What do you think?
Rate this book
Belmont Mansion #2
Frumusețe fără seamăn
Frumusete fara seaman. Seria Conacul Belmont. Volumul 2
O fermecatoare poveste de iubire, ce se infiripa in acelasi magnific loc, vestitul conac Belmont din Nashville, Tennessee.
Eleanor nu este o frumusete, dupa canoanele vremii, insa ea se remarca prin alte calitati, care nu se vestejesc de-a lungul timpului. Pasiunea ei cea mai mare este sa aline ranile si suferintele semenilor si de aici porneste dorinta inimii sale de a construi un adapost pentru vaduvele si orfanii ramasi fara tata in urma cruntului razboi care a dezbinat poporul american.
Arhiducele austriac Marcus Gottfried se refugiaza in Tennessee dorindu-si sa isi ascunda identitatea si sa poata sa se dedice pasiunilor sale: natura si arhitectura.
Eleanor si Marcus vor munci cot la cot la amenajarea noii constructii, ceea ce le va oferi prilejul de a-si descoperi unul altuia sufletele, dar va gasi oare iubirea lor calea spre implinire cand Eleanor este fortata sa accepte ca pretendent pe altcineva, iar Marcus este amenintat sa fie dat in vileag de un personaj fara scrupule?
O fermecatoare poveste de iubire, ce se infiripa in acelasi magnific loc, vestitul conac Belmont din Nashville, Tennessee.
Eleanor nu este o frumusete, dupa canoanele vremii, insa ea se remarca prin alte calitati, care nu se vestejesc de-a lungul timpului. Pasiunea ei cea mai mare este sa aline ranile si suferintele semenilor si de aici porneste dorinta inimii sale de a construi un adapost pentru vaduvele si orfanii ramasi fara tata in urma cruntului razboi care a dezbinat poporul american.
Arhiducele austriac Marcus Gottfried se refugiaza in Tennessee dorindu-si sa isi ascunda identitatea si sa poata sa se dedice pasiunilor sale: natura si arhitectura.
Eleanor si Marcus vor munci cot la cot la amenajarea noii constructii, ceea ce le va oferi prilejul de a-si descoperi unul altuia sufletele, dar va gasi oare iubirea lor calea spre implinire cand Eleanor este fortata sa accepte ca pretendent pe altcineva, iar Marcus este amenintat sa fie dat in vileag de un personaj fara scrupule?
568 pages, Paperback
First published March 25, 2014
307 people are currently reading
3821 people want to read
About the author
Tamera Alexander
26 books3,210 followersTamera Alexander is a USA Today bestselling novelist and one of today's most beloved authors of inspirational historical romance and women’s contemporary fiction. While being Gram Tam is her current favorite role, she’ll never turn down a stroll through an old cemetery or browsing through antique shops.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 517 reviews
July 24, 2021
I just loved this book! It was sweet, relaxing, comforting, inspiring… it was everything I was in the mood for.
The characters quickly stole my heart.
Eleanor was an amazing main character. I related to her so much. She quickly felt like a kindred spirit and a good friend. I just wanted her to succeed and have the best because she deserved it. Her heart was so big. I love how she wanted to do what God was calling her to do, willing to do whatever that was even if it wasn’t what she would’ve chosen for herself. She inspired me so much to do the same. She also inspired me to help people, love on people, be more selfless. She didn’t let her insecurities get in the way of her life. I enjoyed watching her passion for cooking and helping people. It was inspiring. She was just amazing and truly beautiful, inside and out. Plus I LOVE seeing heroine’s like her. Not your typical heroine in romance. She’s taller than most women, and not what other describe as miraculously beautiful. It’s the beauty of her heart that’s focused on most, the thing that counts. I LOVED it so, so much and want to see it more in books! I loved her!
Marcus was another character I loved a whole lot. He was sweet and caring. His integrity and passion made me admire him. Also his desire to be a better man endeared him to me. I admired him and adored how he treated Eleanor. It made my heart melt. Not only that but the way he treated her father as well as the widows and children. He simply stole my heart.❤️
The side characters were also wonderful to see. Adelicia must have been some woman!
Marcus and Eleanor were so sweet and wonderful together. Truly perfect for each other. I loved them so much, and I shipped them the entire time! I was dying for them to be together, really. Their love story was also inspiring as it was sweet.
The part of the story with Eleanor and her father really broke my heart. I cried. It was bittersweet and emotional.
I love the faith in this book, especially Eleanor’s walk with God. The parts where it talked about her trusting Him while not completely understanding Him was so very relatable for me.
Tamera Alexander’s writing really hooks me to the story. She makes me feel as if I’m there, as if I’ve been Belmont Mansion. The historical details are so interesting. I love it!
Overall, this was a beautiful, beautiful book. The characters, the faith the story… all of it. I can’t wait to read the third book in this series.
The characters quickly stole my heart.
Eleanor was an amazing main character. I related to her so much. She quickly felt like a kindred spirit and a good friend. I just wanted her to succeed and have the best because she deserved it. Her heart was so big. I love how she wanted to do what God was calling her to do, willing to do whatever that was even if it wasn’t what she would’ve chosen for herself. She inspired me so much to do the same. She also inspired me to help people, love on people, be more selfless. She didn’t let her insecurities get in the way of her life. I enjoyed watching her passion for cooking and helping people. It was inspiring. She was just amazing and truly beautiful, inside and out. Plus I LOVE seeing heroine’s like her. Not your typical heroine in romance. She’s taller than most women, and not what other describe as miraculously beautiful. It’s the beauty of her heart that’s focused on most, the thing that counts. I LOVED it so, so much and want to see it more in books! I loved her!
Marcus was another character I loved a whole lot. He was sweet and caring. His integrity and passion made me admire him. Also his desire to be a better man endeared him to me. I admired him and adored how he treated Eleanor. It made my heart melt. Not only that but the way he treated her father as well as the widows and children. He simply stole my heart.❤️
The side characters were also wonderful to see. Adelicia must have been some woman!
Marcus and Eleanor were so sweet and wonderful together. Truly perfect for each other. I loved them so much, and I shipped them the entire time! I was dying for them to be together, really. Their love story was also inspiring as it was sweet.
The part of the story with Eleanor and her father really broke my heart. I cried. It was bittersweet and emotional.
I love the faith in this book, especially Eleanor’s walk with God. The parts where it talked about her trusting Him while not completely understanding Him was so very relatable for me.
Tamera Alexander’s writing really hooks me to the story. She makes me feel as if I’m there, as if I’ve been Belmont Mansion. The historical details are so interesting. I love it!
Overall, this was a beautiful, beautiful book. The characters, the faith the story… all of it. I can’t wait to read the third book in this series.
May 8, 2023
reread 2023
4.5 stars ✨
Continuing my reread of all of Tamera's books, I was most excited to start this one since I always viewed it as my favourite of her books. I'm not sure it is still my favourite, since I've been really enjoying all of them, but it is just as good as I remembered. Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, a character I found both formidable and enjoyable to watch in the first book, really annoyed me this time around and lessened my enjoyment of the story. She just had to have her way about everything, without considering others' feelings. Which is why I'm giving it 4.5 stars instead of 5. Otherwise, I really enjoyed visiting Belmont again! Marcus and Eleanor make quite the entertaining couple.
4.5 stars ✨
Continuing my reread of all of Tamera's books, I was most excited to start this one since I always viewed it as my favourite of her books. I'm not sure it is still my favourite, since I've been really enjoying all of them, but it is just as good as I remembered. Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, a character I found both formidable and enjoyable to watch in the first book, really annoyed me this time around and lessened my enjoyment of the story. She just had to have her way about everything, without considering others' feelings. Which is why I'm giving it 4.5 stars instead of 5. Otherwise, I really enjoyed visiting Belmont again! Marcus and Eleanor make quite the entertaining couple.
September 17, 2017
This was a pretty great read. The main characters and side characters were absolutely lovable, and this is one of the few novels where I actually really liked the female lead. Writing was solid, and the plot flowed, although I felt like the book could have been just a bit shorter. Overall really entertaining, and a great addition to the series.
March 19, 2014
Are you ready to be transported to another time and place, one that will capture your heart and attention? If so, then open up A Beauty So Rare. This novel is a treasure trove of delight! To say that I thoroughly enjoyed it, is putting it mildly. The time period, the characters and their story just leap to life. You will be enchanted with the wonderful, well rounded and intriguing characters found within the pages! I loved Eleanor and Marcus, and their fascinating friendship.
Not only that, but this novel is beautifully paced. I did not have that hurried feeling of having to rush through the pages, but instead found that I was thoroughly enjoying every moment of where I was within the story. I was SO glad that this wasn't a light weight read! I savored this novel, and every time I had to leave its' pages I eagerly returned, to once more be transfixed and enchanted. Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful - seriously! Bravo, Tamera Alexander on a novel well done! This is definitely one for the keeper shelf!
Loved it!
