💥 Read for SPFBO, this is only my opinion, the team verdict might wary widely! 💥
This book has a lot of promise, so I shall look up the author again! So even though this review sounds rather negative, let me prevace it with I DID enjoy the book anyway! In my eyes it just could have been amazing instead of "fine", which is why I have to niggle so much.
Sadly it didn't always deliver on those promises, so while it was a quick and enjoyable read, I will have to stick with three stars for it. There's a lot of things I live, but they all just struck a little bit short of how amazing they could have been.
I loved having a family at the heart if the story, two sisters looking for their lost, presumed dead, explorer brother. I am a big fan of families and really any close relationships that rent romance. So that was a big plus! The downside was that it felt a bit on the surface. So we get told they love each other because they are siblings, but the little squabbles as well as their family love felt a bit shallow. Having sisters who run a tea shop and like scones as much as their pistols was definitely a plus for me! So you see, it does have its ups!
I also really enjoyed the world, which combines alchemy, science and magic, with things like tea shops, guns, lifts, and more. But again I also would have liked teh whole world building to be just a bit deeper. It felt more like a movie setting, than a fully fleshed out world where you can almost feel all the things you can yet discover if you only just round that next corner.
The big bad also seems rather lackluster, and doesn't seem to be at all as powerful as we are made to believe in the beginning, and some of the twists just felt cobbled together, raising my eyebrow in a "really?" manner instead of an eye opening "So that's what it was all about!" moment.
There's a lot of action and running away, so it was a fast paced and quick read! And again there is a but - it didn't really feel like one coherent story, but rather a series of reactions to what happened. We are frequently told how the sister know hot to protect themselves, and always carry a weapon - and yet when there's actual danger they are always disarmed right away. They are a strange mix of "run into danger headlong" and timid, and it just didn't feel like a smooth characterization, or growth from one to the other.
Those "reactions" instead of actions were another main problem for me - the sisters seem to be pushed around by everyone around them, instead of deciding to do things for their own. I wished they just had a bit more volition of their own, instead of being told what to do so often.
They also seem to either trust everyone they meet right away, or know people are the true enemy right on. Yes it's a short book, and a fast paced one, so no time to set up the characters very long, but a bit more just would have felt better.
Despite all this complaining, it was a fun, fast paced and entertaining story I read within just two days, and as I said there's a lot of promise here!