Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Mags and Biddy Genealogy Mystery #1

How to Fake an Irish Wake

Rate this book
It’s been a rough year for 26-year-old Mags Murray. First she learns that her dad isn’t her biological father, a secret her mother took to her grave three years earlier. Then her beloved Irish grandmother passes away at Christmas while Mags is visiting her from the States. Now Mags must host her grandmother’s wake and sell her cottage. A cottage filled with cherished memories. A cottage Mags inherited but her odd jobs won’t enable her to keep.

Shortly after the funeral, a young man, Finn O’Brien, arrives at the cottage with an old photograph. Finn believes the boys in the photo are a clue to his father’s identity. Mags can sympathize with him, and because she often helped her genealogist grandmother uncover skeletons in people’s closets, including herself, she agrees to assist Finn.

But searching for Finn’s father stirs up trouble. Finn is in a near-fatal car crash that wasn’t an accident. So Mags and her childhood friend Biddy McCarthy investigate why someone wants to prevent Finn from finding his father. Questioning the quirky locals proves a wee bit difficult as several of the suspects were victims of Mags and Biddy’s childhood shenanigans.

It might take a fake Irish wake to reveal Finn’s father and the would-be murderer.

But what if the two turn out to be the same person?

234 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 19, 2020

322 people are currently reading
353 people want to read

About the author

Eliza Watson

36 books422 followers
Eliza Watson is a USA Today bestselling author, family historian, and former event planner. When Eliza isn't tracing her ancestry roots through Ireland or Scotland, she's at home working on her next novel, bouncing ideas off her husband, Mark, and her cats Frankie and Sammy. Eliza's monthly newsletter features genealogy research advice and info about her latest news, giveaways, and releases! Subscribe at elizawatson.com.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
317 (41%)
4 stars
268 (35%)
3 stars
135 (17%)
2 stars
35 (4%)
1 star
7 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews
Profile Image for Carol Engler.
407 reviews5 followers
January 10, 2023
Genealogy

The book open with Maggie having a waking for her recently passed grandma in her Grandma home in Ireland. While people are visiting a young man name Finn interrupts not realizing what he walked in on. Maggie takes him outside to only to discover he was sent to her because he is looking for his father . The only information he has is a old picture with a phone number on it. The picture was taken in front of the home she is living in taken many years before. He was told she was a genealogist and might be of help.
So the rest of the book is a quest to fine out who his father was. I love the Irish accent that comes threw as you read.
In the mean time she discovers what is true to her own heart. She realizes that she were she should be.
Nice quick read
Profile Image for P.A..
Author 2 books15 followers
March 15, 2021
A light hearted mystery with very lovable characters.
Profile Image for Christine Goodnough.
Author 4 books18 followers
September 13, 2021
The story is fast-paced and well written, humorous, maybe rather zany. The two ladies are a good fit as best friends. This series has potential if the writer will just rein in her protagonist's active imagination a bit. Hopefully in the next book.

As Maggie starts helping Finn find his father, it seems every tall blue-eyed man she sees must be his mother's long-lost lover, plus a couple of men no longer living. Her active imagination fleshes out a backstory for each "This is the one" to explain the how and when -- and who's responsible for Finn's accident. After half a dozen candidates I started to feel like Biddy: "How many fathers does he have anyway?"

The part about genealogical research interested me, but I wondered -- I'm sure Finn did, too -- about Maggie's rambling explanation of surnames. DNA doesn't give you the names of ancestors, doesn't matter if they're adopted, remarried, or changed surnames. DNA results give you the names of people who have taken the test and their genetics match yours. My own "matches" have dozens of different names, only a few have my grandparents' surnames.

