This was a VERY interesting start of a series that I'm going to stick with.
I admit, while I was reading it, I wasn't too sure whether I'd be a fan or not.
Noah Valentine did come across as a pretty boring person, especially since I cannot help but compare this series to Adrien English.
The similarities are overwhelming, but where mystery book store owner Adrien was quirky and a bit clumsy but determined in his romantic endeavors, video rental shop owner Noah seemed downright plain and not particularly interesting, ESPECIALLY regarding romance.
And I don't mean that I didn't like him as a character. It just felt like his life was on hold the entire time.
At first I was confused by the many side characters, like his neighbors who constantly invite him over and share meals and conversations with him. I'm not a big fan of throwing too many characters into a story, but looking back I realize that without them, Noah would have been sitting around alone all day waiting for the next phone call from his mother so he could ignore it or pick up and apologize for missing mother's day yet again.
I didn't get it. I didn't get him. He seemed dry and withdrawn and the mystery of this story was kind of the only thing that kept him occupied. Like a very unusual hobby.
Noah's video rental shop Pinx seems to be doing okay, even when Noah isn't around. His quirky and sometimes even patronizing employees run it pretty smoothly.
We learn that Noah is somewhat of widower, even though he was estranged from his late partner at the end. His dating life is virtually non-existent and when he does date a guy, said person ends up dead after.
Which is how this story begins.
1992, the LA riots. People are on the streets and looters are running rampant. Still, Noah Valentine is sure that there is no danger for his little gay themed video rental shop Pinx where Noah offers a wide variety of mainstream movies alongside... well,... gay porn.
His shop survives the riot okay, but a camera shop nearby is burned down - and with it is shop owner Guy Peterson, whom Noah had briefly dated.
Intending to check out the scene, Noah visits the destroyed building and finds something that to his untrained eye does look like a bloodied murder weapon.
So did Guy actually die in the fire or was he murdered and the shop set on fire to cover the crime?
With this question in mind, Noah starts a research into a crime that gets bigger and bigger each time he uncovers another clue.
But disturbingly, the LAPD, and most importantly handsome detective Javier O'Shea, are not only unhappy with a rookie meddling in their investigation, but they might also be involved in whatever is going on behind the scenes.
The mystery was pretty good. I'm not really reading MM mysteries for the mysteries (I'm always looking for the romantic bits), but this one entertained me very well.
I should also point out that this book felt like a statement to remember gay history in the US. This is a fictional story that takes place during real events and tells a story of something that really happened like this. I'm being ominous now.
Anyway, I already compared it to Adrien English, so let me tell you that Detective O'Shea is the one you should look out for if you're wondering who might be 'The Love Interest'.
Gay shop owners and closeted cops. Don't we just love them?
Oh and I feel it's important to say that while I felt a bit of doubt toward Noah as a powerful lead character, the last few pages reveal something that makes many previous puzzle pieces fall into place. Noah isn't dull and unmotivated in his own life. But there is something weighing on his mind. And now I can't wait to see his future interactions in the next books knowing what I know now.
So yes, this story and the characters worked their way up from a 3.5 star solid but a bit dry mystery read to a 5 star favorite character piece!
And on to the next instalment...