What do you think?
Rate this book
The Imitator
A page-turning World War Two spy thriller, based on true events.
'We trade in secrets here, Evelyn. There's no shame in having a few of your own. Our only concern is for who might discover them.'
Out of place at boarding school, scholarship girl Evelyn Varley realises that the only way for her to fit in is to be like everyone else. She hides her true self and what she really thinks behind the manners and attitudes of those around her. By the time she graduates from Oxford University in 1939, ambitious and brilliant Evelyn has perfected her performance.
War is looming. Evelyn soon finds herself recruited to MI5, and the elite counterintelligence department of Bennett White, the enigmatic spy-runner. Recognising Evelyn's mercurial potential, White schools her in observation and subterfuge and assigns her the dangerous task of infiltrating an underground group of Nazi sympathisers working to form an alliance with Germany.
But befriending people to betray them isn't easy, no matter how dark their intent. Evelyn is drawn deeper into a duplicity of her own making, where truth and lies intertwine, and her increasing distrust of everyone, including herself, begins to test her better judgement. When a close friend becomes dangerously ensnared in her mission, Evelyn's loyalty is pushed to breaking point, forcing her to make an impossible decision.
A powerfully insightful and luminous portrait of courage and loyalty, and the sacrifices made in their name.
'We trade in secrets here, Evelyn. There's no shame in having a few of your own. Our only concern is for who might discover them.'
Out of place at boarding school, scholarship girl Evelyn Varley realises that the only way for her to fit in is to be like everyone else. She hides her true self and what she really thinks behind the manners and attitudes of those around her. By the time she graduates from Oxford University in 1939, ambitious and brilliant Evelyn has perfected her performance.
War is looming. Evelyn soon finds herself recruited to MI5, and the elite counterintelligence department of Bennett White, the enigmatic spy-runner. Recognising Evelyn's mercurial potential, White schools her in observation and subterfuge and assigns her the dangerous task of infiltrating an underground group of Nazi sympathisers working to form an alliance with Germany.
But befriending people to betray them isn't easy, no matter how dark their intent. Evelyn is drawn deeper into a duplicity of her own making, where truth and lies intertwine, and her increasing distrust of everyone, including herself, begins to test her better judgement. When a close friend becomes dangerously ensnared in her mission, Evelyn's loyalty is pushed to breaking point, forcing her to make an impossible decision.
A powerfully insightful and luminous portrait of courage and loyalty, and the sacrifices made in their name.
344 pages, Paperback
First published February 2, 2021
187 people are currently reading
7917 people want to read
About the author
Rebecca Starford
29 books120 followersRebecca Starford is the author of Bad Behaviour, a memoir about boarding school and bullying. The book was optioned for television by Matchbox Pictures and aired in Australia on STAN, as well as streamed through more than 20 other countries across the world. Rebecca's first novel, The Imitator, was published in Australia, and in the United States, Canada, the UK and South Africa under the title An Unlikely Spy.
She is also the co-founder and publishing director of Kill Your Darlings, and has previously worked for Text Publishing and Australian Book Review. Originally from Melbourne, Rebecca currently lives in France.
She is also the co-founder and publishing director of Kill Your Darlings, and has previously worked for Text Publishing and Australian Book Review. Originally from Melbourne, Rebecca currently lives in France.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 397 reviews
July 4, 2021
"An Unlikely Spy" by Rebecca Starford is a WWII Historical Fiction story loosely tied to real events.
Bright, studious Evelyn Varley wins a scholarship to an elite boarding school attended by children of England's wealthiest families. Evelyn struggles to fit in but, as luck would have it, she becomes best-friends with Sally Wesley. Sally's parents develop a trust in Evelyn and treat her like family.
After Evelyn graduates from Oxford University in 1939, Sally's father, Hugh is instrumental in Evelyn securing a position at the War Office in London. Based on her proven work and skill in speaking fluent German, she is recruited and trained by MI5 to become a counterintelligence agent. Her assignment is to infiltrate a subversive group in Britain who are aligned with Hitler's Germany.
Will Evelyn succeed in convincing the Nazi sympathizers she is one of them? Will she be able to handle the emotional toll this may take on her? What lasting impact will this have on her relationships with those she holds so dear?
Evelyn has never exposed her true self to anyone. Her family's working class background is especially kept hidden. She adapts herself to fit best into any situation beginning with her boarding school days and long after her assignments as a counterintelligence agent. Is it any wonder why she is recruited by MI5? They recognize her ability to so easily and convincingly become someone she isn't. She's a perfect fit for their needs.
There are two timelines within this story: Evelyn's story from July 1939 through August 1940 and, sandwiched in between, her life in March 1948. After I finished the book, I went back and re-read the March 1948 timeline chapters and was surprised how they related back to the remainder of the book in such a different way than when I first read them.
I was impressed by this author's writing skills. It held my interest from the very first chapter through to the end and I was excited to get back to it daily. It's definitely not a fast pace espionage thriller but rather a slow-burn character study and I love that! Was this really a debut novel?
I love Historical Fiction and find the best reward of reading this genre is when I come across a story where I learn something new. In this book main character Evelyn Varley is partly based on MI5 Counterintelligence Agent, Joan Miller. Her assignments, although fictionalized here, are a fascinating piece of British WWII history.
Lastly, there are a couple of twists in this story at the end that I didn't see coming. It was a 'Wow" moment for me. Another reason I was impressed by this author's writing ability.
Although I realize this story may not be for everyone, I do recommend it to those who enjoy character studies and stories with under-lying meaning. I love how when I think about this story, I keep discovering little bits and pieces of newness.
Thank you to Goodreads Giveaways, Ecco and Rebecca Starford for a physical ARC of this book. It is my pleasure to give an honest and voluntary review.
Bright, studious Evelyn Varley wins a scholarship to an elite boarding school attended by children of England's wealthiest families. Evelyn struggles to fit in but, as luck would have it, she becomes best-friends with Sally Wesley. Sally's parents develop a trust in Evelyn and treat her like family.
After Evelyn graduates from Oxford University in 1939, Sally's father, Hugh is instrumental in Evelyn securing a position at the War Office in London. Based on her proven work and skill in speaking fluent German, she is recruited and trained by MI5 to become a counterintelligence agent. Her assignment is to infiltrate a subversive group in Britain who are aligned with Hitler's Germany.
Will Evelyn succeed in convincing the Nazi sympathizers she is one of them? Will she be able to handle the emotional toll this may take on her? What lasting impact will this have on her relationships with those she holds so dear?
Evelyn has never exposed her true self to anyone. Her family's working class background is especially kept hidden. She adapts herself to fit best into any situation beginning with her boarding school days and long after her assignments as a counterintelligence agent. Is it any wonder why she is recruited by MI5? They recognize her ability to so easily and convincingly become someone she isn't. She's a perfect fit for their needs.
There are two timelines within this story: Evelyn's story from July 1939 through August 1940 and, sandwiched in between, her life in March 1948. After I finished the book, I went back and re-read the March 1948 timeline chapters and was surprised how they related back to the remainder of the book in such a different way than when I first read them.
I was impressed by this author's writing skills. It held my interest from the very first chapter through to the end and I was excited to get back to it daily. It's definitely not a fast pace espionage thriller but rather a slow-burn character study and I love that! Was this really a debut novel?
I love Historical Fiction and find the best reward of reading this genre is when I come across a story where I learn something new. In this book main character Evelyn Varley is partly based on MI5 Counterintelligence Agent, Joan Miller. Her assignments, although fictionalized here, are a fascinating piece of British WWII history.
Lastly, there are a couple of twists in this story at the end that I didn't see coming. It was a 'Wow" moment for me. Another reason I was impressed by this author's writing ability.
Although I realize this story may not be for everyone, I do recommend it to those who enjoy character studies and stories with under-lying meaning. I love how when I think about this story, I keep discovering little bits and pieces of newness.
Thank you to Goodreads Giveaways, Ecco and Rebecca Starford for a physical ARC of this book. It is my pleasure to give an honest and voluntary review.
January 30, 2021
I have recently discovered that I enjoy historical fiction and The Imitator sounded like a book that could get lost in. While the story was interesting and different I didn’t love it, but you cannot love all the books all the time.
The main character, Evelyn, was a smart and capable woman. She manages to win a scholarship to an elite boarding school where she makes the right connections. Tired of working jn a store on the brink of WWII, she uses who she knows and ends up working for the war office and MI5 as a spy on England’s enemies.