One minor point: Daffodils grow from bulbs. To "pull them up by the roots" you must pull the whole bulb out of the ground -- not so easy to do. "Cutting off the roots," bulb and all, would soon kill the flower. And I don't blame someone for being "nasty about it" if neighbor girls pulled up her two long rows of daffodils.
Profile Image for Helen.
306 reviews2 followers
July 15, 2022
I've read a few other novels by Eliza Watson and enjoyed them a lot, so it saddens me to say that I didn't love this novel. It felt too light and the characters weren't quite developed yet. I do like the genealogy aspect, although she has used this in another series she has written. I'm saying that this was like a rough draft of a series, and she needed another pass or two to strengthen the connection to the reader. If I come across the next book being offered for free, I would read it. I have bought quite a few of this author's other works so I think if this series improves, I would be glad to buy more novels.
Profile Image for Leeanne  G.
312 reviews17 followers
May 12, 2025
"May you get all your wishes but one so you always have something to strive for."

This was such a fun start to this cozy mystery series! Mags and Biddy are a hilarious duo and get into some very funny situations.

I love that Mags solves genealogy mysteries. That makes this series unique in the cozy mystery world. Instead of solving a murder they help a man find his father.

I loved that this was set in Ireland!
1,700 reviews35 followers
November 27, 2020
Maggie has to hold an unexpected wake for her grandmother who passes away while she is visiting over the holidays.
A young man shows up shortly after the wake to ask her for help finding his father. Maggie was the Genealogy assistant for her grandmother.
Later that day, Maggie learns that the same man was in a near fatal accident which sends Maggie and Biddy on a search for clues not only for his father. But for the person who ran him off the road.

This is a fun story with mostly developed characters and a bit of humor.
For me at least the story leaned more towards a chicklit, or even a sweet romance than towards the actual mystery in the story.

This was the first story from Ms. Watson, and I will need to read at least one more to decide if I will continue the series.
611 reviews6 followers
March 22, 2021
Quite unexpected. Lovely

What a wonderful breath of fresh air. I loved it. But I will say some of the terminology stumped me. But it is definitely worth the read.
630 reviews6 followers
March 31, 2021
How to Fake an Irish Wake by Eliza Watson was my first read by this author and I absolutely loved her first genealogy cozy mystery in the Mags and Biddy series. It was an easy read and the characters were delightful, the murder mystery was full of suspense with some romance and a good storyline. Thank you to the author for introducing me to her great writing and this new interesting genealogy mystery. I rated it a five.
Profile Image for Susan.
1,533 reviews110 followers
December 14, 2022
HOW TO FAKE AN IRISH WAKE is a typical cozy mystery. It's fun, upbeat, light-hearted, and entertaining. Other than a few utterances of "Jaysus" (which I consider a swear word, although others may not), it's also a clean book with no profanity or sex and only a little violence. I enjoyed the small-town Irish setting and could feel a lot of warmth between its residents. Genealogy is a love of mine, so I especially dug the family history aspect of the novel. Watson infuses the tale with genealogical tips and tricks, but never bogs down the story with long, overly-detailed explanations. The "Tips & Quips" section at the back also offers helpful advice on researching your ancestors.

Mags and Biddy are likable enough heroines, but neither woman has much depth or personality. I never felt like I really knew either of them. Some fleshing-out would go a long way toward making them more interesting and relatable. Watson's story-telling also gets a bit frenetic as she tries to weave a plethora of characters and plot details together, giving the novel a confusing, all-over-the-place feel. Naturally, HOW TO FAKE AN IRISH WAKE also has some silly, far-fetched antics thrown into the mix. While those are a trademark of the genre and something cozy readers know not to take too seriously, they definitely add to the already-frenzied feel of this story. Still and all, the novel has good bones; some sharp editing could have easily whipped it into a more focused, fuller, better-formed novel.

All this considered, I still enjoyed the novel for the most part. I would probably read another one in the series with the hope that it gets better as it goes.
Profile Image for Debyi  Kucera (Book&BuJo).
874 reviews52 followers
April 4, 2023
How to Fake an Irish Wake by Eliza Watson is the first book in the Mags and Biddy Genealogy Mystery Series. In this first book, we follow Mags Murray as she is in Ireland wrapping up her grandmother’s wake when Finn O’Brien arrives hoping to get Mags’ grandmother's help in finding out who his father is from an old photograph. Mags’ grandmother is the local genealogy sleuth and Mags has helped her in her research over the years and decides to help Finn.

