What do you think?
Rate this book
Hearts of Gold #1
The Test of Gold
Raised in the shadow of a mother who defied convention, but won’t allow her own daughter the right to make the same choices, heiress Evangeline Lindenmayer has been groomed since childhood to marry into the British aristocracy.
When Lindy challenges her mother’s long-laid plans by falling in love with a poor seminary student, the explosion is bigger than the Brooklyn Bridge fireworks on Independence Day.
When Lindy challenges her mother’s long-laid plans by falling in love with a poor seminary student, the explosion is bigger than the Brooklyn Bridge fireworks on Independence Day.
- GenresHistoricalRomance
300 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 31, 2021
94 people are currently reading
61 people want to read
About the author
Renee Yancy
14 books45 followersRenee Yancy is a history and archaeology nut who has been living vicariously through historical fiction since she was a young girl.
Now she writes the kind of books she loves to read—stories filled with historical and archaeological detail on every aspect of living in a different time period, interwoven with strong characters and a tale full of pathos and conflict.
When she isn't writing historical fiction or traveling to see the places her characters have lived, she can be found in the wilds of Kentucky with her husband and two rescue mutts named Ellie and Charlie.
Now she writes the kind of books she loves to read—stories filled with historical and archaeological detail on every aspect of living in a different time period, interwoven with strong characters and a tale full of pathos and conflict.
When she isn't writing historical fiction or traveling to see the places her characters have lived, she can be found in the wilds of Kentucky with her husband and two rescue mutts named Ellie and Charlie.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
March 12, 2021
Heiress Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer has been groomed since childhood to marry into the British aristocracy as her mother's ultimate ambition is a royal title for the family name. But literature fascinates Lindy far more than ballroomss, and she spends all her free time in the library, the only room in the Fifth Avenue mansion where she can safely indulge her passion for reading and find refuge from the prying eyes of her mother. Jack Winthrop is studying for the ministry at Union Theological Seminary and has been invited to use the Lindemayer's library for his studies. His sole experience of upper-class young women has occurred at his uncle's church, where he has found these young debutantes universally featherbrained. When he meets Lindy, he is pleasantly surprised to discover she has wide-ranging interests and is highly intelligent.
A new author to me & it certainly won’t be the last I read. A well written book with charming characters. I really liked both Jack & Lindy & how their secret & forbidden romance progressed. I also perversely liked Lindy's mother even though her aspirations were annoying but humorous. I loved how Lindy grew throughout the book. An engaging read which kept my interest all the way through
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
A new author to me & it certainly won’t be the last I read. A well written book with charming characters. I really liked both Jack & Lindy & how their secret & forbidden romance progressed. I also perversely liked Lindy's mother even though her aspirations were annoying but humorous. I loved how Lindy grew throughout the book. An engaging read which kept my interest all the way through
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
April 11, 2021
3.5 stars
The Test of Gold by Renee Yancy takes us to the heart of the Gilded Age, immersing us equally in the glitter & the grime of the era. Before all is said and done, we’ll have traveled with Lindy to Paris, London, and back home to New York; in each new setting, Yancy’s vivid descriptions and attention to detail have you feeling as though you’re right there, a part of the crowd. And no matter where the story takes us, readers will be rooting for Lindy and her happily-ever-after.
Any romance that begins in a library has a special place in my heart, and that’s exactly how Lindy and Jack meet – in her father’s well-stocked library. Though they are certainly from different tiers in society, here in the library Lindy & Jack are on common ground and the discrepancy in their social statuses doesn’t seem quite as insurmountable. I really liked both of these characters and how authentic they were. Two young adults still trying to find their footing in life, realizing they actually have more in common than they do apart. The juxtaposition of their societal differences versus their internal similarities added new dimension to their characters as well as the plot, and I appreciated how Yancy portrayed them.
There were three other characters I loved as well – Lindy’s maid Claudine, Lindy’s aunt Gertrude & Lindy’s cousin Emma. All three women were independent, strong characters, each fascinating in her own right and each someone who saw Lindy’s true worth & encouraged her to step out into a path of freedom. While neither had a ton of page time in this book, I hope we see more of them in the series because they need their own stories! The majority of the other characters in The Test of Gold? I didn’t care for them at all, and two in particular were really over the top cruel, almost psychotic. They became oppressive to me, to be honest, and interrupted my reading flow.
Bottom Line: The Test of Gold by Renee Yancy is an entertaining dance through the Gilded Age with a couple of villains to hate, a hero to swoon over, and a heroine to love. Readers will desperately cheer for Lindy to break free of her mother’s obsessive mission and will earnestly root for Lindy and Jack to overcome all the obstacles to happily-ever-after. Descriptions make each scene and character come alive on the pages, and though I wasn’t entirely satisfied with how this story ended, I’m interested to see how it continues in book 2. Some of the characters were problematic, as were decisions made by other supporting players, but overall this is a book that will definitely tug at your emotions!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first seen at Reading Is My SuperPower
The Test of Gold by Renee Yancy takes us to the heart of the Gilded Age, immersing us equally in the glitter & the grime of the era. Before all is said and done, we’ll have traveled with Lindy to Paris, London, and back home to New York; in each new setting, Yancy’s vivid descriptions and attention to detail have you feeling as though you’re right there, a part of the crowd. And no matter where the story takes us, readers will be rooting for Lindy and her happily-ever-after.
Any romance that begins in a library has a special place in my heart, and that’s exactly how Lindy and Jack meet – in her father’s well-stocked library. Though they are certainly from different tiers in society, here in the library Lindy & Jack are on common ground and the discrepancy in their social statuses doesn’t seem quite as insurmountable. I really liked both of these characters and how authentic they were. Two young adults still trying to find their footing in life, realizing they actually have more in common than they do apart. The juxtaposition of their societal differences versus their internal similarities added new dimension to their characters as well as the plot, and I appreciated how Yancy portrayed them.