Not only that, but this novel is beautifully paced. I did not have that hurried feeling of having to rush through the pages, but instead found that I was thoroughly enjoying every moment of where I was within the story. I was SO glad that this wasn't a light weight read! I savored this novel, and every time I had to leave its' pages I eagerly returned, to once more be transfixed and enchanted. Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful - seriously! Bravo, Tamera Alexander on a novel well done! This is definitely one for the keeper shelf!
Loved it!
August 24, 2017
An excellent Reconstruction-era tale about a young woman, impoverished in war, attempting to take care of her father, who is losing his reason to dementia. Her very rich cousin-by-marriage takes her in and means well by her, but doesn't understand Eleanor's passion for cooking.
I loved the rich historical detail, the colorful characters, and also that the romantic parts were subdued rather than soapy. I also loved that Eleanor isn't beautiful and is a tall heroine! And the cover matching the story so perfectly was a pleasant plus (conservatory, pink dress, etc).
Part of a series, but not a heavily connected one; the books may be read out of order without confusion.
I loved the rich historical detail, the colorful characters, and also that the romantic parts were subdued rather than soapy. I also loved that Eleanor isn't beautiful and is a tall heroine! And the cover matching the story so perfectly was a pleasant plus (conservatory, pink dress, etc).
Part of a series, but not a heavily connected one; the books may be read out of order without confusion.
September 14, 2021
This book was hard to put down! As many have said before, Tamera Alexander weaves a GREAT story with multiple, unique subplots going on—I love that. When I choose to read one of her books it’s because I’m in the mood for a ‘movie’ type of story that is long, detailed and has lots of facets.
The romance in A Beauty So Rare was so rich. It’s based on two people who are immediately attracted to each other but remain ‘just friends’ (this is part of the story so I won’t divulge more.) The story was so romantic. I was completely captivated by the way the hero, Marcus, loved Eleanor. The story is so, so sweet. I just can’t get enough of a man who loves a woman for who she is and her character. The way the ending is unraveled was especially beautiful to me. ♥️ The dialogue is awesome.
It was really well-written (and I’m pretty sure you will fall in love with Marcus if you haven’t already.)
I was so worried it was going to be ‘wrapped up’ quickly and their communication would be sub-par. If it wasn’t satisfying I probably would’ve hated this book because of my stress levels! …Rest assured, the ending is the best part. This is what separates Tamera from other writers, I trust her enough to read a story like this and know that she’ll make it worthwhile in the end.
The romance in A Beauty So Rare was so rich. It’s based on two people who are immediately attracted to each other but remain ‘just friends’ (this is part of the story so I won’t divulge more.) The story was so romantic. I was completely captivated by the way the hero, Marcus, loved Eleanor. The story is so, so sweet. I just can’t get enough of a man who loves a woman for who she is and her character. The way the ending is unraveled was especially beautiful to me. ♥️ The dialogue is awesome.
It was really well-written (and I’m pretty sure you will fall in love with Marcus if you haven’t already.)
I was so worried it was going to be ‘wrapped up’ quickly and their communication would be sub-par. If it wasn’t satisfying I probably would’ve hated this book because of my stress levels! …Rest assured, the ending is the best part. This is what separates Tamera from other writers, I trust her enough to read a story like this and know that she’ll make it worthwhile in the end.
March 14, 2017
Originally posted on Reveries Reviews.
When I began this book, it’d been a while since I’d read anything by Tamera Alexander. I really love her writing style, and this was no exception.
Historic Nashville is such an intriguing place, and the characters in it – some based on real-life, other fabricated – are equally as fascinating. I really adored this book. The historical details were amazing, I liked both Eleanor and Marcus, and of course I still love ‘Aunt Adelicia.’ She’s really the most amazing character ever. I wish I could have known her (though I doubt we would see eye to eye in real life; we’re both too independent).
I did chop off half a star because it did seem to drag just a little here and there. A few too many botany details, I think.
4.5/5 stars
~Kellyn Roth, Reveries Reviews
When I began this book, it’d been a while since I’d read anything by Tamera Alexander. I really love her writing style, and this was no exception.
Historic Nashville is such an intriguing place, and the characters in it – some based on real-life, other fabricated – are equally as fascinating. I really adored this book. The historical details were amazing, I liked both Eleanor and Marcus, and of course I still love ‘Aunt Adelicia.’ She’s really the most amazing character ever. I wish I could have known her (though I doubt we would see eye to eye in real life; we’re both too independent).
I did chop off half a star because it did seem to drag just a little here and there. A few too many botany details, I think.
4.5/5 stars
~Kellyn Roth, Reveries Reviews
April 12, 2014
My Comments
What a DE-LIGHT-FUL book!! Goodness, this is my first time reading Alexander’s work, but I sensed something SOOOOOO special about this story I couldn’t pass it up…..indeed, EVERY part of this book was wonderfully written and tangibly enjoyed from the FIRST page! I am NOT a fan of pink, but I couldn’t stop looking at that BEAUTIFUL cover while reading and the story never failed to keep my attention through almost 500 pages. It was such an amazing read that I even forgot to take notes! Yes, this book is FILLED with excellent food and dishes, but mostly it appeals to the reader’s heart through Eleanor and the amazing character she is.
The book begins with Eleanor being a volunteer for the wounded during war in 1864 and this entire scene resonates with her in such a way that she remembers it throughout the story. She even makes a promise to one dying soldier and she doesn’t give up the unlikelihood of fulfilling this promise no matter how many years it takes to do so. Most people would’ve given up after a few attempts, there was no one to keep her accountable and no one would’ve been the wiser about such a failed attempt. However, I believe this promise is one of many instances that strengthens Eleanor’s faith and even brings her much needed healing about love.
Eleanor must move in with her aunt later in the story after leaving her father and his ailing mind in an asylum; the scene is powerfully written and my heart ached EXACTLY as Eleanor did in leaving her precious Papa to the hands of the capable medical staff. My heart broke even as I read that part.
I do have to say regarding Aunt Adelicia that I was surprised at how welcoming her aunt is when Eleanor moves in. I really thought the aunt would be cordial, cold, and distant, but she is quite the opposite. Even with her own agenda to guide Eleanor with, this aunt really felt like a surrogate mom in so many ways. I didn’t always agree with her methods/intentions, but I respected their relationship and believed that Adelicia was truly determined to see Eleanor entrusted in a solid arrangement. Though she was not my favorite character in the story, she did keep the plot interesting.
I have no interest in Botany or plant life, but I was taken in with Marcus’s passion towards flowers and his brilliant ways of creating the perfect specimens. I didn’t agree with keeping his secrets so tightly hidden, but I did understand his reasons. More than once he had my sympathies and I had no trouble falling for his character as the man for Eleanor. He really was Mr. Darcy to Eleanor’s Elizabeth! (I found Eleanor very similar to Elizabeth Bennett, especially in how she enjoyed walking so much) He understood everything about her heart and endeavored to give her whatever her heart desired, it became his mission throughout to make her smile. Sigh…..
My heart melted over and over again at Eleanor’s cooking for the widows and the children. Oh my, this book is so utterly touching and honoring to fallen soldiers. With the incredible descriptions, the reader feels like you’re THERE with these beautiful souls that Eleanor comes to love as her own family. Mr. Stover, Naomi and Caleb, Mr. Fitch (wow to those donuts), and even Nurse Smith who takes care of Theodore…..I was amazed by the resilience of this community as they blessed Eleanor and made her dreams come true in a TOTALLY different way than she expected!
Without a doubt, Eleanor was my hero through and through! She is compassionate, diligent, fiercely independent, giving, has an amazing heart that would rival ANY royal, faithful, trustworthy, has an adorable sense of humor, utterly intelligent, hardworking, passionate for people and cooking, and always determined to do the right thing. I never ONCE saw her as plain or unappealing, she is so very tall and completely unconventional as a Southern woman, but that only made her MORE appealing and special! Seeing the world through her eyes in this novel moved me more than once and touched me more than I would’ve thought possible for a fictional character. This is my first read by Alexander, but I’m convinced it won’t be my last. I highly recommend this book even if historical fiction is not your typical genre, it will definitely win you over and leave you smiling. Every single part of the plot was addressed, each character got their individual conclusions, and the ending to this story leaves you feeling warm all over. I’m thrilled I got the chance to review this and I’m grateful for the love found in these pages. *also included are discussion questions and a note from the author describing historical facts in the book*
I want to thank the author and Bethany House Publishers for the review copy provided. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed are my own.
What a DE-LIGHT-FUL book!! Goodness, this is my first time reading Alexander’s work, but I sensed something SOOOOOO special about this story I couldn’t pass it up…..indeed, EVERY part of this book was wonderfully written and tangibly enjoyed from the FIRST page! I am NOT a fan of pink, but I couldn’t stop looking at that BEAUTIFUL cover while reading and the story never failed to keep my attention through almost 500 pages. It was such an amazing read that I even forgot to take notes! Yes, this book is FILLED with excellent food and dishes, but mostly it appeals to the reader’s heart through Eleanor and the amazing character she is.
