I have been wanting this book since the minute I saw it advertised. I am a HUGE fan of Jane Smiley's Horse Heaven (10 stars), and she knows horses, and this premise sounded so delightful. I got hold of the book the MINUTE my library put it out (Dec 9). I'm sorry to say that I was disappointed in it. I was hoping for magic and charm and humor, and largely, it was missing. It was mechanical, the horse did this and then she did this and then the dog did this....At 1/3 I was feeling so disappointed (and glad I hadn't bought the book), but at 2/3 I was getting invested in the characters and had to see if they were going to be all right and by the end, I was happy that it ended well. Surprisingly for me, my favorite character was not the horse, she was a bit empty headed and didn't excite too much interest....it was the raven, Raoul, who was a smarty pants and too opinionated. He was cool. And the mallards were funny. I guess I like birds.
The only time I laughed out loud was on pg 182, when Raoul the raven, who thought the mallards were silly, hysterical creatures, said he had "seen flocks of mallards squawking constantly, as if shouting to humans , "Shoot me! I can't stand myself any longer!". Hahahaha! Can totally picture it. Later, "Sid" the male duck, comes back after a winter in the south, and Raoul doesn't recognize him because he's calm and easy-going now. Sid the duck reveals that he's had a lot of counseling over the winter. He found out that duckling traumas had had a strong impact on his worldview, but he can own his future...Oh, and he finds his mate, Nancy, has had 6 ducklings and "they all look like Nancy." Have you ever seen ducklings???? We needed more of this in this book...!
I did find a few things I wanted to underline, but couldn't because it was a library book...but there weren't many...sorry, Jane Smiley!!! I wanted to love it!! Honest, I've been telling everyone I HAD TO HAVE THIS BOOK! I'm suspecting that if Disney options it for a movie, that the movie will be better than the book, because the movie will make the animals cute and give them better dialogue.
Someone did say that it was interesting to see the animal's view of humans and there were some good parts....Paras the filly says that humans needed to name racehorses because otherwise, they couldn't tell them apart, and she's incredulous over that.
I read all the other reviews and almost all told the whole story and synopsis OVER and OVER and OVER again....not doing that here.
Sometimes all the other people in the story were hard to keep track of: Rania, Delphine, Madeleine, Pierre, Anais, Jerome, Etienne, etc, etc....
And what time period was this? Sounds like modern day, but in the story, Paris is deserted at night, even downtown, near the Eiffel Tower and other famous attractions, but as far as I'm aware this is another city that never sleeps.....right?
Anyway, I'm in the minority here, among all the 4 and 5 star reviews, so maybe others see more in it than I do. I do feel fond about it, but it wasn't GREAT. I was glad that nothing traumatic or sad happened to the animals, at least I didn't have to cry.