this is really a 2.5⭐️ for me, but I'm rounding up bc the author's voice is engaging & I liked the characters. Also to preface: I'm really sorry but this is hella rant-y, largely bc I was so excited for this book and it really disappointed me. if you want to experience me noodling out exactly why this book bothered me, read on
I was pretty hyped for this book, and I’m bummed to say it didn’t live up to expectations. I mean it was cute, & it was funny, but ultimately I had some significant issues. Largely they all boil down to this— the pacing felt really off/forced to me, the characterization of Naomi felt changed from The Roommate to this book, the communication wasn't there, and I was just left wanting more.
The plotting/pacing issues are really well articulated by Jen Prokop in her review, so if you want to hear someone talk about it much more eloquently look there lol. For me, I definitly felt like there was an idea for the story & the characters were at the whim of this story, so there was a lot of time spent doing things that felt inessential to the romance? Like if if pressed, I'm not sure how well I could summarize this book bc I don't feel like the scenes were propelling the plot, they just kinda happened.
I feel like the thing that was the weirdest to me was how Naomi changed? Like, in book 1 she's Josh's ex girlfriend & partner w/ a lot of work stuff, and she's ~very clearly~ a sexual person based on the way she interacts with literally everyone on page, & also the fact that she has a threesome w/ Clara & Josh between books 1 & 2!! And tbh this is part of what I liked about her in the Roommate—she knew what she wanted, and she wasn't afraid to say it/make it happen. She was brazen, fearless. But then we get to this book, and for someone who was previously a sex worker & now runs a company all about pleasure, she seemed to have lost her mojo— Clara doesn't kiss Ethan until after 50%, and the literal ~only~ time they have sex is like at 70%. Which would totally make sense if there was an on-page reason for this— I mean IRL, if adults are not having sex, theres a very specific reason. Whether its because of religious beliefs, health reasons, if they’re asexual, etc. but in my experience people don’t abstain without reason. So for someone who's life was literally centered around sex and pleasure, she kinda felt sexless? Like Naomi doesn’t even masturbate! Her life is ~centered~ around pleasure, you're telling me she never masturbated while thinking about Ethan??? WHYYY is this not on page. And again, if that was the character she was written to be in book one, thats totally chill! Or even if she said on page that she wanted to take time to focus on rediscovering her faith, I would totally get that. But this sudden & unexplained change in her sexuality felt pretty out of left field, and I was disappointed. Which honestly reminds me of the biggest issue I had with the Roommate lol, bc yet again there was this extremely prudish heroine who was ~physically uncomfortable~ with anything remotely sexual, but theres no reason for that on page??
I also think as a book with the “spiritual leader x sex worker/otherwise less spiritual person” trope, The Intimacy Experiment didn’t quite have the tension I was expecting. I've read this trope a few times before & really loved it, and I think there’s a LOT of tension built into that premise. The books I’ve read that do this (I think I’ve read 3 or 4 now?) usually have things play out in one of two ways. Either 1) These ppl can’t fuck/be together but they ~really~ want to, so there’s this sort of “will they won’t they” tension that kind of feels like edging😂 The other way I’ve seen this trope play out is 2) These people can bang (and they probably do) but something in the past/present proves to be a major obstacle to any sort of long-term partnership, so the tension is “This was supposed to be just physical but now I’m catching feelings for this person that I cant have a future with.” This can get REALLY angsty, and a lot of the turmoil of “how long can i pretend this is just temporary, I really don’t want to end this but I have to” is really delicious. I think a book that does the latter really well is Hot Rabbi by Aviva Blakeman, and there’s a comparable conflict between the rabbi hero and his love interest, who (while not a sex worker) is a bisexual cis woman who has a difficult past and thus hasn’t really been practicing her faith for years. In this book, the pair has ~bananas~ chemistry from the get go, and if I recall correctly they end up getting together fairly early on in the book. However, author **really** clearly outlines the obstacles to their relationship, in a way that genuinely had me questioning how they would end up together. There’s a lot of internal processing & external dialogue that shows the work they go through to combat those obstacles and get that HEA🙌🏻
But in The Intimacy Experiment, I didn’t feel really any tension? The framing/promo/everything I’d heard about this book leading up to it’s release really leaned on the on the “she’s a sex worker & he’s a rabbi, what are the gonna do about their attraction???” so I was expecting there to be a propulsive force pulling them apart despite their intense attraction. But I never felt like there was much keeping them apart, at least in any way that had high stakes for either of them. Besides the Board of Directors being uncomfortable w/ Naomi and her past, everything really fell into place with Ethan & Naomi, albeit ~very~ slowly. I guess what I’m getting at is that I felt almost no actual conflict in this book. Like, they’re both into each other from the get-go, they’re just awkward and don’t know how to talk to each other so it takes them until about 60% to admit they’re into each other & kiss. Even when Ethan steps down from being Rabbi because he loves Naomi, it happened so quickly & was resolved so quickly that we didn’t see him grieving the loss and thus it didn’t feel like a big deal— it was said to be a big deal, but i never felt the weight of it? So the book is just a GIANT slow burn where the only substantial obstacle to their HEA is their inability to communicate & be honest with each other (or even themselves at times) and while that’s fine, it’s really not what the book was marketed as, and I was disappointed by the lack of conflict/tension. It just felt like there wasn’t much happening.
And speaking of communication, the way Ethan & Naomi ~barely~ talk honestly & openly to each other about their feelings/their relationship was kind of a bummer. I get it— that’s hard!! But I think in the romance genre, when verbal communication is lacking there’s often communication that happens through the evolution of their physical relationship that adds clarity and drives the narrative. But then that isn’t there either??? So these two just never communicate👀 And to my earlier point about no conflict besides their lack of communication, I think there’s a way you could make that work? Like if it was a deep internal conflict that like ATE at them of like “i really want to be with this person but I can’t, I really wish _____ wasn’t holding me back from being honest, I really want to say _____ but I can’t find the words” etc. But there’s so much page time spent doing other things— usually going over the Modern Intimacy class or adding cute “romcom” style shenanigans— that I never felt like we got DEEP into their heads.
I think ultimately it's a case of trying to be too many things at once? Like bc its pitched/framed as a romcom, I don't think we get deep enough into Naomi/Hannah's journey of returning to her faith so that story thread felt unfinished, and ultimately I felt like the lack of committal meant there wasn't significant emotional payoff. But there's still enough of that journey for the book to feel a little too weighty to be a true romcom? And "the spiritual leader falls for the sex worker/less spiritual one" trope really fell through for me bc I never felt like any tension whatsoever, and in literally every other iteration of this trope I've read, that's been a crucial piece (also not to be obnoxious with the qualifiers, but if there was ~any~ other substantial tension: sexual, occupation, emotional, literally anything else that either pulled these two together or forced them apart then it could've worked!! I just never felt any sort of intensity at allll in this book) It was clear the framing of the modern intimacy class was important to the story this author was trying to tell, but while I found that aspect interesting I think it really slowed down the story, and ultimately I felt like it was detrimental to the characters.
I really really wanted to like this book, but the more I think about it, the more I'm frustrated by how it fell short. It kinda felt like when you FINALLY bang that ~stunner~ you've been fantasizing about forever only to realize that (despite what i"m sure is their best effort) they're never gonna find your clit.
I received an arc from netgalley in exchange for an honest review.