As Finn starts asking questions, he ends up in a near-fatal car crash, which looks like it was not an accident. Mags and her best friend Biddy, whose father owns the local pub, are on the case. Will they find out who the father is before someone else gets hurt?

This book is so cute, I thoroughly enjoyed it. There is mystery, romance, hilarious antics, friends, and family. The characters are lovable with a touch of zany-ness thrown in.

It is a short book and overall is fast-paced with a nice wrap-up at the end. There are also a couple of twists to keep you guessing. It was like a nice glass of iced tea on a warm summer’s day.
Profile Image for Carlin.
1,757 reviews18 followers
October 22, 2020
What a fun book. I've read all the Travel Mishaps of Caity Shaw books and loved them so was happy to see the author has started a new series.... especially since it involves genealogy and Ireland!

Mags inherited her grandmother's home in a small Irish town. Though Mags, raised in America, spent many summers with her grandmother learning genealogy at her knee, she was sure she couldn't afford to keep the home and make all the needed repairs. So in spite of the townspeople, including her best friend Biddy, wanting her to stay, Mags put the house on the market. In the meantime she was approached by a young man who wanted help to find his biological father (setting up her future business as a genealogist).

The story was delightful, humorous, and full of love. I look forward to more in this cozy mystery series.
Profile Image for Roy Murry.
Author 11 books112 followers
October 7, 2021
How to Fake an Irish Wake

Eliza Watson

Review by Author Roy Murry

Mags and Biddy solve a genealogy mystery by accident. Mags' grandmother, a genealogist, died in Ireland, and she is there directing her wake, giving the reader insight into Irish mores - charming.

In the course of things, Finn arrives in town looking for his father, whom he has never met. Unfortunately, Mags doesn't know who her father is either.

This adventure is book one in a series, so it's a setup. First, Finn shows a snap (photo) to everyone around town, which lands him in the hospital. Next, Mags, who just met Finn, gets involved in investigating his mishap and genealogy.

She brings Biddy, her life's friend, into a hilarious adventure that leads to another wake. Those encounters lead to a sobering ending the reader will enjoy.

The writing and characters are endearing, capturing the readers' attention and wanting to buy the series. I know I will buy another in the series.

33 reviews
March 12, 2023
Enjoyable

I enjoyed the chemistry between Mags and Biddy, and some scenes really had me laughing out loud. A few portions felt repetitive, and a few felt confusing enough to wish for pen and paper to make my own notes as the mystery progressed.

Talking of the mystery, it was interestingly written. A lot of the "suspects" seemed plausible, so the final answer was somewhat exciting. All the questions that the reader may have do get answered, but sometimes the answers looked a bit weak or unconvincing to me. The actual idea of holding a wake felt harebrained to me, hence the 3 stars.

I learnt a little bit of the Irish culture and traditions too, so that was a bonus. The book had hardly any proofreading errors, so that's grand ;)

I might check out more in the series, but only if it is available on Kindle Unlimited.
Profile Image for Lise.
1,067 reviews
July 26, 2022
In Ireland to celebrate Christmas with her grandmother, Mags Murray is heartbroken when she has to hold a wake for her beloved relative instead. During the visitation, Finn O'Brien arrives at Mags' inherited cottage trying to find his long-lost father. When Finn is run off the road, Mags realises there's more at stake than just genealogy and vows to track down his past before the villain strikes again.

Mags and her friend Biddy are madcap fun. I loved their misadventures but thought that their approach to some of their difficulties stretched the limits of imagination at times. I was thrilled to see hints and tips for genealogical work scattered throughout the story as well as a good sprinkling of trivia.

