*Warnings*
#1 This is a long review, so pull up a chair and grab a bowl of popcorn. You’ll be here awhile. #2 When I read a review, I want substantial information. So I will not skimp on the details. Which may mean some spoilers, so watch out.
Stars: 4.5
Synopsis: Breakthrough is about to come for popular social media influencer Molly McKenzie and all that she needs to make it big is—a charity case? So says her talent manager/adoring boyfriend, which means Molly is set on getting a volunteer position with The Bridge, a transitional home for kids aging out of the foster system. One thing: they won’t hire her. Correction, Zorro-lookalike/home director Silas Whitaker won’t hire her.
Favorite Quotes: “There’s nothing you can sacrifice that is worthy of what God gives us freely.”
“You don’t honor God with your life by changing your personality and tossing out everything that unique about who you are. You honor Him by giving those very gifts back to Him.”
I’ve been noticing a trend in contemporary Christian fiction lately—kindhearted and lovable heroines...who aren’t Christians. Maybe it’s breaking away from the stereotypical bad girl, or it’s entirely unintentional, or it could even be a jab at Christians. I don’t know—all I can say is that, whatever the case, Nicole Deese pulled it off.
After reading Before I Called You Mine, I wanted to read more by Deese. BICYM wasn’t my favorite book by far and, to be honest, I didn’t really connect with the characters or the story or any of it, really. But, Deese proved to be an amazing writer, so I knew I could enjoy her writing in a different story.
Even still, my expectations for All That Really Matters weren’t all that high.
That could be why it exceeded them. Or, ATRM could simply be an exemplary novel.
I’m leaning toward the latter.
First of all, I really liked Molly. She wasn’t my favorite heroine ever, no, but her character was unique and energetic and...I don’t know. She just wasn’t the type of girl to cause problems and get into petty arguments and be annoying. I liked that. She had a strong personality, ambition, and a purpose in the story.
This would be the moment where you look at me with your eyebrows raised and say “Well, of course she had a purpose, Grace. She was the heroine of the story, for crying out loud.” And then I would go on to say that just because she was the heroine didn’t necessary mean her character automatically had a purpose—let alone a good one.
Most heroines nowadays are simply there—to whine about their circumstances, to get into trouble, to make snarky comments. Never to actually do anything worth doing or have a definable arc.
But not Molly. Nope, Molly did something with her life, did something for other people, made people’s lives better, had a lovely arc, and made me come to appreciate and respect her. Which I rarely do, so that’s a major accomplishment in and of itself.
Anyway, let’s move on to the rest of the story, shall we?
I’ve already mentioned that Deese is a great writer. I love her style—it flows well, while still being personable and unique. Of course, the quality is top notch, and there’s a clarity to her writing but not a bluntness—something I really like. As far as contemporary authors go, Nicole Deese is one of my favorites (of which there are few, so that means something).
Because of that, I breezed through this story. Coming off of an unsatisfactory read, All That Really Matters started out as a breath of fresh air...then it morphed into a story I was sucked into and enjoyed in almost every way.
What’s funny to me is that I actually felt more drawn to and connected with Molly than I did Silas. Which is really weird. He was a good character, don’t get me wrong, but he just wasn’t as vibrant as Molly and the supporting cast.
Speaking of the supporting cast...I wanted more of the kids!!! Wren was so precious, and I LOVED watching Molly interact with the girls at The Bridge, and with Glo and Clara! And...yeah. Basically all of the secondary characters were amazing! I can’t wait to read more about Val and Miles in the next book, too!
All in all, the cast of All That Really Matters was amazing. I do wish I’d had more interactions with everyone, simply because I loved them so much.
On that note, I read another review that stated the book focused mainly on reforming Molly rather than her romance with Silas or, in some aspects, her relationships with everyone else. Which was good in its own right, but I agree with that reviewer when they said they really wanted more between Silas and Molly. I didn’t realize it until now, but their moments together were kind of limited, and I, the obsessive romantic, wanted a little more…oomph in their relationship. Savvy?
But, then, Molly did have a really good character arc, so at least the sacrifice was worth it, eh?
Speaking of, though, I really did like seeing Molly’s transformation. It was amazingly well-done, and even though I felt like I didn’t get the reassurance that Molly gave her life to Christ, there was this beautiful message woven in about honoring God and living for Him that was lovely. Still wish I had some closure, though. I just can’t stand it when you don’t have the certainty that the character’s saved. Like, c’mon, authors, I really don’t want these guys going to hell, you know? Good works without true faith and commitment never saved a man...or a beauty influencer, for that matter.
But then, this is coming from the girl who is so obsessive about book characters that she does indeed dream about marrying some of them. (Seriously, y’all, don’t tell me I’m not the only one who wouldn’t mind taking Elizabeth Bennet’s place… Mr. Darcy and I would be perfect for each other, don’t you think? After all, I do read extensively.)
*reads back over her review* I think...that may just sum things up. I’m sure I had more thoughts when I first read it...several months back...but I’m so backlogged on books and reviews right now that I’ve not been able to jot down my reviews as soon as I finish reading. (Hence why I’ve started a reading journal...with bulleted lists!)
Long story short (this was actually one of the shorter ones...under 2k words this time), I loved breaking up the monotony with All That Really Matters and being able to read without looking for an excuse to stop reading. (Which is terrible, I know, but that goes to show the kind of literature I’ve been stuck with lately.) Molly was a pretty good character, as far as heroines go, and the story itself was spectacular! (Plus, it might have helped that I’d just watched Discarded Things before starting on ATRM, and so had the home-for-troubled-teens vibe down.)
Nicole Deese is definitely going on my top contemporary authors list!
Disclaimer: A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.