What do you think?
Rate this book
Tales of the Swordsman #1
Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy
There is only one kind of justice in the jianghu: the kind you bring with a sword.
After maiming a nobleman’s son, Shu Yan thought the best place to hide was in the company of a legendary swordsman. But she certainly didn’t expect to join him in his quest to find the man who murdered his master and family. Li Ming is the last swordsman of Blue Mountain. He has sworn an oath to avenge his master’s death and bring the man who murdered his family to justice.
In the search for his master’s killer, the swordsman and the runaway will face bandits, conmen, conspiracies, and scheming nobles — because the road to revenge is never straight and always full of danger.
Inspired by classic Kung Fu films and spaghetti western movies, Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy is the first volume of tales of the swordsman—adventures of wuxia action, witty banter, martial arts camaraderie, bandits, princesses, and treacherous villains.
After maiming a nobleman’s son, Shu Yan thought the best place to hide was in the company of a legendary swordsman. But she certainly didn’t expect to join him in his quest to find the man who murdered his master and family. Li Ming is the last swordsman of Blue Mountain. He has sworn an oath to avenge his master’s death and bring the man who murdered his family to justice.
In the search for his master’s killer, the swordsman and the runaway will face bandits, conmen, conspiracies, and scheming nobles — because the road to revenge is never straight and always full of danger.
Inspired by classic Kung Fu films and spaghetti western movies, Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy is the first volume of tales of the swordsman—adventures of wuxia action, witty banter, martial arts camaraderie, bandits, princesses, and treacherous villains.
352 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 14, 2020
188 people are currently reading
767 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 69 reviews
October 12, 2020
This delightful read has rekindled my love for wuxia/fantasy. I was a childhood fan of Jin Yong's famous martial arts novels and the parallel universe (called "jianghu", literally meaning rivers and lakes) that he so masterfully created. It's a fantastical world where wrongs are strenuously righted by super-skilled swordsmen whose mission is to uphold justice.
JF Lee's evenly paced debut novel is filled with deftly described tension-filled fight scenes as well as philosophical musings about duty, guilt and redemption. It also subtly explores the meaning of life and death, while the intricate plot glides along with fluidity and playfulness. The writing is suffused with humor and warmth. The novel is as much a great escape from the present unsettling times as it is an invitation for us to look deeper into our own souls to find our raison d'être.
This novel is the first in a series, and the sequel looks most promising.
I'm giving it four full stars.
JF Lee's evenly paced debut novel is filled with deftly described tension-filled fight scenes as well as philosophical musings about duty, guilt and redemption. It also subtly explores the meaning of life and death, while the intricate plot glides along with fluidity and playfulness. The writing is suffused with humor and warmth. The novel is as much a great escape from the present unsettling times as it is an invitation for us to look deeper into our own souls to find our raison d'être.
This novel is the first in a series, and the sequel looks most promising.
I'm giving it four full stars.
March 29, 2024
Done! A fun episodic adventure about vengeance and family. Think kung fu meets the last Ronin. Although there is nothing earth shattering in this book, the story, pacing, and action scenes will keep the pages turning. Doesn’t require a high attention span and can be read after any kind of delay. Enjoy!!!
October 27, 2020
Fun collection of stories. Lots of action and humor.
November 13, 2023
3.5/5
It only took me like three months to finish lol.
The story wasn't a drag but there was also nothing so special that made me really love this book. I really enjoy the Wuxia genre but the translated vers of 'A Hero Born' was really disappointing so I had high hopes for this one or at least I was excited to read another book in this genre. There was depth but I feel like there was nothing so invigorating but in saying that there were a handful of very vividly beautiful phrases just sprinkled throughout the book which I wish was done more often and perhaps in a more subtle way that would allow the book to flow more smoothly. But other than that I really love the not-biological-father-daughter-duo that was really cute and overall the book was slightly better than alright
It only took me like three months to finish lol.
The story wasn't a drag but there was also nothing so special that made me really love this book. I really enjoy the Wuxia genre but the translated vers of 'A Hero Born' was really disappointing so I had high hopes for this one or at least I was excited to read another book in this genre. There was depth but I feel like there was nothing so invigorating but in saying that there were a handful of very vividly beautiful phrases just sprinkled throughout the book which I wish was done more often and perhaps in a more subtle way that would allow the book to flow more smoothly. But other than that I really love the not-biological-father-daughter-duo that was really cute and overall the book was slightly better than alright
October 10, 2020
I really enjoyed Lee's writing. The story is engaging, full of wit, and what I feel a great introduction to the genre. This was by first Wuxia book and I was introduced to and immersed in a new world. The relationship of Li Ming and Shu Yan is tender and engaging. Looking forward to the next volume.
August 1, 2022
Good, action-packed wuxia with heart. On to the next volume!
November 30, 2022
Very fun wuxia with two enjoyable main characters. Fast paced with a very entertaining and action packed feel to it all. The opening dedication stuck with me and laid the perfect tone for the book, this is a book J.F. Lee wanted made for people's enjoyment and it shows.
March 14, 2022
Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy is the story of a wandering swordsman, Li Ming, and a runaway, Shu Yan, as they ramble about and do things, generally looking out for each other and killing bad guys.
The book falls into the wuxia genre, of which Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon remains the most well-known work in the west. I don’t know if wuxia is one of my favorite-ever book genres, but some of the wuxia works of Jin Yong are my favorite-ever books (Laughing in the Wind, Legends of the Condor Heroes.) That being said, I’ve only explored a few other authors, Wang Dulu, Zheng Feng, and Gu Long. Gu Long might be the second most well-known wuxia author behind Jin Yong, and their styles are quite opposite. Gu Long is terse and inspired by Hemingway. Jin Yong is epic, world-building, and sometimes will spend 300 pages before even introducing the main character.
If 1 on the brevity scale is Gu Long and 10 is Jin Yong, JF Lee is probably a 2 or 3. This concision results in a breezy and fast-paced book but makes things feel almost too simple. While there is plenty of conflict, each tale gets wrapped up in just a few short chapters. This speed ends up reducing the complications and, to some extent, the depth, in favor of ‘adventures of the week’ that could fill up an hour-long episode. Perhaps that is exactly what Lee is going for (or hoping that Netflix goes for), but I like my wuxia to be epic and sprawling, not bite-sized.
In fact, the book picks up the most steam in its second half when characters from early tales start to come back into the mix to create problems. However, that doesn’t entirely remedy the fact that the tales themselves unfold in a fashion slightly too direct for my preferences.
There are many things to appreciate, though. Since Li Ming and Shu Yan are the only two characters appearing in each tale, their relationship does mature. It grows in quite the way you would expect, but the execution is touching. The book also has a sense of humor. To put it in perspective, if you can make jokes in footnotes and also make fun of yourself for making said jokes in other footnotes, you have my respect.
Even if the book's episodic nature doesn’t suit my tastes exactly, the ‘wandering’ nature of the narrative does fit the theme of aimlessness that is central to Li Ming’s character.
