Any compilation of short stories is difficult to rate, as some stories are stronger than others, so I've decided to rate and summarize each story separately in hopes of giving the book as a whole a more accurate review. There are some minor spoilers in a few of my summaries, but not enough to ruin the actual experience of reading each story.
I've rated the stories below from my favorites to my least favorites:
5/5 - For Lies and Liberty: This was a wonderful tale focused on the Forsaken, who are one of my favorites races both in the game and the book series. We're introduced to a newly risen batch of Forsaken who are struggling to cope with their new un-life and all the terrifying implications that come with it, including a young foot soldier who believes his name is Abel. He's incredibly quiet and withdrawn as they talk about how they died, but he opens up and becomes more animated when he talks about the heroic Captain Whitney, the man who inspired Abel to join the fight in the first place. But all is not as it seems surrounding the story of the fabled Captain, and Abel and the rest of the Forsaken struggle with standing up for themselves and embracing the truth, even if it means letting go of the only shreds of hope they still have in their new lives.
This story was both heartbreaking and humorous, and one of my favorites in the book. I laughed, I cried, and I loved the Forsaken even more after reading this!
5/5 - The Courageous Kobold and the Wickless Candle: I never would have expected a story about Kobolds to bring tears to my eyes, but here we are. The story begins with Twig telling her favorite story to all the little Kobold girls and boys, about how her Granny Whiskersnoot went against Kobold tradition and dug above her snout, tunneling up through the caverns and revealing the light of the "wickless candle." Of course, no one believes the story but Twig and Tallow, and many of her family view it as silly nonsense that will only lead to cave-ins and death. When Tallow goes in search of the legendary wickless candle, it's up to Twig to save him and prove to her people that not all folk tales are made up.
I love that they included the Kobolds in this story compilation, and really gave them personalities and a culture of their own. However, it is going to be slightly more awkward when I'm told to ruthlessly slaughter them in the game.
5/5 - Why the Mermaids Left Boralus: This was a really touching story about the people of Boralus and their somewhat troubled relationship with the mermaids, and how a mermaid and a tidesage helped them overcome their prejudice. As humans (or Kul Tirans, in this case) tend to do when other intelligent beings are involved, the people of Boralus mistook the benevolent behavior of the mermaids and attributed just about every natural disaster and calamity to them. Eventually, the mermaids grew tired of being blamed and hated for simply existing and stopped trying to help the Kul Tirans, instead doing their best to keep their distance. However, one mermaid, Halia, becomes so entranced with the tidesage Ery that she can't help but try to show her her true feelings. Ery falls in love with her over time, but they must remain apart and keep their relationship a secret due to the prejudice of the Kul Tirans and the strict duty of being a tidesage. During a particularly bad storm that threatens to destroy Boralus, Ery and Halia work together to build a protective wall against the violent sea, eventually inspiring the other mermaids to help, at great cost to their species.
This was a wonderful, heartbreaking story about duty and honor and the strength of love in the face of adversity and prejudice. The relationship between Ery and Halia felt natural and was written well, rather than feeling as though the author had an agenda, which I appreciated :)
5/5 - Sister is Another Word for Always: Another emotional and heartbreaking story about Vereesa Windrunner attempting to save the soul of her sister, Sylvanas. I loved the way this was written, as it really focused on how the events of Sylvanas' death and transformation into the Banshee Queen affected her for years afterward. After having a vision/flashback of a moment in their childhood, Vereesa leaves the battlefield and her duties to wander the world, eventually traveling to Ardenweald and the Maw, where she encounters the Jailer. She comes so close to retrieving her sister's soul, or what's left of it, but a good-intentioned action to save her ends up backfiring, and she is cast out from the Maw to return to her duties and accept the fact that her sister is truly lost forever.
This was such a well-written, poignant story, and well-timed as I had just watched a very relevant cinematic concerning Sylvanas. This story really gave it more meaning and emotional depth, and it was one of the best in the story compilation.
5/5 - The Uninvited Guest: A great story about the goblin Boogeyman, known only as the Uninvited Guest, which targets goblins who get just a little too greedy (which is saying something when it comes to their race). It feeds on their greed, stealing it from them and driving them to give away their possessions and *gasp* give back to the community, until they have nothing left...
This was a fun little story that takes a common conception in human folk tales - being charitable and sharing your good fortune with others - and turns it into a horrible fate that can only be avoided by tricking the creature and pretending to be charitable. I chuckled several times during the story, and thoroughly enjoyed it :)
4/5 - Visage Day: A cute story about Chronormu the bronze dragon and his struggle to choose a mortal form in time for Visage Day. I never considered that choosing a mortal form would be such a big event in a dragon's life, nor that it would be something incredibly difficult (and permanent), but I think this story adds quite a bit to the lore and personalities of the individual dragons we meet in the game and book series. Chronormu speaks to a few well-known dragons - Nozdormu, Onyxia, and Kalecgos - about how they made their own decisions, and each one reveals how their mortal form represents them and how they want to be seen by the mortals of Azeroth. Through their help, Chronormu learns more about himself and how he wants to be seen outside of his dragon form, and chooses the form of everyone's favorite gnome, Chromie.
