This book might be a shorter summary of Vishal's book, but has very similar strengths and weaknesses. The absence of biblical discernment is much more obvious in this book, as it blatantly endorses Roman Catholic works and confuses those with the fruits of the work in CHRISTOS.
The obvious truth is that pagans and anti-Christs alike can do the same morally good works and still not be in the SPIRIT of CHRISTOS. The Catholic church has blinded billions through their good works (e.g. Mother Teresa who was very evil while blinding the world through good works), but this does not legitimize them as part of the Christian Church as plainly assumed by the author.
It is a negative surprise after having read her other 2 outstanding books, to notice here a strong Augustinian spirit of anti-Christ, both in the form of the Roman Catholic church and the Presbyterian church, both being heavily promoted in this book.
PROS
+ As usual, the author does a good investigation on a purely historical level.
CONS
- The book is spiritually empty and there is no Good Message found in it. It is much rather a social g‑spel and goes as far as to lean onto Neo-Calvinism and Dominionism.
- The author repeatedly endorses the missionary Ann Judson and her husband Adoniram. It is evil to make such an endorsement, and Sharon James has no excuse because she wrote the book 'Ann Judson: A Missionary Life for Burma'.
It should be well-known that Adoniram practiced the outmost heretical Guionism (extreme form of Roman Catholic Mysticism) since even before the Death Prison days, meaning when Ann still had some years to live. They were not only attracted to Catholic (Augustinian) mystics, but set out as Calvinists (Congregationalist) and then brought Calvinism into the Baptist denomination. He and his son(Elnathan) were Freemasons from before they left America until his death, precisely a member of the fraternity 'Philermenian Society'.
It is therefore also no surprise, that the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC), which would probably not even exist without the Judson's, is deeply penetrated with both Calvinists (~30% in 2007, growing) and Freemasons (~14-18% amongst pastors and deacons in the 1990s).
- Quote: "But from the inception of the Christian Church at Pentecost, the followers of Jesus have sought to love their neighbor and to reflect G-d's moral character."
While her intentions might be noble (and mainstream), such a statement shows rather an insufficient understanding of Christianity. Christianity started when CHRISTOS created the earth and created the first human beings, and equipped them with laws Joseph and others followed long before Mt. Sinai. Christianity was in the ears of the people when they read the countless prophecies pointing to the First Coming of CHRISTOS. Christianity is not a religion that came suddenly into being at Pentecost, it existed from minute 1 of humanity. The term Judaism is neither found in the Greek OT nor in the Hebrew OT and it has done more harm than good to divide the true faith into two separate religions. Every Christian is a spiritual Jew, and every Jew is a Christian if he does not deny the fulfillment of all those prophecies in IESOUS CHRISTOS.
- The author is very close to Catholicism:
Some quotes: "[speaking about the US & GB] While Catholics had a clear understanding of the humanity and dignity of unborn life, many Protestants, including evangelicals, believed the 'experts' and assumed that support of abortion (in certain circumstances) was the 'compassionate' thing to do. Only when the appalling scale of the destruction of unborn life became apparent, did an evangelical pro-life movement gain momentum."
"... by the end of the nineteenth century Roman Catholic missionaries had had a major social impact: ..."
"Generations of school children were told, wrongly, that the Catholic Church thought the earth was flat, and so opposed Christopher Columbus's voyage of exploration in 1492."
- Endorsement of many (highly) problematic teachers such as Aquinas, Augustine, Calvin, Grudem, Luther, Martin Luther King, Spurgeon, and of religions / denominations such as Catholicism, Calvinists, Dominicans, Presbyterians, Puritans ...