There were three other characters I loved as well – Lindy’s maid Claudine, Lindy’s aunt Gertrude & Lindy’s cousin Emma. All three women were independent, strong characters, each fascinating in her own right and each someone who saw Lindy’s true worth & encouraged her to step out into a path of freedom. While neither had a ton of page time in this book, I hope we see more of them in the series because they need their own stories! The majority of the other characters in The Test of Gold? I didn’t care for them at all, and two in particular were really over the top cruel, almost psychotic. They became oppressive to me, to be honest, and interrupted my reading flow.
Bottom Line: The Test of Gold by Renee Yancy is an entertaining dance through the Gilded Age with a couple of villains to hate, a hero to swoon over, and a heroine to love. Readers will desperately cheer for Lindy to break free of her mother’s obsessive mission and will earnestly root for Lindy and Jack to overcome all the obstacles to happily-ever-after. Descriptions make each scene and character come alive on the pages, and though I wasn’t entirely satisfied with how this story ended, I’m interested to see how it continues in book 2. Some of the characters were problematic, as were decisions made by other supporting players, but overall this is a book that will definitely tug at your emotions!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first seen at Reading Is My SuperPower
March 27, 2021
The Test of Gold is the first book in Hearts of Gold series.
Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer is ready to be presented to high society. Her mother will make sure of it, it's has to be just so and she's been planning this presentation for years. Her mother is planning further and will do anything to make sure her daughter catches the eye of a Duke for marriage.
When Lindy tries to stand up to her mother she is impossible to reason with and turns to her husband for his support. Now one thing her father has never been able to do is stand up to her mother.
Lindy is her own person and is a modern woman with her own mind. She wants to marry a man of her own choosing she has fallen in love with and do something very few women did back then .
There is a general halabaloo with this modern minded woman not bowing and scraping to her mother and I was glad to see she is standing up for herself.
This is my first read by this author and I look forward to reading more by her.
Pub Date 15 Mar 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer is ready to be presented to high society. Her mother will make sure of it, it's has to be just so and she's been planning this presentation for years. Her mother is planning further and will do anything to make sure her daughter catches the eye of a Duke for marriage.
When Lindy tries to stand up to her mother she is impossible to reason with and turns to her husband for his support. Now one thing her father has never been able to do is stand up to her mother.
Lindy is her own person and is a modern woman with her own mind. She wants to marry a man of her own choosing she has fallen in love with and do something very few women did back then .
There is a general halabaloo with this modern minded woman not bowing and scraping to her mother and I was glad to see she is standing up for herself.
This is my first read by this author and I look forward to reading more by her.
Pub Date 15 Mar 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
February 22, 2021
The Test of Gold follows Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer as she prepares to be presented to high society. Only, she's more interested in spending her days reading in the family's library, where she meets a young man studying. She is distraught that they must say goodbye, but her mother will not be swayed from her plans. Until Lindy is inspired to stand her ground that is.
I really resonated with Lindy as a character, I too preferred books over boys when I was 18. I enjoyed watching Jack and Lindy bond over their shared love of books. My heart broke for Lindy, what kind of mother treats their child that way?
There were a few things that I paused and though, "Hm, that doesn't seem accurate to the time period.", but historical accuracy isn't too important to me.
Overall this book was a well written and enjoyable romance.
*This eARC was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I really resonated with Lindy as a character, I too preferred books over boys when I was 18. I enjoyed watching Jack and Lindy bond over their shared love of books. My heart broke for Lindy, what kind of mother treats their child that way?
There were a few things that I paused and though, "Hm, that doesn't seem accurate to the time period.", but historical accuracy isn't too important to me.
Overall this book was a well written and enjoyable romance.
*This eARC was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
August 11, 2025
Captivating and clean!
I read a lot of books, too many probably. Always I’m looking for that escape, that thrill of being so ensconced in a story that life is forgotten for a few moments while you laugh and cry with newfound friends. With boldly drawn characters, a deep and twisting plot and enough details to satisfy even the most active of imaginations (mine included), Renee Yancy has done just that! I especially appreciate the cleanliness of her writing as I find the sordid details distracting to the nth degree. I’ve found a new favorite author!
I read a lot of books, too many probably. Always I’m looking for that escape, that thrill of being so ensconced in a story that life is forgotten for a few moments while you laugh and cry with newfound friends. With boldly drawn characters, a deep and twisting plot and enough details to satisfy even the most active of imaginations (mine included), Renee Yancy has done just that! I especially appreciate the cleanliness of her writing as I find the sordid details distracting to the nth degree. I’ve found a new favorite author!
March 9, 2021
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for this copy in exchange for my honest review.
This book was a lovely story, not very in depth but all together a good story. I enjoyed reading the historical fiction romance from New York other than the standard English that I have read (I have only just got into this genre). The use of the old English words but Americanised was really fitting and made the story that little bit better!
The character building was slightly rushed and I felt that in some parts there was things missing that a little detail here and there would have made it a little better.
I throughly enjoyed watching Lindys life unfold and to finally step up to her horrendous mother, the one thing I would have really lived if the ending wasn’t so rushed... there was a lot of running back and forward and no one was getting anywhere. I personally would have loved to see Jack and Lindy’s story progress more than it had.
This book was a lovely story, not very in depth but all together a good story. I enjoyed reading the historical fiction romance from New York other than the standard English that I have read (I have only just got into this genre). The use of the old English words but Americanised was really fitting and made the story that little bit better!
The character building was slightly rushed and I felt that in some parts there was things missing that a little detail here and there would have made it a little better.
I throughly enjoyed watching Lindys life unfold and to finally step up to her horrendous mother, the one thing I would have really lived if the ending wasn’t so rushed... there was a lot of running back and forward and no one was getting anywhere. I personally would have loved to see Jack and Lindy’s story progress more than it had.
February 11, 2021
What a lovely, sweet romance! The plot twists and turns in such an unpredictable manner that I read on at a rapid pace, anxiously hoping for Lindy and Jack to find a way to be together.
Lindy's narcissistic mother creates enormous problems for the couple. She doesn't brook having her will crossed, and her ambitious plans for Lindy throw many obstacles in her path.
