Cozy mysteries should: 1) have an amateur sleuth who plausibly gets involved with the investigation, 2) a dead body is found within the first 50 pages, 3) the romance doesn’t overpower the mystery, 4) the killer is introduced and their story is weaved within the plot….don’t introduce the killer and then we don’t read about them until the end, 5) don’t have the killer just confess, the amateur sleuth needs to work to find the motive, and 6) make the amateur sleuth interesting.
This is not a cozy. A mystery, yes. But not a cozy. OK, I got that out. So I’m reviewing this as a mystery novel.
Gabriella Quinn is an estate lawyer who’s asked to take on a probate case of a local man who passed away while in New York. Gaby has suffered a tragic loss and moved to a small town in Connecticut to start fresh. She has her friendly and trusted dog and has a healthy appetite. And we know this because we’re told about almost every single meal she eats. As she digs through the dead man’s papers and property, it’s a puzzle she has to put together to settle his estate. I liked Gaby a lot and the investigation into the dead man’s life kept me reading. That was by far my favorite part of the mystery.
Although there’s little tension throughout the book, the mystery of Pieter (the dead man) and the eeriness of his strange house and the fear of what could be behind the locked door certainly kept one guessing. When we find out what’s behind the door, though, it’s really rather disturbing.
The main reasons I wouldn’t classify this as a cozy is, one, there was no murder (Pieter’s death was not suspicious), two, as there’s no murder, there’s nothing for Gaby to investigate, and three, what is found in the basement.
Overall, the story is strong enough that the flaws I had with the writing, dialogue, and character descriptions didn’t stop me from finishing and enjoying the book. I hope that Ms. O’Connor’s writing matures as the series progresses.
I’ll definitely give the second book in the series a read.
DISCLOSURE: I received a review copy for free from Book Sirens in exchange for a fair and honest review.