This is a series I will be following.
Profile Image for Pamela Devereux.
1,032 reviews2 followers
November 5, 2021
This was a fun book to read. It all started with a funeral for Mags grandma and ended with a fake Irish wake. In between there was a mystery to solve. Who is Finn's dad? He had an old photo with a phone number on the back. So Mags and her best friend Biddy decided to go in search. From an old teacher to some of the boys in the photo. It seems the best advice was given by Biddy's dad. Just ask. Any dad would want to know. So that was the plan. Also, they needed to catch the person who tried to run Finn off the road and knock Mags out. Nothing turned out as plan but still mission was accomplished. I look forward to reading more stories about Mags and Biddy.
Profile Image for Amanda Jane.
1,337 reviews9 followers
November 18, 2021
Too rushed..

Too many names and what-ifs and may-bes.. circling around and around until it's just a mass of similar names with no real research or actual genealogy.

Mags and Biddy aren't really particularly likeable.. lacks description of them as characters.. we know how Finn looks, we know that there's allegedly a spark, we're told frequently, but there's no actual evidence of one to back it up..

Most oddly written, feels like a plot that got completely out of hand and turned into a book by accident. We have description we don't need and where it would help just too much talking about the lengthy list of similar names.

Wish I hadn't bought all of them in one go.
966 reviews8 followers
February 4, 2022
I loved this book set in Ireland. Mags returns to Ireland to see her granny who is a geneologist. Mags is heartbroken at the loss of her granny and plans her wake. During the wake a stranger comes looking for her granny to help him find his father. Mags recently discovered her dad isn’t her dad so she decides to help him look. When he gets hit by a car and is badly injured she thinks it’s related to the search. When sh gets injured he quits but she continues The search for him.
I really enjoyed this funny, adventurous book. A lot of the townspeople remind me of my family and friends around Dublin. I really enjoyed it and recommend this book.
2,332 reviews
March 8, 2022
This was different type of cozy mystery that centered around genealogy. It was really interesting as Mags does research into not only her biological, but Finn’s as well aka that was where mystery came in especially when someone attacked Finn. I liked seeing what Mags did as she crossed off potential fathers off the list. Admittedly there were a lot of possibilities so it was hard to keep track of the families and the candidates for fathers at times. It was just a lot information to take in. It was intriguing to say the least though. I do wish that Mads paternity was revealed because I was very invested in that storyline. Overall it was a good, quick read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Rhonda Clark.
345 reviews1 follower
January 16, 2023
I would like to read a prequel of this series to include Mags as a girl spending time with Biddy and her grandmother.
I laughed out loud a few times and mainly enjoyed this genealogy mystery. The nickname Mags was fine; Biddy made me think "old lady" even though they're the same age. I could relate to Mags, a single woman hopeful about a potential relationship and living in an old house that needs work (wondering how to pay for the repairs). Loved the setting in Ireland, picking up the phrases like "Janey Mac!" -- much tamer than Tana French's language in her books. 4.5/5 stars would be more accurate.
Profile Image for Charlyn.
808 reviews3 followers
August 1, 2023
An Irish lad searches for his dad.

Mags is just finishing her own grandmother’s wake when a stranger, Finn, appears with a photo in hand. One of the lads in it is his father, a stranger to him who is apparently unaware he even has a son. When Finn is injured in a car accident, Mags becomes involved in his search for his father. Her best friend Biddy helps in whatever way she can, but it is Mags who uses her genealogy prowess to try to search for both Finn’s father and her own. There are no deaths involved in this search, although there is a fake wake. Not so much humor here as just a light-hearted mystery.
528 reviews2 followers
October 13, 2023
I really enjoyed reading this book. The last three books I have read dealt with DNA testing to find one's parents, and this one also included genealogical research. Both topics are fascinating for me.

Mags and Biddy have a long friendship beginning in childhood, and I can certainly appreciate that also. The author reveals both their good qualities and those not so good. The women aren't perfect, but their friendship continues.

The fact that the story takes place in Ireland and involves a woman from Chicago adds to my enjoyment.

I found only one or two typos, and they were minor.