I was shocked at the extravagance of the times, and I see now why this period in American history was called the Gilded Age. All that glitters isn't gold, however, and the high concentration of wealth in certain areas of society was only a patina, a thin shiny layer on the surface of something far less salubrious. It was eye-opening and saddening to read about the suffering of the less fortunate members of society at this time.
Although there are some serious elements to this story, the writing has a lightness of touch, which I appreciated. I particularly enjoyed the end of the book, which was both poignant and amusing at the same time.
I highly recommend this novel to lovers of sweet historical romance, who enjoy an inspirational flavour to their reading.
Lindy's narcissistic mother creates enormous problems for the couple. She doesn't brook having her will crossed, and her ambitious plans for Lindy throw many obstacles in her path.
I was shocked at the extravagance of the times, and I see now why this period in American history was called the Gilded Age. All that glitters isn't gold, however, and the high concentration of wealth in certain areas of society was only a patina, a thin shiny layer on the surface of something far less salubrious. It was eye-opening and saddening to read about the suffering of the less fortunate members of society at this time.
Although there are some serious elements to this story, the writing has a lightness of touch, which I appreciated. I particularly enjoyed the end of the book, which was both poignant and amusing at the same time.
I highly recommend this novel to lovers of sweet historical romance, who enjoy an inspirational flavour to their reading.
March 26, 2021
Hands up - who does not love a forbidden romance? I most certainly do. But Test of Gold is so much more than the typical Regency romance novel. Firstly, this book is set in America. But Vera, Lindy's mother, is determined that her daughter has a season in London, with the hope that Lindy will find herself a duke to give the Lindenmayer family, or Vera in particular, the ability to boast that they are connected with the British aristocracy. What Lindy wants is neither here nor there. She has been groomed her entire life to become a duchess, but that was until she met Jack Winthorp. Unfortunately, Jack is neither a duke nor British nor is he particularly well connected. In fact, he is so below Lindy's social standing that they would be ridiculously stupid to fall in love with each other!
Another thing that makes this book different from other historical romances is that the heroine is not rescued by the handsomely heroic love of her life. Instead, Lindy must save herself. This, I thought, was really refreshing. If Lindy wants to marry the man she loves, she is going to have to fight for him.
I cannot write a review without mentioning Vera. If ambition had a face, it would be hers. Vera is so self-absorbed in achieving her own greatness and living the life she wanted through her daughter that she never stops to think where her actions will lead. She is a dominating and incredibly cruel woman who will not think twice about playing dirty to get her daughter to comply with her commands. This formidable woman is truly awful, but in a way, she sums up how many mothers must have felt in the aristocracy - a love match was not what they desired for their daughters; what they wanted were titles and wealth.
This is a novel that really got under my skin because of the emotional abuse that Lindy has to go through. But I also think it gives the reader a sense of hope - but I feel that I really need to add a link to Refuge: https://www.refuge.org.uk/ for anyone who might read this book and recognise themselves in Lindy's situation.
I thought this novel was a wonderful, written and a very insightful story. I will certainly be checking out more novels from this very talented author.
*I received a copy of this book via The Coffee Pot Book Club for review consideration.
Another thing that makes this book different from other historical romances is that the heroine is not rescued by the handsomely heroic love of her life. Instead, Lindy must save herself. This, I thought, was really refreshing. If Lindy wants to marry the man she loves, she is going to have to fight for him.
I cannot write a review without mentioning Vera. If ambition had a face, it would be hers. Vera is so self-absorbed in achieving her own greatness and living the life she wanted through her daughter that she never stops to think where her actions will lead. She is a dominating and incredibly cruel woman who will not think twice about playing dirty to get her daughter to comply with her commands. This formidable woman is truly awful, but in a way, she sums up how many mothers must have felt in the aristocracy - a love match was not what they desired for their daughters; what they wanted were titles and wealth.
This is a novel that really got under my skin because of the emotional abuse that Lindy has to go through. But I also think it gives the reader a sense of hope - but I feel that I really need to add a link to Refuge: https://www.refuge.org.uk/ for anyone who might read this book and recognise themselves in Lindy's situation.
I thought this novel was a wonderful, written and a very insightful story. I will certainly be checking out more novels from this very talented author.
*I received a copy of this book via The Coffee Pot Book Club for review consideration.
February 22, 2021
Set in the late 1890s and based on a true story, The Test of Gold is an enjoyable, entertaining glimpse into high society during the Gilded Age in America and the life of a young debutante, Evangeline “Lindy” Lindenmayer who wants no part of it! With her expressive, flowing style, Ms. Yancy impressively portrays the culture, attitudes, and social mores of the times. Whether the setting be New York, Paris, or London; Ms. Yancy’s vivid descriptions transport you to the scene. The quickly moving, suspenseful plot keeps you turning pages. Historical figures and places are infused into the fictional narrative with ease. The lead characters Lindy and Jack are delightful and endearing, and the development of their sweet, forbidden romance tugs at your heartstrings. I especially enjoyed their clandestine meetings in the library as they shared book discussions and their hearts. I also liked cousin Emma who was a breath of fresh air in a stuffy society and would love to know more about her. A bit of humor, especially at the debutante ball, and a sprinkling of spiritual truths were a bonus. Ms. Yancy is a new author to me, and I am looking forward to the next book in The Hearts of Gold series. I decidedly recommend this book especially for lovers of historical romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher/author. All opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher/author. All opinions are my own.
February 23, 2021
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own. I’ve never been known to be a fan of historical fiction. But I think I’m learning that there are niches of historical fiction that I enjoy. I’ve been wanting to read a book like this for a while, and I’m so glad that I had the opportunity to read A Test of Gold. I loved the dynamics between the characters: Lindy and her mom, Lindy and Jack and their forbidden romance. This was a great read and it didn’t disappoint.
April 6, 2021
If you are looking for a introduction into Sweet Historical Romances this is the book for you!
Jack Winthrop is your typical nerdy guy studying for the ministry and doing dual degrees. He happens to be allowed into the home of the Lindenmayers because they have a library that is top notch!
