saw this at work and recalled seeing it on my mom's library account, i started reading it and couldn't stop. Really really upsetting and heartbreaking. Made me question through some moral conundrums. Like I logically know all the parallels between the mental health system and the prison system and that our solutions for mental illness are tantamount to locking people up and not much else (and sometimes just straight up doing that with the prison system w no grey area to speak of). Greiling's opponents on one of the bills she sponsored about making it easier to civilly commit people had some points imo, wrt the fact that it takes away the autonomy of mentally ill individuals. On paper I would 100% agree with that bc I am against taking away people's freedoms. But she was also speaking as a mother in a desperate situation. I myself have had three separate loved ones in my life where I have been absolutely desperate to make them stay in some kind of rehabilitative facility that they often didn't want to be in because I was afraid of what would happen if they were not there, and I was never once afraid of any of these people being a danger to others the way Grieling and the other mothers in the book were. It reminded me of a twitter argument I saw once about the use of restraints with some people saying it's never ever okay to restrain another human being, and someone else said "okay let's allow people to jump out of the window for woke points". I struggle with thinking through these contradictions and wanting to know what the best solution is, but it is important to think about and question your own dissonances.
I had never heard of advocacy work to have schizophrenia categorized as a brain disease like alzheimers rather than a mental illness. It's true, no one would ever think an alzheimers patient needs to work harder or go to therapy more to retain their memories, and it might help funding research. I started this review 2 weeks ago and forgot to finish it, so I'm sure I had more to say but I can't remember! Being a parent seems so hard.
Ok I'm adding some stuff I remembered
Even though it is a memoir and she wasn't required to include anything outside of her own experience, I do feel that as a representative there should have been maybe a little bit more time devoted to the issue of access to mental healthcare based on race and poverty. She does frequently mention wondering how people do it when she, with all her connections and being middle class, can barely hang on. She laments the fact that when you need help the only resource is the police and is angry that the criminal justice system is the only institution provided when medical care is what is needed. There was a focus on the fact that nonwhite people have distrust of medical institutions, but no explanation as to why, and therefore no mention of the fact that black people having mental health episodes could be killed let alone sent to jail. I am not expecting a dissertation on race and the Minnesota mental health care system but just a small amount of info was my only critique, because things people complain about in our city like the increase in homelessness are directly tied to the inadequacies of our mental healthcare system. I may have felt differently if the author was a regular mom writing a memoir and not speaking from a 30 year career legislator in the district right next to where I live.
I commend her for how much she bared her soul including the things that are really hard to admit. My thoughts on this as it relates to things my family has gone through are too much to say on goodreads but I do applaud her for making people feel less alone. I was also struck by her honesty with herself when she is upset Jim is gaining weight as a result of his meds that are helping his brain and how she knows it's messed up to care about something so shallow. Grieling truly bared it all on a topic that contains a ton of taboos and I think she did it in a way that was also respectful to her son.