I struggled with the jumping back and forth of timelines and long chapters. I could not warm to Evelyn at all and her way she dealt with things.
Thanks to Allen and Unwin for sending this book to me.
The main character, Evelyn, was a smart and capable woman. She manages to win a scholarship to an elite boarding school where she makes the right connections. Tired of working jn a store on the brink of WWII, she uses who she knows and ends up working for the war office and MI5 as a spy on England’s enemies.
I struggled with the jumping back and forth of timelines and long chapters. I could not warm to Evelyn at all and her way she dealt with things.
Thanks to Allen and Unwin for sending this book to me.
September 15, 2021
Since "unlikely" is the key word here, I will review accordingly.
While this is not a bad read in any way, it is unlikely that I will remember it in six months, or possibly even in six days - although I will remember the cover, as it reminds of me of a 1970's Nancy Drew mystery book (and I don't mean that as a positive).
It is clear from the beginning that Evelyn Varley is unlikely to overcome her modest beginnings, but despite the odds, she does by winning a scholarship to a private school and eventually to Oxford, where she masters the German language. Although she is a wallflower with few friends, she somehow manages to befriend the daughter of one of England's wealthiest families, which serves her well, as her connections help to secure her a job working in the War Office. She is eventually handpicked to be a part of the counterintelligence unit, and all of a sudden, every single potential Nazi sympathizer decides to confide their deepest, darkest secrets to her. The only word that comes to mind here is - unlikely. 🙄 She eventually must make a choice between betraying those closest to her or failing in her mission, and her choice has ramifications, even ten years in the future.
An interesting premise if you're into WWII coming-of-age, espionage stories; but if you are even a wee bit tired of this genre, it is unlikely you will find this one to your liking. It was unnecessarily long for one thing, with dual timelines that jumped between the 1930s and the 1940s. I thought the timeline changes were hard to follow at times and confusing, as much of the backstory didn't seem to serve much of a purpose, other than to prolong the reading experience. Just when things got a bit more interesting, the book abruptly ends. There is an unlikely a good answer, but why needlessly drag things out for two hundred plus pages and then rush the ending? Evelyn was also not a great character at all, and by the end, I was indifferent to what she had done that haunted her so, and to would what happen to her in the future.
Overall, it's a snail-paced, female-centered spy story that is unlikely to ever garner more than 3 stars from me.
While this is not a bad read in any way, it is unlikely that I will remember it in six months, or possibly even in six days - although I will remember the cover, as it reminds of me of a 1970's Nancy Drew mystery book (and I don't mean that as a positive).
It is clear from the beginning that Evelyn Varley is unlikely to overcome her modest beginnings, but despite the odds, she does by winning a scholarship to a private school and eventually to Oxford, where she masters the German language. Although she is a wallflower with few friends, she somehow manages to befriend the daughter of one of England's wealthiest families, which serves her well, as her connections help to secure her a job working in the War Office. She is eventually handpicked to be a part of the counterintelligence unit, and all of a sudden, every single potential Nazi sympathizer decides to confide their deepest, darkest secrets to her. The only word that comes to mind here is - unlikely. 🙄 She eventually must make a choice between betraying those closest to her or failing in her mission, and her choice has ramifications, even ten years in the future.
An interesting premise if you're into WWII coming-of-age, espionage stories; but if you are even a wee bit tired of this genre, it is unlikely you will find this one to your liking. It was unnecessarily long for one thing, with dual timelines that jumped between the 1930s and the 1940s. I thought the timeline changes were hard to follow at times and confusing, as much of the backstory didn't seem to serve much of a purpose, other than to prolong the reading experience. Just when things got a bit more interesting, the book abruptly ends. There is an unlikely a good answer, but why needlessly drag things out for two hundred plus pages and then rush the ending? Evelyn was also not a great character at all, and by the end, I was indifferent to what she had done that haunted her so, and to would what happen to her in the future.
Overall, it's a snail-paced, female-centered spy story that is unlikely to ever garner more than 3 stars from me.
March 5, 2021
⭐️3.5 Stars⭐️
The Imitator is an intriguing story of an ordinary young woman who becomes a spy.
The book examines the period leading up to WWII in England known as the Phoney War which I must admit I was unaware of.
Winning a scholarship at an elite boarding school and feeling out of place due to her social class, Evelyn as a young student learns to blend in as she hides behind facades so she doesn’t stand out. It’s there she meets and becomes best friends with Sally who has an affluent family.
From there she heads to Oxford University, Evelyn is an intelligent woman who can speak fluent German which makes her an ideal candidate when she takes on a role with ‘The War Office’ which is actually MI5 intelligence during the Second World War. She progresses on to becoming a spy and learns to cultivate friendships and betray people while dangerously infiltrating groups sympathetic to the Nazi’s at the beginning of the war.
When a close friend is mixed up in one of her missions Evelyn must make a decision between her country and her friend.
There is plenty of suspense in the story yet I couldn’t warm to the portrayal of Eveyn’s character which is a shame, I’m not sure why but she felt standoffish and cold, possibly the perfect candidate to be a spy although I really loved the characters of Julia and Sally.
I thought the concept of the story was unique, it was not something I had read about the war before.
Thank you to publishers Allen & Unwin for the opportunity to win a copy of the book.
The Imitator is an intriguing story of an ordinary young woman who becomes a spy.
The book examines the period leading up to WWII in England known as the Phoney War which I must admit I was unaware of.
Winning a scholarship at an elite boarding school and feeling out of place due to her social class, Evelyn as a young student learns to blend in as she hides behind facades so she doesn’t stand out. It’s there she meets and becomes best friends with Sally who has an affluent family.
From there she heads to Oxford University, Evelyn is an intelligent woman who can speak fluent German which makes her an ideal candidate when she takes on a role with ‘The War Office’ which is actually MI5 intelligence during the Second World War. She progresses on to becoming a spy and learns to cultivate friendships and betray people while dangerously infiltrating groups sympathetic to the Nazi’s at the beginning of the war.
When a close friend is mixed up in one of her missions Evelyn must make a decision between her country and her friend.
There is plenty of suspense in the story yet I couldn’t warm to the portrayal of Eveyn’s character which is a shame, I’m not sure why but she felt standoffish and cold, possibly the perfect candidate to be a spy although I really loved the characters of Julia and Sally.
I thought the concept of the story was unique, it was not something I had read about the war before.
Thank you to publishers Allen & Unwin for the opportunity to win a copy of the book.
May 26, 2021
Who is the real Evelyn Varley? We first meet her in 1948 when an unexpected reunion with an old friend catapults her back to the early years of WW II and her work for the 'War Office.' The narrative flows along two timelines. One shows us how Evelyn grew up learning to adapt her environment and gain success. Her connections to a lucrative button factor owner give her a chance to help with the war effort. She eagerly jumps in with both feet and then begins to realize the personal toll of deception and espionage. This book is an intimate character study of before and after. The second timeline shows what life is like for Evelyn after the war and we realize she has a choice to make that will have a huge impact on her future. This book is a reminder of the value of our personal connections and the courage it takes to carry on.
Thank you to Ecco and NetGalley for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to Ecco and NetGalley for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
March 11, 2024
I love a good spy book and An Unlikely Spy was a great one. This book was different because it has the usual intrigue, secrets, danger, and uncertainty found in most spy novels. What makes this book stand out is that it focuses on how a person must think and function in order to be a spy. It is a study into the psychological mind set that the main character must process and continue on as to be effective. If one slips up, it is literally a life and death situation for herself, but others, too. Incredible to really absorb this all. Rebecca Stanford does an excellent job in her writing to bring this out.
The book begins with Evelyn Varley, who lives in a working class neighborhood of Lewes. She has always been an intelligent girl and gets a scholarship to an elite boarding school. Evelyn realizes early on that she will need to change herself in order to fit in with these types of girls. They come from money and power. So, Evelyn does. She becomes very good friends with Sally Wesley and is often at her family’s estate. Her father Hugh especially likes Evelyn. Evelyn and Sally go on to study at Oxford. Mr. Wesley helps Evelyn secure a job at the War Office. This is during World War II. Evelyn is excited to do something different and stay in London.
This is when life changes dramatically for Evelyn. She is recruited to work for MI5, a counter intelligence agency where Evelyn will work to infiltrate fascists and Nazi sympathizers. Evelyn is a natural fit, as she has been playing a role of herself for a long time. She knows how to be the person others expect her to be. She doesn’t see her family or talk of her lower level in society. She can easily adapt her personality with a subtle shift; being a hater of Jews, and Passionate about needing a change that the other side of the war is fighting for. Evelyn likes being on her own and wants to continue working. She does not seem to realize the heavy cost this takes from her. She is never honestly her true self anymore. She doesn’t have deep romantic relationships. It’s just too hard and she has many secrets. She holds secrets even to herself.
