DNF @48 pages.
I have never been so LOST in my life. I get that this is #4 in a series, but a little help in knowing the premise of things would be nice. This does not in *ANY* way stand alone. And the writing is really bad t'boot.
First page: "The early daffodils and dandelions... lifted their heads to the sun, The old oaks and red maples were lush with new leaves." If there are lush leaves? It's not daffodil time. Leaves are May, Daffodils are late March.
Josie tells Tobias in a flashback that she was from Ohio, and went to Kentucky with a friend (maybe in a previous book? Or just backstory here? We don't know). She fell in love with Tobias in Kentucky, was raped by his Englisch friend, took off two months before their wedding, and then went 'home'. Then it says Tobias sold his father's farm in Kentucky and headed to find Josie... IN PENNSYVLANIA. *WHAT* the what!?
Then later we find out she grew up in Pennsylvania. But that wasn't conveyed to the reader initially, so we're ALL shades of screwed up trying to figure out how she could be from Ohio and Pennsylvania at the same time. Until we read that her brother took her to Ohio after her parents died in a fire. Which apparently was covered in another book, but not here.
Which brings us to the next stupid thing: We're told that Josie can't go in the house she grew up in, because her parents died tragically in a fire. THEN we're told they were out in the barn fighting, and tiny Josie brought out a lamp (WHY???) and broke it and started the fire so... she can't go in the farmhouse, now. Because her parents died in a barn fire, she can't go in a house. Makes. No. Sense. The house wasn't where they died, hello.
Then we have Naomi inviting Josie to walk her to supper, but Josie says she wants to wait for Josiah to tell her about the house sale. After a back-and-forth, Naomi says, "The sooner we get to supper, the sooner we can hear what Josiah has to say." ?!?!?!?! GAH!!! Then *WHY* was she waiting for Josiah, if he was going to be at supper?!
We're also told the heroine had the baby (from the rape), then dropped the baby off at her brother's door (last book?) and he "found her in the hospital with pneumonia". But then pg 42 says he "found her with the baby in the old house". The one she can't go in? Because her parent's *didn't* die in there? What about the pneumonia and finding her in the hospital?!?!?! I... apparently need the last book to explain, because none of it made *ANY* sense.
Additionally, Josie couldn't have her baby back after abandoning it at her brother's, because... I... don't get it. Her brother and his wife are raising it in the SAME HOUSE that she's living in, now, and she's miserable about it, but she has no husband or home of her own, so she can't be a mother, apparently. Wait, what!?!?! That makes NO sense to me.
Then Worth tells us how during the last conversation Tobias had with Josie before she ran from Kentucky, he was talking about building his own house on his own land with her... except that's not how the Amish work - he would've stayed and worked his father's land, with his parents in the dawdi haus, as his brother already had a farm in Illinois. Additionally, his dad was in poor health and died (which held him up in going to find Josie)... so his death meant he would've had that house, anyhow... so WHY would he have built his own house?!
I don't know. It was such a hot, indiscernible mess, I was out less than a quarter of the way through. It's just not worth struggling to figure out what happened before, especially when the writing makes everything seem contradictory.