What do you think?
Rate this book
The Amazing Spider-Man (1963-1998) #176-180
The Amazing Spider-Man: A New Goblin
Collects Amazing Spider-man 176-180
94 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2008
About the author
Len Wein
1,600 books162 followersLen Wein was an American comic book writer and editor best known for co-creating DC Comics' Swamp Thing and Marvel Comics' Wolverine, and for helping revive the Marvel superhero team the X-Men (including the co-creation of Nightcrawler, Storm, and Colossus). Additionally, he was the editor for writer Alan Moore and illustrator Dave Gibbons' influential DC miniseries Watchmen.
Wein was inducted into the Will Eisner Comic Book Hall of Fame in 2008.
Wein was inducted into the Will Eisner Comic Book Hall of Fame in 2008.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
March 19, 2009
With the (seeming) multitude of Green Goblins that run around the Spider-Man universe, it could be easy to forget there was, for a short time, a third person who donned the Goblin outfit back in the day.
"A New Goblin" collects that storyline together and it's full of all the things that made Spider-Man, well, Spider-Man. It's got angst with Aunt May, it has Peter struggling to balance his real identity with that of his secret identity, it's got villians in a power struggle and it's got an undercurrent of relationship angst for Parker. All these come to a boil when the Goblin decides he wants to be the crime boss of New York and will trade Spidey's secret identity for this. Meanwhile, Aunt May is in the hospital, waiting for Peter to arrive to give consent for a life-saving surgery.
In a lot of ways, this is a greatest hits of themes from Amazing Spider-Man days of old. It's enjoyable and fun to read and they to try to throw in a twist or two. But it's still not as strong as some of Spidey's original battles with Goblin back when Stan Lee was writing the book.
"A New Goblin" collects that storyline together and it's full of all the things that made Spider-Man, well, Spider-Man. It's got angst with Aunt May, it has Peter struggling to balance his real identity with that of his secret identity, it's got villians in a power struggle and it's got an undercurrent of relationship angst for Parker. All these come to a boil when the Goblin decides he wants to be the crime boss of New York and will trade Spidey's secret identity for this. Meanwhile, Aunt May is in the hospital, waiting for Peter to arrive to give consent for a life-saving surgery.
In a lot of ways, this is a greatest hits of themes from Amazing Spider-Man days of old. It's enjoyable and fun to read and they to try to throw in a twist or two. But it's still not as strong as some of Spidey's original battles with Goblin back when Stan Lee was writing the book.
May 29, 2025
This is a pretty good quality 70s vintage Spidey tale! It does better than most of the era at balancing the soap opera drama, Peter's aw-shucks navel gazing, and really quality superheroics. It's got a twist that anyone with a couple of brain cells could see coming, but it's well-executed and serves Harry Osborn's character quite well. It hits a lot of the Spidey tropes, but does so in fun and somewhat fresh ways: Aunt May's back in the hospital, of course - but it's because she was out agitating with the Grey Panthers! Peter has to rush to her side, sure - but this time, he's the one who has to sign off on her life-saving surgery! (Not sure how that works...) And fine, another underworld crime war is brewing - but the Green Goblin is just going to murder all their asses!
I also like the little convention that carried over from the Silver Age of naming Green Goblin battles with these kind of off kilter, nursey rhyme-esque little titles: "Goblin in the Middle!" "Green Grows the Goblin!" "The Goblin's Always Greener!" "Who Was That Goblin I Saw With You?" It's cute and I wish it never stopped!
I also like the little convention that carried over from the Silver Age of naming Green Goblin battles with these kind of off kilter, nursey rhyme-esque little titles: "Goblin in the Middle!" "Green Grows the Goblin!" "The Goblin's Always Greener!" "Who Was That Goblin I Saw With You?" It's cute and I wish it never stopped!
October 18, 2026
Another entry into the overall Goblin rivalry, but this time it’s a bigger Hardy story than it is Peter, Spidey or Goblin story. It’s fun and it’s narratively solid, despite a lackluster conclusion and unexciting, predictable twist.
