Cool idea with a so-so execution.
This book's a YA adventure story. It's about two ethimologist students from a near-future earth with little-to-no biosphere remaining, that join a VR online RPG game to escape a somewhat dull life trajectory, thus immersing into a rich world built around nature and dozens of sentient animal races. So far this sounds like most litRPG stories, hence execution is paramount and can make or break the book.
After reading it I'd say its neither. It has its good parts, its boring parts, with everything expected from a litRPG in between.
Brief note! there's a hefty load of "F" bombs in between.
The "ok, you got my attention!":
I liked the slow paced and thoughtful leveling system with low numbers to follow (i.e. 100HP with 100MP on second third)
I also enjoyed the helper avatar's persona "YuAi" even if for limited screen time.
Also the great "Venom" team vibe is great to watch both in action and outside of it.
The evolution system of both the character's body as well as of the pets' is also something that I followed with interest. GG!
In the audiobook, the bard songs are somehow dope.
The "Meh! whatever":
The class system consists in the average rooster, like: thiefs, mages, paladins, bards or gray knights, among many others.
The abilities are average with none that stand out. Run faster, sense the world better, do [this activity] better, etc. The tele/portals are a nice exception.
The quest that drives the plot forward is as generic as it gets: explore the world and find 3 artefacts of power to receive a cool reward.
The "bad, bad, bad! I really expected better."
The world! is lack-luster, with little to no history or lore whatsoever. The reader needs to fill the huge blanks with no hints available. Except of a brief mention of a war/skirmish between the wolf and reptile races (40years ago) and a brief gray knights story of a magical war (1000 years ago) there's no mention of history, topology, politics, kingdoms, etc. It's unclear the technical era of this world. Are there any machineries available? Is it pure fantasy, steampunk, medieval, antiquity? There's a single mention of a "victorian era" like rich neighborhood in one of the cities.
Max, the villan, is sooo unidimetional, that even a dot seams complex in comparison.
The main character! is so badly written I had to reread some chapters thinking I missed something. He's presented as a ethimologist enthusiast IRL, but except his initial thoughts and amazement of the lush world, there are few-to-no moments where these skills are used or mentioned. I would have loved to read some trivia on biosphere from his POV; the serendipity of various elements in the game; his exploits of the world, given his perfect background, anything that would build on the great expectations set in the first chapters. But there's none of that. So dry and dull.
I might countinue the series, but only if on sale and only if I'm lacking any other decent books on wait list. A lot of IFs.