Lindy is the only daughter and so she has been groomed by mommy to make a match and her mother covets one from the British overseas! Lindy on the other hand is a secret blue stocking and privately has been meeting Jack,
You see where I am going! Mommy Dearest erupts and the outcome is not pretty! Read this book because you won’t believe what all happens!!
I received a free advanced copy from NetGalley and these are my willingly given thoughts and opinions.
Jack Winthrop is your typical nerdy guy studying for the ministry and doing dual degrees. He happens to be allowed into the home of the Lindenmayers because they have a library that is top notch!
Lindy is the only daughter and so she has been groomed by mommy to make a match and her mother covets one from the British overseas! Lindy on the other hand is a secret blue stocking and privately has been meeting Jack,
You see where I am going! Mommy Dearest erupts and the outcome is not pretty! Read this book because you won’t believe what all happens!!
I received a free advanced copy from NetGalley and these are my willingly given thoughts and opinions.
March 15, 2021
This is the first novel I have read by this author and I enjoyed it very much. I really liked her writing style and the characters were very relatable. I love how the author immediately pulls you into this story. Set in the 1890’s this engrossing read is based on a true story.
Evangeline “Lindy” Lindenmayer was preparing to be presented to high society. But Miss Lindy would much rather hide away in the family library spending her days reading, then learning to dance in the ballroom of her Fifth Avenue mansion. While hiding away in the library she she meets a young man, Jack Winthrop, who has been invited to use the library to study for Theological Seminary. They become friends discussing the books they love to read, and connecting hearts. But Lindy’s mother has been grooming her since birth to marry a British royal. You will find yourself laughing out loud, especially during the debutant ball, and cheering on Lindy and Jack. The plot twists and turns will have you up all night, flying through the pages. The well developed characters are so real, and the dynamic connections of them are amazingly portrayed throughout the story. The historical aspects were spot on. As the story unfolds you will literally be moved from place to place feeling like you are standing in the corner watching each conversation happen before your eyes.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, this historical fiction is a must read. I was so happy to know that it is the first book of a series as I look forward to reading the next books to find out what next is to come. If you haven’t read this author yet, I highly recommend her, you won’t be disappointed. Thank you Renee Yancy for such a fabulous read.
Evangeline “Lindy” Lindenmayer was preparing to be presented to high society. But Miss Lindy would much rather hide away in the family library spending her days reading, then learning to dance in the ballroom of her Fifth Avenue mansion. While hiding away in the library she she meets a young man, Jack Winthrop, who has been invited to use the library to study for Theological Seminary. They become friends discussing the books they love to read, and connecting hearts. But Lindy’s mother has been grooming her since birth to marry a British royal. You will find yourself laughing out loud, especially during the debutant ball, and cheering on Lindy and Jack. The plot twists and turns will have you up all night, flying through the pages. The well developed characters are so real, and the dynamic connections of them are amazingly portrayed throughout the story. The historical aspects were spot on. As the story unfolds you will literally be moved from place to place feeling like you are standing in the corner watching each conversation happen before your eyes.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, this historical fiction is a must read. I was so happy to know that it is the first book of a series as I look forward to reading the next books to find out what next is to come. If you haven’t read this author yet, I highly recommend her, you won’t be disappointed. Thank you Renee Yancy for such a fabulous read.
March 17, 2021
Do not make the mistake of assuming this story is just a romantic stroll through the “Gilded Age” of American history with debutante balls, extravagant parties in Newport, Paris and London and arranged marriages. It is so much more.
Rene Yancy is an accomplished author of historical fiction. This time she has drawn our attention to the late 19th century and the approaching 20th century focusing on a typical upper class family in New York City and the clash of mindsets and personalities within that family. Her lifelong experience as a mother, wife and Registered Nurse are obvious as she captures all the nuances of family life. As Evangeline a/k/a Lindy, the independent teenage woman at the center of this story, begins to contemplate her future, she skirmishes with her strong willed mother. Does that sound familiar? Mother and daughter have vastly different dreams. Mother’s lifelong plan for her daughter’s entire life creates a conflict all men and women can empathize with. The twists and turns of the story are realistic and gripping.
Do not assume for one moment you know what comes next! That is my warning to all readers. If you read THE TEST OF GOLD assuming you already know what will happen, sadly you will miss the overall theme and the deep revelations about ourselves. This is the perfect book for Women’s History Month celebrating strong women.
You will not be disappointed!
Mike Emminger
Rene Yancy is an accomplished author of historical fiction. This time she has drawn our attention to the late 19th century and the approaching 20th century focusing on a typical upper class family in New York City and the clash of mindsets and personalities within that family. Her lifelong experience as a mother, wife and Registered Nurse are obvious as she captures all the nuances of family life. As Evangeline a/k/a Lindy, the independent teenage woman at the center of this story, begins to contemplate her future, she skirmishes with her strong willed mother. Does that sound familiar? Mother and daughter have vastly different dreams. Mother’s lifelong plan for her daughter’s entire life creates a conflict all men and women can empathize with. The twists and turns of the story are realistic and gripping.
Do not assume for one moment you know what comes next! That is my warning to all readers. If you read THE TEST OF GOLD assuming you already know what will happen, sadly you will miss the overall theme and the deep revelations about ourselves. This is the perfect book for Women’s History Month celebrating strong women.
You will not be disappointed!
Mike Emminger
January 31, 2021
I had the pleasure to read an early copy of The Test of Gold by Renee Yancy. Historical fiction is not the genre I normally read, but this book was excellent. I was emotionally invested in Lindy's character and had to keep reading to find out the ending. There is much detail about the extravagance of the wealthy in the late 1890's as well as the poverty. You'll want to read this to see whether Lindy follows her mother's wishes and marries the Duke to gain a title in the family or is able to follow her heart. This is the first book in a series of 3 books and I look forward to reading more in this series!
March 19, 2021
I had to wait awhile for this book but it was ohhhh so worth it! I enjoyed it to a T. I finished it one day it was so good! This is a different kind of story from this author that I was thrilled with completely! My heart ached for Lindy yet I really admired her for her strength, determination and love among many other things! I found myself rooting for her and Jack the whole entire time! People can be so cruel and selfish! But it really surprised me that this person would be. I didn't like her at all. Heaven help them whomever crossed her path. You know, in a way this book reminds me of Disney's Tangled. This book was better than that.