So, the question is ultimately for the prospective reader - is a stack of fun-sized snickers as good as a whole candy bar?
The book falls into the wuxia genre, of which Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon remains the most well-known work in the west. I don’t know if wuxia is one of my favorite-ever book genres, but some of the wuxia works of Jin Yong are my favorite-ever books (Laughing in the Wind, Legends of the Condor Heroes.) That being said, I’ve only explored a few other authors, Wang Dulu, Zheng Feng, and Gu Long. Gu Long might be the second most well-known wuxia author behind Jin Yong, and their styles are quite opposite. Gu Long is terse and inspired by Hemingway. Jin Yong is epic, world-building, and sometimes will spend 300 pages before even introducing the main character.
If 1 on the brevity scale is Gu Long and 10 is Jin Yong, JF Lee is probably a 2 or 3. This concision results in a breezy and fast-paced book but makes things feel almost too simple. While there is plenty of conflict, each tale gets wrapped up in just a few short chapters. This speed ends up reducing the complications and, to some extent, the depth, in favor of ‘adventures of the week’ that could fill up an hour-long episode. Perhaps that is exactly what Lee is going for (or hoping that Netflix goes for), but I like my wuxia to be epic and sprawling, not bite-sized.
In fact, the book picks up the most steam in its second half when characters from early tales start to come back into the mix to create problems. However, that doesn’t entirely remedy the fact that the tales themselves unfold in a fashion slightly too direct for my preferences.
There are many things to appreciate, though. Since Li Ming and Shu Yan are the only two characters appearing in each tale, their relationship does mature. It grows in quite the way you would expect, but the execution is touching. The book also has a sense of humor. To put it in perspective, if you can make jokes in footnotes and also make fun of yourself for making said jokes in other footnotes, you have my respect.
Even if the book's episodic nature doesn’t suit my tastes exactly, the ‘wandering’ nature of the narrative does fit the theme of aimlessness that is central to Li Ming’s character.
So, the question is ultimately for the prospective reader - is a stack of fun-sized snickers as good as a whole candy bar?
November 15, 2024
I am so overwhelmed, I don’t know where to start.
Main character, Li Ming: gorgeous realized, in such a way that he feels genuine and human. He’s powerful, but not unbelievably so or even unbeatably so. He recognizes his own limitations, and that awareness disquiets him in a way that is so relatable. There’s this world weariness to him, even for someone so young, that makes him a stand-in for an entire generation of people, every generation, that feels like they’ve lived through too much. His sense of humor through it all is quick and light and balanced so well within the context of the story.
Though the story revolves around Li Ming, he’s not the only character that thought & care was put into. JF Lee could teach a master class on writing strong, realistic female characters. There is no apologizing for the feminine traits, no diminishment as a character as though it makes them weaker or less valuable. Each woman is a celebrated, well-rounded, well-executed entity. There are no more physical descriptors of them than there are of any male counterparts, and their motivations and aspirations are varied. Women are well represented in this book.
The story reminds me of Jim Butcher’s “Dresden” series for some reason, even though they are vastly different works; I think it’s the tone that harkens back to it? And the main character still fighting on, even if getting a bit dumped on, the levity well placed relief. I think Lee has a much lighter touch than Butcher does, which is needed and appreciated because it allows the story to be the driving force forward instead of feeling dragged ahead. And as mentioned above, the female characters are handled much, much better in the “Dresden” series.
If I had a comment, I would say the action is a little intense in places, which makes me feel like I am going to have to go back and read it again & again to catch everything. But the pacing is excellent and keeps you turning pages, so I’ll have to work at slowing down & enjoying the ride.
Highly recommend.
Main character, Li Ming: gorgeous realized, in such a way that he feels genuine and human. He’s powerful, but not unbelievably so or even unbeatably so. He recognizes his own limitations, and that awareness disquiets him in a way that is so relatable. There’s this world weariness to him, even for someone so young, that makes him a stand-in for an entire generation of people, every generation, that feels like they’ve lived through too much. His sense of humor through it all is quick and light and balanced so well within the context of the story.
Though the story revolves around Li Ming, he’s not the only character that thought & care was put into. JF Lee could teach a master class on writing strong, realistic female characters. There is no apologizing for the feminine traits, no diminishment as a character as though it makes them weaker or less valuable. Each woman is a celebrated, well-rounded, well-executed entity. There are no more physical descriptors of them than there are of any male counterparts, and their motivations and aspirations are varied. Women are well represented in this book.
The story reminds me of Jim Butcher’s “Dresden” series for some reason, even though they are vastly different works; I think it’s the tone that harkens back to it? And the main character still fighting on, even if getting a bit dumped on, the levity well placed relief. I think Lee has a much lighter touch than Butcher does, which is needed and appreciated because it allows the story to be the driving force forward instead of feeling dragged ahead. And as mentioned above, the female characters are handled much, much better in the “Dresden” series.
If I had a comment, I would say the action is a little intense in places, which makes me feel like I am going to have to go back and read it again & again to catch everything. But the pacing is excellent and keeps you turning pages, so I’ll have to work at slowing down & enjoying the ride.
Highly recommend.
June 28, 2022
I love wuxia genre so I already read/watched my fair share pf the genre.
The Book is divided into nine parts. The story has different arcs which are quite short. The chapters are also short which makes it convenient to stop at. As the plot progresses you can see the character developemnet of the two main characters and how they grow closer on their journey.
The writing is fine, it is more of a modern writing. I was expecting a more historical writing style given the setting which is actually more to my preference but it is still well written. The book does have a bit of an wester touch to it.
The characters are kinda boring. Sadly there was nothing cool or mysterious about Li Ming the swordsman. His personality does fit him tho. They are kinda too easy to read and often very fragile. To me they all seem weak. The side characters are likable but didnt leave any lasting impression.
It took me quite a while to finish this book.
It wasnt bad, I recommed it if you like such stories.
I went into it with wrong expectations and it wasnt that of my preference.
The Book is divided into nine parts. The story has different arcs which are quite short. The chapters are also short which makes it convenient to stop at. As the plot progresses you can see the character developemnet of the two main characters and how they grow closer on their journey.
The writing is fine, it is more of a modern writing. I was expecting a more historical writing style given the setting which is actually more to my preference but it is still well written. The book does have a bit of an wester touch to it.
The characters are kinda boring. Sadly there was nothing cool or mysterious about Li Ming the swordsman. His personality does fit him tho. They are kinda too easy to read and often very fragile. To me they all seem weak. The side characters are likable but didnt leave any lasting impression.
It took me quite a while to finish this book.
It wasnt bad, I recommed it if you like such stories.
I went into it with wrong expectations and it wasnt that of my preference.
August 12, 2022
2.5 stars - I think I consume Wuxia better in a visual format where my expectations differ as to what I'm wanting from the piece of entertainment, because this wasn't really to my tastes. I think it's a decent time to read this, but the characters did not speak to me and their relationships weren't exactly the main focus anyway, and the story didn't progress enough to speak to my reading preferences.
I still think if you like reading books like this that you could give it a try, but for my personal reading preferences, it was a miss - but at least I learned more about my reading tastes.