The book begins with Eleanor being a volunteer for the wounded during war in 1864 and this entire scene resonates with her in such a way that she remembers it throughout the story. She even makes a promise to one dying soldier and she doesn’t give up the unlikelihood of fulfilling this promise no matter how many years it takes to do so. Most people would’ve given up after a few attempts, there was no one to keep her accountable and no one would’ve been the wiser about such a failed attempt. However, I believe this promise is one of many instances that strengthens Eleanor’s faith and even brings her much needed healing about love.
Eleanor must move in with her aunt later in the story after leaving her father and his ailing mind in an asylum; the scene is powerfully written and my heart ached EXACTLY as Eleanor did in leaving her precious Papa to the hands of the capable medical staff. My heart broke even as I read that part.
I do have to say regarding Aunt Adelicia that I was surprised at how welcoming her aunt is when Eleanor moves in. I really thought the aunt would be cordial, cold, and distant, but she is quite the opposite. Even with her own agenda to guide Eleanor with, this aunt really felt like a surrogate mom in so many ways. I didn’t always agree with her methods/intentions, but I respected their relationship and believed that Adelicia was truly determined to see Eleanor entrusted in a solid arrangement. Though she was not my favorite character in the story, she did keep the plot interesting.
I have no interest in Botany or plant life, but I was taken in with Marcus’s passion towards flowers and his brilliant ways of creating the perfect specimens. I didn’t agree with keeping his secrets so tightly hidden, but I did understand his reasons. More than once he had my sympathies and I had no trouble falling for his character as the man for Eleanor. He really was Mr. Darcy to Eleanor’s Elizabeth! (I found Eleanor very similar to Elizabeth Bennett, especially in how she enjoyed walking so much) He understood everything about her heart and endeavored to give her whatever her heart desired, it became his mission throughout to make her smile. Sigh…..
My heart melted over and over again at Eleanor’s cooking for the widows and the children. Oh my, this book is so utterly touching and honoring to fallen soldiers. With the incredible descriptions, the reader feels like you’re THERE with these beautiful souls that Eleanor comes to love as her own family. Mr. Stover, Naomi and Caleb, Mr. Fitch (wow to those donuts), and even Nurse Smith who takes care of Theodore…..I was amazed by the resilience of this community as they blessed Eleanor and made her dreams come true in a TOTALLY different way than she expected!
Without a doubt, Eleanor was my hero through and through! She is compassionate, diligent, fiercely independent, giving, has an amazing heart that would rival ANY royal, faithful, trustworthy, has an adorable sense of humor, utterly intelligent, hardworking, passionate for people and cooking, and always determined to do the right thing. I never ONCE saw her as plain or unappealing, she is so very tall and completely unconventional as a Southern woman, but that only made her MORE appealing and special! Seeing the world through her eyes in this novel moved me more than once and touched me more than I would’ve thought possible for a fictional character. This is my first read by Alexander, but I’m convinced it won’t be my last. I highly recommend this book even if historical fiction is not your typical genre, it will definitely win you over and leave you smiling. Every single part of the plot was addressed, each character got their individual conclusions, and the ending to this story leaves you feeling warm all over. I’m thrilled I got the chance to review this and I’m grateful for the love found in these pages. *also included are discussion questions and a note from the author describing historical facts in the book*
I want to thank the author and Bethany House Publishers for the review copy provided. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed are my own.
July 20, 2018
About this book:
“Eleanor Braddock, a spinster--plain, practical, no stunning Southern beauty--has long since dismissed any hope of marriage. But when a dying soldier whispers his final words, she believes her life can still have meaning and determines to find his widow. But this compassionate deed takes a harsh turn, and Eleanor finds herself dependent upon the richest woman in America and the most despised woman in Nashville--her aunt, Adelicia Acklen, mistress of Belmont Mansion. A clandestine act of kindness leads Eleanor to an unlikely path for her life--building a home for destitute widows and children from the Civil War. And while Eleanor knows her own heart, she also knows her aunt will never approve.
Gerhard Marcus Gottfried, Archduke of the House of Habsburg and fourth in line to the Austrian throne, arrives in Nashville in search of a life he determines, instead of one determined for him. Collaborating with botanist Luther Burbank, Marcus seeks to combine his own passion for nature with his expertise in architecture. But his plans to incorporate natural beauty into the design of the widow's and children's home run contrary to the wishes of practical, frugal Eleanor, who sees his ideas as costly nonsense.
Yet as the construction project continues, Marcus and Eleanor find common ground--and a love neither of them expected. But Marcus is not the man Adelicia has chosen for Eleanor to marry, and even if he were, someone who knows Marcus's secrets is about to reveal them all.”
Series: “Belmont Mansion” book #2. Can be a stand-alone novel. (book #1, “A Lasting Impression” here!)
Spiritual Content- Prayers are said; Eleanor & Marcus have a Faith and trust the Lord in their lives.
Negative Content- In the prologue, Eleanor is a nurse and there’s a bit of blood, but it’s not detailed.
Sexual Content- A couple kisses (one lightly detailed)
-Eleanor Braddock
-Marcus Gottfried
P.O.V. switches between them.
471 pages (!!)
Set in 1868 (Prologue in 1864)
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre & New Teens- Four Stars
(only because it’s a large book with a pretty deep story line)
High School Teens- Five Stars
My personal Rating- Five Stars
Reading the first book in the “Belmont Mansion” series, “A Lasting Impression” got me hooked me Miss Tamera Alexander’s writing- as soon as I finished “A Lasting Impression” I was counting down the days till the next book in the series “A Beauty So Rare”. When that day came and the mailman handed me the package…well this was my reaction:
Excited? Who, me? Maybe a LOT! ;)
Miss Tamera Alexander has put “Visit Belmont Mansion” on my Bucket List- and the way she makes you feel like you’re there I could almost check off that I’ve been there! I cannot wait till 2015 when the next book in the “Belmont Mansion” series comes out. :)
And if you’re like me, I love seeing behind the scenes of how the author wrote this book:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVV1E...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher for this review. (But I was going to buy it with my own money- I was that excited about this book!)
“Eleanor Braddock, a spinster--plain, practical, no stunning Southern beauty--has long since dismissed any hope of marriage. But when a dying soldier whispers his final words, she believes her life can still have meaning and determines to find his widow. But this compassionate deed takes a harsh turn, and Eleanor finds herself dependent upon the richest woman in America and the most despised woman in Nashville--her aunt, Adelicia Acklen, mistress of Belmont Mansion. A clandestine act of kindness leads Eleanor to an unlikely path for her life--building a home for destitute widows and children from the Civil War. And while Eleanor knows her own heart, she also knows her aunt will never approve.
Gerhard Marcus Gottfried, Archduke of the House of Habsburg and fourth in line to the Austrian throne, arrives in Nashville in search of a life he determines, instead of one determined for him. Collaborating with botanist Luther Burbank, Marcus seeks to combine his own passion for nature with his expertise in architecture. But his plans to incorporate natural beauty into the design of the widow's and children's home run contrary to the wishes of practical, frugal Eleanor, who sees his ideas as costly nonsense.
Yet as the construction project continues, Marcus and Eleanor find common ground--and a love neither of them expected. But Marcus is not the man Adelicia has chosen for Eleanor to marry, and even if he were, someone who knows Marcus's secrets is about to reveal them all.”
Series: “Belmont Mansion” book #2. Can be a stand-alone novel. (book #1, “A Lasting Impression” here!)
Spiritual Content- Prayers are said; Eleanor & Marcus have a Faith and trust the Lord in their lives.
Negative Content- In the prologue, Eleanor is a nurse and there’s a bit of blood, but it’s not detailed.
Sexual Content- A couple kisses (one lightly detailed)
-Eleanor Braddock
-Marcus Gottfried
P.O.V. switches between them.
471 pages (!!)
Set in 1868 (Prologue in 1864)
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre & New Teens- Four Stars
(only because it’s a large book with a pretty deep story line)
High School Teens- Five Stars
My personal Rating- Five Stars
Reading the first book in the “Belmont Mansion” series, “A Lasting Impression” got me hooked me Miss Tamera Alexander’s writing- as soon as I finished “A Lasting Impression” I was counting down the days till the next book in the series “A Beauty So Rare”. When that day came and the mailman handed me the package…well this was my reaction:
Excited? Who, me? Maybe a LOT! ;)
Miss Tamera Alexander has put “Visit Belmont Mansion” on my Bucket List- and the way she makes you feel like you’re there I could almost check off that I’ve been there! I cannot wait till 2015 when the next book in the “Belmont Mansion” series comes out. :)
And if you’re like me, I love seeing behind the scenes of how the author wrote this book:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVV1E...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher for this review. (But I was going to buy it with my own money- I was that excited about this book!)
April 9, 2016
I am so thankful that the author is not afraid to write a long book. It is not long for the sake of being long, but long to do justice to the plot, and she certainly does that. Besides working several plot threads that require time, Alexander develops the characters, the setting, and the historic detail that bring the novel to life, turning the length purely to her advantage. There is no pointless puttering around, but every passage is working towards the conclusion.
