First of all, thank you NetGalley for providing me an ARC and giving me the chance to read it. It’s been a pleasure.
The Wise One follows the story of McKenna, a 17 year old teenager that starts experiencing weird and magical things that belong to those stories of fairytales. She then sets off on a journey which purpose is both discovering herself and investigating as well as trying to find someone she never thought she’d ever meet. Now, accompanied by a new friend Nissa and a stranger, McKenna faces new challenges as well as she gets to know more about her past and her origins.
I believe this is the first book in the saga “The Scottish Scrolls” and even though it started really slow-paced, things get interesting as we dive more into the action. I have to admit I was dreading to start it, but that’s what happens to most of the books I read. However, I am very pleased to say it has been worth every second of my time.
Let’s dive into what I liked and I didn’t like, shall we?
** WARNING: this review contains spoilers (I just couldn’t help myself [laughs nervously])
The story is quite slow-paced, at some points too slow-paced for my liking, and sometimes I had to put the book down just to process what I was reading; between all the touristic and history facts that are told about every place they go. However, I can tell I learned great things and that’s one of the things that I find the most intriguing about books.
My favourite character? I don’t think I really have one in specific, I’d have to read more to actually find a character that I can relate to and love. But I do specially like Nissa, the carefree girl who’s all anout nature, who cares so much about nature and constantly thinks of ways to preserve it. She’s really passionate about what she likes and the fact that she reads nature books,,,, that’s what made me like her so much. In addition, her blindly trusting someone she barely knows and joining McKenna in her journey to self-discovery says a lot about her. Nissa is such a baby and by that I mean she’s got to be protected at all costs. I love her a lot. Despite this, I also would like to mention how she’s way too innocent and maybe takes very dangerous risks, for instance when she follows an old lady into a narrow and dark street and when she convinces McKenna to stay with a pair of strangers. That’s what weirded me out quite a lot because we’ve all been told since we were children that we must never trust strangers, lest follow them to wherever they might lead us. I thank the God above Nissa’s been lucky to find trustful and good people.
The characters didn’t actually feel real to me. There’s so many things I find so strange and risky, maybe it’s due to my european upbringing and my lack of knowledge on american culture and habits. First of all we have McKenna running away to Boston to get to Dublin and then go to Ballycastle, leaving a two-line short note to her parents, persuading another teenager to accompany her and not even once caring about what this might do to her parents. Yes, she did end up wondering about what her parents might have thought and feeling guilty, which was a plus because I hated reading how she “didn’t want to think of her parents because they wouldn’t understand her emotions and what she’s going through” at that moment. Seán and Andre are her family, the only family she ever needed and she was fast to leave them behind pursuing a lead to find her mum whom she doesn’t know if is alive or has perished. She sets off on a long journey with nothing planned, a rather improvised decision that shows she was too angry, overwhelmed by her own emotions and thoughts to think clearly and give a second thought before running to find her mum without hesitation.
I’ve got to say Seán was right to go look for her and get her home safely. Andre’s opinion to let her cool down, find her answers and come back once she was ready was one of the most unrealistic things I’ve ever read, but I do understand why he may have said it. We teenagers tend to act rather unpredictable and we tend to take decisions made just when we are overwhelmed. McKenna took a big decision without second thoughts and I felt like Andre was wrong to tell Seán to let her come back when she was ready. Let’s remember McKenna is 17 years old, still a minor. If I were her mother, my first thought would’ve been to go look for her, get her back home and tell her off. And maybe then just be grateful I’d found McKenna and that nothing bad happened to her. Don’t forget she didn’t just run away to another city or town or state, instead she ran away to another continent, which is something to really really worry about. And this may be the reason why I started liking Seán, till he kissed Abby, which with me counts as cheating on her husband. I was really pleased to see Seán and Andre parenting McKenna though.
However, the big big NO was McKenna and Nissa going through her journey and trusting complete strangers: from the adorable old couple to Cillian, whom they just met like maybe 5 days ago, and with whom shared a bedroom and the journey through the green landscape of Ireland. In real life that’s the most most MOST dangerous thing to ever do, but I also understand this is a book and not going to lie, if I were a book character I’d probably do the same. I’ve even dreamed and wondered doing this while sleeping at night.
The story didn’t keep me guessing. I was partly angry at McKenna for acting rather childish and selfish and the other part of me was just soaking up all the information and taking notes on the scottish and irish words used throughout the whole book. I did wonder though if McKenna would ever find where her mother was hiding, and if she would cross paths with her father and her mother at some point. And I’m still waiting for this to happen in the following book.
My favourite part of the book might have been when McKenna met a faerie with whom she exchanged pleasentries and who returned her Converses to her way after she returned to the “real world”. Another favourite moment of mine is when Nissa and McKenna reunite again, after McKenna finally realises her mistake and astral projects herself to where Nissa may be and then, when she goes back to her to apologize, both of them hug each other and then share their findings.
As for the question whether the book made me laugh and cry,,,,,, it’s safe to say I didn’t do either? I did find every scene written greatly which helped me picture every word in my head and play it as if it was a film. However, this is the first book so there hasn’t been lots of pure action,,,, which brings me to the following point: there weren’t enough sad or tense and romantic scenes for me to actually appreciate the way they’re written. I DO love slow-burn romances so I’m cheering and rooting for McKenna and Cillian in the second book.
All in all, the surprising thing has been the ending. With a cliffhanger like that, who expects the book to no longer give you more scenes? It basically cuts off your supply on chapters right after she finally meets her mother through astral projection. It’s frustrating and I’m just waiting for the next book to come so I can read what’s going to happen but at the same time I wanna leave it because I’m dreading what might happen next. I am ready for the next book but at the same time I’m scared what the next book might bring to the characters. I do want, of course, Andre and Seán meeting and fixing their marriage, because these two are the best thing in the whole book. And I just wish them the best.
As I’ve said before, I found it hard to like the main character, and maybe that’s just me but I didn’t actually like her a lot. She had her reasons to do what she did and I respect that, but I do not find myself relating to her in any aspect and maybe that —and also how she barely cared about what her parents might go after her fleeing their home and country with no clue as to where she was going (well there was one but not explicitly stated)— is what made me so reluctant to emotionally attach myself to her. Despite this, though, I ended up liking her a little bit more in the end. Do not ask me why because I wouldn’t be able to tell you precisely what I like about her.
To summarize, I’d like to thank again the publisher for giving me an ARC and letting me read this story. As for what public this may be directed to, I’d daresay this book is perfect for teens (teenagers) around 14-18 maybe 14-17. For young readers who love a slow-burn romance and slow-paced story that might teach you quite a lot of things about Ireland and its myths.
Despite the things I’ve learned and the new vocabulary, I give this book a solid 2 star rating. I really hope the next one picks up and gives us more action as well as more backstory and maybe shows us the character development of McKenna. I truly wish to love her with all my heart and I want to be able to say I love McKenna after the following book.