I still think if you like reading books like this that you could give it a try, but for my personal reading preferences, it was a miss - but at least I learned more about my reading tastes.
February 28, 2023
An entertaining story set in China with the main characters a legendary swordsman and a young girl who is running away from her owner. The swordsman is seeking revenge for the killing of his wife and child, carried out by the same man who murdered his teacher. They come through various adventures together and the book ends on a cliffhanger designed to keep you reading the next book in the series.
November 24, 2024
A lot of fun but could use an edit for some grammar
August 21, 2022
"Fifteen years on the cold trail of his master's murderer, and he was now babysitting. How had it come to this?" - Li Ming
Who doesn't love a grumpy legend? Li Ming's trying to stay focused on his duty of tracking down the murderer. When he's rudely interrupted by Shu Yan, who's needing his help. Begrudgingly agreeing to help her they set out together. Though her having a deep purse isn't a bad thing for Li Ming's pocket.
Little do the duo know that bandits and conmen will be the least of their worries. Their journey is long but will the two be able to stand one another long enough to see the end? Both having different motives. Nobody said babysitting a fourteen-year-old girl would be easy. Will Li Ming find the person he is after? And will Shu Yan ever get to see the legendary swordsman in action with his sword?
This is a wuxia genre book!
"Wuxia is a genre of Chinese fiction that features itinerant warriors of extreme (almost supernatural) martial arts skill in ancient China." - From Author's Page
I really loved this story and instantly got "The Witcher" vibes. We love the trope with a grumpy, older legend who has to deal with a younger person. Not realizing that they are forming a parental bond with the youth. Li Ming just wants to eat his dumplings in peace and Shu Yan isn't letting him.
I loved the quick pacing of the book and the little short stories within. There's of course the main arc of the story but then there are mini arcs. Because this is a book where you get to travel all around with the characters! Encountering several places and many people!
The action in this book is something I really enjoyed. There's violence but the author doesn't go into great depth or bloody details. I loved being able to see the swordsman show off his teachings, when it was necessary. Li Ming states that the sword is the last resort.
The characters were well rounded and I hope to see them in volume two and three. Including a certain magistrate that is found of a new title. . . I want to see more of Jin Lang in the next books and I am crossing my fingers the author will bring him back. I don't want to spoil anything but I was very excited when I saw his character and Li Ming toward the end of an arc.
"The only demons in this world are the ones we become. . ." - Jin Lang
There was action, quick pacing, drama, a sprinkle of romance, and the swordsmanship! Along with so much more and I am excited to continue the series so I can read volume three. Rumor has it the third book's the best in the series. . . I am eager to get to it because volume on was excellent.
I also grew up with Kung Fu films and spaghetti westerns so this book was honestly down my alley! Made me miss those days of being young and carefree watching the movies with my dad. I really loved this genre and the whole grumpy legend keeping a low profile. Seeing the world negatively until a young person drops into their life and shows them there's more. The grump enjoying every minute of it, even if they don't realize it or want to acknowledge it.
These volumes are going in chronological order so expect that cliffhanger! I am ready to dive into volume two because I need to know what happens. Also need to see if Jin Lang's going to appear again. There's some language in the book but it's in Chinese. The author does provide a list of the characters and a brief description of each at the front of the book. In the back of the book there's a glossary for some of the words used throughout the book.
I loved this story so much and the banter was incredible. I live for the witty banter that just flows! Shu Yan's a terrific girl with a sharp tongue and mind. She doesn't hold back and Li Ming finds it amusing, even if he won't admit it out loud.
Enjoy the epic adventure with a grumpy swordsman and give the author some stars!
shutupandbookup.blogspot.com
Who doesn't love a grumpy legend? Li Ming's trying to stay focused on his duty of tracking down the murderer. When he's rudely interrupted by Shu Yan, who's needing his help. Begrudgingly agreeing to help her they set out together. Though her having a deep purse isn't a bad thing for Li Ming's pocket.
Little do the duo know that bandits and conmen will be the least of their worries. Their journey is long but will the two be able to stand one another long enough to see the end? Both having different motives. Nobody said babysitting a fourteen-year-old girl would be easy. Will Li Ming find the person he is after? And will Shu Yan ever get to see the legendary swordsman in action with his sword?
This is a wuxia genre book!
"Wuxia is a genre of Chinese fiction that features itinerant warriors of extreme (almost supernatural) martial arts skill in ancient China." - From Author's Page
I really loved this story and instantly got "The Witcher" vibes. We love the trope with a grumpy, older legend who has to deal with a younger person. Not realizing that they are forming a parental bond with the youth. Li Ming just wants to eat his dumplings in peace and Shu Yan isn't letting him.
I loved the quick pacing of the book and the little short stories within. There's of course the main arc of the story but then there are mini arcs. Because this is a book where you get to travel all around with the characters! Encountering several places and many people!
The action in this book is something I really enjoyed. There's violence but the author doesn't go into great depth or bloody details. I loved being able to see the swordsman show off his teachings, when it was necessary. Li Ming states that the sword is the last resort.
The characters were well rounded and I hope to see them in volume two and three. Including a certain magistrate that is found of a new title. . . I want to see more of Jin Lang in the next books and I am crossing my fingers the author will bring him back. I don't want to spoil anything but I was very excited when I saw his character and Li Ming toward the end of an arc.
"The only demons in this world are the ones we become. . ." - Jin Lang
There was action, quick pacing, drama, a sprinkle of romance, and the swordsmanship! Along with so much more and I am excited to continue the series so I can read volume three. Rumor has it the third book's the best in the series. . . I am eager to get to it because volume on was excellent.
I also grew up with Kung Fu films and spaghetti westerns so this book was honestly down my alley! Made me miss those days of being young and carefree watching the movies with my dad. I really loved this genre and the whole grumpy legend keeping a low profile. Seeing the world negatively until a young person drops into their life and shows them there's more. The grump enjoying every minute of it, even if they don't realize it or want to acknowledge it.
These volumes are going in chronological order so expect that cliffhanger! I am ready to dive into volume two because I need to know what happens. Also need to see if Jin Lang's going to appear again. There's some language in the book but it's in Chinese. The author does provide a list of the characters and a brief description of each at the front of the book. In the back of the book there's a glossary for some of the words used throughout the book.
I loved this story so much and the banter was incredible. I live for the witty banter that just flows! Shu Yan's a terrific girl with a sharp tongue and mind. She doesn't hold back and Li Ming finds it amusing, even if he won't admit it out loud.
Enjoy the epic adventure with a grumpy swordsman and give the author some stars!
shutupandbookup.blogspot.com
November 2, 2021
Probably more of a 3.5 but I’m rounding up.
It’s been a long while since I’ve read anything on Kindle Unlimited, but one day I got an email with this book as a recommendation and I knew I couldn’t resist. I’ve been on a wuxia kick for a while now, and reading any book in the genre that I don’t have to look for translated on multiple blogs is an unexpected convenience. So I immediately decided to get this one.
