This companion to the "Wolf Hall" trilogy, a publishing juggernaut, is a gem. Dr Mackay, whose previous published works include biographies of Eustace Chapuys and Thomas Boleyn, weaves in and out of Mantel's Tudor-inspired novels. Rather than a dry discussion, it is well written, lively, and thoughtful. I also loved the accompanying illustrations, vaguely in the style of modernised early modern woodcuts.
Mackay manages well the tricky task of balancing her critiques on the novels' much-vaunted accuracy with her respect for their beautiful prose. So convincing was Mantel's gorgeous writing that historians are now routinely confronted with the question, indeed the assumption, the novel's storyline that Thomas Cromwell sentimentally chose the men to frame as Anne Boleyn's lovers because they had participated in a mean-spirited masque mocking his mentor Cardinal Wolsey a few years earlier. (That, as is a novel's right, is a complete fiction; Henry Norris, identified as one of the Wolsey-mockers in the novel was, in reality, one of the few courtiers to go out of his way to show the Cardinal some kindness after he fell.) Going through a companion piece which constantly harps on with, "Well, actually, what happened was..." would be a depressing enough task for any reader and Mackay avoids it. Given that she completed her PhD on the Boleyn men, she is refreshingly magnanimous about the trilogy's depressingly one-note characterisation of the Boleyns, particularly Thomas's son, George, who emerges from the "Wolf Hall" novels as a demented, unlikeable, talentless idiot, somewhere between the monstrous and the moronic. (Anne, it has to be said, fares little better, but perhaps that's to be expected in a novel rehabilitating Cromwell, whose most nebulous action surely was how he behaved will destroying Anne in 1536.) Dr Mackay also highlights Mantel's achingly tangible portrayals of the places, everyday life, and etiquette in Thomas Cromwell's London - for me personally, Mantel's descriptions of palaces, suppers, and fireside chats have an immediacy, a realness, which takes the breath away. Dr Mackay has written a thoughtful, well-researched, respectful, moving, and intelligent companion to Hilary Mantel's beloved trilogy of novels; in the process, reminding us why "Wolf Hall" and its two sequels have become beloved by millions of readers across the world.