So, there are twists and turns that happen. I did not see much of them coming. How much will Evelyn sacrifice and can she maintain friendships with both Fascist Sympathizers and her regular friends. Will that even be possible? At some point, she is asked to make difficult choices about her life. Can she change back to herself, when she has been acting for so long? This is a psychological glimpse into her mind and it is hard to fathom how she decides.
So, this was an excellent book and I highly recommend it, especially for women who read a lot of WWII books.
Thank you NetGalley, Rebecca Stafford, and Ecco Publishing for an ARC of this book. I really enjoyed reading it and appreciate receiving a copy.
The book begins with Evelyn Varley, who lives in a working class neighborhood of Lewes. She has always been an intelligent girl and gets a scholarship to an elite boarding school. Evelyn realizes early on that she will need to change herself in order to fit in with these types of girls. They come from money and power. So, Evelyn does. She becomes very good friends with Sally Wesley and is often at her family’s estate. Her father Hugh especially likes Evelyn. Evelyn and Sally go on to study at Oxford. Mr. Wesley helps Evelyn secure a job at the War Office. This is during World War II. Evelyn is excited to do something different and stay in London.
This is when life changes dramatically for Evelyn. She is recruited to work for MI5, a counter intelligence agency where Evelyn will work to infiltrate fascists and Nazi sympathizers. Evelyn is a natural fit, as she has been playing a role of herself for a long time. She knows how to be the person others expect her to be. She doesn’t see her family or talk of her lower level in society. She can easily adapt her personality with a subtle shift; being a hater of Jews, and Passionate about needing a change that the other side of the war is fighting for. Evelyn likes being on her own and wants to continue working. She does not seem to realize the heavy cost this takes from her. She is never honestly her true self anymore. She doesn’t have deep romantic relationships. It’s just too hard and she has many secrets. She holds secrets even to herself.
So, there are twists and turns that happen. I did not see much of them coming. How much will Evelyn sacrifice and can she maintain friendships with both Fascist Sympathizers and her regular friends. Will that even be possible? At some point, she is asked to make difficult choices about her life. Can she change back to herself, when she has been acting for so long? This is a psychological glimpse into her mind and it is hard to fathom how she decides.
So, this was an excellent book and I highly recommend it, especially for women who read a lot of WWII books.
Thank you NetGalley, Rebecca Stafford, and Ecco Publishing for an ARC of this book. I really enjoyed reading it and appreciate receiving a copy.
February 16, 2021
‘It was during those cold mornings that Evelyn learnt that truth was found at the edges of people…’
I enjoyed this novel far more than I expected, and that’s not at all because my expectations were low, rather, the novel itself was just so much deeper and more insightful on a level I wasn’t anticipating. The era it deals with is at the beginning of WWII, during a phase sometimes referred to as ‘the phony war’. Evelyn is recruited into MI5 to infiltrate an underground movement of Nazi sympathisers. While this novel is on the one hand a suspenseful thriller filled with spies and double crossing, it’s also a deeply affecting character study of a woman caught between lives. I really loved it, the literary aspect gripping me even more than the suspense.
‘Evelyn thought about her own mother standing at the kitchen sink, the slope of her shoulders, that fragile bun. She could see the course of their estrangement like footprints trailing down the hallway and out the front door, but for once it didn’t feel as though she had done something wrong.’
Evelyn is a woman who is no stranger to making herself into someone new for whatever the situation requires. She does this from a young age in boarding school and continues on from there. She is, in essence, the perfect person to become a spy. Evelyn herself is thrilled with the opportunity, feels she is not only doing something exciting as a job but also making a worthwhile contribution to the war effort. But of course, nothing is ever as it seems on the surface, and there is a cost to this type of job, an impact upon her life that she could not possibly have foreseen. The experience of being a spy was different for women, there was a particular pressure to use your ‘feminine charm’ to ingratiate yourself. There was also a particular tendency for women to get thrown under the bus when everything went pear shaped. I appreciated the subtle ways in which this was conveyed throughout the narrative. There was a great deal implied with a minimum degree of obviousness.
‘Truth didn’t matter. These people had come because they knew they would have their insane beliefs confirmed.’
For those who know Evelyn, she is something of an enigma. Considered cold and standoffish, but with an obvious intelligence that makes her appealing. She is also attractive, not beautiful enough to be threatening, but pretty enough to draw interest. I really felt for Evelyn though, out of necessity she kept people at arms-length, but it eventually became par for the course and so normal for her that she was unable to allow people in. The characteristics of being a spy eventually became so ingratiated that they disabled her from being a normal person again long after she had ceased to be a spy. I loved the way this was explored on such a deep and meaningful level, and it was this aspect of the novel overall that appealed to me the most and kept me enthralled. I’ve always loved novels that dive deep into their characters, turning them inside out and exposing their most inner thoughts.
‘If I were to disappear, she thought, the world would continue just as it always has. Nothing would change. I would have never made an imprint. I would never be remembered. But she also knew if she kept living like this she would disappear anyway. Dwindle, reduce, evaporate. She could already feel herself diminishing. It had been gradual, wearing her away like the sea against rock.’
The writing throughout this novel is sublime. Moments of pure poetry with stunning visualisation attached to the descriptions of emotions. While the author is not new to writing, this is her first novel, and as far as first novels go, it’s impressive and also exciting; I look forward to reading further novels by her. The Imitator is recommended to fans of literary historical fiction and lovers of thought provoking and deeply insightful novels.
Thanks is extended to Allen & Unwin for providing me with a copy of The Imitator for review.
I enjoyed this novel far more than I expected, and that’s not at all because my expectations were low, rather, the novel itself was just so much deeper and more insightful on a level I wasn’t anticipating. The era it deals with is at the beginning of WWII, during a phase sometimes referred to as ‘the phony war’. Evelyn is recruited into MI5 to infiltrate an underground movement of Nazi sympathisers. While this novel is on the one hand a suspenseful thriller filled with spies and double crossing, it’s also a deeply affecting character study of a woman caught between lives. I really loved it, the literary aspect gripping me even more than the suspense.
‘Evelyn thought about her own mother standing at the kitchen sink, the slope of her shoulders, that fragile bun. She could see the course of their estrangement like footprints trailing down the hallway and out the front door, but for once it didn’t feel as though she had done something wrong.’
Evelyn is a woman who is no stranger to making herself into someone new for whatever the situation requires. She does this from a young age in boarding school and continues on from there. She is, in essence, the perfect person to become a spy. Evelyn herself is thrilled with the opportunity, feels she is not only doing something exciting as a job but also making a worthwhile contribution to the war effort. But of course, nothing is ever as it seems on the surface, and there is a cost to this type of job, an impact upon her life that she could not possibly have foreseen. The experience of being a spy was different for women, there was a particular pressure to use your ‘feminine charm’ to ingratiate yourself. There was also a particular tendency for women to get thrown under the bus when everything went pear shaped. I appreciated the subtle ways in which this was conveyed throughout the narrative. There was a great deal implied with a minimum degree of obviousness.
‘Truth didn’t matter. These people had come because they knew they would have their insane beliefs confirmed.’
For those who know Evelyn, she is something of an enigma. Considered cold and standoffish, but with an obvious intelligence that makes her appealing. She is also attractive, not beautiful enough to be threatening, but pretty enough to draw interest. I really felt for Evelyn though, out of necessity she kept people at arms-length, but it eventually became par for the course and so normal for her that she was unable to allow people in. The characteristics of being a spy eventually became so ingratiated that they disabled her from being a normal person again long after she had ceased to be a spy. I loved the way this was explored on such a deep and meaningful level, and it was this aspect of the novel overall that appealed to me the most and kept me enthralled. I’ve always loved novels that dive deep into their characters, turning them inside out and exposing their most inner thoughts.
‘If I were to disappear, she thought, the world would continue just as it always has. Nothing would change. I would have never made an imprint. I would never be remembered. But she also knew if she kept living like this she would disappear anyway. Dwindle, reduce, evaporate. She could already feel herself diminishing. It had been gradual, wearing her away like the sea against rock.’