The author does a marvelous job setting the story in history. It is not just a romance that takes place after the Civil War - it is a meticulously researched tale firmly anchored in the Reconstruction era with real people and events. The rise of women's shelters, safe asylums for the insane, troubled relations between Austria and Russia, research with plant genetics and grafting, the search for a potato not prone to rot - all were issues being dealt with at the time. Not only were Adelicia Acklen, her immediate family, and her servants all real, set in the meticulously described Belmont estate, but so also were numerous places described in Nashville, such as the insane asylum. Additionally, historic figures such as Dorothea Dix (activist for the insane), Gregor Mendel (geneticist), and Luther Burbank (developer of the Russet potato) cameo in the story.
One of the strongest themes of the story (hinted at by the title) is that of beauty. Eleanor knows that true beauty is dependent on what is inside a person, not in their outward appearance; however, as a plain woman, she struggles with the fact that, by worldly standards, she isn't beautiful. There are few women I've known who cannot relate with that feeling of deficiency, no matter their outward appearance. And the author makes a really good point - something I have noticed myself - that the better you know someone and the more you love them, the more beautiful they become. And conversely, the uglier a person acts, the less and less attractive they appear, no matter how physically flawless. In this world where so much weight is placed on physical appearance, it is good to be reminded of what beauty truly is.
I suspect historical novels such as this - by captivating my interest and prompting me to research further - have led to as much if not more of my knowledge of history than I learned in school. Like all of Alexander's books, this novel is rich with historic detail, a well-thought-out plot, faith, and encouragement. 5 out of 5 stars!
Thank you First Reads and Bethany House for providing a free copy!
The author does a marvelous job setting the story in history. It is not just a romance that takes place after the Civil War - it is a meticulously researched tale firmly anchored in the Reconstruction era with real people and events. The rise of women's shelters, safe asylums for the insane, troubled relations between Austria and Russia, research with plant genetics and grafting, the search for a potato not prone to rot - all were issues being dealt with at the time. Not only were Adelicia Acklen, her immediate family, and her servants all real, set in the meticulously described Belmont estate, but so also were numerous places described in Nashville, such as the insane asylum. Additionally, historic figures such as Dorothea Dix (activist for the insane), Gregor Mendel (geneticist), and Luther Burbank (developer of the Russet potato) cameo in the story.
One of the strongest themes of the story (hinted at by the title) is that of beauty. Eleanor knows that true beauty is dependent on what is inside a person, not in their outward appearance; however, as a plain woman, she struggles with the fact that, by worldly standards, she isn't beautiful. There are few women I've known who cannot relate with that feeling of deficiency, no matter their outward appearance. And the author makes a really good point - something I have noticed myself - that the better you know someone and the more you love them, the more beautiful they become. And conversely, the uglier a person acts, the less and less attractive they appear, no matter how physically flawless. In this world where so much weight is placed on physical appearance, it is good to be reminded of what beauty truly is.
I suspect historical novels such as this - by captivating my interest and prompting me to research further - have led to as much if not more of my knowledge of history than I learned in school. Like all of Alexander's books, this novel is rich with historic detail, a well-thought-out plot, faith, and encouragement. 5 out of 5 stars!
Thank you First Reads and Bethany House for providing a free copy!
April 17, 2023
I haven't read a lot of Tamera Alexander, but I appreciate that her stories have bulk - that they deal with multiple storylines and the whole person and problems that aren't solved in 150 pages. I didn't enjoy the relationship triangles, especially since the outside characters were such caricatured "villains" and just overall brought the story down. But otherwise it was a good book, about "older" characters coming into their own and the purpose God had prepared them for.
August 15, 2017
I’m very behind with this review due to enjoying a wonderful Christmas season and putting my eARC reviews high on the priority list. My mother-in-law even asked me why I hadn’t reviewed it yet! (I loaned her book #1 a few months ago.) So, here we go. (For those of you who regularly read my reviews, you will note a bit of a “rerun” on the bottom of this review from my review for To Win Her Favor about the books in this series and those of Ms. Alexander’s other recent series set in the Nashville area.) Let me just say briefly that if you are likely to read the entire series, I’d recommend starting at the beginning. It isn’t essential, though, as this is a standalone novel with no loose ends.
A Beauty So Rare (2014, Bethany House), second in the Belmont Mansion series by Tamera Alexander, is a historical Christian romance set in Nashville, Tennessee in 1868. I read this book because I received it as a gift, and because Ms. Alexander is one of the few authors I try to keep up with.
Rating: 5 stars
The heroine: Eleanor Braddock, 29, has served as her father’s caretaker for a few years, but is now dropping her father off to live at a rest home with a heavy heart. Her aunt, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, the mistress of Belmont Mansion, used her influence to secure a spot for Eleanor’s father at the rest home, and has invited Eleanor to live at Belmont.
The hero: Marcus Geoffrey, 33, desires “to experience the life of the common man.” So who is he, what is he doing, and why is he not a common man? He is “the Archduke Gerhard Marcus Gottfried von Habsburg”, second in line to be the emperor of Austria. He has, to his frustration, been much sought after by wealthy women in his country wanting a good match. Marcus has come to America incognito, with Mrs. Cheatham as “his benefactress of sorts.” Even though Marcus comes from a privileged background, he is intelligent and has aspirations in two occupations simultaneously. I found both to be very interesting.
Waiting in line at the post office, Marcus sees Eleanor. He recognizes her as the recently-arrived niece of Mrs. Cheatham. “He had no intention of pursuing her acquaintance, nor encouraging it in any way.” When I went back to review my flagged quotes for writing this review, I nearly laughed at this one, because Marcus becomes very good friends with Eleanor later on.
Christian elements:
*From an early age, I’ve been taught to tell the truth by my parents, my church, and the Bible. I believe wholeheartedly in this, and teach the same to my children. On a purely practical level, having a reputation for consistently telling the truth (even to one’s own detriment) is essential to being trustworthy. I see this upheld again and again in my daily life as a mother.
In the prologue, Eleanor deceives a patient three times in order to comfort him. As this is a Christian novel, I was taken aback by this, because I felt the deception was presented in a positive way. I have mixed feelings about this. But I’ve never been in the presence of a dying person, and it seems like it would be a catch-22 situation. It’s tough situations like these that make me wonder what Jesus would have done. (In parenting, I very occasionally take the “I do not want to answer your question” way out. It gives me the opportunity to be honest without giving information I do not wish to share, while simultaneously guarding against feeling tempted to lie.) However, the deathbed scene was a very small portion of the story, and Eleanor’s actions were obviously done with the best of intentions.
What I liked:
*I like the fact that this series is unified not only by Belmont Mansion, but also by the fact that the heroines’ skills are front and center in the plot of each book. (The heroine in book one is a skilled painter, book two’s heroine is a skilled cook, and the heroine in book three is a skilled musician.) These kinds of parallels make me happy. :-D
*I think it’s hilarious that the dress Eleanor wears on the cover is her hated pink (but unfortunately, best) dress! Too funny!
*Alzheimer’s disease (or something very similar) is an issue in this book, and Ms. Alexander does a remarkable job depicting the effects of it. My mind was in shock at some aspects of the disease which I had never considered before.
What I didn’t like:
*I can only point to the deception issue as outlined above, which isn’t enough to bring it down from five stars. As I always find with Tamera Alexander, this was a tightly woven story.
--------------------------------------------
I will definitely continue to read more of Ms. Alexander’s stories. I have put To Mend a Dream (a novella in the Among the Fair Magnolias collection), on my to-read list. I recommend this book to fans of Tamera Alexander and Christian historical romance. I have no compunctions about recommending this book to teens and up.
---------------------------------------------
The timeline of the Belle Meade Plantation and Belmont Mansion series are intertwined. (They’re very near each other in Nashville.) At the bottom of this review, I’ve listed the six books (and one novella) of the two series in what I believe to be the chronologically correct order. (A Beauty So Rare actually ends up being third in the sequence of seven stories.) For your convenience, see the list below.
A Lasting Impression , (Belmont Mansion #1, published 2011)
To Whisper Her Name (Belle Meade Plantation #1, published 2012)
A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion, #2, 2014) (set in 1868)
To Win Her Favor , (Belle Meade Plantation #2, published 2015) (set in 1869-1870)
To Mend a Dream , (Belle Meade #2.5, published 2015 in Among the Fair Magnolias )
A Note Yet Unsung , (Belmont Mansion #3, 2017)
To Wager Her Heart , (Belle Meade Plantation #3, 2017)
A Beauty So Rare (2014, Bethany House), second in the Belmont Mansion series by Tamera Alexander, is a historical Christian romance set in Nashville, Tennessee in 1868. I read this book because I received it as a gift, and because Ms. Alexander is one of the few authors I try to keep up with.
Rating: 5 stars
The heroine: Eleanor Braddock, 29, has served as her father’s caretaker for a few years, but is now dropping her father off to live at a rest home with a heavy heart. Her aunt, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, the mistress of Belmont Mansion, used her influence to secure a spot for Eleanor’s father at the rest home, and has invited Eleanor to live at Belmont.
