Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Crime

A Dubious Witch Cozy Mystery #2

by Fiona Grace

When Mia Bold, 30, learns that the pharmaceutical company she works for only cares about money, she quits on the spot, walking away from a high-powered career—and from her long-time boyfriend, who breaks up with her.

With the podcast taking off, and with a romance brewing, Mia and the crew film the first episode of their new TV show, in the haunted house of one of the original Salem witches. Mia’s working hard to debunk the unexplained happenings—when suddenly, someone dies unexpectedly.

Even worse—the suspicion falls on her.

With her future at stake and her career and reputation on the line, Mia has no choice but to solve the inexplicable death. Could the cause be supernatural?

Genres: Audiobook, Cozy Mystery, Mystery, Paranormal, Fantasy, Fiction, Cozy

221 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 11, 2021

About the author

Debut author Fiona Grace is author of the LACEY DOYLE COZY MYSTERY series which includes MURDER IN THE MANOR (Book #1), DEATH AND A DOG (Book #2) and CRIME IN THE CAFE (Book #3). Fiona would love to hear from you, so please visit www.fionagraceauthor.com to receive free ebooks, hear the latest news, and stay in touch.

Reviews

[Emmalynn · Rating 3 out of 5]

Ughhh Mia is an idiot

[Sheryl · Rating 2 out of 5]

I think this is the end of my short dalliance with cozy mysteries.
This second book in the "Skeptic In Salem" series left me really angry about the liberties the author takes with history and lore and geography (not to mention grammar)
I am a huge fan of historical fiction, and in most cases I can turn a blind eye to speculation and inaccuracies in service of a good plot.
But this book twists some elements of Salem's history in a manner which comes across as convenient to the story, but is unsettling and maybe even a little dangerous. And definitely disrespectful to the historical people involved.
I'm sure most people who read this series won't know enough of the lore of Salem to be bothered, and to me that is even more disturbing. I'm distressed by the thought that someone might hear a name connected to Salem and have a whole bunch of inaccurate associations.
In the end, my interest in Salem (which led me to start this series) is the thing that makes these books less cozy than uncomfortable.

[Keith Beasley-Topliffe · Rating 2 out of 5]

This is listed as the second book in this series about a young woman who loses her job and fiancé in one afternoon and moves to Salem, MA, to become a paranormal research vlogger. It probably should be listed as book 1.5 or less because so many plot twists and character conflicts seem to be taken from the first book with little change. And then there is the narration. (Goodreads doesn't seem to know about the audiobook edition.) This has a different reader, and she is slow enough to remind me of a library children's time reader. Strange pauses and emphases. I usually listen to audiobooks at 1.25 speed. At 1.5 speed, she was still slow. I did stick with it to the end, so I'll give it 2 stars. But I don't plan to continue to book 3, even though it lists yet another reader.

[Nellie · Rating 2 out of 5]

I enjoyed the first book, however this seems to be a copy and paste with the names changed. Pity. It had so much potential.

[Jennifer · Rating 3 out of 5]

This one might be 3 and 1/2 stars. Either the writing style is wearing me down or it’s a bit better than the previous in the series. It still feels like the main character acts really naive at times and it makes me grit my teeth. The story isn’t awful though and in the right hands might be very compelling. A skeptic, a doubter living in Salem, MA and confronted by true paranormal happenings still trying not to become a believer has real potential. I also think the narrator makes this even more annoying. She enunciates to the point of taking forever to read the sentence. I listened to this on 1.6x speed and that helped….somewhat.

[Lucinda Race · Rating 5 out of 5]

I enjoyed this next installment of Mia Bold tracking down ghost and murderer in Salem. When a professor is murdered she's on the track to find out who dun it all while the murderer is tracking her every move. The climax a spooky graveyard at midnight. I even shouted to the audio book narration- don't go in there, while driving.
I'm currently on book #3

[Kathleen · Rating 5 out of 5]

I need more! This was the last one at my library :(

[beverly La Rock · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a good book just like the first. It was hard to put down. I love all the history about Salem. The only caveat is there was a scene where Mia and Sylvie were eating after goin got the library for the first time. However there was no mention of them going anywhere fro food. It was if a couple of pages was missing.

[Carol · Rating 5 out of 5]

Mia has yet to come across a phenomenon that cannot be explained by science and she truly believes that what the brain-washed totally-bought-into-the-paranormal town of Salem needed was a good dose of reality and less of the mumbo jumbo. But the Society of Spirits is determined that Mia is the enemy, set on destroying Salem and everything it stands for but when threatening letters and leaflets start being distributed in town, things start getting serious. And when Mia comes across a dead body, it gets even worse.

Another winner from Fiona Grace, fast paced, full of excitement and fun. What a great read!