The writing throughout this novel is sublime. Moments of pure poetry with stunning visualisation attached to the descriptions of emotions. While the author is not new to writing, this is her first novel, and as far as first novels go, it’s impressive and also exciting; I look forward to reading further novels by her. The Imitator is recommended to fans of literary historical fiction and lovers of thought provoking and deeply insightful novels.
Thanks is extended to Allen & Unwin for providing me with a copy of The Imitator for review.
February 16, 2021
The Imitator by Rebecca Starford
Australian Author, historical fiction
Synopsis /
'We trade in secrets here, Evelyn. There's no shame in having a few of your own. Our only concern is for who might discover them.'
Out of place at boarding school, scholarship girl Evelyn Varley realises that the only way for her to fit in is to be like everyone else. She hides her true self and what she really thinks behind the manners and attitudes of those around her. By the time she graduates from Oxford University in 1939, ambitious and brilliant Evelyn has perfected her performance.
War is looming. Evelyn soon finds herself recruited to MI5, and the elite counterintelligence department of Bennett White, the enigmatic spy-runner. Recognising Evelyn's mercurial potential, White schools her in observation and subterfuge and assigns her the dangerous task of infiltrating an underground group of Nazi sympathisers working to form an alliance with Germany.
But befriending people to betray them isn't easy, no matter how dark their intent. Evelyn is drawn deeper into a duplicity of her own making, where truth and lies intertwine, and her increasing distrust of everyone, including herself, begins to test her better judgement. When a close friend becomes dangerously ensnared in her mission, Evelyn's loyalty is pushed to breaking point, forcing her to make an impossible decision.
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, my sincere thanks to Allen & Unwin for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
In the last six months, I have enjoyed reading quite a few historical fiction novels, and this one fits right into that ‘enjoyable’ category. Other synonyms I could use to describe this book would be – pleasant, delightful and, agreeable. It was definitely enjoyable, but I didn’t love it.
It turns out this work of fiction is loosely based on the true story of Joan Miller, who, as an English M15 recruit, infiltrated a fascist underground political group that sought to rally support for Hitler within England.
If I could base my star rating solely on the cover, I’d give it 5 stars – the cover is beautiful. There were just a few issues which I struggled with in the book.
1. The timelines. Jumping between the 1930’s to the 1940’s. I thought it was unnecessary and did little to enhance what was happening with the story.
2. The chapters. They were unnecessarily long. They were well written, but moved about as quickly as a day-time soap opera. It was only when I got to around page 239 (of 344) that I felt like the story picked up pace. The ending of the book was rushed – it all happened in a whoosh. Which is a shame because that’s where the story picked up pace and you found yourself being drawn in to what was going on.
3. The characters. The main character is Evelyn. I felt like I never got any further than a glimpse of Evelyn’s character and because of this I thought she came across constrained, frigid and one-dimensional, and as such, unlikeable. I found I enjoyed the secondary characters a lot more – they seemed to have a bit more oomph. Personally, I found Julia to be a much more interesting character. She was puzzling, contradictory and had lots of depth to her. Likewise Sally was like a ray of sunshine in the glooms of London.
I'm sure that many of you will read and love this book. Reading is a very personal subjective experience and not every book is for every reader. So, if you read this book synopsis and think that the plot will interest you, please go ahead and read and I hope you will enjoy it.
Thank you Allen & Unwin Australia Pty. Ltd. for giving me the chance to read and review this book
Australian Author, historical fiction
Synopsis /
'We trade in secrets here, Evelyn. There's no shame in having a few of your own. Our only concern is for who might discover them.'
Out of place at boarding school, scholarship girl Evelyn Varley realises that the only way for her to fit in is to be like everyone else. She hides her true self and what she really thinks behind the manners and attitudes of those around her. By the time she graduates from Oxford University in 1939, ambitious and brilliant Evelyn has perfected her performance.
War is looming. Evelyn soon finds herself recruited to MI5, and the elite counterintelligence department of Bennett White, the enigmatic spy-runner. Recognising Evelyn's mercurial potential, White schools her in observation and subterfuge and assigns her the dangerous task of infiltrating an underground group of Nazi sympathisers working to form an alliance with Germany.
But befriending people to betray them isn't easy, no matter how dark their intent. Evelyn is drawn deeper into a duplicity of her own making, where truth and lies intertwine, and her increasing distrust of everyone, including herself, begins to test her better judgement. When a close friend becomes dangerously ensnared in her mission, Evelyn's loyalty is pushed to breaking point, forcing her to make an impossible decision.
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, my sincere thanks to Allen & Unwin for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
In the last six months, I have enjoyed reading quite a few historical fiction novels, and this one fits right into that ‘enjoyable’ category. Other synonyms I could use to describe this book would be – pleasant, delightful and, agreeable. It was definitely enjoyable, but I didn’t love it.
It turns out this work of fiction is loosely based on the true story of Joan Miller, who, as an English M15 recruit, infiltrated a fascist underground political group that sought to rally support for Hitler within England.
If I could base my star rating solely on the cover, I’d give it 5 stars – the cover is beautiful. There were just a few issues which I struggled with in the book.
1. The timelines. Jumping between the 1930’s to the 1940’s. I thought it was unnecessary and did little to enhance what was happening with the story.
2. The chapters. They were unnecessarily long. They were well written, but moved about as quickly as a day-time soap opera. It was only when I got to around page 239 (of 344) that I felt like the story picked up pace. The ending of the book was rushed – it all happened in a whoosh. Which is a shame because that’s where the story picked up pace and you found yourself being drawn in to what was going on.
3. The characters. The main character is Evelyn. I felt like I never got any further than a glimpse of Evelyn’s character and because of this I thought she came across constrained, frigid and one-dimensional, and as such, unlikeable. I found I enjoyed the secondary characters a lot more – they seemed to have a bit more oomph. Personally, I found Julia to be a much more interesting character. She was puzzling, contradictory and had lots of depth to her. Likewise Sally was like a ray of sunshine in the glooms of London.
I'm sure that many of you will read and love this book. Reading is a very personal subjective experience and not every book is for every reader. So, if you read this book synopsis and think that the plot will interest you, please go ahead and read and I hope you will enjoy it.
Thank you Allen & Unwin Australia Pty. Ltd. for giving me the chance to read and review this book
March 11, 2024
I love a good spy book and An Unlikely Spy was a great one. This book was different because it has the usual intrigue, secrets, danger, and uncertainty found in most spy novels. What makes this book stand out is that it focuses on how a person must think and function in order to be a spy. It is a study into the psychological mind set that the main character must process and continue on as to be effective. If one slips up, it is literally a life and death situation for herself, but others, too. Incredible to really absorb this all. Rebecca Stanford does an excellent job in her writing to bring this out.
The book begins with Evelyn Varley, who lives in a working class neighborhood of Lewes. She has always been an intelligent girl and gets a scholarship to an elite boarding school. Evelyn realizes early on that she will need to change herself in order to fit in with these types of girls. They come from money and power. So, Evelyn does. She becomes very good friends with Sally Wesley and is often at her family’s estate. Her father Hugh especially likes Evelyn. Evelyn and Sally go on to study at Oxford. Mr. Wesley helps Evelyn secure a job at the War Office. This is during World War II. Evelyn is excited to do something different and stay in London.
This is when life changes dramatically for Evelyn. She is recruited to work for MI5, a counter intelligence agency where Evelyn will work to infiltrate fascists and Nazi sympathizers. Evelyn is a natural fit, as she has been playing a role of herself for a long time. She knows how to be the person others expect her to be. She doesn’t see her family or talk of her lower level in society. She can easily adapt her personality with a subtle shift; being a hater of Jews, and Passionate about needing a change that the other side of the war is fighting for. Evelyn likes being on her own and wants to continue working. She does not seem to realize the heavy cost this takes from her. She is never honestly her true self anymore. She doesn’t have deep romantic relationships. It’s just too hard and she has many secrets. She holds secrets even to herself.
So, there are twists and turns that happen. I did not see much of them coming. How much will Evelyn sacrifice and can she maintain friendships with both Fascist Sympathizers and her regular friends. Will that even be possible? At some point, she is asked to make difficult choices about her life. Can she change back to herself, when she has been acting for so long? This is a psychological glimpse into her mind and it is hard to fathom how she decides.
So, this was an excellent book and I highly recommend it, especially for women who read a lot of WWII books.
Thank you NetGalley, Rebecca Stafford, and Ecco Publishing for an ARC of this book. I really enjoyed reading it and appreciate receiving a copy.
