Restoring poetry to the Christian experience in the 21st century is a tall order. I think it must be done, for poetry is largely dormant force in so much of contemporary Christianity. But how is this to be done? No one person can do it, but a community of poets might.
So we hope and pray that God raises up poets to give the mighty power of language a kingdom role again, in evangelism, worship and discipleship.
I'm thankful for this volume and for Jeremy Johnston's contribution to a poetry of the Christian life. In terms of evaluation I'll speak simply as a reader and not as any kind of authority on poetry:
I thought that, first of all, there were a lot of poems in this volume. While I didn't connect with all of them, I consistently came across poems that were eye-opening and delightful, convicting and edifying. And sometimes I came across single lines that were simply sublime for one reason or another. I know I am going to enjoy returning to the starred, highlighted, and underlined pages.
I also liked the thematic assembly, the introductions to the book and the sections, and the appendix.
All in all, a great effort at devotional Christian poetry for the 21st century, of which we certainly need more, not less.