And I wasn’t wrong. I will not say that the prose is beautiful or stunning or any such superlatives, but what this book offered to me was fun. The prose is very accessible, with some of the dialogues and particularly the swears making me laugh a lot with their inventiveness. The plot itself is mostly fast moving, but it’s typical of the wuxia dramas I’ve come to love - encountering foes while traveling the jianghu, some spectacular fight sequences, meeting old friends and making new ones, and all these adventurous bouts interspersed with moments of contemplation and reminiscing the joys and sorrows of the past. Even though it took me a few sittings to complete because I kept putting it down, I found the second half particularly engaging with its multiple betrayals and devious villains and finally the past coming to light.
Li Ming and Shu Yan are also stereotypical protagonists whom I’ve gotten used to encountering in multiple other media. Li Ming is a grumpy swordsman who is just alive but not living, probably sustaining on the hope that he will get his revenge one day and show his filial piety to his dead master. Shu Yan is running away literally from her tragic past, in the hope for a better future. They are a very unlikely duo and despite their nonstop bickering throughout, it’s obvious that they start to care for each other as father and daughter as the story goes on. While I loved the realization about life that Li Ming has towards the end, what I found most unforgettable about the book was how shrewd and cunning as well as sweet talking Shu Yan could be, excellent at extracting money from every opportunity. But I don’t mean this in a bad way because she is ultimately very good at survival, while also caring for those she loves.
There are some more interesting side characters who add some heart to the proceedings. Han Mama is like a mother figure who has to do lots of unsavory things to ensure the innocent people in her town survive, but ultimately her warmth is very soothing. Jingyi is a formidable woman in her own right, taking over her father’s business and ensuring that everything goes well, making her like a role model for Shu Yan. And then Tao Jun - the very charming and sly magistrate and sworn brother of Li Ming whose presence brings a lot of entertainment to the story. I loved his bond with Li Ming and I have a feeling we’ll see more of him in the sequel.
In the end, this was fun and entertaining and exactly what I was looking for during a bad week. It definitely took my mind off all my worries and I’m happy for that. It also ends on a terrifying cliffhanger, so I guess I just have to read the sequel soon because I badly wanna know what happens next.
It’s been a long while since I’ve read anything on Kindle Unlimited, but one day I got an email with this book as a recommendation and I knew I couldn’t resist. I’ve been on a wuxia kick for a while now, and reading any book in the genre that I don’t have to look for translated on multiple blogs is an unexpected convenience. So I immediately decided to get this one.
And I wasn’t wrong. I will not say that the prose is beautiful or stunning or any such superlatives, but what this book offered to me was fun. The prose is very accessible, with some of the dialogues and particularly the swears making me laugh a lot with their inventiveness. The plot itself is mostly fast moving, but it’s typical of the wuxia dramas I’ve come to love - encountering foes while traveling the jianghu, some spectacular fight sequences, meeting old friends and making new ones, and all these adventurous bouts interspersed with moments of contemplation and reminiscing the joys and sorrows of the past. Even though it took me a few sittings to complete because I kept putting it down, I found the second half particularly engaging with its multiple betrayals and devious villains and finally the past coming to light.
Li Ming and Shu Yan are also stereotypical protagonists whom I’ve gotten used to encountering in multiple other media. Li Ming is a grumpy swordsman who is just alive but not living, probably sustaining on the hope that he will get his revenge one day and show his filial piety to his dead master. Shu Yan is running away literally from her tragic past, in the hope for a better future. They are a very unlikely duo and despite their nonstop bickering throughout, it’s obvious that they start to care for each other as father and daughter as the story goes on. While I loved the realization about life that Li Ming has towards the end, what I found most unforgettable about the book was how shrewd and cunning as well as sweet talking Shu Yan could be, excellent at extracting money from every opportunity. But I don’t mean this in a bad way because she is ultimately very good at survival, while also caring for those she loves.
There are some more interesting side characters who add some heart to the proceedings. Han Mama is like a mother figure who has to do lots of unsavory things to ensure the innocent people in her town survive, but ultimately her warmth is very soothing. Jingyi is a formidable woman in her own right, taking over her father’s business and ensuring that everything goes well, making her like a role model for Shu Yan. And then Tao Jun - the very charming and sly magistrate and sworn brother of Li Ming whose presence brings a lot of entertainment to the story. I loved his bond with Li Ming and I have a feeling we’ll see more of him in the sequel.
In the end, this was fun and entertaining and exactly what I was looking for during a bad week. It definitely took my mind off all my worries and I’m happy for that. It also ends on a terrifying cliffhanger, so I guess I just have to read the sequel soon because I badly wanna know what happens next.
July 9, 2025
My first review for my first ARC!
Despite many tries, this was my first time receiving an arc, and to get four books in a series was amazing! I am an avid fantasy reader and have read other Asian inspired fantasies (Poppy Wars, Sword of Kaigan, etc), but I believe this was my first official Wuxia book. Given how this one was, I'm looking forward to reading more. I've been nervous about leaving reviews before since I believe everyones reading taste is different and what I may like someone else may not. I am a firm believer in no judgements on anyone's reading taste and every book has a reader. So the fairest way to go about it seems to be a simple pros and cons list from my own personal point of view and reading taste.
Pros:
* Great description in fight scenes. Sometimes when I'm reading an action scene it seems like people have 6 arms and are simultaneously facing in 3 directions to fight lol. This was very precise in its handling the action, and I always enjoy when different styles are present and create different challenges for the hero.
*Great characters. I always enjoy a slightly grumpy traveling hero and Li Ming was a perfect fit. I loved seeing bits of his humor come out with Tao Jun (who was probably my favorite character). Watching Shu Yan grow and learn from each person they met was nice character growth to see rather than her just staying a helpless "child".
*The world. My only experience with wuxia being through movies, I had a vague idea of the setting going in but appreciated it having laid out. I like how even though there were big scale empire problems, we see different parts of the country that are like little empires unto themselves.
*The pace. There is always something happening. In a lot of fantasy you can get bogged down sometimes with characters talking and talking about the main problem while doing nothing in the mean time. While Li Ming and Shu Yan have big end goals and plans, they stay busy with what's in front of them, using the experiences to learn and move them forward.
Cons* (Again just personal experience!)
*Not sure how to title this one. The book read a little younger than what I was expecting, especially at the beginning. Given Shu Yans age not unexpected, but even Li Ming seemed a little immature in his thoughts and actions until later. Which of course could be the point.
*More "why". I enjoy a found family story, and part of the experience is watching people grow together, begin to trust, and merge from friends to family. I feel like it was a little rushed in this. I would've liked more from Li Mings perspective especially of the why he agreed and kept agreeing with her in the beginning.
All in all I'd say a solid four stars and an excellent beginning to a series. The last bit of the book, when you really start getting details of Lin Mings history things get really interesting and leave you wanting more.
Side note: my teenager is super into anime and manga and I can't wait for them to read it. I also think this would be a great anime tv series.
