Honor’s Gauntlet skillfully balances political machinations, moral introspection, and blowing stuff up with a well-mixed grab bag of mechanical killing machines. The very first scene will assure you that Young knows how to handle action. His battle scenes are dynamic and high-octane. There is a real sense of danger, even as we assume (hope) that Pryde will win the day. Perhaps more impressive, though, is the slow-winding tension of intra-Clan politics. There are, admittedly, fewer explosions, but just as much danger. Maybe more. Inside his ‘Mech, at least he has armor.
Young could have stopped there. He could have delivered a book filled with clashing philosophies and smashing technologies, and readers would have walked away happy. Smash. Think. Smash. It’s a good story sandwich. You eat that and you’re satisfied. But he didn’t stop there. There’s a secret sauce, something subtle, something you don’t notice sneaking up on you until it hits you in the mouth. A final bite of story so good it makes you realize you didn’t fully appreciate the sandwhich you were reading until… listen, this analogy has gone a little off the rails. Still, the point remains.
Honor’s Gauntlet delivers on everything you expect from good, fun science fiction. But it isn’t paint-by-numbers. It’s smarter than that. If you’re familiar with the world of BattleTech, there’s plenty here to enjoy and you’ll be delighted with the story Young tells and the groundwork he lays for whatever comes next. For my part, I had never read a BattleTech book before, never played the games or watched the cartoon. I went into this novel with a certain amount of anxiety that I wouldn’t be able to follow it. I needn’t have worried. If you’re uninitiated, you’ll find this book to be accessible, with world building layered in, in ways which allows it to be understood in context and will leave you wanting to know more about the characters and the worlds they inhabit.