A Chew book that's not about a witch! Still a fantasy for the youngest readers, though I think the other reviewer who shared it with a 5 yo was pushing it. There are some relatively sophisticated ideas here, like a pirate who isn't happy in his line of work, and the means & motive by which the kids get home. Unfortunately I'm not perfectly comfortable with the portrayal of the generic 'Indians' though and cannot quite recommend this, unless you are prepared to discuss it with your children.
(A bit of white savior, nation not specifically named, not sure if the 'apron' and headband are accurate to those who would have lived near Flatbush at the time.)
---
Decided to read it one more time before donating it. 3.5 stars this time; otherwise the review stands. I like the trick of imagining the annoying night noises of the place you landed in as your own familiar noises instead... so the girl here, one rough night, imagined the hooting of an owl as traffic noise in Brooklyn, etc.