This story and the characters did feel a bit simplistic compared to some others, and perhaps that's only because the dragons weren't written as old and wise and mature as I expect them to be. However, it is a folk/fairy tale likely meant for the children of Azeroth, so perhaps I'm being a bit too critical of the writing here. Overall, I really enjoyed reading about the origin of Chromie and love her even more than I already did!
4/5 - Lay Down My Bones: I was thrilled to see the Vulpera included in this book, and right after my fiance and I started our own adventures as Vulpera! It follows Hava and Siy, two young Vulpera who were tasked with using the ceremonial "Wailing Bone" to find the final resting place for one of their elders. Of course, being young, impatient, and dismissive of such fables, they grow tired of the long journey and decide to just let the river do their work for them. It... doesn't go well, as you can imagine.
This was a darker story than I was expecting, and was definitely a surprise after the first two stories, which were a bit more simplistic and/or light-hearted in nature. I really enjoyed the story overall and was delighted to read more about the Vulpera!
4/5 - The Paladin's Beast: An interesting story about Uther Lightbringer and his first solo adventure as a paladin. He and his fellow paladins are tasked by their archbishop to find ways to prove their resolve and their dedication to the light. While traveling through inclement weather, his horse is spooked by lightning and tosses him into a lake, where he travels to another realm and meets a princess named Miatharas. After learning of a tournament her father holds each year, in which knights repeatedly attempt to slay a monster and fail, he decides to join the tournament to prove his might as a paladin, despite her warnings. During the tournament, as he watches each of his fellow champions be slain by the monster, he realizes the monster isn't simply an aggressive, cruel beast, but shackled and in pain. Rather than try to kill the creature, he lays his sword down, choosing the path of peace, and wins the tournament. After finding out the truth about the monster, he returns to Lordaeron with no memory of the events. Feeling as though he hasn't done anything brave or heroic to merit the title of paladin, he is instead rewarded for choosing the peaceful and compassionate path.
This was an interesting story about how oftentimes peace and compassion is the best option, and I loved that there were several hints at his later death at the hands of Arthas.
3/5 - Eyes of the Earth Mother: This was the first story in the compilation, and appropriately timed as my fiance and I had just entered Mulgore with our Vulpera. The story tells of the creation of the world and the Tauren, and how the Earth Mother managed to fight back the evil and corruption that threatened to infect the Tauren and destroy her creations, but at a great cost to herself.
It was a really interesting story and definitely set up the tone of the "folk tales" aspect of this book, and I appreciated that it was written in such a way that it could be read without any knowledge of World of Warcraft lore.
3/5 - One Small Tuskar: A cute little story that essentially boils down to "The Little Tuskar Who Could." It follows Taruka, an undersized Tuskar girl whose father died at a young age, forcing her to learn everything she knows about fishing on her own. She's often picked on and underestimated by others of her clan, and feels guilty that she can't support her family as well as she wants to. When one of the village elders tell her to avoid a particularly dangerous fishing area, she assumes they're trying to sabotage her efforts, and goes out on her own to prove herself. She manages to kill a gigantic and fearsome creature, and triumphantly returns to her village, where she is greeted happily by everyone.
This was a cute story, but was a bit too simplistic, especially considering how little we get to see of the Tuskar as it is. I did feel as though the Tuskar were written a bit more callous in this story than they really are. It seems as though a clan that depends on each other for survival in a harsh environment would try to help each other as much as possible, rather than alienating those who were unlucky enough not to be taught everything by their fathers. Tradition is one thing, but it seemed a bit strange that everyone would be so unsympathetic toward Taruka.
3/5 - The Embrace: This story tells of the origin myth of the second moon of Azeroth, and a rare celestial alignment known as "the Embrace." Like "The Eyes of the Earth Mother," it was definitely written more like a standard folk tale that doesn't require any knowledge of WoW lore, and gives emotion and meaning to celestial events like tidal shifts, and how even the smallest change can cause great devastation to the land and people of Azeroth.
This was a well-written story, but to be honest, I was expecting a bit more considering it was written by Christie Golden. I feel as though they should have let her take the reigns on a different story, though perhaps her strength just doesn't lie in short stories.
2/5 - Stones, Moss, and Tears: This was my least favorite story out of the compilation, which is a shame, because it could've been great if handled differently. This story follows Keda Bloomblade, a night elf Sentinel who struggles to admit her feelings for the Lorekeeper, Toreth. She feels as though she needs to impress him throughout the story, as she doesn't feel she is good enough to be worthy of his attention. We find out throughout the story that she struggles with her identity and lack of acceptance from her family, who don't agree with the path she has chosen in life. Eventually, she comes to realize that just being herself is good enough, and she is worthy of love no matter what her family may think.
I liked the concept of this story, but their choice to use a night elf Sentinel for a premise that feels more suited for a younger, less mature character was completely wrong, as it seems a bit silly to have an ordinarily stoic, fierce warrior acting like a nervous teenager with a crush. And unlike the stories of Chromie and Halia/Ery, the LGBT aspects felt forced in this story. I love that Blizzard is becoming more inclusive, and there are a few examples where they've done it well, but it really felt as if they had an agenda and let the writing/story take a backseat on this one.
Overall, I really enjoyed this story compilation, as I can never seem to get enough of WoW lore! While some of the stories were weaker than others, the stories that were written well were really memorable, and added quite a bit of depth to characters and races that haven't been explored as well in the game and book series so far.