[Mackenzie · Rating 2 out of 5]

The recycled writing of this narrative is difficult to parse. A notable portion of this narrative is dedicated to Mia's repetitive, long winded summaries of events that occurred during, and prior to, the first installment of this series. The occasional information dump can be over looked, but these recaps are not limited to the first few chapter; Mia makes a point of reiterating the same dry speeches throughout the narrative as though the reader is not trusted to remember. These speeches have precious little to do with the case at hand and distract form any actual clues the plot manages to steer Mia into "discovering".

[Charlie · Rating 3 out of 5]

Repeat

Not as good as the first one because it is almost exactly the same story but with a different murder. The characters are charming, but showed no growth.

[Emily Pennington]

When Mia Bold was disillusioned by the greedy pharmaceutical company she worked for, she left and moved to Salem. Her job now involved making podcasts and assuming a role as the skeptic regarding the supernatural saturation existing in Salem.

Ollie Cooper, one of the producers, sent a computer reminder that they were filming for the first time and would meet at The House of the Sea Witch, the location for the initial episode. Mia was co-hosting and was nervous. This was the haunted house of one of the original Salem witches. Witnesses reported cold spots, objects that moved on their own, and a mysterious figure who appeared in the master bedroom. The owner, Alice Parker, was one of the last women condemned at the Salem witch trials and hanged on September 22, 1692. Mia’s intention was to prove the haunting was nonsense and would run tests to check for strong electromagnetic activity or anything to logically account for physical disturbances.

Mia and her friend, Sylvie -- sound engineer for the podcast, film editor, and neighbor -- went to Café Noir for breakfast. Mia saw the owner, Hugh Wolfe, and blushed as he greeted her warmly. An odd group of people sat at a table and were staring at her. She was sure they said she was the one trying to destroy Salem, and they didn’t need her kind. Then they got up and left. Mia was about to invite Hugh to dinner when the show’s host, Johnny Astor called her name and approached them. They all sat at a table and Hugh brought over cappuccinos with a heart on top of Mia’s.

Finally the crew gathered to begin the interviews and filming at The House of the Sea Witch. The interviews went well, Mia actually relaxing as she concentrated on the discussions and asked questions. On the ghost hunt portion, the halls were darkened as if at night, reminding Mia of telling scary stories by a campfire. Mia’s working hard to debunk the unexplained happenings, yet their meter equipment was registering heavy activity in spots. Johnny pulled out the ghost box, which allegedly let spirits speak. And to their surprise, a female voice joined the static and clearly said, “Beware! Death comes.” The EMF readings went high as a dark shadow moved across the room and, when it passed right through Johnny’s body, he gasped and doubled over, telling her he felt sick. Mia tried explaining infrasound can affect the meters that way and can also make you feel sick. But Tandy, Mia’s dog, had raced up the stairs and stood in front of Mia and Johnny, growling at something.

They went downstairs to film the wrap-up. Johnny commented he had felt a presence, but Mia wanted to steer the investigation back to FACTS and away from FEELINGS. When Johnny suggested Alice Parker may have been a real witch and opened a plane to the other side, it was time to speak up and teach them a lesson. Her research had revealed that at the time of the witch trials, the weather conditions created a fungus infesting the rye crop, and it caused hallucinogenic effects. This ergot outbreak was nothing but food poisoning affecting people’s minds. A mass hallucination and not an actual supernatural element. The owner gave them an extra evening at the house to re-film the final wrap-up which everyone except Professor Brumley and Mia felt veered away from their reason for this investigation. When everyone left, Professor Brumley chased after Mia to tell her he found proof of what she had been saying but he would show it to her later. Instead, Mia found his cold, dead body crumpled at the bottom of the haunted stairs in The House of the Sea Witch. She called 9-1-1, never figuring the police would look with suspicion at her!

Her future, career, and reputation would be destroyed unless she can solve the inexplicable death. But was she ready to admit that the cause might actually be supernatural?

[Imjussayin · Rating 4 out of 5]

Review of Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Crime (A Dubious Witch Cozy Mystery #2) by Fiona Grace

Having enjoyed the first instalment in the series, I dove straight into Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Crime by Fiona Grace, eager to see how the characters and romance evolved. This second book continues to blend mystery and humour while introducing a fresh perspective to the cosy genre through its sceptical protagonist, Eleanor "Ellie" Harper, who embodies the spirit of a good scientist.

Grace masterfully weaves a narrative that keeps readers on their toes, and the twist of having a sceptic at the centre of the story adds an intriguing dynamic. Ellie's scientific approach to supernatural elements enhances the mystery and allows thoughtful exploration of themes around belief and evidence. This unique angle sets the book apart, making it a compelling read for fans of cosy mysteries and those who appreciate a more rational approach to the genre.

The development of the romance adds another layer of interest, with subtle hints skillfully integrated into the storyline. As Ellie navigates her personal relationships amid the chaos of a new crime investigation, readers are left curious about how her romantic entanglements will unfold. The chemistry between characters is palpable, creating a delightful tension that keeps you engaged.