The book begins with Evelyn Varley, who lives in a working class neighborhood of Lewes. She has always been an intelligent girl and gets a scholarship to an elite boarding school. Evelyn realizes early on that she will need to change herself in order to fit in with these types of girls. They come from money and power. So, Evelyn does. She becomes very good friends with Sally Wesley and is often at her family’s estate. Her father Hugh especially likes Evelyn. Evelyn and Sally go on to study at Oxford. Mr. Wesley helps Evelyn secure a job at the War Office. This is during World War II. Evelyn is excited to do something different and stay in London.
This is when life changes dramatically for Evelyn. She is recruited to work for MI5, a counter intelligence agency where Evelyn will work to infiltrate fascists and Nazi sympathizers. Evelyn is a natural fit, as she has been playing a role of herself for a long time. She knows how to be the person others expect her to be. She doesn’t see her family or talk of her lower level in society. She can easily adapt her personality with a subtle shift; being a hater of Jews, and Passionate about needing a change that the other side of the war is fighting for. Evelyn likes being on her own and wants to continue working. She does not seem to realize the heavy cost this takes from her. She is never honestly her true self anymore. She doesn’t have deep romantic relationships. It’s just too hard and she has many secrets. She holds secrets even to herself.
So, there are twists and turns that happen. I did not see much of them coming. How much will Evelyn sacrifice and can she maintain friendships with both Fascist Sympathizers and her regular friends. Will that even be possible? At some point, she is asked to make difficult choices about her life. Can she change back to herself, when she has been acting for so long? This is a psychological glimpse into her mind and it is hard to fathom how she decides.
So, this was an excellent book and I highly recommend it, especially for women who read a lot of WWII books.
Thank you NetGalley, Rebecca Stafford, and Ecco Publishing for an ARC of this book. I really enjoyed reading it and appreciate receiving a copy.
June 29, 2021
This is an entertaining, well-written, WWII historical fiction novel. It is based on the life of an M15 operative, and has mystery, intrigue, romance, and twists and turns. Ms. Starford does an excellent job engaging her readers from the beginning of this novel until its surprising conclusion, and her notes at the end are much appreciated.
March 19, 2021
*https://mrsbbookreviews.wordpress.com
Rebecca Starford vividly brings to life the fascinating world of female spies during World War Two in The Imitator. With plenty of exciting and tense movements of espionage, The Imitator is an intricately plotted novel that provided me with an alternative picture of the war.
Drawn from real life events following the experiences of a female spy operative during the Second World War, The Imitator is a mind-bending novel with plenty of twists to keep the reader on their toes. Directing the proceedings of The Imitator is Evelyn Varley, a woman who likes to blend into the background. Unable to reveal her true identity and feelings, Evelyn is an enigma. Evelyn has carefully crafted her persona over a number of years and 1939, following the successful completion of her university studies Evelyn is as ambitious as ever. When the war arrives on Evelyn’s doorstep, this highly intelligent and brave young woman is thrust into a world of espionage. Evelyn is a woman with a great deal of potential to make a difference to world, especially with her unique talents. Recruited by the world’s most well-known spy agency, Evelyn sets about completing a series of assignments that present a great deal of danger. In this exhilarating spy game tale, Rebecca Starford has crafted a highly engaging World War Two mystery based narrative.
With a television series of her highly regarded memoir Bad Behaviour in development, Rebecca Starford is one busy writer. It is always great to see an author branch out into different fields writing wise and The Imitator is quite contrasted to Starford’s previous release, a memoir which I enjoyed in 2015. The Imitator is carefully drawn from real life experiences and is presented in the form of a very engaging historical fiction narrative. I know I greatly valued the intent and direction of this novel, it was a riveting read.
The strength in The Imitator does rest in the presentation of lead protagonist Evelyn Varley. A pillar of strength, high interest, bravery and resilience, I think Evelyn was lovingly drawn by Rebecca Starford. There is also a strong sense of authenticity and realism to Evelyn’s character, which is down to the research efforts of Rebecca Starford. I genuinely enjoyed every waking moment I spent with Evelyn. At times Evelyn’s life was quiet as Starford worked to build a fascinating world around her prime protagonist. In other instances Evelyn was surrounded by intrigue, tension, high octane experiences and intricate espionage activities. A perceptive and calculating read is issued to the audience, that really packs a punch.
When there is just so much variety in the World War Two fiction arena, it can be overwhelming to decide what is worth selecting from this plentiful genre. Thankfully, The Imitator is a book that I believe is well worth plucking from this overwhelming selection pool. With a strong attention to period detail and an excellent representation of female war time experiences with an espionage slant, I am certain The Imitator will satisfy keen eyed historical fiction readers. Please turn your attention to the very detailed author’s note contained at the back of the book if you have this book in your possession, it offers an enlightening focus on some truly fascinating real life experiences during the war.
The Imitator delivers a powerful tale of gallantry and valor on behalf of the amazing female trailblazers during the war. Inspiring and exalting, Rebecca Starford’s new novel is an influential read that I have no hesitation in recommending to fans of historical fiction.
*Thanks extended to Allen & Unwin for providing a free copy of this book for review purposes.
The Imitator is book #21 of the 2021 Australian Women Writers Challenge
Rebecca Starford vividly brings to life the fascinating world of female spies during World War Two in The Imitator. With plenty of exciting and tense movements of espionage, The Imitator is an intricately plotted novel that provided me with an alternative picture of the war.
Drawn from real life events following the experiences of a female spy operative during the Second World War, The Imitator is a mind-bending novel with plenty of twists to keep the reader on their toes. Directing the proceedings of The Imitator is Evelyn Varley, a woman who likes to blend into the background. Unable to reveal her true identity and feelings, Evelyn is an enigma. Evelyn has carefully crafted her persona over a number of years and 1939, following the successful completion of her university studies Evelyn is as ambitious as ever. When the war arrives on Evelyn’s doorstep, this highly intelligent and brave young woman is thrust into a world of espionage. Evelyn is a woman with a great deal of potential to make a difference to world, especially with her unique talents. Recruited by the world’s most well-known spy agency, Evelyn sets about completing a series of assignments that present a great deal of danger. In this exhilarating spy game tale, Rebecca Starford has crafted a highly engaging World War Two mystery based narrative.
With a television series of her highly regarded memoir Bad Behaviour in development, Rebecca Starford is one busy writer. It is always great to see an author branch out into different fields writing wise and The Imitator is quite contrasted to Starford’s previous release, a memoir which I enjoyed in 2015. The Imitator is carefully drawn from real life experiences and is presented in the form of a very engaging historical fiction narrative. I know I greatly valued the intent and direction of this novel, it was a riveting read.
The strength in The Imitator does rest in the presentation of lead protagonist Evelyn Varley. A pillar of strength, high interest, bravery and resilience, I think Evelyn was lovingly drawn by Rebecca Starford. There is also a strong sense of authenticity and realism to Evelyn’s character, which is down to the research efforts of Rebecca Starford. I genuinely enjoyed every waking moment I spent with Evelyn. At times Evelyn’s life was quiet as Starford worked to build a fascinating world around her prime protagonist. In other instances Evelyn was surrounded by intrigue, tension, high octane experiences and intricate espionage activities. A perceptive and calculating read is issued to the audience, that really packs a punch.
When there is just so much variety in the World War Two fiction arena, it can be overwhelming to decide what is worth selecting from this plentiful genre. Thankfully, The Imitator is a book that I believe is well worth plucking from this overwhelming selection pool. With a strong attention to period detail and an excellent representation of female war time experiences with an espionage slant, I am certain The Imitator will satisfy keen eyed historical fiction readers. Please turn your attention to the very detailed author’s note contained at the back of the book if you have this book in your possession, it offers an enlightening focus on some truly fascinating real life experiences during the war.
The Imitator delivers a powerful tale of gallantry and valor on behalf of the amazing female trailblazers during the war. Inspiring and exalting, Rebecca Starford’s new novel is an influential read that I have no hesitation in recommending to fans of historical fiction.
*Thanks extended to Allen & Unwin for providing a free copy of this book for review purposes.
The Imitator is book #21 of the 2021 Australian Women Writers Challenge
June 21, 2021
An Unlikely Spy is a historical fiction novel about a spy posing as a Nazi sympathizer and how her past is coming after her. I found the story interesting and unique. I felt like more character development would've added to the story. I still enjoyed it and recommend to fans of World War II novels.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Jane Collingwood. I thought her narration was decent but didn't pull me into the story.
Thank you Ecco and Harper Audio for An Unlikely Spy.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Jane Collingwood. I thought her narration was decent but didn't pull me into the story.