The hero: Marcus Geoffrey, 33, desires “to experience the life of the common man.” So who is he, what is he doing, and why is he not a common man? He is “the Archduke Gerhard Marcus Gottfried von Habsburg”, second in line to be the emperor of Austria. He has, to his frustration, been much sought after by wealthy women in his country wanting a good match. Marcus has come to America incognito, with Mrs. Cheatham as “his benefactress of sorts.” Even though Marcus comes from a privileged background, he is intelligent and has aspirations in two occupations simultaneously. I found both to be very interesting.
Waiting in line at the post office, Marcus sees Eleanor. He recognizes her as the recently-arrived niece of Mrs. Cheatham. “He had no intention of pursuing her acquaintance, nor encouraging it in any way.” When I went back to review my flagged quotes for writing this review, I nearly laughed at this one, because Marcus becomes very good friends with Eleanor later on.
Christian elements:
*From an early age, I’ve been taught to tell the truth by my parents, my church, and the Bible. I believe wholeheartedly in this, and teach the same to my children. On a purely practical level, having a reputation for consistently telling the truth (even to one’s own detriment) is essential to being trustworthy. I see this upheld again and again in my daily life as a mother.
In the prologue, Eleanor deceives a patient three times in order to comfort him. As this is a Christian novel, I was taken aback by this, because I felt the deception was presented in a positive way. I have mixed feelings about this. But I’ve never been in the presence of a dying person, and it seems like it would be a catch-22 situation. It’s tough situations like these that make me wonder what Jesus would have done. (In parenting, I very occasionally take the “I do not want to answer your question” way out. It gives me the opportunity to be honest without giving information I do not wish to share, while simultaneously guarding against feeling tempted to lie.) However, the deathbed scene was a very small portion of the story, and Eleanor’s actions were obviously done with the best of intentions.
What I liked:
*I like the fact that this series is unified not only by Belmont Mansion, but also by the fact that the heroines’ skills are front and center in the plot of each book. (The heroine in book one is a skilled painter, book two’s heroine is a skilled cook, and the heroine in book three is a skilled musician.) These kinds of parallels make me happy. :-D
*I think it’s hilarious that the dress Eleanor wears on the cover is her hated pink (but unfortunately, best) dress! Too funny!
*Alzheimer’s disease (or something very similar) is an issue in this book, and Ms. Alexander does a remarkable job depicting the effects of it. My mind was in shock at some aspects of the disease which I had never considered before.
What I didn’t like:
*I can only point to the deception issue as outlined above, which isn’t enough to bring it down from five stars. As I always find with Tamera Alexander, this was a tightly woven story.
--------------------------------------------
I will definitely continue to read more of Ms. Alexander’s stories. I have put To Mend a Dream (a novella in the Among the Fair Magnolias collection), on my to-read list. I recommend this book to fans of Tamera Alexander and Christian historical romance. I have no compunctions about recommending this book to teens and up.
---------------------------------------------
The timeline of the Belle Meade Plantation and Belmont Mansion series are intertwined. (They’re very near each other in Nashville.) At the bottom of this review, I’ve listed the six books (and one novella) of the two series in what I believe to be the chronologically correct order. (A Beauty So Rare actually ends up being third in the sequence of seven stories.) For your convenience, see the list below.
A Lasting Impression , (Belmont Mansion #1, published 2011)
To Whisper Her Name (Belle Meade Plantation #1, published 2012)
A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion, #2, 2014) (set in 1868)
To Win Her Favor , (Belle Meade Plantation #2, published 2015) (set in 1869-1870)
To Mend a Dream , (Belle Meade #2.5, published 2015 in Among the Fair Magnolias )
A Note Yet Unsung , (Belmont Mansion #3, 2017)
To Wager Her Heart , (Belle Meade Plantation #3, 2017)
August 15, 2024
Both of the first two books in this series are very much influenced by the American Civil War. The setting is Nashville, TN, just after the war ended. I didn't label the first one as civil war because it was after. However, the prologue of this book takes place in the middle of the fighting; so I am going to count this one for my RATA challenge.
February 9, 2017
Impoverished and struggling to care for her ailing father, Eleanor arrives at Belmont Mansion, home of her aunt, Adelicia Acklen, the richest woman in America--and possibly the most demanding, as well. Adelicia insists on finding her niece a husband, but a simple act of kindness leads Eleanor down a far different path--building a home for destitute widows and fatherless children from the Civil War. While Eleanor knows her own heart, she also knows her aunt will never approve of this endeavor. Archduke Marcus Gottfried has come to Nashville from Austria in search of a life he determines, instead of one determined for him. Hiding his royal heritage, Marcus longs to combine his passion for nature with his expertise in architecture. But Marcus is not the man Adelicia has chosen for Eleanor, and even if he were, someone who knows his secrets is about to reveal them all.
This second book in the Belmont Mansion series is set immediately after the Civil War. Alexander has an incredible gift of combining romance with historical aspects and setting. Her books never disappoint in giving a story that captures your attention from start to finish. Filled with 2 wonderful main characters, Eleanor and Marcus, and supported by so many delightful secondary characters, this story depicts the aftermath of war so well in the widows and children left behind by the men who fought and died in the War. Eleanor's care and concern for them was always at the forefront of every decision she made even when it came to love and her father. Alexander did an excellent job of portraying Eleanor's father, Theodore, and the various aspects of dementia and how it was handled during that time period. Marcus was definitely a charismatic charmer who saw beyond Eleanor's "plain exterior" to her inner beauty that in turn made him see her as a beautiful woman. I look forward to reading the rest of the Belmont Series.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "Every brick laid in the foundation of a life, however meaningfully or haphazardly placed, shaped the whole."
"Not everything has to be beautiful to be worthy of admiration..."
"She wasn't responsible for seeing to everyone's needs. That was God's responsibility. Hers was to do what He brought to her attention, what He placed in her path."
"The goodbyes here are only temporary. Someday there will be only together forever."
This second book in the Belmont Mansion series is set immediately after the Civil War. Alexander has an incredible gift of combining romance with historical aspects and setting. Her books never disappoint in giving a story that captures your attention from start to finish. Filled with 2 wonderful main characters, Eleanor and Marcus, and supported by so many delightful secondary characters, this story depicts the aftermath of war so well in the widows and children left behind by the men who fought and died in the War. Eleanor's care and concern for them was always at the forefront of every decision she made even when it came to love and her father. Alexander did an excellent job of portraying Eleanor's father, Theodore, and the various aspects of dementia and how it was handled during that time period. Marcus was definitely a charismatic charmer who saw beyond Eleanor's "plain exterior" to her inner beauty that in turn made him see her as a beautiful woman. I look forward to reading the rest of the Belmont Series.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "Every brick laid in the foundation of a life, however meaningfully or haphazardly placed, shaped the whole."
"Not everything has to be beautiful to be worthy of admiration..."
"She wasn't responsible for seeing to everyone's needs. That was God's responsibility. Hers was to do what He brought to her attention, what He placed in her path."
"The goodbyes here are only temporary. Someday there will be only together forever."
April 17, 2014
Beauty So Rare, A
~Bethany House Publishers
5.0 out of 5 stars Another Belmont Hit!, March 24, 2014
By Carrie F. Pagels "Carrie Fancett Pagels"
This review is from: Beauty So Rare, A (A Belmont Mansion Novel Book #2) (Kindle Edition)
What a wonderful read! A Beauty So Rare starts out a little bit slow but have no worries, Tamera Alexander soon takes off with a story wonderfully woven. I was tickled pink over heroine, Eleanor's reaction to certain colors of clothing, which I enjoy. Mr. Geoffries, a German archduke, and is a wonderful hero. Eleanor is strong and capable and learns to trust her heart, over the course of the story. Loved the secondary characters, with the widowed ladies and their children receiving help through the H/H's efforts. Some terrific antagonists, with great characterization. Highly recommend--don't miss this!
This is the second book in the Belmont series and I can't wait to read the next book when it releases!
This book will be on my best of 2014 list on my blog, Overcoming With God.
I purchased this book as a paperback through Amazon but I also received a Kindle copy through NetGalley and am under no compulsion to post a positive review. The reviewers on the OWG blog love Tamera's books so much that we made sure everyone got a copy of this new release, in paperback, for the gorgeous cover, too.
~Bethany House Publishers
5.0 out of 5 stars Another Belmont Hit!, March 24, 2014
By Carrie F. Pagels "Carrie Fancett Pagels"
This review is from: Beauty So Rare, A (A Belmont Mansion Novel Book #2) (Kindle Edition)
What a wonderful read! A Beauty So Rare starts out a little bit slow but have no worries, Tamera Alexander soon takes off with a story wonderfully woven. I was tickled pink over heroine, Eleanor's reaction to certain colors of clothing, which I enjoy. Mr. Geoffries, a German archduke, and is a wonderful hero. Eleanor is strong and capable and learns to trust her heart, over the course of the story. Loved the secondary characters, with the widowed ladies and their children receiving help through the H/H's efforts. Some terrific antagonists, with great characterization. Highly recommend--don't miss this!
This is the second book in the Belmont series and I can't wait to read the next book when it releases!
This book will be on my best of 2014 list on my blog, Overcoming With God.
I purchased this book as a paperback through Amazon but I also received a Kindle copy through NetGalley and am under no compulsion to post a positive review. The reviewers on the OWG blog love Tamera's books so much that we made sure everyone got a copy of this new release, in paperback, for the gorgeous cover, too.
