Together with longtime collaborator Mark Olshaker, John “The Original Mindhunter” Douglas is at it again, interviewing the iciest of killers to find out what makes their cold hearts tick. Since he is retired from his old home at the FBI’s Behavioral Science Unit, John—now an independent contractor—takes his four psycho-killer interviews wherever he can find them: one commissioned by the New Jersey State Parole Board, two for a prospective MSNBC pilot, and one for a six-part ID Network documentary series entitled Serial Killer: the Devil Unchained It is obvious, though, that John Douglas isn’t in it just for the money. He never accepts interviews with run-of-the-mill murderers; no, he only seeks dialog with the most intriguing cases, subjects who can help him answer a compelling question or two about how exactly predators think.
Take Joseph McGowan, for example. What compelled the 27-year-old high school chemistry teacher to murder the 7-year-old Brownie from across the street who had come to his door to deliver two boxes of Girl Scout cookies? McGowan was an intelligent man, but the murder was extraordinarily reckless: the girl was known to him, lived across the street from him, and his house was most likely known to be her destination. Why did he choose her—and that particular moment—for his first and only murder?
Then there is Joseph Kondro, who evokes in Douglas’ mind a similar question. Kondro, locked up for the sexual assault and murder of two young girls—one eight years old, one twelve, a decade apart—knew both of his victims well and was a close friend with their two families. Why not pick strangers as victims instead? Why take such an obvious risk, even once? And why take it twice?
The third killer, hospital orderly Donald Harvey, known as the Angel of Death, took care to make all his murders seems to be from natural causes, and thefore managed to commit three dozen to five dozen murders before he was eventually caught. And Douglas’ fourth interview, the apparently reasonable real estate agent Todd Kohlhepp, unknown perpetrator of the notorious “Superbike Murders,” and then, years later, two cases of couple abduction and murder. Each has particular aspects to his case that interests Douglas and motivates his interview.
There are more than a few gory details here, a score of illuminating references to some of Douglas’ better known cases, and a few inspiring passages as well (Rosemarie D’Alessandro, mother of the murdered Girl Scout, is a courageous and memorable woman). But the real interest here is in Douglas’ cat-and-mouse game with his four subjects. Each of these four devious men still has his secrets, and Douglas—ever patient, ever the good listener--is just the right man to smell them out.