Thank you Ecco and Harper Audio for An Unlikely Spy.
June 30, 2021
[Thank you to Harper Collins for gifting me an ARC of An Unlikely Spy in exchange for an honest review!]
I had hoped to enjoy this one. I’m a fan of historical fiction, I’m always here for a strong woman protagonist, and who doesn’t love a good spy story? Unfortunately, though, this wasn’t a good one. The pacing was painfully slow; the story didn’t really even start until about 150 pages in. It felt like so much of this book was just unnecessary description and fluff, when the real plot could have been summed down to about 60 pages. The pace finally quickened in the last 50 pages of the book, but by then I had long since lost interest. I feel bad because, at times, I could see what the author was trying to do or could feel that she was attempting to build tension, but the execution was simply lacking. Even in the few occasions when I felt there was good tension built or an interesting problem for the author to resolve, the resolution missed the mark for me.
For instance (without spoiling), early on in the story, it is revealed that our protagonist Evelyn harbors a deep secret: a grave past mistake that haunts her to this date. And the rest of the book (a solid 300 pages) is spent *slowly* unraveling Evelyn’s past—with crumbs from the present sprinkled in. But I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop. A fancy shoe. A red-bottomed shoe. Cinderella’s damned glass slipper. After all this build-up, what’s the huge reveal?? What’s this horrible, unforgivable thing that Evelyn did that makes this whole story worth reading? And then, after all that investment, the author presents you with Crocs. Still a shoe. But definitely not the shoe I waited hours in line for. (Sorry, Crocs.)
All in all, I loved the idea for this book. I think it had major potential. But there were several plot points that could have been taken better advantage of and many characters that could have been better developed. I just wish this book had been edited down to the real meat of the story and then been fleshed out from there.
I had hoped to enjoy this one. I’m a fan of historical fiction, I’m always here for a strong woman protagonist, and who doesn’t love a good spy story? Unfortunately, though, this wasn’t a good one. The pacing was painfully slow; the story didn’t really even start until about 150 pages in. It felt like so much of this book was just unnecessary description and fluff, when the real plot could have been summed down to about 60 pages. The pace finally quickened in the last 50 pages of the book, but by then I had long since lost interest. I feel bad because, at times, I could see what the author was trying to do or could feel that she was attempting to build tension, but the execution was simply lacking. Even in the few occasions when I felt there was good tension built or an interesting problem for the author to resolve, the resolution missed the mark for me.
For instance (without spoiling), early on in the story, it is revealed that our protagonist Evelyn harbors a deep secret: a grave past mistake that haunts her to this date. And the rest of the book (a solid 300 pages) is spent *slowly* unraveling Evelyn’s past—with crumbs from the present sprinkled in. But I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop. A fancy shoe. A red-bottomed shoe. Cinderella’s damned glass slipper. After all this build-up, what’s the huge reveal?? What’s this horrible, unforgivable thing that Evelyn did that makes this whole story worth reading? And then, after all that investment, the author presents you with Crocs. Still a shoe. But definitely not the shoe I waited hours in line for. (Sorry, Crocs.)
All in all, I loved the idea for this book. I think it had major potential. But there were several plot points that could have been taken better advantage of and many characters that could have been better developed. I just wish this book had been edited down to the real meat of the story and then been fleshed out from there.
July 8, 2021
AN UNLIKELY SPY centers on England before the inclusion of the United States in the war against Germany. Surprisingly it seems that Hitler was in a sympathetic position at the start of the war and that many Europeans, as well as Americans, supported his position. This was, of course, before it became inclusive of the entire world. But while it was still small and localized, England recruited bright individuals into MI5 to fight against what was deemed as treasonist. The book includes real events in a beguiling and dark way. There is a great deal of deception and Evelyn has to sacrifice much.
Evelyn Varley is from a working-class family, yet she wins a scholarship to a fairly prestigious boarding school and then on to Oxford. The year is 1939 and she is working for a cosmetics company but is invited for a job interview with the war office, or so she thinks.
While she has a high education, her claim to fame is that she is able to adapt or remake herself in the images of those she is attempting to impress or fit in with. She did it while at school and was great friends with Sally, a wealthy girl at school with whom she becomes almost a family member. Until she can no longer fit in. The book moves back and forward in time to tell the story, from 1939 to 1948 when Evelyn is trying to get her life in order after she discovers that she might be good at her job, but everyone is expendable so there is always the human cost.
I thought the novel was well written and did a fairly good job of presenting that the dangers of espionage can be from anywhere and the impact on personal relationships can be painful. I enjoyed the intrigue but wished the characters had been a bit more developed.
3 star read
Happy Reading!
Evelyn Varley is from a working-class family, yet she wins a scholarship to a fairly prestigious boarding school and then on to Oxford. The year is 1939 and she is working for a cosmetics company but is invited for a job interview with the war office, or so she thinks.
While she has a high education, her claim to fame is that she is able to adapt or remake herself in the images of those she is attempting to impress or fit in with. She did it while at school and was great friends with Sally, a wealthy girl at school with whom she becomes almost a family member. Until she can no longer fit in. The book moves back and forward in time to tell the story, from 1939 to 1948 when Evelyn is trying to get her life in order after she discovers that she might be good at her job, but everyone is expendable so there is always the human cost.
I thought the novel was well written and did a fairly good job of presenting that the dangers of espionage can be from anywhere and the impact on personal relationships can be painful. I enjoyed the intrigue but wished the characters had been a bit more developed.
3 star read
Happy Reading!
May 3, 2021
GR win received 4/28. ARC.
Scholarship student Evelyn is befriended by Sally and her family, which includes Sally's wayward cousin Julia. These three misfits embark on different paths during the phony war period: Sally planning marriage to her RAF fiancé, Julia partying and Evelyn engaging in counterintelligence operations against the Nazi sympathizers replete in Britain.
While most spy novels focus on daring missions or cerebral jousting by opponents, An Unlikely Spy looks at the toll of role-playing on an agent, particularly amongst colleagues who have their own agenda and prejudices.
While an interesting take, built around a real-life espionage group, the pacing seemed slow in parts. Thus 3 stars, rather than 4.
Scholarship student Evelyn is befriended by Sally and her family, which includes Sally's wayward cousin Julia. These three misfits embark on different paths during the phony war period: Sally planning marriage to her RAF fiancé, Julia partying and Evelyn engaging in counterintelligence operations against the Nazi sympathizers replete in Britain.
While most spy novels focus on daring missions or cerebral jousting by opponents, An Unlikely Spy looks at the toll of role-playing on an agent, particularly amongst colleagues who have their own agenda and prejudices.
While an interesting take, built around a real-life espionage group, the pacing seemed slow in parts. Thus 3 stars, rather than 4.
December 20, 2020
That cover grabbed me and the gorgeously written narrative kept me rapt ‘til the end. Yes, this is another WWII novel with spies but its execution and well developed characters elevate it. What does it cost the soul to be a good spy? Read on!
4 of 5 Stars
Pub Date 01 Jun 2021
#AnUnlikelySpy #NetGalley
Thanks to the author, Ecco, and NetGalley for the review copy. Opinions are mine.
4 of 5 Stars
Pub Date 01 Jun 2021
#AnUnlikelySpy #NetGalley
Thanks to the author, Ecco, and NetGalley for the review copy. Opinions are mine.
May 2, 2021
I received a free publisher's advance review copy, via Netgalley.
For the first almost two years of World War II in Europe, before Hitler made the colossal error of going to war against the USSR, there were realistic fears in Britain that Germany would invade. Some right-wing Britons even welcomed the possibility, including the influential members of the secret society called the Right Club. The Right Club was rabidly antisemitic and favored appeasement
The head of the Right Club was Archibald Ramsay, a Conservative Member of Parliament. Club members often met at the Russian Tea Room in South Kensington, hosted by Anna Wolkoff, a Russian whose family had fled the Russian Revolution. The Right Club passed government secrets to the German government, including documents from the American Embassy provided by a cipher clerk there named Tyler Kent.
Unbeknownst to the members of the Right Club, the British intelligence agency MI5 had infiltrated it with a number of agents, including a beautiful young woman named Joan Miller. Now I’m going to include a sentence about how that operation went. I’ll mark it with spoiler tags, since it’s also part of the plot of this book.