I highly recommend.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
I highly recommend.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
March 16, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed this sweet historical romance. I found myself wanting to dodge chores to escape with my book instead. From the start I enjoyed Lindy and Jack’s secret meetings and lively discussions. The authors attention to the details of the time period brought everything to life. Lindy’s mother drove me crazy, how could she be so cruel and I questioned how Lindy could still be so devoted to someone so cruel and manipulative. I enjoyed meeting cousin Emma and was sad that she just rode off never to be heard from again. I hope her story is told soon. I look forward to reading the other books in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions are my own.
March 15, 2021
Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer's mother has her life all planned out. Mrs. Lindenmayer has spent countless dollars on providing the finest education, introducing her daughter to the "right people", buying her fashionable gowns, and organizing social events to give her the best of life. Or, is it actually to have Lindy be the crowning jewel of social success to further her own place in society?
There is only one flaw in Mrs. Lindenmayer's plan, her daughter. Lindy questions her opulent and extravagant lifestyle, wondering if there is more to life than power and parties. She sees that all of the wealth and privilege her mother so desperately wants is not for her. The charming and handsome seminarian, Jack Winthrop continues to open her eyes to others' needs by example and see that life offers so much more.
Lindy is drawn more and more to Jack and living a life of simple contentment. Things look bleak for their bourgeoning relationship as Mrs. Lindenmayer does all she can to achieve her goal of having wealth and power through Lindy. Mrs. Lindenmayer was such a conniving and scheming parent! I was frustrated and worried for Lindy as her mother never really took into account what Lindy wanted to do with her life. Because of Mrs. Lindenmayer's insatiable need to be a part of society, her beautiful and sweet daughter is just a means to that end. I had to keep reading to see what she was going to do next.
Standing up to her controlling and manipulative mother takes great courage and I liked and admired Lindy all the more for following her heart and convictions. I recommend reading this beautiful love story. This is the first book in The Hearts of Gold series and look forward to reading more of these historical romances.
Thank you to the author for a complimentary copy of the book. I was not required to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
There is only one flaw in Mrs. Lindenmayer's plan, her daughter. Lindy questions her opulent and extravagant lifestyle, wondering if there is more to life than power and parties. She sees that all of the wealth and privilege her mother so desperately wants is not for her. The charming and handsome seminarian, Jack Winthrop continues to open her eyes to others' needs by example and see that life offers so much more.
Lindy is drawn more and more to Jack and living a life of simple contentment. Things look bleak for their bourgeoning relationship as Mrs. Lindenmayer does all she can to achieve her goal of having wealth and power through Lindy. Mrs. Lindenmayer was such a conniving and scheming parent! I was frustrated and worried for Lindy as her mother never really took into account what Lindy wanted to do with her life. Because of Mrs. Lindenmayer's insatiable need to be a part of society, her beautiful and sweet daughter is just a means to that end. I had to keep reading to see what she was going to do next.
Standing up to her controlling and manipulative mother takes great courage and I liked and admired Lindy all the more for following her heart and convictions. I recommend reading this beautiful love story. This is the first book in The Hearts of Gold series and look forward to reading more of these historical romances.
Thank you to the author for a complimentary copy of the book. I was not required to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 12, 2021
So - this book and I had a love hate relationship. I adore golden age stories and I loved the author's detailed descriptions of the fashion and the surroundings. But here's the thing - the hero and heroine could not have had more than 7 scenes together in the entire book - and I'm not even sure if they even kiss at any point - I don't think they did. And this was not a short book. In fact I reached the 26% mark and was shocked that the book wasn't over yet. I did read the whole - thing - but at the end I wasn't satisfied or even happy I did.
Beyond the lack of interaction between the hero and heroine - I also took issue with the number of characters that appear and disappear throughout the book. Like Lindy's cousin Emma - who was fascinating - and when she appeared I thought we might be getting to a transition point in the book, but no. She disappears never to be seen again. Or the introduction of the truly unstable Gillian at the end of the book.
I also thought Lindy's mother Vera, who is truly abusive to all around her, and a complete sociopath was handled in a way that was shocking. The woman locks Lindy in her room for a long time and then fakes serious illness to force Lindy into doing what she wants - ending with serious threats to murder the man Lindy loves. Even with all of this, Lindy is upset that her mother won't talk to her and hopes she'll forgive her someday? What??? There is absolutely no satisfying resolution there.
In fact, I really left the book feeling wholly unsatisfied. Yes Lindy and Jack finally find each other and vow to get married. But that is the end of the book. No glimpse in to what happens to them - no resolution with Lindy's parents. Nothing.
Overall - and I never say this - I would not recommend this book. The author wrote so beautifully about the time period - that it pains me to say that. But the story - the story just wasn't there for me.
I received this as an ARC from Goodreads, but these opinions are my own.
Beyond the lack of interaction between the hero and heroine - I also took issue with the number of characters that appear and disappear throughout the book. Like Lindy's cousin Emma - who was fascinating - and when she appeared I thought we might be getting to a transition point in the book, but no. She disappears never to be seen again. Or the introduction of the truly unstable Gillian at the end of the book.
I also thought Lindy's mother Vera, who is truly abusive to all around her, and a complete sociopath was handled in a way that was shocking. The woman locks Lindy in her room for a long time and then fakes serious illness to force Lindy into doing what she wants - ending with serious threats to murder the man Lindy loves. Even with all of this, Lindy is upset that her mother won't talk to her and hopes she'll forgive her someday? What??? There is absolutely no satisfying resolution there.
In fact, I really left the book feeling wholly unsatisfied. Yes Lindy and Jack finally find each other and vow to get married. But that is the end of the book. No glimpse in to what happens to them - no resolution with Lindy's parents. Nothing.
Overall - and I never say this - I would not recommend this book. The author wrote so beautifully about the time period - that it pains me to say that. But the story - the story just wasn't there for me.
I received this as an ARC from Goodreads, but these opinions are my own.