The criminal sparring is good enough to stand on its own, so the aunt may health subplot (for the 50th time) feels a bit like fluff to stretch the page count. The old school Marvel editorial trick of sending Aunt May to the hospital to stress Peter out is so uninspired. This era spent a lot of time retelling the same stories that Lee paved the way with, and that Conway polished. Really, most of Spider-Man 150-220ish is forgettable, save for a few special issues, and this third Goblin identity tale is no exception to that generalization. The big reveal lacks any punch and doesn’t service any future plots so it’s a bit flat.
Biggest highlight is Harry choosing his own path forward, love to see it. This run has a lot of themes of golden age Spidey, but isn’t as substantive as other Goblin stories.
The criminal sparring is good enough to stand on its own, so the aunt may health subplot (for the 50th time) feels a bit like fluff to stretch the page count. The old school Marvel editorial trick of sending Aunt May to the hospital to stress Peter out is so uninspired. This era spent a lot of time retelling the same stories that Lee paved the way with, and that Conway polished. Really, most of Spider-Man 150-220ish is forgettable, save for a few special issues, and this third Goblin identity tale is no exception to that generalization. The big reveal lacks any punch and doesn’t service any future plots so it’s a bit flat.
Biggest highlight is Harry choosing his own path forward, love to see it. This run has a lot of themes of golden age Spidey, but isn’t as substantive as other Goblin stories.
February 13, 2022
A five issue tale from the 70's which is fine but not really worth a special collection. You have solid writing by Len Wein and solid art by Ross Andru but it is a mostly forgettable tale of a "new Goblin". I have to say - it doesn't make any sense that this new Goblin is "the fastest thing" because he never got a special formula to make him strong like Norman Osborn did. He is an ordinary human and, in theory, Spider-man should take care of him with one punch. I always get a little frustrated when a hero's powers fluctuate depending on the need of the writer and the story they are currently writing.
Overall the big reveal was kind of obvious to me so it lacked a wow factor. Also - the subplot of "Aunt May is dying - where is Peter!!?" is so old. I found a lot of these 70's Spider-man stories were just retreading ground Stan Lee had established and they didn't bring much new to the table.
Overall the big reveal was kind of obvious to me so it lacked a wow factor. Also - the subplot of "Aunt May is dying - where is Peter!!?" is so old. I found a lot of these 70's Spider-man stories were just retreading ground Stan Lee had established and they didn't bring much new to the table.
July 20, 2024
This is one of those left-field trades. Why on Earth would they collect a 30 plus year old arc that has no bearing on today’s continuity? I’m not complaining, just curious! I owned all of the floppies as cheap-o back issues some 20 odd years ago. Len Wein's writing is great with the exception of the over-used phrase "web slinger", as if everyone who meets him would call him that. It would be more fun if you made a drinking game out of it, I imagine. While most of the peeps on the Intrawebs hate on Ross Andru, I actually enjoy his take on the character. Sure, it's a bit rough around the edges, but his action sequences are good and he met his deadlines. Trades like this are great because they offer a slice of Bronze Age goodness at an affordable price.
July 7, 2019
A classic 1970s Green Goblin story.
September 18, 2013
It's fun to see how Marvel was playing with the legacy of the Goblin back in the day (and I enjoyed finally getting to read this complete story, as I'd only owned #180, the last issue, when I was young). Unfortunately Len's pace is too plodding and there's way too much artificially created drama for this to be a particularly great story.
September 21, 2014
Spiderman is attacked by the Green Goblin, but Harry was thought to be cured. Meanwhile Aunt May is very ill again. A short book, and predictable story line. The Aunt May plot was a bit of a repeat, I'd heard it all before. The slight twist at the end, though predictable was a nice change. A good read.
November 12, 2008
good silver-age story about the third green goblin. alluding that it's harry, there's a nice plot twist that was probably huge back then. i wish marvel would put out more of these older spidey stories out, cause comics these days just don't have the same feel.
April 25, 2012
For better or worse, they just don't write comics like this anymore. *g* The narration is amusing, florid, and festooned with exclamation points. It really takes me back.
I figured out the Green Goblin's identity way before I should have, though.
I figured out the Green Goblin's identity way before I should have, though.
January 26, 2009
An alright Spidey story but even though I love the character some of the inane expositionary speech from the older comics is still a little annoying.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews