did. We learn about the schools of magic, and something called the Void War, and Mage Games, etc. The initial premise is interesting out of the gate... until it kind of meandered into nothingness. I think there's hope it could improve, though! Although whether or not he can manage to continue to expand and have it be interesting in later volumes remains to be seen.
Another slightly positive aspect is that I didn't feel like the book was overly rushed. What I mean by that is, it did not present multiple scenarios and then rush through them, which is what the books written by the other two authors tend to do. We get introduced into the world, and then go on one quest, and that's the novel. While it could certainly be argued that this book failed to present a meaningful and compelling plot once the introduction finished, it did at least not feel like it was sprinting through plot points in order to meet some sort of quota. Succeeded in one category, failed in another.
I do commend this book for having the first love interest and sex scene be with an older woman. A slightly older woman - only about 30 I think - but older nonetheless. All the other books I've tried seem to only focus on 20-somethings and avoid anything older at every turn, which has been a constant disappointment to me. It's nice to see a little variance.
Now, onto the negatives. I'll start out with something that isn't necessarily a negative, but a weird choice - usually, in these fish-out-of-water (or isekai) harem novels, the protagonist is more or less a nobody in his previous life, and then becomes a "somebody" in whatever world the book is creating. However, Justin here is already a "chad" - the story literally starts because he had slept with a mage (without him knowing that she was one), and it even makes reference to him having a ton of booty call numbers on his phone. Again, not a negative, but I think it's a weird direction to go in. Makes it all feel less "earned." Related to that, all the women are attracted to him from the start, without him having to put any effort into it. That can be ok, but it kind of becomes uninteresting when it happens all the time.
- Hand in hand with the protagonist already being a "chad" is his attitude. He is a stereotypical frat dudebro douche, and it gets annoying as shit. Definitely the worst aspect of the book, in my opinion. He is constantly ogling women and thinking about having sex with them. Yeah, that's kind of the point of this genre, but you don't need to be such a brainless asshole about it. It makes the protagonist completely unlikable to me. He's also rattling off terribly unfunny jokes (that are presented as being hilarious) and making inappropriate comments at everything, regardless of his current company. It's quite grating.
- Way too many references to real world things in this. I don't get why these authors continually do it. Do they think it makes it more relatable somehow? It just looks like incredibly lazy and unskilled writing to me.
- Relationships with women being unrealistic is one thing. But something that always sticks out to me is how forced and fake the friendships with other men are. The 4 frat members meet, and within hours they are calling each other by nicknames and roaring with laughter at each other's jokes and stories. But it's even worse in this book than I have encountered before - one of the frat members is literally introduced as being a dick, and he even engages Justin in a fight because he's being so unreasonable. After a long fight, he is beaten, and then all is well moments after they stop fighting, and they're all the best of friends. It doesn't feel organic whatsoever. I'd rather just not have any of that at all. Speaking of which, we are told that female mages vastly outnumber males because of how magic works, but we sure do meet a lot of male characters compared to female. Odd choice for a harem novel.
Anyways, it has a decent premise, with the potential to be something better. It's at least hooked me enough to continue on with it. I've already started on the second.