Despite many tries, this was my first time receiving an arc, and to get four books in a series was amazing! I am an avid fantasy reader and have read other Asian inspired fantasies (Poppy Wars, Sword of Kaigan, etc), but I believe this was my first official Wuxia book. Given how this one was, I'm looking forward to reading more. I've been nervous about leaving reviews before since I believe everyones reading taste is different and what I may like someone else may not. I am a firm believer in no judgements on anyone's reading taste and every book has a reader. So the fairest way to go about it seems to be a simple pros and cons list from my own personal point of view and reading taste.
Pros:
* Great description in fight scenes. Sometimes when I'm reading an action scene it seems like people have 6 arms and are simultaneously facing in 3 directions to fight lol. This was very precise in its handling the action, and I always enjoy when different styles are present and create different challenges for the hero.
*Great characters. I always enjoy a slightly grumpy traveling hero and Li Ming was a perfect fit. I loved seeing bits of his humor come out with Tao Jun (who was probably my favorite character). Watching Shu Yan grow and learn from each person they met was nice character growth to see rather than her just staying a helpless "child".
*The world. My only experience with wuxia being through movies, I had a vague idea of the setting going in but appreciated it having laid out. I like how even though there were big scale empire problems, we see different parts of the country that are like little empires unto themselves.
*The pace. There is always something happening. In a lot of fantasy you can get bogged down sometimes with characters talking and talking about the main problem while doing nothing in the mean time. While Li Ming and Shu Yan have big end goals and plans, they stay busy with what's in front of them, using the experiences to learn and move them forward.
Cons* (Again just personal experience!)
*Not sure how to title this one. The book read a little younger than what I was expecting, especially at the beginning. Given Shu Yans age not unexpected, but even Li Ming seemed a little immature in his thoughts and actions until later. Which of course could be the point.
*More "why". I enjoy a found family story, and part of the experience is watching people grow together, begin to trust, and merge from friends to family. I feel like it was a little rushed in this. I would've liked more from Li Mings perspective especially of the why he agreed and kept agreeing with her in the beginning.
All in all I'd say a solid four stars and an excellent beginning to a series. The last bit of the book, when you really start getting details of Lin Mings history things get really interesting and leave you wanting more.
Side note: my teenager is super into anime and manga and I can't wait for them to read it. I also think this would be a great anime tv series.
August 22, 2025
J.F. Lee’s Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy is an exhilarating adventure that blends the honor-driven quests of classic wuxia with the grit and drama of spaghetti westerns. From the very first clash of steel, the story pulls you into the jianghu, where justice is earned only at the edge of a blade and loyalty is tested at every turn.
The novel follows Shu Yan, a runaway hiding from the consequences of maiming a nobleman’s son, and Li Ming, the last swordsman of Blue Mountain, bound by oath to avenge his slain master and family. Their reluctant partnership creates a compelling dynamic—Shu Yan’s quick wit and impulsive defiance serve as the perfect foil to Li Ming’s stoic honor and unshakable resolve. Their banter injects warmth and humor into an otherwise grim quest for vengeance, giving the book its balance of sharp tension and camaraderie.
The road they travel is anything but simple. Bandits, scheming nobles, and elaborate conspiracies fill their journey with danger at every turn, and Lee’s writing captures the cinematic energy of wuxia fight sequences beautifully. The swordplay is vivid and balletic, yet grounded in emotional weight, each duel more than just a clash of blades—it’s about legacy, loyalty, and justice.
What makes this book shine is its blend of tones: equal parts sorrow and joy, grim vengeance and lighthearted banter. Inspired by kung fu films and westerns, the story shifts seamlessly from heartfelt moments to high-octane action, creating a reading experience that is both entertaining and deeply engaging.
The pacing, while brisk and action-packed, at times moves so quickly that certain emotional beats could have been given more space to resonate—especially around Li Ming’s vow of revenge and Shu Yan’s inner struggles. Still, this doesn’t detract much from the overall impact; rather, it leaves you hungry for more of their journey in the volumes to come.
The novel follows Shu Yan, a runaway hiding from the consequences of maiming a nobleman’s son, and Li Ming, the last swordsman of Blue Mountain, bound by oath to avenge his slain master and family. Their reluctant partnership creates a compelling dynamic—Shu Yan’s quick wit and impulsive defiance serve as the perfect foil to Li Ming’s stoic honor and unshakable resolve. Their banter injects warmth and humor into an otherwise grim quest for vengeance, giving the book its balance of sharp tension and camaraderie.
The road they travel is anything but simple. Bandits, scheming nobles, and elaborate conspiracies fill their journey with danger at every turn, and Lee’s writing captures the cinematic energy of wuxia fight sequences beautifully. The swordplay is vivid and balletic, yet grounded in emotional weight, each duel more than just a clash of blades—it’s about legacy, loyalty, and justice.
What makes this book shine is its blend of tones: equal parts sorrow and joy, grim vengeance and lighthearted banter. Inspired by kung fu films and westerns, the story shifts seamlessly from heartfelt moments to high-octane action, creating a reading experience that is both entertaining and deeply engaging.
The pacing, while brisk and action-packed, at times moves so quickly that certain emotional beats could have been given more space to resonate—especially around Li Ming’s vow of revenge and Shu Yan’s inner struggles. Still, this doesn’t detract much from the overall impact; rather, it leaves you hungry for more of their journey in the volumes to come.
January 10, 2023
I did not know much about the wuxia genre (like many others, the movie 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon' was probably the greatest exposure I've had), but Kindle Unlimited has this available and I was curious to maybe change things up a bit for some variety. I was interested in this tale of revenge and adventure, with a young Shu Yan trying to hide from a nobleman's son after scarring his face and taking up with swordsman Li Ming who is looking for avenge his family's murder.
Initially I thought it was really good with an introduction to the characters. What I did not realize is that it's really a set of short episodic stories that take our heroes from place to place, problem to problem, etc. There's nothing wrong with that (once I figured that was the approach that helped) but when I moved further along I admit I was frustrated with what felt like an incoherent storyline and difficulty keeping characters straight.
Still, it was interesting and is apparently not a bad way to be introduced to wuxia. With my lack of familiarity I can't say how well the genre translates to the page (vs. screen) but I do think if it was adapted for a miniseries or something it would do quite well.
So I think it's really a 3.5 out of 4 but will bump it up. It's still intriguing enough to me that the cliffhanger got me curious (although I wouldn't say I have to know.) For now I'd say that I'm a reader who is interested and should continue on with the trilogy if I want to find out what happens and if I don't pick it up right away I'll lose interest.
Kindle Unlimited borrow, but if I could have bought this trilogy as a bargain buy I wouldn't have minded. Similar to my previous paragraph, though, if I had to wait or couldn't get all three to binge read at once I might not keep going. All the same, it's enough to keep me interested. Library borrow would also be a good option.
Initially I thought it was really good with an introduction to the characters. What I did not realize is that it's really a set of short episodic stories that take our heroes from place to place, problem to problem, etc. There's nothing wrong with that (once I figured that was the approach that helped) but when I moved further along I admit I was frustrated with what felt like an incoherent storyline and difficulty keeping characters straight.