February 26, 2019
While I liked this book, I don't think it was as strong as the other Tamera Alexander novels I've read. I liked both Eleanor and Marcus, and saw character growth in both of them to some extent (though it seemed more so with Marcus), and I really liked that their relationship was based on friendship.
I wasn't a fan of the way they both 'lied by omission' to each other, especially after their friendship was strong. There was one part that was especially bothersome to me, when Eleanor questioned Marcus' integrity, choosing to believe something that a character she knew far less than she knew Marcus said about him, rather than Marcus himself. Those issues (the lying, and the mistrust) weren't dealt with at all, to my way of thinking. Just kinda swept under the rug, which didn't sit well with me.
I liked the book, and I will definitely be finishing out the series (as well as reading other Tamera Alexander books) simply because I feel like this was a one-off 'miss' (if you can even call it that), since all the other books I've read by the author have been amazing.
I wasn't a fan of the way they both 'lied by omission' to each other, especially after their friendship was strong. There was one part that was especially bothersome to me, when Eleanor questioned Marcus' integrity, choosing to believe something that a character she knew far less than she knew Marcus said about him, rather than Marcus himself. Those issues (the lying, and the mistrust) weren't dealt with at all, to my way of thinking. Just kinda swept under the rug, which didn't sit well with me.
I liked the book, and I will definitely be finishing out the series (as well as reading other Tamera Alexander books) simply because I feel like this was a one-off 'miss' (if you can even call it that), since all the other books I've read by the author have been amazing.
September 8, 2020
If you enjoy reading stories about the Postbellum era then yes I recommend this book. The characters are real with faults and with strengths. There are portions that will stir a sympathetic chord in your heart, but there are also portions that will have you spouting at the characters. It is a very well balanced story. You will find some characters insufferable, but the main characters you will love and root for as they reach for their dreams and face challenges that were a basic truth of the era. It is a different sort of story from this particular time in history. I am finding Tamera Alexander to be a delightful author. She touches on things that are not often spoken of in other books written about this era. They will in turn cause you to pause and think a little more about what many faced as they rebuilt their beloved homeland.
May 2, 2023
2019 Rating: 5/5
2023 Rating: 4/5
I thoroughly enjoyed my re-read of this book, although I felt the pacing was too slow at times and I didn't connect to the romance as much as I was hoping to. Otherwise a great story.
2023 Rating: 4/5
I thoroughly enjoyed my re-read of this book, although I felt the pacing was too slow at times and I didn't connect to the romance as much as I was hoping to. Otherwise a great story.
April 23, 2014
I was very excited when I saw the cover for A Beauty so Rare. I have to say, before reading it I was wondering whether the plot would be a repeat of the first two books in the series. However, it was decidedly not. It wasn’t much similar to Lasting Impressions or To Whisper Her Name save for the time period. But I think I enjoyed it even more than them, if that is even possible.
I have read all of Tamera Alexander's books and I do believe that A Beauty so Rare is my absolute favorite of all that she has written yet! I think it’s because her heroine was so unique. Most heroine's I read about are pretty and feminine and dreamy and sweet. Eleanor Braddock is considered plain and sensible and too tall. I think I liked her all the more because the author chose to make her those things. Again and again Eleanor’s practical side was revealed. Practicality is usually not a trait in the women of historical Christian fiction published today. But it certainly was in Eleanor.
Marcus was also an enjoyable character. He offset Eleanor’s practical side perfectly. I loved reading how their banter played out throughout the novel. It was almost flirting but not quite because they were both determined to be “just friends”. Yes…well…saying that never really does seem to work, does it? I really liked how he kept on going after what he wanted. No matter if it was his career, the new kind of potato he was trying to breed, or the woman he fell in love with, he kept pursuing and never gave up. He also showed remarkable restraint and respect toward Eleanor, which I greatly admire. He was also patient and intelligent and strong and…well…nearly perfect now that I think about it. His flaw was that he had a somewhat shady past despite his being an Archduke. But other than that he was perfect.
The relationship between Eleanor and her aunt was both well-written and complex. Adelica Acklen was, after all, the richest woman in America. I think I held my breath every time Eleanor needed to talk to her about something. Adelicia had the most interesting personality which was both undeniably feminine and unbelievably headstrong. She always knew her opinions, stuck to her ideals, and never wavered in anything. I found the conversations she had with Eleanor quite interesting. And sometimes I couldn’t help but cringe and think, “Poor Eleanor!” with absolute horror as her aunt severely scolded her for something. But unlike most female characters, Eleanor was always practical about her emotional response to her aunt’s sometimes severe diatribes. She never cried. She adjusted her behavior and moved on, never thinking about it twice.
I have always admired the way Tamera Alexander incorporates other languages in her books. German was highly prominent in this one. However, I was somewhat confused when sometimes the German was not translated. I was left a little bewildered and trying to piece together what the characters were saying. I can’t read German, though it is slightly similar to English. At a few places I had to go back and re-read the German to try to find out what was said because it was not translated. Sometimes the translation was given a few pages later, though. But most often not. This was the only flaw I could find with the book as a whole. Otherwise, it was perfectly delightful and wonderful in every way. Though A Beauty So Rare is close to 500 pages, because I had such a blissful experience reading it I sooo wanted there to be more once I reached the end!
One more thing I'll mention that I was impressed with before I conclude. She included characters from her last two books! I almost didn't catch their subtle introduction to the story because it has been so long since I've read To Whisper Her Name and Lasting Impressions. However, I managed to do so and enjoyed the novel even more because I did. So, although her books do not need to be read together I do suggest reading them in the order they were published because it will increase your enjoyment of each story. Also (and I just realized this) To Whisper Her Name is the first in the Belle Meade Plantation Series. Lasting Impressions is the first in the Belmont Mansion Series and A Beauty so Rare is the second in the Belmont Mansion Series. However, they all three still are set in the same time frame with characters that intertwine with one another, though loosely.
Bravo, Tamera Alexander! I am expectantly looking forward to your next novel. I didn't want A Beauty so Rare to end and was thoroughly disappointed that it had to. Your book left me breathless sometimes and blissful the rest of the time. I do believe that this one has a 100% chance of my reading it again! May the Lord bless you in the writing of your next novel. It cannot come soon enough for me!
I give this book 4/12 out of 5 stars.
*I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publishers for an honest review, which I have given. The opinions expressed in this review are mine and mine alone.
I have read all of Tamera Alexander's books and I do believe that A Beauty so Rare is my absolute favorite of all that she has written yet! I think it’s because her heroine was so unique. Most heroine's I read about are pretty and feminine and dreamy and sweet. Eleanor Braddock is considered plain and sensible and too tall. I think I liked her all the more because the author chose to make her those things. Again and again Eleanor’s practical side was revealed. Practicality is usually not a trait in the women of historical Christian fiction published today. But it certainly was in Eleanor.
Marcus was also an enjoyable character. He offset Eleanor’s practical side perfectly. I loved reading how their banter played out throughout the novel. It was almost flirting but not quite because they were both determined to be “just friends”. Yes…well…saying that never really does seem to work, does it? I really liked how he kept on going after what he wanted. No matter if it was his career, the new kind of potato he was trying to breed, or the woman he fell in love with, he kept pursuing and never gave up. He also showed remarkable restraint and respect toward Eleanor, which I greatly admire. He was also patient and intelligent and strong and…well…nearly perfect now that I think about it. His flaw was that he had a somewhat shady past despite his being an Archduke. But other than that he was perfect.
The relationship between Eleanor and her aunt was both well-written and complex. Adelica Acklen was, after all, the richest woman in America. I think I held my breath every time Eleanor needed to talk to her about something. Adelicia had the most interesting personality which was both undeniably feminine and unbelievably headstrong. She always knew her opinions, stuck to her ideals, and never wavered in anything. I found the conversations she had with Eleanor quite interesting. And sometimes I couldn’t help but cringe and think, “Poor Eleanor!” with absolute horror as her aunt severely scolded her for something. But unlike most female characters, Eleanor was always practical about her emotional response to her aunt’s sometimes severe diatribes. She never cried. She adjusted her behavior and moved on, never thinking about it twice.
I have always admired the way Tamera Alexander incorporates other languages in her books. German was highly prominent in this one. However, I was somewhat confused when sometimes the German was not translated. I was left a little bewildered and trying to piece together what the characters were saying. I can’t read German, though it is slightly similar to English. At a few places I had to go back and re-read the German to try to find out what was said because it was not translated. Sometimes the translation was given a few pages later, though. But most often not. This was the only flaw I could find with the book as a whole. Otherwise, it was perfectly delightful and wonderful in every way. Though A Beauty So Rare is close to 500 pages, because I had such a blissful experience reading it I sooo wanted there to be more once I reached the end!
