Stuff I Read - Lovecraft Review
I got this because, at least in part, I really do like Lovecraft's stories and his ideas about horror. And I like comics, so this seemed like something that would be right up my alley. I should have known something was a little off, though, when the foreword, written by horror filmmaker John Carpenter, was about evil. Sure, he tries to make a point about the word Lovecraftian, but I couldn't really take that seriously when he then went on to talk about evil. Because, in my mind, there are few things as far away from Lovecraft's writing than depictions of good and evil.
It's a trap the graphic novel explores in a rather interesting way, though, building a fictional biography for Lovecraft around his obsession with the weird. And while I can appreciate that the graphic novel is basically a way to try and make Lovecraft's life mirror his prose, there are some serious problems with the final product. Not that the book isn't good, because it is. The art is fitting for the rather surreal story, and the monsters are rendered well and the story flows from beginning to end. Really if this was about anyone else I probably would have less to say about it. It's a fine story.
My main issue comes from the way the story flows, the way it posits the Old Ones as a force of evil trying to force their way into our world. Which is really not how Lovecraft presented them, not where the horror is supposed to arise from to, in my opinion, be Lovecraftian. In Lovecraft's work the Old Ones weren't evil. Not in the sense that they had grand plans on invading Earth. They were so far above and beyond humans that their mere presence was enough to drive people insane. It was with facing humanity's insignificance that the true horror came from, not from the fact that monsters were after us but that they existed, they existed and were so foreign that we couldn't even begin to understand them or really perceive them.
And my main disappointment was that all the monsters in this graphic novel were mundane in comparison, just evil monsters that can be fought against and defeated. And that doesn't seem quite right to me, doesn't seem Lovecraftian. The characters in Lovecraft's stories cannot often, if ever, fight back against the darkness. Sometimes they are overlooked, or escape, but to say that Lovecraft's work is the binding on the door that keeps the Old Ones locked away seems to fly wholly in the face of what Lovecraft did with his prose.
So while this is a fine book, I had my fair share of problems with it. Again, if it wasn't about Lovecraft this works great. It's dark and disturbing in places, and the art is appropriate and visceral. The plot is fine, if a little strange, but it's not a strageness that was difficult to follow. I just expected more from something called Lovecraft, more than just a story about good versus evil. And without that, I can only give the book a 6/10.