March 5, 2021
The Test of Gold is a sweet story of romance, drama, love and hate, set mainly in 1897 New York, when the family expectations for wealthy women and men were to marry for money or a title, not necessarily for love.
From the first few pages when Lindy and Jack met in her father's library, I was drawn into their story and that interest didn’t waiver throughout the rest of the book. Would she obey her mother's wishes or follow her heart? I couldn't wait to find out.
The characters felt so real to me, and I could just picture the gorgeous gowns and ornate mansions from the vivid and well researched descriptions by Ms. Yancy. I was transported to another time! Knowing that the book was based on a true story made it even more compelling for me. I highly recommend it!
I received this book from the author for my honest review and I honestly loved it!
From the first few pages when Lindy and Jack met in her father's library, I was drawn into their story and that interest didn’t waiver throughout the rest of the book. Would she obey her mother's wishes or follow her heart? I couldn't wait to find out.
The characters felt so real to me, and I could just picture the gorgeous gowns and ornate mansions from the vivid and well researched descriptions by Ms. Yancy. I was transported to another time! Knowing that the book was based on a true story made it even more compelling for me. I highly recommend it!
I received this book from the author for my honest review and I honestly loved it!
August 5, 2025
Sweet Romance
I would like to highly recommend this book.
Great story about love and love lost and then found again.
A wonderful story.
Read it and I guarantee you will love it too.
Great author as well.
I would like to highly recommend this book.
Great story about love and love lost and then found again.
A wonderful story.
Read it and I guarantee you will love it too.
Great author as well.
March 1, 2021
I love historical fiction and this one doesn’t disappoint! I felt like I was living alongside the romance between Lindy & Jack. A few times I was sure I knew what was going to happen, but the plot twists kept me guessing (and reading late into the night!)
August 20, 2021
Renee Yancy’s “The Test of Gold” was a delightfully captivating tale of class, social status in society and romance!
Heiress Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer has been groomed since childhood to marry into the British aristocracy as her mother's ultimate ambition is a royal title for the family name as were many young women of the gilded age. But Lindy was different, she preferred books to ballrooms and wanted to live life on her own terms.
The author takes us from New York to Paris and London, and back to New York as Lindy’s social climbing mother seeks a title for her daughter. Lindy would far rather spend her time in her father’s library extensive library where she can indulge her love of literature. That is where she meets Jack Winthrop, a young ministerial student at Union Theological Seminary who has been invited to use the Lindemayer's library for his studies. Warned to stay away from Lindy, he finds her far different than the feather brained young heiresses he’s met at his uncles church. With her eclectic interest and her superb intelligence they find that they have much in common. And it is in this setting they get to know one another and fall in love. A love forbidden by social status and her mother’s incessant desire to control her daughter’s future for her own benefit.
I was caught between trying to savor and devour this fabulous story at the same time. The author has penned fascinating, well-rounded, believable, and very alive characters in this story. The characters were all written extremely well, though you loved or liked and though you abhorred. Jack was certainly a swoon worthy, charming hero of honor and great character. Lindy was a young woman of intelligence, wisdom, insight and an honest sweetness.
The authors rich, visual and sensory prose crafts with immense skill a story that both captivates your heart and takes your breath away. The scenes come alive with her vivid descriptions and the lush opulence that such extravagant wealth provided. Her imagery was excellent! The dialogue was perfect and befitting the story. The story line was wonderfully woven and the author was able to seamlessly weave historical people and facts. This is a beautifully poignant story that will have you rooting fo Jack and Lindy from the start.
Thank you so much Renee Yancy for a wonderfully written and beautifully told love story!
Heiress Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer has been groomed since childhood to marry into the British aristocracy as her mother's ultimate ambition is a royal title for the family name as were many young women of the gilded age. But Lindy was different, she preferred books to ballrooms and wanted to live life on her own terms.
The author takes us from New York to Paris and London, and back to New York as Lindy’s social climbing mother seeks a title for her daughter. Lindy would far rather spend her time in her father’s library extensive library where she can indulge her love of literature. That is where she meets Jack Winthrop, a young ministerial student at Union Theological Seminary who has been invited to use the Lindemayer's library for his studies. Warned to stay away from Lindy, he finds her far different than the feather brained young heiresses he’s met at his uncles church. With her eclectic interest and her superb intelligence they find that they have much in common. And it is in this setting they get to know one another and fall in love. A love forbidden by social status and her mother’s incessant desire to control her daughter’s future for her own benefit.
I was caught between trying to savor and devour this fabulous story at the same time. The author has penned fascinating, well-rounded, believable, and very alive characters in this story. The characters were all written extremely well, though you loved or liked and though you abhorred. Jack was certainly a swoon worthy, charming hero of honor and great character. Lindy was a young woman of intelligence, wisdom, insight and an honest sweetness.
The authors rich, visual and sensory prose crafts with immense skill a story that both captivates your heart and takes your breath away. The scenes come alive with her vivid descriptions and the lush opulence that such extravagant wealth provided. Her imagery was excellent! The dialogue was perfect and befitting the story. The story line was wonderfully woven and the author was able to seamlessly weave historical people and facts. This is a beautifully poignant story that will have you rooting fo Jack and Lindy from the start.
Thank you so much Renee Yancy for a wonderfully written and beautifully told love story!
March 22, 2021
The Test of Gold starts as many historical romances do that are set during this era. There is a young debutante who is about to make her first appearance in fashionable society, and a mother who is determined to find a man worthy of her daughter's hand—a duke preferably. The debutante comes with a very large dowery—thanks to her father's successful business ventures, and so she is sure to be snapped up by one of the British aristocrats, for everyone knows their large estates take a fortune to maintain. No expense shall be spared. They must go to Paris for the dresses, then London for the balls. Many of American's wealthiest families were taking there daughter to London for a season— why should the Lindenmayer's be any different?
Oh my goodness, this novel made me so incredibly angry at times—not because of the writing, but because of that obnoxious creature the author has created— Vera Lindenmayer. Poor, poor, Lindy. How could anyone not feel sorry for her for having such an awful mother? Vera is selfish, manipulative and downright cruel. At times this cruelty did overshadow the romance, for it is extreme and seemingly unstoppable. How I loathed that woman.