This novel fictionalizes the story of Joan Miller and the Right Club. The book’s main character, Evelyn Varley, is from a working-class family and wins a scholarship to a posh boarding school, where she makes every effort to fit in with the snobbish girls, but is fortunate to win the true friendship of one of them, who makes her a friend of her family. Evelyn meets more influential people when she attends Oxford and studies German. Like Joan Miller, after school Evelyn works at a cosmetics firm in London, is recruited by British intelligence and becomes part of a team battling internal subversion. She works on several cases, but spends months infiltrating and earning the trust of the members of the Right Club, especially Nina Ivanova (Anna Wolkoff).
Rebecca Starford dramatizes the intrigue of the Right Club operation fleshes out her main character to make us understand the complex emotions of a young woman who, even before her intelligence career, had to become a different person to fit in. I would say that this isn’t an espionage novel of the thriller type, though it certainly has its moments of tension and drama. Instead, it is more of a character study of the loneliness—even alienation—of the spy.
One of the things I like most about espionage fiction is the psychic toll on a spy of pretending to be a different person. It can amount to a betrayal of oneself and sometimes one’s past, family and friends. And when the agent is asked to spend long periods of time infiltrating a group, she necessarily must betray people she has come to know and perhaps care about. The result of the spy role is necessarily loneliness, at least of the soul, and often psychic trauma.
While I sometimes felt Evelyn is so reticent a character that she’s hard to figure out, I still admired and enjoyed the story and Starford’s handling of Evelyn’s complex position, the terrible decisions she had to make, and the emotional aftermath.
I think it would be helpful to do a little reading on the Right Club and the MI5 operation against it before reading this book. It’s not absolutely necessary, but it may provide helpful context that will enrich the story as you read. The book is mostly set during 1939 and 1940, with a small handful of short chapters looking at Evelyn’s life in 1948. Once I’d finished the book, it was illuminating to go back and read the 1948 chapters again.
For the first almost two years of World War II in Europe, before Hitler made the colossal error of going to war against the USSR, there were realistic fears in Britain that Germany would invade. Some right-wing Britons even welcomed the possibility, including the influential members of the secret society called the Right Club. The Right Club was rabidly antisemitic and favored appeasement
The head of the Right Club was Archibald Ramsay, a Conservative Member of Parliament. Club members often met at the Russian Tea Room in South Kensington, hosted by Anna Wolkoff, a Russian whose family had fled the Russian Revolution. The Right Club passed government secrets to the German government, including documents from the American Embassy provided by a cipher clerk there named Tyler Kent.
Unbeknownst to the members of the Right Club, the British intelligence agency MI5 had infiltrated it with a number of agents, including a beautiful young woman named Joan Miller. Now I’m going to include a sentence about how that operation went. I’ll mark it with spoiler tags, since it’s also part of the plot of this book.
This novel fictionalizes the story of Joan Miller and the Right Club. The book’s main character, Evelyn Varley, is from a working-class family and wins a scholarship to a posh boarding school, where she makes every effort to fit in with the snobbish girls, but is fortunate to win the true friendship of one of them, who makes her a friend of her family. Evelyn meets more influential people when she attends Oxford and studies German. Like Joan Miller, after school Evelyn works at a cosmetics firm in London, is recruited by British intelligence and becomes part of a team battling internal subversion. She works on several cases, but spends months infiltrating and earning the trust of the members of the Right Club, especially Nina Ivanova (Anna Wolkoff).
Rebecca Starford dramatizes the intrigue of the Right Club operation fleshes out her main character to make us understand the complex emotions of a young woman who, even before her intelligence career, had to become a different person to fit in. I would say that this isn’t an espionage novel of the thriller type, though it certainly has its moments of tension and drama. Instead, it is more of a character study of the loneliness—even alienation—of the spy.
One of the things I like most about espionage fiction is the psychic toll on a spy of pretending to be a different person. It can amount to a betrayal of oneself and sometimes one’s past, family and friends. And when the agent is asked to spend long periods of time infiltrating a group, she necessarily must betray people she has come to know and perhaps care about. The result of the spy role is necessarily loneliness, at least of the soul, and often psychic trauma.
While I sometimes felt Evelyn is so reticent a character that she’s hard to figure out, I still admired and enjoyed the story and Starford’s handling of Evelyn’s complex position, the terrible decisions she had to make, and the emotional aftermath.
I think it would be helpful to do a little reading on the Right Club and the MI5 operation against it before reading this book. It’s not absolutely necessary, but it may provide helpful context that will enrich the story as you read. The book is mostly set during 1939 and 1940, with a small handful of short chapters looking at Evelyn’s life in 1948. Once I’d finished the book, it was illuminating to go back and read the 1948 chapters again.
June 28, 2021
This one pulled it out in the end. For most of the book, I was thinking "eh, this is alright, not really grabbing me." But the last quarter of the book really upped the stakes and I was both surprised and satisfied to see how it ended.
Evelyn is not a particularly likable character. However, she isn't unlikable either. She's just Evelyn. I think that's why it made her the perfect spy - she's nondescript and doesn't leave much of an impact. Therefore, she can fly under the radar since no one seems to take much notice of her.
This was both the good thing and bad thing about this book. On one hand, it was interesting to imagine how this might have been in real life and how a woman like Evelyn would have lived her life after espionage. On the other hand, I didn't care too much about her so I wasn't really invested in what did or didn't happen to her. Oddly enough, I was much more into Julia and wanted an epilogue just about her.
Overall, this book was alright. It held my interest for the most part but it didn't suck me in and I don't think it's one I'll think about much afterward.
Evelyn is not a particularly likable character. However, she isn't unlikable either. She's just Evelyn. I think that's why it made her the perfect spy - she's nondescript and doesn't leave much of an impact. Therefore, she can fly under the radar since no one seems to take much notice of her.
This was both the good thing and bad thing about this book. On one hand, it was interesting to imagine how this might have been in real life and how a woman like Evelyn would have lived her life after espionage. On the other hand, I didn't care too much about her so I wasn't really invested in what did or didn't happen to her. Oddly enough, I was much more into Julia and wanted an epilogue just about her.
Overall, this book was alright. It held my interest for the most part but it didn't suck me in and I don't think it's one I'll think about much afterward.
May 21, 2021
This was a fascinating story, well written and a fairly quick read. I learned a bit about the British Nazi sympathizers and their actions before war was declared as well as the role of the United States in its relationship with Britain. An Unlikely Spy gave food for thought especially about the effects of living life undercover and having to profess beliefs contrary to your own. However, it bothered me that Evelyn made some really poor choices. I almost felt that it gave women in these roles a bad name. Not that men in her position haven’t also made bad choices, but she seemed just a bit too capricious in the actions that led to the unraveling of her life.
This couple of years, I have read quite a few novels that take place around the rise of Nazi Germany. I think it is no coincidence that so many have been written and look at them as cautionary tales. In the book, there is a statement “truth doesn’t matter.” It is chilling reflection of our times.
This couple of years, I have read quite a few novels that take place around the rise of Nazi Germany. I think it is no coincidence that so many have been written and look at them as cautionary tales. In the book, there is a statement “truth doesn’t matter.” It is chilling reflection of our times.
July 3, 2021
Although The Imitator (Allen and Unwin 2021) is Rebecca Starford’s debut novel, she is not without a writing track record, having published a memoir and also being the publishing director of Kill Your Darlings literary journal. This depth of experience, and no doubt her many and varied readings of other people’s work, has honed her writing skills to the point that this novel feels more like an accomplished work by an established author rather than a first novel. Written in luscious, descriptive and evocative prose, informed by intensive research and curiosity about World War Two espionage, and driven by a page-turning and suspenseful plot, The Imitator is a novel of secrets and spies, love and longing, ideology and zeal, courage and choices, betrayal and loyalty. It is also about female friendship, and how that might be tested in the most egregious way.
Set in a dual timeline of 1940 and 1948, the narrative shifts between the two periods of the beginning of WWII and several years afterwards. It opens by introducing us to the main characters in 1948 – there is mystery and intrigue there but as readers we can only guess at what history or backstories have led to the conflicted and strained relations that we first encounter.
The main story takes place before the start of WWII, with schoolgirl Evelyn Varley completing a scholarship at a posh boarding school (while feeling out of place), and then a degree at Oxford, becoming – by 1939 – ambitious, clever and excited about what opportunities might await her. With the spectre of war becoming more real by the day, Evelyn is recognised for her brilliance and her unusual capacity and is recruited by MI5 as part of an elite espionage and counterintelligence operation that is investigating British subversives. Evelyn receives further training in observation, subterfuge, and impersonation, and is given the dangerous mission to infiltrate an underground group of Nazi sympathisers who want to form an alliance with Germany.