Grace's writing continues to shine in this sequel, maintaining the charming and engaging dialogue that made the first book enjoyable. The pacing is brisk, and the well-constructed plot introduces new twists and turns while scepticism keeps the heart of the mystery intact.

Overall, Skeptic in Salem is a captivating continuation of the series, further developing its intriguing characters and their relationships. I found myself eagerly turning pages, invested in both the mystery and the romantic tension. If you enjoyed the first book, this sequel will undoubtedly keep you entertained and guessing. I look forward to seeing where Ellie’s journey leads next! I would rate it four stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐ for its clever premise and engaging storytelling.

[moxieBK · Rating 5 out of 5]

Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Crime (A Dubious Witch Cosy Mystery—Book 2) — Fiona Grace/Narrator: Quinn Francis (33 chapters + Epilogue) Jan. 2, 2024

Things are still topsy-turvy for Mia as she sets about starting a new episode… only this time, the producers have decided to go live and create an online series.

Mia’s scientific thought is put to the test several time however when she believes she has witnessed something that science can’t solve.

Meanwhile, does Jack like her? She knows she likes Wolfgang [I think that his name?] But Mia can't help but be worried about Jack as he seems to be distant lately and Mia is concerned about what that means.

Then Mia gets a call from a professor who has found a priceless book. When she goes to his house, she finds him dead… and a certain police officer wants her arrested for the death.

I am so glad I finally read the first two books in this series, and plan to read the third one.

Longer than the first book, but a very fine read with an excellent narrator.

This author is becoming one of my favorites!

Five stars.

[Chris · Rating 3 out of 5]

This reads very much like a dumbed down episode of standard solve a murder in 45 min show, Like Monk or Bones. Only issue is the main character is too naive. I dont understand how this 20 something adult who is also a genius biologist is living off a podcast income and only on the 2nd episode. Also long term being based in Salem i imagine there are only so many hunted places to explore so cannot see this being long term. If the same person finds two bodies within a 12 month span i am pretty sure the FBI starts to pay attention.

[D Marie · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have read other series by this author but this is my favorite. I love that it takes place in Salem and involves the supernatural. The whole premise behind the podcast is awesome and I like that it involves opposing views. I would recommend this series.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Mickey Kay Troxell · Rating 5 out of 5]

Even Better Than the Last

Each book in this series appears to be getting better and better! The relationship with Jonny has begun to turn into something more, while Hugh is an option too. Hence, Mia is not just solving a murder, but growing as a main character with romance in the near future.

[Molli · Rating 3 out of 5]

Cute book. Nancy Drew - esque. Audiobook narrator has an odd, theatrical way of speaking. Had to bump up narration speed to 1.25x for a more normal pace. A complaint I have about the plot is that the main characters’s family is so weird that it is too unbelievable. I also think the amount of people hitting on the main character is pretty cringy. Otherwise, an entertaining read.

[Andrea Olarte · Rating 4 out of 5]

Another enjoyable installment of this series.

I like Mia’s growth, though her decision making is questionable at times.

I’ve also noticed this interesting commonality that there is an element of paranormal occurrences to someone as skeptical as Mia.

The romance was meh.

Still going to move forward with book three.

[Larry · Rating 5 out of 5]

The absolute best thing an author can do, when writing a series, is to write a book even better than the first one, and this author did it. The main characters are believable, endearing and fun. The plot is easily followed and the entire story was fun to read. I definitely recommend this book.

[Sheila Burke · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book was good. This was the second book in this series I've read. I found it creative, and entertaining. It kept my attention and was hard to put down. Better than expected, and worth the time to read.

[Teresa · Rating 3 out of 5]

I listened to the book, and the reason I gave three stars has more to do with not liking the reader than the book itself. She drew out the book to an unnecessary length - I put it on 1.25 speed so it would sound like a normal pace (to me).

[Summer · Rating 3 out of 5]

Sulla falsa riga del primo episodio della serie, si riconfermano gli stessi pregi e difetti. La lettura incuriosisce e invoglia a proseguire, anche se alla fine molte cose rimangono non chiarite. Che si debba leggere il terzo e ultimo volume per avere delle risposte soddisfacenti?

[Darlena D Doak · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wonderful

I just love this book. It has some history, paranormal activity, romance and enough intriguing to keep you guessing. Can't wait to read the next in the series.

[Debbie · Rating 4 out of 5]

Second book of a series. Never disappoints.

[Lisa · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.5

[Heather Venard · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 Very cute and an improvement on the first book. Salem continues to be an interesting environment for these stories

[Dayle · Rating 4 out of 5]

I thought it went a bit slow in spots but good story. It does have a “sort of” cliffhanger…not a fan.

[Rebecca · Rating 5 out of 5]

really enjoyed reading these book

[Lea · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars - the narration was very halted and distracting. The story is good and entertaining. Historical parts and maybe some ghosts!