Lindy, on the other hand, was a character that one could not help but adore, and I was really hoping that she would find her happy-ever-after with Jack—who is considered a totally unsuitable match because of his social standing and the fact that he is not English, and nor is he a duke!
This is a novel where love triumphs over many obstacles, but at times, it is a very dark and disturbing read. Lindy must walk through Hell before she can break free and chose her own destiny.
This is the kind of novel that one simply cannot put down and walk away from. In fact, I stayed up to the early hours to finish it. This book is undoubtedly one that would appeal to those who enjoy carefully crafted and tender historical romances, which also has a sinister edge to it.
*I received a copy of this book from The Coffee Pot Book Club for review consideration.
Oh my goodness, this novel made me so incredibly angry at times—not because of the writing, but because of that obnoxious creature the author has created— Vera Lindenmayer. Poor, poor, Lindy. How could anyone not feel sorry for her for having such an awful mother? Vera is selfish, manipulative and downright cruel. At times this cruelty did overshadow the romance, for it is extreme and seemingly unstoppable. How I loathed that woman.
Lindy, on the other hand, was a character that one could not help but adore, and I was really hoping that she would find her happy-ever-after with Jack—who is considered a totally unsuitable match because of his social standing and the fact that he is not English, and nor is he a duke!
This is a novel where love triumphs over many obstacles, but at times, it is a very dark and disturbing read. Lindy must walk through Hell before she can break free and chose her own destiny.
This is the kind of novel that one simply cannot put down and walk away from. In fact, I stayed up to the early hours to finish it. This book is undoubtedly one that would appeal to those who enjoy carefully crafted and tender historical romances, which also has a sinister edge to it.
*I received a copy of this book from The Coffee Pot Book Club for review consideration.
March 26, 2021
I was expecting this novel to be an emotionally explosive read from the blurb, but the number of times I was reaching for the tissues did surprise me.
Lindy was a character that I grew to love. She is not blinded, like her mother is, to the plight of the poor, and she feels a terrible sense of guilt at the thought that she has so much when others have so little. This very caring, very empathetic nature makes Lindy all the more susceptible to her mother's cruel games. Lindy is treated throughout this novel as a commodity. She will be sold to the highest bidder. My heart repeatedly broke as Lindy is threatened and then forced to comply with her mother's demands. The fact that her father stood by and did nothing made Lindy's plight all the more moving. Jack's desperate attempt to save the woman he loves is thwarted over and over again. But he is the shining light of hope that perhaps there is a way to escape the torment she is being forced to endure.
Jack is a quiet, calming presence in this novel. Young, he may be, but he holds the world upon his shoulders, for his mother is dying of consumption. When he accidentally meets Lindy in her father's library (you will have to read the book if you want to know why he was in her father's library), he instantly recognises a kindred spirit. And despite their social differents, Jack is determined to make him his wife. Thankfully, Lindy is of the same mind—she really wants to be his wife. Needless to say, her mother is less than keen - it is an English Duke, and anything short of that is a disaster.
This story really centres upon the abuse Lindy is forced to endure at the hands of her mother, with the romance being somewhat in the background, which is a little unusual for a romance novel. But I will say this. If anyone reading this book is going through a similar experience to Lindy, this novel will give them hope. There is a way out. You can escape. So thank you, Renee Yancy, for the depiction of Lindy. A truly inspirational character.
Lindy was a character that I grew to love. She is not blinded, like her mother is, to the plight of the poor, and she feels a terrible sense of guilt at the thought that she has so much when others have so little. This very caring, very empathetic nature makes Lindy all the more susceptible to her mother's cruel games. Lindy is treated throughout this novel as a commodity. She will be sold to the highest bidder. My heart repeatedly broke as Lindy is threatened and then forced to comply with her mother's demands. The fact that her father stood by and did nothing made Lindy's plight all the more moving. Jack's desperate attempt to save the woman he loves is thwarted over and over again. But he is the shining light of hope that perhaps there is a way to escape the torment she is being forced to endure.
Jack is a quiet, calming presence in this novel. Young, he may be, but he holds the world upon his shoulders, for his mother is dying of consumption. When he accidentally meets Lindy in her father's library (you will have to read the book if you want to know why he was in her father's library), he instantly recognises a kindred spirit. And despite their social differents, Jack is determined to make him his wife. Thankfully, Lindy is of the same mind—she really wants to be his wife. Needless to say, her mother is less than keen - it is an English Duke, and anything short of that is a disaster.
This story really centres upon the abuse Lindy is forced to endure at the hands of her mother, with the romance being somewhat in the background, which is a little unusual for a romance novel. But I will say this. If anyone reading this book is going through a similar experience to Lindy, this novel will give them hope. There is a way out. You can escape. So thank you, Renee Yancy, for the depiction of Lindy. A truly inspirational character.
June 11, 2021
Interesting, engaging, but did I enjoy it? There were some tender scenes between Jack and Lindy, but not enough of them. There were also a couple of characters who disturbed me because their cruelty and irrational behaviour. There were also some inconsistencies in the plot, including characters who appeared for a brief time and then played no further part, and sidetracks that showed Lindy’s soft heart and generosity but seemingly had no relevance to the rest of the story. The biggest inconsistency occurred towards the end where Jack travelled in a frenzy between New York, Chautauqua, Buffalo and back to Chautauqua while Lindy apparently waited at Chautauqua to board a steamer back to Buffalo and Jack raced frenetically between the two locations trying to find her!
However true love came through in the end, but I would have liked to see more if the young couple together. Perhaps in the sequel?
It made me do some research to get an understanding of locations I’d never heard of and this gave me an appreciation of the research done for the novel. The beauty of New York State and it’s cities and countryside was well depicted as was the description of the opulence and extravagance of society with all of its excesses.
So did I enjoy it? The good parts were very sweet and if I ignored the abusive mother and deranged young lady, yes I will read the sequel to get some closure.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review
However true love came through in the end, but I would have liked to see more if the young couple together. Perhaps in the sequel?