Still, it was interesting and is apparently not a bad way to be introduced to wuxia. With my lack of familiarity I can't say how well the genre translates to the page (vs. screen) but I do think if it was adapted for a miniseries or something it would do quite well.
So I think it's really a 3.5 out of 4 but will bump it up. It's still intriguing enough to me that the cliffhanger got me curious (although I wouldn't say I have to know.) For now I'd say that I'm a reader who is interested and should continue on with the trilogy if I want to find out what happens and if I don't pick it up right away I'll lose interest.
Kindle Unlimited borrow, but if I could have bought this trilogy as a bargain buy I wouldn't have minded. Similar to my previous paragraph, though, if I had to wait or couldn't get all three to binge read at once I might not keep going. All the same, it's enough to keep me interested. Library borrow would also be a good option.
December 29, 2023
I am always happy to journey to the Wuxia world of JF Lee’s imagination. He takes the misty grey mornings of a simpler time in China, where itinerant magistrates and wandering swordsmen are everyday sights, and paints them with his words.
As with traditional martial arts movies, the plot is simple: revenge. Add in the actors we follow; Li Ming, the swordsman; Shu Yan, his disciple - more interested in managing her financial empire than in waving around a sword; and Tao Jun, the swordsman’s magistrate brother, who has a sense of humour the other lacks.
“More? Isn’t this overkill?” Tao Jun rolled to his feet, wincing at the slash wound on his leg.
“It definitely feels like overkill.”
“You made someone mad at you,” Tao Jun accused.
“I’m pretty sure these are angry customers that want their bribe money back,” Li Ming retorted.
“You don’t get bribe money back. That’s not how corrupt officials work.”
What’s left is the need for a bad guy. Enter Shazu Kui, a man whose very name can be - must be - uttered only while gritting your teeth and growling.
The plot isn’t complicated. But the road the characters take is endlessly entertaining as obstacles spring up, often in the way of money-making offers that Shu Yan insists upon taking while on the way to various other places.
The language isn’t flowery. Yet, it’s beautiful in its simplicity. “By the time they returned to the caravan camp, the sun was a thought on the horizon.” That phrase painted the predawn for me so accurately, where birds are just beginning to stir and fluff their feathers in the minutes before midnight black gives way to indigo.
Of course, JF Lee books are not complete without footnotes. He likes to give extra information (the text contains some Wuxia or Chinese terminology) or to just poke fun at his characters.
Settle in with a bowl of tea and enjoy the writing.
As with traditional martial arts movies, the plot is simple: revenge. Add in the actors we follow; Li Ming, the swordsman; Shu Yan, his disciple - more interested in managing her financial empire than in waving around a sword; and Tao Jun, the swordsman’s magistrate brother, who has a sense of humour the other lacks.
“More? Isn’t this overkill?” Tao Jun rolled to his feet, wincing at the slash wound on his leg.
“It definitely feels like overkill.”
“You made someone mad at you,” Tao Jun accused.
“I’m pretty sure these are angry customers that want their bribe money back,” Li Ming retorted.
“You don’t get bribe money back. That’s not how corrupt officials work.”
What’s left is the need for a bad guy. Enter Shazu Kui, a man whose very name can be - must be - uttered only while gritting your teeth and growling.
The plot isn’t complicated. But the road the characters take is endlessly entertaining as obstacles spring up, often in the way of money-making offers that Shu Yan insists upon taking while on the way to various other places.
The language isn’t flowery. Yet, it’s beautiful in its simplicity. “By the time they returned to the caravan camp, the sun was a thought on the horizon.” That phrase painted the predawn for me so accurately, where birds are just beginning to stir and fluff their feathers in the minutes before midnight black gives way to indigo.
Of course, JF Lee books are not complete without footnotes. He likes to give extra information (the text contains some Wuxia or Chinese terminology) or to just poke fun at his characters.
Settle in with a bowl of tea and enjoy the writing.
July 19, 2025
First, thank you so much to the author of this book, J.F. Lee for sharing an ARC copy with me!
This book is a phenomenal piece of work. The story follows Li Ming, a skilled swordsman almost turned into a legend that has been wandering The Southern Province for more than a decade seeking to avenge the murder of his master and his family. A young orphan girl named Shu Yan crosses his path and hires his services to be escorted out of the city and be reunited with her family. They start their journey as reluctant companions, but an unlikely bond ends up forming between the two.
Sword of Sorrow Blade of Joy is a story about grief, trauma, resilience, and adventure that explores a plethora of topics and relies heavily on the found family trope. It follows a format similar to a series, since every couple of chapters follow our main characters throughout different cities, villages and other places. We are introduced to many secondary characters that enrich the story. Some of them are temporary and some are recurring.
The story has important action scenes, but since this is the first installment action is not exactly the center of it. This is more about exploration, mercenary work and political intrigue. The characters are memorable and the character development is subtle but palpable until we reach the climax.
It is important to note that this book isn’t particularly descriptive. The majority (but not all) of the characters’ feelings, emotions and development is shown to us instead of explained most of the time. The final battle is of epic proportions and all the emotions are revealed, leaving nothing hidden. It is guaranteed that we will adore our main characters’ story and how their bond keeps strengthening.
This piece of art is a love letter to Chinese culture and the wuxia genre. Can’t wait to read the rest of the series!
This book is a phenomenal piece of work. The story follows Li Ming, a skilled swordsman almost turned into a legend that has been wandering The Southern Province for more than a decade seeking to avenge the murder of his master and his family. A young orphan girl named Shu Yan crosses his path and hires his services to be escorted out of the city and be reunited with her family. They start their journey as reluctant companions, but an unlikely bond ends up forming between the two.
Sword of Sorrow Blade of Joy is a story about grief, trauma, resilience, and adventure that explores a plethora of topics and relies heavily on the found family trope. It follows a format similar to a series, since every couple of chapters follow our main characters throughout different cities, villages and other places. We are introduced to many secondary characters that enrich the story. Some of them are temporary and some are recurring.
The story has important action scenes, but since this is the first installment action is not exactly the center of it. This is more about exploration, mercenary work and political intrigue. The characters are memorable and the character development is subtle but palpable until we reach the climax.
It is important to note that this book isn’t particularly descriptive. The majority (but not all) of the characters’ feelings, emotions and development is shown to us instead of explained most of the time. The final battle is of epic proportions and all the emotions are revealed, leaving nothing hidden. It is guaranteed that we will adore our main characters’ story and how their bond keeps strengthening.
This piece of art is a love letter to Chinese culture and the wuxia genre. Can’t wait to read the rest of the series!
April 6, 2024
"Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy" is a wuxia novel by author JF Lee, the first in a series of novels that follows the adventures of lone swordsman Li Ming. The story starts with him (grudgingly) agreeing to accompany teenage brothel employee Shu Yan to her hometown. Both of them have their own shady pasts and initially dislike each other, but with each mini-adventure along the way, they learn to put up with the other and even come to develop a surrogate father-daughter bond.
