An uneven, yet intriguing and informative history.
“Uneven” because of its scattershot approach. Is this book about individual British Empire airmen and their families? Is it about the British bombing commanders and their strategy disputes and personal vendettas, is it about the advantages of the equipment, the technology and techniques that were developed by both the British and the Germans in their sky battles, or is it about the German civilian victims on the ground? All these topics are thrown into this volume higgledy-piggledy. But despite the patchwork, the book does manage to hold together, albeit like a flak-battered Lancaster bomber struggling back to base on two engines.
“Intriguing” is shorthand for the feelings of interest, excitement, frustration, anger, and sadness I experienced successively as I progressed through the book. I did not previously know what a nasty piece of work “Bomber” Harris was, and how, in his obsessive desire to ‘show the Germans’, he got hundreds of British bomber crews and thousands of German civilians needlessly killed. It was unfortunate that the intelligence at the time could not know that bombing cities did not have the effect of breaking morale, and all those explosives would have been better used on war logistics centers or production. The disputes and dysfunction among the British top brass and their mistakes about strategy were frustrating. And the personal stories of crew men told in intimate detail in the weeks and days leading up to a final flight operation over Germany usually ended with gut-wrenching abruptness.
“Informative” is for the information on targeting technology that I did not previously know. And it was also interesting to know that, ironically, the British bombing campaign against Germany ended up making essentially the same mistake that it is said the Luftwaffe made during the Battle of Britain. In 1940, the Germans turned from bombing RAF airfields and radar emplacements to bombing British cities just when the RAF was nearly at collapse. In 1943, the British bombing campaign had concentrated on the industrial Ruhr Valley and had reduced steel production by 20% and if they had continued, could have seriously damaged the German war production effort. But the Brits stopped and turned instead to bombing German cities, which had little effect on German morale, and no effect on their war effort.
Overall, a good book.