It made me do some research to get an understanding of locations I’d never heard of and this gave me an appreciation of the research done for the novel. The beauty of New York State and it’s cities and countryside was well depicted as was the description of the opulence and extravagance of society with all of its excesses.
So did I enjoy it? The good parts were very sweet and if I ignored the abusive mother and deranged young lady, yes I will read the sequel to get some closure.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 15, 2021
A tender romance. A controlling mother. And a young woman determined to take control of her own future.
Test of Gold by Renee Yancy is a Cinderella story in reverse. Evangeline isn't looking for a handsome prince - she is looking for a way to escape the destiny that her mother has so carefully planned for her. And to make matters worse, instead of a duke, which would be the ultimate triumph for her mother. Lindy falls in love with a man who is most unsuitable!
This novel is not a typical romance. The heroine is not swept off her feet. Instead, she has to find the courage to break free from her mother's influence and hold.
Lindy's mother is a vile creature - worse even than Cinderella's step-mother. The lengths she is willing to go to to get what she wants is truly awful. And how Lindy comes out the other side is a testimony to her strength and her determination.
I thought this was a fantastic novel from beginning to end, and although it is not a typical romance, it is one of those stories that, once read, is impossible to forget.
*I received a copy of this book from The Coffee Pot Book Club. I was under no obligation to leave a review.
Test of Gold by Renee Yancy is a Cinderella story in reverse. Evangeline isn't looking for a handsome prince - she is looking for a way to escape the destiny that her mother has so carefully planned for her. And to make matters worse, instead of a duke, which would be the ultimate triumph for her mother. Lindy falls in love with a man who is most unsuitable!
This novel is not a typical romance. The heroine is not swept off her feet. Instead, she has to find the courage to break free from her mother's influence and hold.
Lindy's mother is a vile creature - worse even than Cinderella's step-mother. The lengths she is willing to go to to get what she wants is truly awful. And how Lindy comes out the other side is a testimony to her strength and her determination.
I thought this was a fantastic novel from beginning to end, and although it is not a typical romance, it is one of those stories that, once read, is impossible to forget.
*I received a copy of this book from The Coffee Pot Book Club. I was under no obligation to leave a review.
March 7, 2021
When Evangeline "Lindy" Lindenmayer decides to challenge her mother’s plans for her, she finds the challenge nearly insurmountable. Lindy has always found reading more interesting than any societal event. Yet when she meets Jack Winthrop, a young seminary student, she knows that her life will never be the same. Jack makes her question her current lifestyle and the privileges that she has enjoyed. Lindy must face the reality of whether she can agree to her mother’s demands or follow her heart.
This is a book set at the end of the 1800s and is based on a true story, making for a most interesting read. I found the descriptive images of the backdrop, added to the story, giving life to this story. This book is fast moving and kept me reading with the unknown future of this delightful couple. Whilst theirs was a forbidden love story, I found their lively discussions well delivered and thoughtful.
Once again, Ms Yancy has written a page-turner which will have a reader interested from start to finish.
I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
This is a book set at the end of the 1800s and is based on a true story, making for a most interesting read. I found the descriptive images of the backdrop, added to the story, giving life to this story. This book is fast moving and kept me reading with the unknown future of this delightful couple. Whilst theirs was a forbidden love story, I found their lively discussions well delivered and thoughtful.
Once again, Ms Yancy has written a page-turner which will have a reader interested from start to finish.
I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
March 15, 2021
Test of Gold, by Renee Yancy, beautifully tells the love story between Ms Evangeline Lindenmeyer and "below her class" lover (want to know his name? Kindly grab a copy). This budding love which started in the library (of all places) is set to be extinguished by "iron Lady Lindenmeyer", Evangeline's mother, who climbs hill and mountain to make sure her only daughter marries her specially chosen titled man.
The story line is quite different from other "Cinderella" tale because you get to enjoy the beautiful scenery of an unaffected climate, the quiet and vastness of a big personal library and of course the struggle of both lovers against the "pruners" of their blossoming love.
Did "Iron Lady Lindenmeyer" get her wish?
I'll love for you to tell me when you're done reading.
I can't wait for you to read this book!
I highly recommend it and rate it 5 stars!
The story line is quite different from other "Cinderella" tale because you get to enjoy the beautiful scenery of an unaffected climate, the quiet and vastness of a big personal library and of course the struggle of both lovers against the "pruners" of their blossoming love.
Did "Iron Lady Lindenmeyer" get her wish?
I'll love for you to tell me when you're done reading.
I can't wait for you to read this book!
I highly recommend it and rate it 5 stars!
Currently reading
March 3, 2021I received an early copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review. I don't read historical fiction very often but since I just finished watching Bridgerton I thought it was a good time to read this book. At times I thought I knew where the plot was going but I kept being pleasantly surprised to find sometimes I was correct and sometimes there was an unexpected turn of plot. I liked the characters. They all rang true. I loved the way the author pulled me into the time period. I could imagine the dances and the opulence and the clothing. It is good to know this is the first in a series. I will look forward to her next installment of these characters. I wonder where she will take them. I like that thought.
March 15, 2021
While I really enjoyed the Gilded age setting and getting to see parts of New York in this time, this story and the romance was just missing something for me.
I really enjoyed how much our characters loved reading and their discussions on literature were great. But the characters had such a short time together before having to go their separate ways I just didn’t believe they were truly in love. They are apart for a big chunk of the book and basically pining after each other but I just needed more chemistry to believe they could still fight for each other after that long.
It should also be noted that this book is very low on the steam level and I would have loved to see at least a kiss but if that is something you like in your historicals this one might be for you.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for this arc.
I really enjoyed how much our characters loved reading and their discussions on literature were great. But the characters had such a short time together before having to go their separate ways I just didn’t believe they were truly in love. They are apart for a big chunk of the book and basically pining after each other but I just needed more chemistry to believe they could still fight for each other after that long.
It should also be noted that this book is very low on the steam level and I would have loved to see at least a kiss but if that is something you like in your historicals this one might be for you.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for this arc.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews