The Bad Luck Lighthouse is a magical murder mystery novel by Nicki Thornton. It is the second book in the Seth Seppi Mysteries series. It takes place after the first, with Seth having found out in the first book that magic exists and that he himself may have some magical abilities. Another character is about to undertake an investigation, and Seth finds himself following him. He arrives at a lighthouse and there is a murder soon after he arrives.
I had borrowed a boxset of the three books from BorrowBox. Though I didn’t particularly like the first, I found myself reading this one because I wanted to find out what happens, due to the author leaving things on quite a cliffhanger at the end of the first book. One of my first thoughts is that, while the first book ended on a bit of a cliffhanger, the beginning of this book doesn’t follow that portion well. It gives a very quick rehash of what happened in the first book, without explaining a lot of important things about characters or the lore of the world. I am glad I’m reading this book so soon after the first because, if I hadn’t, I might have forgotten a lot of important things in between.
Just like the first, I feel like the author does not create or use characters very well. As an example, there’s a talking cat called Nightshade, who is not a well-used character. She just turns up to make some offhand remarks every now and then, but doesn’t have any kind of important role to the book or stuff happening. I reckon she ought to have been left out of the book. And the same for other characters. A lot of the characters just aren’t used very well. Especially the ones that follow on from the first book. I know the author is trying to create some sort of mystery to the investigation, but there’s very little common sense with what they’re doing. It’s as if their actions are to just further the storyline, regardless of how bad the decisions are, rather than being logical choices. For example, the main antagonist. With the antagonist’s behaviour, it just makes zero sense at all. The author has a character mention that (paraphrasing) “it’s the type of thing” the character would do. But there’s no logical reason for this behaviour, no decent explanation. It makes no sense. It’s a character being evil for the sake of being evil. I don’t like the way this character was written at all.
Mmmm… The mystery was somewhat bland. With the first book, one of my complaints is that there wasn’t much of a build up to the murder victim or learning about them before their death. This book is the same in that respect. While the author does include a lot of people gossiping about the murder victim, there’s not much of an actual introduction to this character and to give the audience an actual show of what they’re like, in terms of personality. It leaves the mystery feeling really lacklustre, in my opinion. And the same with the actual suspects. The majority of personality explanation about them is merely from assumptions and gossip, rather than the author giving us a display of their personality. There’s a bunch of pretty standard murder mystery tropes. And I feel like they’re often not used very well. In terms of the series, I don’t think it built up much from the first. By the end of the second, Seth still has relatively no information about his family, who they were and stuff like that. I know I said this about the first, but I feel as if the entirety of the family stuff could have been left out and the book would be better for it.
Again, this is another book in the series where I feel like the death mystery ought to have been separate to the magic and family aspects of the story. Like I said with book one, I think the author ought to have spent more time developing the family and magic aspects to Seth’s story, rather than to distract from those aspects by having this death and the stuff with running the lighthouse.
Overall, it was better than the first book. Yet it is so lacklustre in so many ways. I feel like it follows standard genre tropes way too closely. Such as with the standard “whodunit” murder mystery tropes. There’s not much originality to the murder mystery, even considering the magic aspects of the book And, again, the author leaves the book on a cliffhanger and it feels so unfinished.