One more thing I'll mention that I was impressed with before I conclude. She included characters from her last two books! I almost didn't catch their subtle introduction to the story because it has been so long since I've read To Whisper Her Name and Lasting Impressions. However, I managed to do so and enjoyed the novel even more because I did. So, although her books do not need to be read together I do suggest reading them in the order they were published because it will increase your enjoyment of each story. Also (and I just realized this) To Whisper Her Name is the first in the Belle Meade Plantation Series. Lasting Impressions is the first in the Belmont Mansion Series and A Beauty so Rare is the second in the Belmont Mansion Series. However, they all three still are set in the same time frame with characters that intertwine with one another, though loosely.
Bravo, Tamera Alexander! I am expectantly looking forward to your next novel. I didn't want A Beauty so Rare to end and was thoroughly disappointed that it had to. Your book left me breathless sometimes and blissful the rest of the time. I do believe that this one has a 100% chance of my reading it again! May the Lord bless you in the writing of your next novel. It cannot come soon enough for me!
I give this book 4/12 out of 5 stars.
*I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publishers for an honest review, which I have given. The opinions expressed in this review are mine and mine alone.
October 23, 2025
I'm kind of reading this series in reverse, but thankfully, it works. I started with the last book in the series first, A Note Yet Unsung. Even though these books are in order, they can still work as a stand-alone.
Tamera Alexander brings post Civil War Nashville to life in this 2nd installment of the Bellemont Mansion series. There is very intricate detail to the historical facts that pop off of the page. The characters are very well fleshed out. Along with those two very important things, she has very real issues for these characters to face.
Elanor Braddock is a woman, who is now a spinster at her age. She is considered plain, and is now poor woman, who must rely on extended family to get by. She must also worry about and care for her fathers failing mental health. There wasn't a lot of knowledge of dementia and other mental issues at the time, but with the portrayal that Tamera showed, I would hope it was like it. It was heart breaking to read about, but the love that Elanor showed was hopeful and the staff she had to rely on, you routed for best outcome possible, even though with how it is today, you already know how it is.
It was a tough subject, but it was an amazing topic to be touched on.
Marcus has been added to my dream hero list. He was one who even though had a rough past, wants to change from it. He doesn't want to follow in his family footsteps. And what a family he has! The mystery and intrigue behind them kept me wanting to read more.
Marcus and Elanor I thought were the perfect balance to each other. They came from different backgrounds, but their passions were similar. Elanor was a woman who had very giving heart and seeing what all she was willing to give up to help made me think and ask, what could I do. Even though fictional, she was an inspiring character. Her desire for those around her was fantastic to read about.
I can't wait to read the first book from this series and see all the pieces. I also can't wait to go and search out even more books by Tamera Alexander. She is an author who has moved to my favorites list.
This review was originally posted @ www.readwithkate.com
Tamera Alexander brings post Civil War Nashville to life in this 2nd installment of the Bellemont Mansion series. There is very intricate detail to the historical facts that pop off of the page. The characters are very well fleshed out. Along with those two very important things, she has very real issues for these characters to face.
Elanor Braddock is a woman, who is now a spinster at her age. She is considered plain, and is now poor woman, who must rely on extended family to get by. She must also worry about and care for her fathers failing mental health. There wasn't a lot of knowledge of dementia and other mental issues at the time, but with the portrayal that Tamera showed, I would hope it was like it. It was heart breaking to read about, but the love that Elanor showed was hopeful and the staff she had to rely on, you routed for best outcome possible, even though with how it is today, you already know how it is.
It was a tough subject, but it was an amazing topic to be touched on.
Marcus has been added to my dream hero list. He was one who even though had a rough past, wants to change from it. He doesn't want to follow in his family footsteps. And what a family he has! The mystery and intrigue behind them kept me wanting to read more.
Marcus and Elanor I thought were the perfect balance to each other. They came from different backgrounds, but their passions were similar. Elanor was a woman who had very giving heart and seeing what all she was willing to give up to help made me think and ask, what could I do. Even though fictional, she was an inspiring character. Her desire for those around her was fantastic to read about.
I can't wait to read the first book from this series and see all the pieces. I also can't wait to go and search out even more books by Tamera Alexander. She is an author who has moved to my favorites list.
This review was originally posted @ www.readwithkate.com
May 26, 2015
I adore Tamera Alexander's historical romances set in post Civil War Nashville. They capture the essence of reconstruction in a realistic way while telling a story I can disappear into. This story-telling sets a high standard and leaves me wondering if she can do it again. She does!
In A Beauty so Rare, Eleanor Braddock is not a beautiful woman in the traditional southern sense, so she has resigned herself to a life of singleness. because of her father's illness she has to find a way to support herself. The story weaves in the plight of war widows and orphans while also pulling in an element of European royalty. Trust me: it works beautifully. And in the telling, the author addresses true beauty and the importance of looking beyond the superficial to the heart and essence of a person. I finished the last page with a happy sigh for a story well told, quickly followed by a sad sigh because now I have to wait for her next book!
If you love antebellum historical romance with strong Christian threads, you will adore this story that transports you to that time in Nashville.
In A Beauty so Rare, Eleanor Braddock is not a beautiful woman in the traditional southern sense, so she has resigned herself to a life of singleness. because of her father's illness she has to find a way to support herself. The story weaves in the plight of war widows and orphans while also pulling in an element of European royalty. Trust me: it works beautifully. And in the telling, the author addresses true beauty and the importance of looking beyond the superficial to the heart and essence of a person. I finished the last page with a happy sigh for a story well told, quickly followed by a sad sigh because now I have to wait for her next book!
If you love antebellum historical romance with strong Christian threads, you will adore this story that transports you to that time in Nashville.
February 23, 2022
I enjoyed A Beauty So Rare even more than the first book of this series. I forgot how rich Tamera Alexander's writing is - rich in culture, history, tone, and description. Her style made this book a delight to read. But the characters are what really brought it to life. Eleanor was phenomenal, both in her character and in the author's portrayal of her wisdom and strength, balanced with a touch of delicacy. If she existed in real life, I would highly respect and admire her - which I don't often say of many main characters, regardless of the genre. Marcus made for a unique, well-crafted character, a blend of gruff and compassionate, with an enjoyable sense of humor.
I'll admit, I'm not a regular romance reader, and there were a few times where the romance in this book felt a little excessive, though not inappropriate. Hence the four stars instead of five - but again, this is more my preference than anything against the book.
I'll admit, I'm not a regular romance reader, and there were a few times where the romance in this book felt a little excessive, though not inappropriate. Hence the four stars instead of five - but again, this is more my preference than anything against the book.
February 7, 2017
Part of what I said about the first novel of this series holds true for this second one: "I really loved this historical novel. It was a complex, sweet story, and I enjoyed the characters." Also like the first novel, this second one was written well and had well developed characters; however, there wasn't an element of suspense in this one as there was in the first, which I was a bit disappointed by, but I still really loved the novel and how the main characters gradually ended up truly becoming known to the other with no important secrets left between them. So, this novel joins its predecessor on my favorites list.
December 22, 2017
This book wasn’t bad, there was just a lot going on, plot-wise, that never seemed to go anywhere. For instance:
She was from a high social standing but was now poor. She helped out the doctors during the war and saw a lot of men die. She held on to a dying man’s handkerchief and wanted to find his wife to return it. Her only brother died in the war. Her father had dementia and was put into an asylum. Her mother was dead. Her very rich aunt arranged a marriage for her but she didn’t go through with it. The haughty women’s league member (and daughter) didn’t like her and spread lies. She disobeyed her aunt and started a charity kitchen. She got engaged to a different man she didn’t love. She was too tall and too plain and too old. She thought he was an under gardener when he was an archduke. She thought his desires to make things beautiful just to be beautiful was frivolous. A man like that would never be interested in her, although he was just an under gardener. She started a home for widows and orphans. She runs out of money and is desperate. He was a European archduke incognito in Nashville. His father and uncle didn’t approve of his pursuits. He was a reformed rake, maybe. His older brother committed suicide and shamed the royal family. He was a brilliant botanist. He was trying to create a specific color of rose for her aunt but never succeeded. He was trying to fix the issues with potatoes but never succeeded. He was engaged since childhood to an awful woman he didn’t love. He was a brilliant architect who wanted to build new buildings but couldn’t win any contracts because of the manipulations of the jerk mayor. The mayor spread lies about him and did shady deals. He befriended orphans and poor people. He was never forthcoming with the truth. He met and befriended her mentally ill father but didn’t tell her. She hid her father’s condition from him because she was ashamed. He thought she was neglecting her father based on her father’s mentally ill ravings. He proposed multiple times and she turned him down. She decided on a remodel (which hurt his feelings because he wanted to build a new building). Her aunt disapproved of her match because she didn’t thatknow he was royalty. He refuses the throne and never return home. He convinces his fiancé to seek a different duke, but not until after she meets the heroine and ruins everything.
So many of these plot threads should have blown things up, caused dramatic problems that had to be worked on for a considerable time to be solved. But they didn’t. It felt like nothing came to fruition. If someone was mad, they weren’t three paragraphs later. He hid his identity from her, shouldn’t she care? He caught her in hiding the truth about her father, shouldn’t he confront her? She promised to marry another man after she kissed him, isn’t that a big deal? He never said he was engaged, and then a beautiful and terrible woman just shows up and claims him, wouldn’t that make her feel betrayed? Shouldn’t there be some kind of conflict and resolution after all this buildup? So many plot lines went nowhere. The author should have picked 5 things from the above list and written a good book about them instead of dragging on forever trying to include everything.
#rantover
She was from a high social standing but was now poor. She helped out the doctors during the war and saw a lot of men die. She held on to a dying man’s handkerchief and wanted to find his wife to return it. Her only brother died in the war. Her father had dementia and was put into an asylum. Her mother was dead. Her very rich aunt arranged a marriage for her but she didn’t go through with it. The haughty women’s league member (and daughter) didn’t like her and spread lies. She disobeyed her aunt and started a charity kitchen. She got engaged to a different man she didn’t love. She was too tall and too plain and too old. She thought he was an under gardener when he was an archduke. She thought his desires to make things beautiful just to be beautiful was frivolous. A man like that would never be interested in her, although he was just an under gardener. She started a home for widows and orphans. She runs out of money and is desperate. He was a European archduke incognito in Nashville. His father and uncle didn’t approve of his pursuits. He was a reformed rake, maybe. His older brother committed suicide and shamed the royal family. He was a brilliant botanist. He was trying to create a specific color of rose for her aunt but never succeeded. He was trying to fix the issues with potatoes but never succeeded. He was engaged since childhood to an awful woman he didn’t love. He was a brilliant architect who wanted to build new buildings but couldn’t win any contracts because of the manipulations of the jerk mayor. The mayor spread lies about him and did shady deals. He befriended orphans and poor people. He was never forthcoming with the truth. He met and befriended her mentally ill father but didn’t tell her. She hid her father’s condition from him because she was ashamed. He thought she was neglecting her father based on her father’s mentally ill ravings. He proposed multiple times and she turned him down. She decided on a remodel (which hurt his feelings because he wanted to build a new building). Her aunt disapproved of her match because she didn’t thatknow he was royalty. He refuses the throne and never return home. He convinces his fiancé to seek a different duke, but not until after she meets the heroine and ruins everything.
So many of these plot threads should have blown things up, caused dramatic problems that had to be worked on for a considerable time to be solved. But they didn’t. It felt like nothing came to fruition. If someone was mad, they weren’t three paragraphs later. He hid his identity from her, shouldn’t she care? He caught her in hiding the truth about her father, shouldn’t he confront her? She promised to marry another man after she kissed him, isn’t that a big deal? He never said he was engaged, and then a beautiful and terrible woman just shows up and claims him, wouldn’t that make her feel betrayed? Shouldn’t there be some kind of conflict and resolution after all this buildup? So many plot lines went nowhere. The author should have picked 5 things from the above list and written a good book about them instead of dragging on forever trying to include everything.
#rantover
March 24, 2014
I found this book to be one I didn't want to put down. The characters were well developed, there was a good tension between the two main characters, and it wasn't full of mushy romance.
As I said in other reviews, I will rate the sex factor. This book proves a good Christian novel can be written without the questionable foreplay that is so popular in today's "Christian" novels. There is a sexual tension hinted at, but there is honor in both characters.
This is a book I can recommend.
As I said in other reviews, I will rate the sex factor. This book proves a good Christian novel can be written without the questionable foreplay that is so popular in today's "Christian" novels. There is a sexual tension hinted at, but there is honor in both characters.
This is a book I can recommend.
May 19, 2014
A Beauty So Rare was like your favorite dessert. You savor every minute because it's so good and then it's finished before you are ready for it to be done.
I was taken in by this novel from page one and fully engaged until its sweet conclusion.
I was taken in by this novel from page one and fully engaged until its sweet conclusion.
July 30, 2025
As good as when I read it the first time. Alexander has a way of writing historical rich backgrounds with compelling characters that just keep you turning pages.
March 1, 2017
I don't know what it is but I really enjoy these books. The look at post Civil War in Nashville and the society rules, roles and norms just fascinates me. The stories and characters are original and fun to read.
Highly recommend.
Highly recommend.
April 22, 2014
Hug-worthy! Gush-worthy! I adored(ADORED!!!)this book, from beginning to end!
Eleanor won a place in my heart as one of my favorite leading ladies to ever pass through my reading imagination. She's considered "plain" as far as her outward appearance goes. She's exceedingly tall for a lady, taking her looks from her father, and well past the "marrying" age. With so many men lost to the war, combined with her "plainness", she's given up hope of a husband. Inward, though, she's as beautiful as they come! Her father suffers from Alzheimer's and barely remembers her. When he does, it's with anger. Despite missing him terribly, and knowing she has to make a way for herself, she doesn't roll around in self pity. She rolls her sleeves up and tackles the world with her humble stubbornness, and I loved that about her.
Marcus! He won himself a place in my reading heart, too! I'm not typically a fan of the whole "bad boy" thing. Marcus is Austrian, and has a bit of an arrogant attitude about him. He was also once a "bad boy". Within this story, he's anything but, though. I enjoyed all the "plant talk" and creative architect imaginings that he brings into the story.
A Beauty So Rare is seriously one of the sweetest romances I've ever read! It's not all romance, though. There's an abundance of layers added within this book. There's a little mystery that I almost forgot about through part of the story. There's encouragement to pull ourselves out of our own little world and help those in need. I was left with many things to ponder as I closed the last page with a happy sigh. And, again, there's the sweet(so very sweet) romance. It's not a quick read by any means. I encourage you to read it slowly and simply enjoy your time in it. It's what I consider a "chunkster", but well worth the time investment. I'd also encourage you to read A Lasting Impression first, just so you can have a better appreciation for Adelicia. You probably won't like her at all without reading A Lasting Impression first. Otherwise, it's perfectly fine as a standalone.
I loved this book so much, I'm determined to convince you to put all other reading aside, and read the two books in this series! I smiled, laughed, cried, and ended the book with a little hug. What more could you ask for from a book?! ;)
*Thank you to Bethany House for providing me with a review copy in exchange for my honest opinion!
Eleanor won a place in my heart as one of my favorite leading ladies to ever pass through my reading imagination. She's considered "plain" as far as her outward appearance goes. She's exceedingly tall for a lady, taking her looks from her father, and well past the "marrying" age. With so many men lost to the war, combined with her "plainness", she's given up hope of a husband. Inward, though, she's as beautiful as they come! Her father suffers from Alzheimer's and barely remembers her. When he does, it's with anger. Despite missing him terribly, and knowing she has to make a way for herself, she doesn't roll around in self pity. She rolls her sleeves up and tackles the world with her humble stubbornness, and I loved that about her.
Marcus! He won himself a place in my reading heart, too! I'm not typically a fan of the whole "bad boy" thing. Marcus is Austrian, and has a bit of an arrogant attitude about him. He was also once a "bad boy". Within this story, he's anything but, though. I enjoyed all the "plant talk" and creative architect imaginings that he brings into the story.
A Beauty So Rare is seriously one of the sweetest romances I've ever read! It's not all romance, though. There's an abundance of layers added within this book. There's a little mystery that I almost forgot about through part of the story. There's encouragement to pull ourselves out of our own little world and help those in need. I was left with many things to ponder as I closed the last page with a happy sigh. And, again, there's the sweet(so very sweet) romance. It's not a quick read by any means. I encourage you to read it slowly and simply enjoy your time in it. It's what I consider a "chunkster", but well worth the time investment. I'd also encourage you to read A Lasting Impression first, just so you can have a better appreciation for Adelicia. You probably won't like her at all without reading A Lasting Impression first. Otherwise, it's perfectly fine as a standalone.
I loved this book so much, I'm determined to convince you to put all other reading aside, and read the two books in this series! I smiled, laughed, cried, and ended the book with a little hug. What more could you ask for from a book?! ;)
*Thank you to Bethany House for providing me with a review copy in exchange for my honest opinion!
September 17, 2014
I am a fan of Tamera Alexander because I can always count on her novels to be decent and delightful, filled with engaging dialogue and great characters.
And with A Beauty So Rare, I was not disappointed.
The first thing I loved about this novel is how many pages it had! It sounds odd, but it has been my experience that when a book is bulky, it usually means that I'm in for a well-rounded story experience. And it was true with A Beauty So Rare.
I also loved the different perspective Alexander took on the relationship between Eleanor and Marcus. It was extremely refreshing to read a novel where love is not all about a person's looks-but is primarily based on their character.
But what I liked most about A Beauty So Rare i is the characterization of Eleanor's father, and his struggle with dementia. It was a part of the novel that hit close to home, as I have a relative in its final stages. Watching this relative go from a vibrant individual to a state of often not knowing her own children's faces and names is a pretty difficult pill to swallow. But mixed with the hard days are the easier ones, and through it all God is with us.
Reading Eleanor's struggle connected me to her in a personal way, and that connection was what made this my favorite part of A Beauty So Rare.
I really enjoyed this novel. While I do not think that this novel surpasses Beyond This Moment (another really really great novel by Alexander) it does come fairly close. I cannot wait to read her next novel, To Win Her Favor.
Happy Reading!
Liz
Displaying 1 - 30 of 517 reviews