The novel is very episodic, with the book divided into multiple parts, each centering around a specific adventure along the way. Li Ming's main quest is to find and kill the man who murdered his master, wife and child years before. But to get there, he will have to deal with corrupt officials, warring gangs, smuggling rings, powerful assassins, and perhaps even a monster!
The best part about Lee's writing is the playful rapport between the characters, especially Li Ming and Shu Yan. Their banter and growth as characters is what really makes the story fun to read, even though there are frequent opportunities for Lee to write exciting swordplay sequences between one of the most powerful swordsmen in the land and a plethora of different opponents. The supporting characters are all interesting, from the lovely Luoying to the penitent Monk Kong. The main protagonists' interactions with these people feels real and makes for entertaining reading.
The story ends on a cliffhanger, so onto "Fangs of the Black Tiger!"
The novel is very episodic, with the book divided into multiple parts, each centering around a specific adventure along the way. Li Ming's main quest is to find and kill the man who murdered his master, wife and child years before. But to get there, he will have to deal with corrupt officials, warring gangs, smuggling rings, powerful assassins, and perhaps even a monster!
The best part about Lee's writing is the playful rapport between the characters, especially Li Ming and Shu Yan. Their banter and growth as characters is what really makes the story fun to read, even though there are frequent opportunities for Lee to write exciting swordplay sequences between one of the most powerful swordsmen in the land and a plethora of different opponents. The supporting characters are all interesting, from the lovely Luoying to the penitent Monk Kong. The main protagonists' interactions with these people feels real and makes for entertaining reading.
The story ends on a cliffhanger, so onto "Fangs of the Black Tiger!"
November 29, 2020
BOOK OF ACTION, PAGES OF PLOT
This was a fun and engaging book to read in the vein of wuxia novels. I particularly liked the fact that it reads like a series of short stories with a thread of continuity that ties together the adventures of the swordsman Li Ming and his female teenage tag-along Shu Yan. The cast of supporting characters are well developed, and aren't there for just a 'one and done' appearance, but actual play pivotal roles in the overarching story line. JF Lee is also good to splice in Chinese terms, which bring a flavor to the storytelling. The chemistry between the main characters of Li Ming, a tragic hero and a loner, and Shu Yan, a naive yet smart young woman, is handled quite well, with neither character coming across as overbearing or annoying, and as a reader I soon became enrapt by the intertwining of the two, especially in their dialogues. The action is fairly paced, and the book ends on a cliffhanger. (That's not a deterrent to me, though I know some readers aren't always fans of that.) I do wish there was more detail in the action, though some readers tend to prefer otherwise, and this will be right up their alley. Also, I wish the finale had run a touch longer. Regardless, it's a solid effort with good characters, intriguing story arcs, and splashes of action. (Ideal for teens & adults alike. I appreciate the lack of profanity & gratuitous sex.) I'm looking forward to the continuation.
This was a fun and engaging book to read in the vein of wuxia novels. I particularly liked the fact that it reads like a series of short stories with a thread of continuity that ties together the adventures of the swordsman Li Ming and his female teenage tag-along Shu Yan. The cast of supporting characters are well developed, and aren't there for just a 'one and done' appearance, but actual play pivotal roles in the overarching story line. JF Lee is also good to splice in Chinese terms, which bring a flavor to the storytelling. The chemistry between the main characters of Li Ming, a tragic hero and a loner, and Shu Yan, a naive yet smart young woman, is handled quite well, with neither character coming across as overbearing or annoying, and as a reader I soon became enrapt by the intertwining of the two, especially in their dialogues. The action is fairly paced, and the book ends on a cliffhanger. (That's not a deterrent to me, though I know some readers aren't always fans of that.) I do wish there was more detail in the action, though some readers tend to prefer otherwise, and this will be right up their alley. Also, I wish the finale had run a touch longer. Regardless, it's a solid effort with good characters, intriguing story arcs, and splashes of action. (Ideal for teens & adults alike. I appreciate the lack of profanity & gratuitous sex.) I'm looking forward to the continuation.
January 23, 2025
My review is of all 4 books that are currently available.
This is an outstanding series, one of the best I have read in decades. In my opinion it is incredible entertainment for any fan of action or fantasy fiction but it is a true pleasure for fans of Kung Fu films and Chinese Martial Artists.
This story really compares to the lore and majesty of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and the charm and Kung Fu traditions of stories like Avatar the Last Airbender, the animated series but for adults.
There is great world building and superior secondary characters that standout; a sweeping epic tale that has noble but flawed antagonists; a swordsman that must choose between revenge for his family and master or salvation for his country, his promising new student, and perhaps a beautiful new love.
There are no easy answers and in the ancient setting of mystical China all under heaven gets their hands dirty and bloody.
Throw into that mix rare powerful swords that channel a master’s Chi and allow them to use abilities that any martial artist would die for.
This is an adventure that cannot be missed! You will be thinking about Li Ming, Tao Jun, Shu Yan and their quest to save the kingdom and the Blue Mountain Sect even after you are finished reading the last page.
As a fan of Kung Fu fiction and a Chinese Martial artist who had studied for 32 years the Tales of the Swordsman Series has my highest recommendation.
This is an outstanding series, one of the best I have read in decades. In my opinion it is incredible entertainment for any fan of action or fantasy fiction but it is a true pleasure for fans of Kung Fu films and Chinese Martial Artists.
This story really compares to the lore and majesty of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and the charm and Kung Fu traditions of stories like Avatar the Last Airbender, the animated series but for adults.
There is great world building and superior secondary characters that standout; a sweeping epic tale that has noble but flawed antagonists; a swordsman that must choose between revenge for his family and master or salvation for his country, his promising new student, and perhaps a beautiful new love.
There are no easy answers and in the ancient setting of mystical China all under heaven gets their hands dirty and bloody.
Throw into that mix rare powerful swords that channel a master’s Chi and allow them to use abilities that any martial artist would die for.
This is an adventure that cannot be missed! You will be thinking about Li Ming, Tao Jun, Shu Yan and their quest to save the kingdom and the Blue Mountain Sect even after you are finished reading the last page.
As a fan of Kung Fu fiction and a Chinese Martial artist who had studied for 32 years the Tales of the Swordsman Series has my highest recommendation.
August 3, 2021
“Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy” marks the start to the “Tales of the Swordman” series by JF Lee, who masterfully mixes traditional wuxia elements with a western writing style that offers the reader the best of both worlds. A real treat for any already fan of these martial arts/fantasy adventures and a wonderful lecture for those still not acquainted to the genre, who are looking to expand their lecture horizon.
The adventure consists of a series of short stories linked together through their main characters- Shu Yan and Li Ming – united in their journey by a destiny that appears to be random at the very first sight. While Li Ming quest consist of avenged the death of his own master, but exacting justice on the man that not only killed said master but also murdered his own family, Shu Yan just joined the quest to be able to hide from her pursues after having injured a nobleman’s son.
Both characters embark into a quest that have them facing bandits, con artists, and conspiracies along the way, much to the joyful entertainment of the reader.
