Plot spoilers ahead. Read at your own risk.
I tend to avoid novella because I feel that they tend to be too short for my liking, but a novella was exactly what I was looking forward at the time. The fact this was Halloween cozy mystery that I was reading on Halloween made this right up my alley.
The length of this story didn’t bother me. Yes, it was really fast paced and not a lot of suspense or development character wise or plot wise, but I felt it was just enough to keep my interest. It advanced the plot in a quick yet smart way. It gave the crime right away. It presented some clues along the way, leading to suspects along the way. There was an agent, Jackson that was helping Adeline solve the crime of the death of her neighbor. The crime was solved with plausible logic. It hit all the cozy mystery requirements just in a shorter format. I really appreciated that.
Another thing that I really appreciated about this story was the element of the paranormal. Adeline was a witch. She had vampire friends. She had a familiar in form in Pudding the cat, who was freaking hilarious and made me snort laugh a couple times. There was the whole underground world of the paranormal that had to kept from the human world because if these supernatural creatures were discovered they were thrown into an isolated prison away from the human kind even if they weren’t a threat. So, there was secret keeping going on between Adeline and Jackson as she tried to keep her identity of a witch a secret from him while trying to use her gifts to help solve the crime, which was very interesting. There were also a couple of twists that revolved around the paranormal that I didn’t see coming, and it was a very nice surprise. I enjoyed that very much.
As for the slight romance between Jackson and Adeline. I didn’t hate it, but I didn’t need it either. If it was just the two of them just working together to solve this murder, I think it would have worked fine. I liked that they had a connection and attraction to each other, but necessarily need it to go beyond that. When this kiss came at the end, it just felt little abrupt and out of place. I think I would have preferred if he just asked her out on a date, instead going for that kiss. I just needed more substance between the two before they went there. It just threw me off a little bit.
What I was most disappointed by was the fact that I didn’t get the Halloweeny feels like I was wanting and expecting especially since this was labeled as a Halloween novella. I get that this was done as a shorter format and really needed to get to the point without dwelling on things too, too long, but I just wanted more Halloween feeling. Halloween was more of an afterthought than anything else. Yes, paranormal/witchy vibes, but that doesn’t always spell Halloween for me. I needed like ghosts, haunted house, costume parties, or pumpkins, but like that was in here that bummed me out because that was what I wanted.
Overall, I did really like the story. Yes, it was a quick novella that had a really fast pace without a lot of development or buildup, but in the case of this book it really worked. Aside from not having those Halloween feels that I wanted, it really wasn’t missing anything. It had a beginning, a middle, and an end, which was all could ask for in a novella. It those great cozy mystery vibes in a condensed format. There was interesting crime with interesting clues with a bit of the paranormal thrown in just to give it a little extra flavor. I was surprised that there were a couple twists that I didn’t see coming. I wasn’t expecting that especially from a novella. As for the romance, I was neutral about it because I didn’t fell like it was needed. I think it could have worked fine if just Jackson and Adeline worked together and nothing more, but it was okay even if was abrupt by the kiss at the end. This impressed me and did more than I thought it would do in this short format. So, it was a good quick, easy cozy mystery read that I enjoyed, which was the most important thing.