I much prefer a genealogical mystery to a gory story.
Profile Image for Cecellia Rogers.
661 reviews
March 2, 2025
Poorly written. Some plot points telegraphed early and WAY too frequently. Others unrevealed until the last few pages. Yes, I understand that the main character's insistence on misplaced blame is going to be proven wrong in the end, but for the love of Mike, give me half a clue as to where the blame might truly lie. A reader wants the chance to solve the mystery and delight in twists and turns along the way. This book doesn't do that.

And take notes if you want to try to remember who's who and why we should care.

Someone else in the book club says the books in this series get better, but I'm disinclined to test it.
Profile Image for Marilyn.
1,513 reviews
November 30, 2020
I was drawn to this book because of the connection to genealogy. I am a genetic genealogist and I use DNA matches to create trees for those who were adopted in order to identify biological parents. The author did mention this type of work, but did not go in to any detail about the process. I hope she is aware of the work of CeCe Moore and will dig deeper in to the possibilities of this process in future books. I love books set in Ireland. An interesting look at detective work to try to identify the biological family of a young man.
677 reviews2 followers
March 5, 2022
Finding Film's father

Mags and Biddy are best friends with a wild imagination return detectives to help Finn find his biological father. Finn did a DNA test and learned the man who raised him wasn't his father. The only clue he had was a picture with four boys and a telephone number written on the back. When accidents begin happening it looks like someone doesn't want him to find his Dad.

I thought it was curious that Finn allowed Mags and Biddie to do most of the investigation. There were some funny parts . I didn't find it believable but it was entertaining.
Profile Image for Linda.
1,371 reviews
November 11, 2025
Fake a wake?

Mags Murray is at a crossroad. Her grandmother passed away and left Mags her house in Ireland. A wanderer by nature, Mags is supposed to sell it and travel the world. When Finn arrives at her her grandmother's wake looking for help listing his father, Mags who helped her grandmother with her genealogy research in the past, agrees to help him. She never expects that someone would hurt her or Finn to hide the truth. Determined to succeed, she'll not stop and just may learn that Ireland is in her blood.
Profile Image for Suzan.
1,642 reviews17 followers
December 4, 2020
A fun story set in Ireland. Mags and Biddy are childhood friends who have kept in touch and even though Mags moved to America she would come back and visit her beloved Grandma. This time she is planing the wake for her beloved Grandma. In walks a handsome man looking to find his father and who better to help him but Mags. Mags and Biddy are great fun to watch solve this mystery. I will be reading more in this series. I received this book as an ARC but this review is my own.
Profile Image for Nancy.
1,577 reviews
December 10, 2020
I recived this book as an ARC.
What a great book to read. It was fun to go into the world of genealogy.
Maggie is back in Ireland visiting her Grandmother. While she is here her Grandmother passes away and Maggie has to plan the Wake for her.
While she is there a man approaches her to ask for her assistance in finding his biological father.
With the help of her longtime childhood friend Biddy they jump into to finding his father.
The story is a great start to a new series.





864 reviews7 followers
March 11, 2022
I found this story rather funny. When in Ireland do as the Irish do. Mags is back home for her favorite Grandmother's funeral when she meets a good looking very blue eyed man looking for his father. Mags and her friend decide there are too many choices to eliminate and decide to fake a wake. You have to read it to enjoy it. The story has two twists and you probably will not guess right who the bad person(s) are.
427 reviews43 followers
April 11, 2022
A Warm Cozy Read

What could be better than a cozy mystery set in beautiful Ireland? . The novel looks at family - the family we know , distant relatives and ancestors. The mystery centers around the search for unknown biological parents, how they might be found, and possible consequences. There are moments that will make you!laugh and some that may make you sad. Overall it's craic!
4 reviews
February 10, 2025
Good, but flawed

The author's habit of naming the color of every item of clothing just drove me to distraction. And not just clothing--why did iy HAVE to be a "green" lawn? Why not just a healthy lawn, or just a lawn, period?
And why not even ONE reference to the song "Finnegan's Wake"? And a couple of stream-of-consciousness jumps had me scratching my head.
The story's okay, the characters quirky, the setting's perfect (well, Ireland, how not?)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.