4 Stars
6/16/22- reread
By far my favorite in the series for sure, which is super odd because this book had tropes I hate. The hero is a 32 year old, single, divorced, dad, not a manh*, but the last time he had sex was a ONS, three months before he met heroine. The heroine is a 26 year old virgin. Again, all tropes I hate, and yet I was actually really entertained here, even with the length of the book. The heroine is super sweet and caring, won't stand for settling, and she does have a bit of a backbone, although sometimes BBS does get in the way, though it didn't really annoy too much. There are multiple mentions of his ex wife and how their relationship was, but it never causes jealousy for the heroine seeing as the hero hates his ex, and she isn't a good person. His trust issues from that relationship do affect their own relationship a bit though.
There were little things that were just weird or off though. One weird thing is how literally EVERYONE in her family knew she was a virgin. Like, huh?? Then we have the hero who has a goatee and I was hoping to forget it but the heroine kept bringing it up. Will I ever find goatees attractive in books? Probably never. Then we have too many people that were against the MCs or holding grudges. There was his ex student/player, the heroine's friend, and the hero's ex wife. I didn't mind the drama that came from them necessarily, I just didn't really care for how everything was wrapped up, it was a little unrealistic.
Also, when she lost her virginity to hero, I wasn't a fan of how she kept saying she was unknowingly waiting for him and had only ever kissed other guys before, because it made it even more obvious how much he was NOT waiting for her. I didn't mind her actually being a virgin until him, mainly because it brought out his super possessive side, but I just wish that it would be a little less obvious of him having been with other women before. For example, he makes a comment of how he can't wait for her to be on birth control because it feels SO much better bare. Kudos to the heroine for never being jealous though.
Besides all that, there were a couple other really small things I wasn't a fan of, but compared to the first 2 books, they are pretty insignificant since I actually really liked this story, unlike the first two. And it definitely reminds me of why I loved this author's writing in the first place. Absolutely loved the hero here, and definitely my favorite heroine in this series. And the hero being a single dad actually worked for me too. It was super cute seeing him with his kids, and how he loved seeing her with them too. Great book.