The relationship between master and sidekick (which is one of the pivotal elements of wuxia tales) takes on a very modern mantle, while still remaining faithful to the genre, which in itself is already a huge accomplishment. Already looking forward to the next instalment.
The adventure consists of a series of short stories linked together through their main characters- Shu Yan and Li Ming – united in their journey by a destiny that appears to be random at the very first sight. While Li Ming quest consist of avenged the death of his own master, but exacting justice on the man that not only killed said master but also murdered his own family, Shu Yan just joined the quest to be able to hide from her pursues after having injured a nobleman’s son.
Both characters embark into a quest that have them facing bandits, con artists, and conspiracies along the way, much to the joyful entertainment of the reader.
The relationship between master and sidekick (which is one of the pivotal elements of wuxia tales) takes on a very modern mantle, while still remaining faithful to the genre, which in itself is already a huge accomplishment. Already looking forward to the next instalment.
July 23, 2021
The stories of the "wulin" are like a combination perhaps of the Star Wars saga and Lord of the Rings but imagine they had been written about for centuries rather than just in the 20th century alone. They are perhaps best known the rest of the world through the film "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon."
This is the "wuxia" genre and "Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy" is an excellent introduction. A tale both legendary and grounded in the heartbeat of the joys and sorrows that we all experience, the first in the series is a subtle combination of action, drama, and mystery.
Supported by an useful glossary and end notes, the story builds off the foundation of the well-known tropes and literary devices of the genre while simultaneously weaving together a gentle introduction to the many words and ideas that make these stories unique unto themselves.
If you've ever enjoyed "kung fu" films or legendary epics with melancholy swordsmen bent on revenge (and perhaps learning a thing or two in the process about life) then be sure to read "Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy."
This is the "wuxia" genre and "Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy" is an excellent introduction. A tale both legendary and grounded in the heartbeat of the joys and sorrows that we all experience, the first in the series is a subtle combination of action, drama, and mystery.
Supported by an useful glossary and end notes, the story builds off the foundation of the well-known tropes and literary devices of the genre while simultaneously weaving together a gentle introduction to the many words and ideas that make these stories unique unto themselves.
If you've ever enjoyed "kung fu" films or legendary epics with melancholy swordsmen bent on revenge (and perhaps learning a thing or two in the process about life) then be sure to read "Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy."
September 17, 2025
The book is about Li Ming, a disenfranchised martial arts master with a clouded history and a desire for revenge on the evil man that killed his Master. Early on he meets a girl, precocious, smart, doesn’t understand the meaning of the word no, who gloms onto him as his travel companion. She becomes a foil for banter and most of the plot forwarding choices for the rest of the book (and probably series). It’s an enjoyable relationship to experience.
Although the story has a couple of overarching arcs, it is really an assembled set of vignettes, mini adventures that are cobbled together to show the growth of the relationship and give us some fun-time action. The book is rather light on the fantastical aspects but it’s there as a minor thread, if you’re patient. The book almost reads as a 1970’s KungFu western serial.
It’s good and I enjoyed it. Will probably read the others just because I want to follow the characters.
Although the story has a couple of overarching arcs, it is really an assembled set of vignettes, mini adventures that are cobbled together to show the growth of the relationship and give us some fun-time action. The book is rather light on the fantastical aspects but it’s there as a minor thread, if you’re patient. The book almost reads as a 1970’s KungFu western serial.
It’s good and I enjoyed it. Will probably read the others just because I want to follow the characters.
February 19, 2022
I loved this book! The characters were warm, funny and engaging; the stories were varied and action-packed. I was invested in the characters and stories right from the off and I stayed engaged through the whole book; I can't wait to read the next one!
I really enjoyed the serialised set-up of the book, it reminded me of the Witcher series. I liked that even though there was a 'main' story that we were following, the side stories made up the main focus of the book.
It was funny (even the footnotes made me laugh) but it also touched on the moral implications of the jianghu lifestyle, as well as other broader societal issues: such as the interactions between different social classes.
Basically, I don't have a bad word to say about it!
I really enjoyed the serialised set-up of the book, it reminded me of the Witcher series. I liked that even though there was a 'main' story that we were following, the side stories made up the main focus of the book.
It was funny (even the footnotes made me laugh) but it also touched on the moral implications of the jianghu lifestyle, as well as other broader societal issues: such as the interactions between different social classes.
Basically, I don't have a bad word to say about it!
December 5, 2024
A good Wuxia fantasy. a little too episodic and meandering for my taste, kinda like each story section was written individually as a stand alone and everything was connected together later in a loose plot. which, mild spoilers, but the plot is just revenge and wandering like most Kung fu movies. The character goals are nebulous and their motivations are simple, which works for this type of narrative. some good writer 'fudging' of time and distance traveled, which helps the story move along, whenever there is story to tell. well written, but no flowery dialogue or poetic prose. Fun characters with good relationships that actually develop. well worth the read and a worthy place on my Wulin shelf
January 27, 2023
My main interest in this trilogy is primarily to do with the wuxia element. I grew up watching these types of tv series though I've not watch many in the last couple of decades so it was more of a walk through memory lane. While it's not the same story or characters, this novel is full of the 'same' (ie. identical) characters and it was tropes after tropes after tropes that you find in this type of story. So while it was a comfortable and entertaining read, it was also a tad disappointing that there wasn't anything new or any unexpected twist. I still plan on continuing with the rest of the series though as this one sort of end in a bit of cliffhanger.
February 7, 2023
The
Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy
is a fun wuxia action adventure. I think J.F. Lee has a solid debut on his hands.
The story has two main POV’s Li Ming a master swordsman and Shu Yan a runaway who was sold off as a child and has been doing whatever it takes to survive ever since. The scene where these two meet is filled with laughs and their dynamic cracks me up right up until the end.
The pacing is very quick and makes for easy reading although at times it feels a little too rushed leaving some chapters only 1 or 2 pages at most. While the overall story feels very connected, each part as it's broken up is a story within a story.
Overall I really enjoyed the book and plan to continue on with the series. The only other critique with the book is the author's choice of font in the physical edition. While the main text is fine at times when he wants to emphasize a point the font he chose can be really hard to read on some words and I hope this got addressed in the follow up books in the series. If not I might just stick with eBooks moving forward.
The story has two main POV’s Li Ming a master swordsman and Shu Yan a runaway who was sold off as a child and has been doing whatever it takes to survive ever since. The scene where these two meet is filled with laughs and their dynamic cracks me up right up until the end.
The pacing is very quick and makes for easy reading although at times it feels a little too rushed leaving some chapters only 1 or 2 pages at most. While the overall story feels very connected, each part as it's broken up is a story within a story.
Overall I really enjoyed the book and plan to continue on with the series. The only other critique with the book is the author's choice of font in the physical edition. While the main text is fine at times when he wants to emphasize a point the font he chose can be really hard to read on some words and I hope this got addressed in the follow up books in the series. If not I might just stick with eBooks moving forward.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 69 reviews