This is where the story becomes emotionally complicated. Evelyn’s role is to befriend people then to betray them, a goal with obvious intellectual and emotional conflicts. No matter how bad these people are, or how desperate their intent, she still – inevitably – sees them as people, even as people she comes to know as friends. And she knows they like and trust her. To betray them, then, even for the sake of her country, seems an impossible and maybe unconscionable act.
Evelyn’s very nature assumes a duplicitous aspect, and her own truth and lies become so entangled that she is unsure herself where her loyalties lie. This is especially true when it emerges that a close friend is somehow involved or caught up in her mission, and Evelyn must make some truly heartbreaking choices about loyalty and duty.
This book is a fascinating insight into the role of women during the war, particularly their positions as spies or infiltrators. Just being female was often the perfect cover for some operations, although in the end, even brave and outstanding performers were expected to return to the dull work of typing and making phone calls once their role was complete. Evelyn is certainly not content to accept that; she is part of the generation of women that was just beginning to assert their independence and to demand rights and positions previously deigned as the privilege of men. The Imitator is inspired by real-life operatives and the details are authentic. The dialogue is very much of the time and adds to the rich layers of each character. The second half of the novel especially builds to a taut and tense atmospheric climax, in which Evelyn must confront not only her erstwhile friends and enemies, but also her own divided loyalties, and perhaps even her misguided beliefs. The conclusion is unforeseen and shocking.
Set in a dual timeline of 1940 and 1948, the narrative shifts between the two periods of the beginning of WWII and several years afterwards. It opens by introducing us to the main characters in 1948 – there is mystery and intrigue there but as readers we can only guess at what history or backstories have led to the conflicted and strained relations that we first encounter.
The main story takes place before the start of WWII, with schoolgirl Evelyn Varley completing a scholarship at a posh boarding school (while feeling out of place), and then a degree at Oxford, becoming – by 1939 – ambitious, clever and excited about what opportunities might await her. With the spectre of war becoming more real by the day, Evelyn is recognised for her brilliance and her unusual capacity and is recruited by MI5 as part of an elite espionage and counterintelligence operation that is investigating British subversives. Evelyn receives further training in observation, subterfuge, and impersonation, and is given the dangerous mission to infiltrate an underground group of Nazi sympathisers who want to form an alliance with Germany.
This is where the story becomes emotionally complicated. Evelyn’s role is to befriend people then to betray them, a goal with obvious intellectual and emotional conflicts. No matter how bad these people are, or how desperate their intent, she still – inevitably – sees them as people, even as people she comes to know as friends. And she knows they like and trust her. To betray them, then, even for the sake of her country, seems an impossible and maybe unconscionable act.
Evelyn’s very nature assumes a duplicitous aspect, and her own truth and lies become so entangled that she is unsure herself where her loyalties lie. This is especially true when it emerges that a close friend is somehow involved or caught up in her mission, and Evelyn must make some truly heartbreaking choices about loyalty and duty.
This book is a fascinating insight into the role of women during the war, particularly their positions as spies or infiltrators. Just being female was often the perfect cover for some operations, although in the end, even brave and outstanding performers were expected to return to the dull work of typing and making phone calls once their role was complete. Evelyn is certainly not content to accept that; she is part of the generation of women that was just beginning to assert their independence and to demand rights and positions previously deigned as the privilege of men. The Imitator is inspired by real-life operatives and the details are authentic. The dialogue is very much of the time and adds to the rich layers of each character. The second half of the novel especially builds to a taut and tense atmospheric climax, in which Evelyn must confront not only her erstwhile friends and enemies, but also her own divided loyalties, and perhaps even her misguided beliefs. The conclusion is unforeseen and shocking.
April 17, 2021
I don’t know what to make of this book. I had difficulty following the story line and determining which side Evelyn was really on. I’m still not sure I grasp the entire arc of the novel. I really like the cover. Evelyn is very aloof and standoffish. I couldn’t get a reading on her. She reminded me of a cold fish. This book just wasn’t my cup of tea. Thanks to NetGalley, Edelweiss, and Ecco for the advance read.
September 21, 2021
“An Unlikely Spy” by Rebecca Starford is a historical novel set in the early days of WWII, and then in 1948, mostly in London. Although I love historical novels and tales of espionage, I found this offering sorely lacking.
Evelyn, a small town girl from modest circumstances is smart enough to gain scholarships to boarding school and Oxford and to get herself befriended by a very well-off, well-connected family. She moves to London and, through the family’s contacts, is hired by MI5 where, eventually, she works in counterintelligence against those seeking to align Great Britain with Nazi Germany. Early in the novel, we are led to believe a serious betrayal has taken place—which is the hook meant to keep us going.
Clearly, “An Unlikely Spy” has the makings for a cracking good story that keeps readers turning the pages. And author Starford knows how to put words on a page. Her sentences are clear and professional. You don’t feel as though you’re in the hands of a rank amateur, which is so often not the case these days.
But instead of a great story, “An Unlikely Spy” turned out to be a muddled, confusing tale that left me not caring very much about the characters, not learning anything about what it was like to live in war-time London, never believing anyone was in any real danger, and not wanting to read anything more by Ms. Starford.
The main problem, for me, was Evelyn. It’s tough to care about a character who is repeatedly described as cold and aloof and thinking of herself as better than others and who, by her actions, seems driven, not by any sense of patriotism or right and wrong, but by her own ambition and desire for meaning and excitement. And its tough to care about a character who continually complains about how tired and stressed she is; and who, while supposedly very intelligent, makes some pretty bad mistakes, including disobeying orders, her reasons for which just don’t make sense.
The structure of the novel is also problematic. To begin with, the first 40% consists almost entirely of set-up and backstory. Plot-wise, nothing much seems to happen and actual points of conflict—the stuff that keeps readers turning the pages—are few and far between. Indeed, during that first 40%, I felt like I was on a very slow plane moving down a very long runway wondering when-oh-when would it ever take off. The author’s choice to keep switching back and forth between 1940 and 1948, all the while continuing to set up and fill in backstory, often makes things very confusing.
And the reveal of the betrayal, the hook meant to keep us going, when we finally get to it, does not really hang together or make a lot of sense. I was left with the feeling: “I came all the way here for this?”
And not to nitpick, but near the beginning there’s a pretty huge historical inaccuracy. Evelyn turns to a friend and says about some people she doesn’t like: “Well you know what they say: ‘Keep your friends close …’” Unfortunately, that quote “Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer,” originated with “The Godfather, Part II,” which came out in 1974, and thus could not have been what they were saying in the 1930s or 40’s.
All in all, “An Unlikely Spy” was very disappointing.
Evelyn, a small town girl from modest circumstances is smart enough to gain scholarships to boarding school and Oxford and to get herself befriended by a very well-off, well-connected family. She moves to London and, through the family’s contacts, is hired by MI5 where, eventually, she works in counterintelligence against those seeking to align Great Britain with Nazi Germany. Early in the novel, we are led to believe a serious betrayal has taken place—which is the hook meant to keep us going.
Clearly, “An Unlikely Spy” has the makings for a cracking good story that keeps readers turning the pages. And author Starford knows how to put words on a page. Her sentences are clear and professional. You don’t feel as though you’re in the hands of a rank amateur, which is so often not the case these days.
But instead of a great story, “An Unlikely Spy” turned out to be a muddled, confusing tale that left me not caring very much about the characters, not learning anything about what it was like to live in war-time London, never believing anyone was in any real danger, and not wanting to read anything more by Ms. Starford.
The main problem, for me, was Evelyn. It’s tough to care about a character who is repeatedly described as cold and aloof and thinking of herself as better than others and who, by her actions, seems driven, not by any sense of patriotism or right and wrong, but by her own ambition and desire for meaning and excitement. And its tough to care about a character who continually complains about how tired and stressed she is; and who, while supposedly very intelligent, makes some pretty bad mistakes, including disobeying orders, her reasons for which just don’t make sense.
The structure of the novel is also problematic. To begin with, the first 40% consists almost entirely of set-up and backstory. Plot-wise, nothing much seems to happen and actual points of conflict—the stuff that keeps readers turning the pages—are few and far between. Indeed, during that first 40%, I felt like I was on a very slow plane moving down a very long runway wondering when-oh-when would it ever take off. The author’s choice to keep switching back and forth between 1940 and 1948, all the while continuing to set up and fill in backstory, often makes things very confusing.
And the reveal of the betrayal, the hook meant to keep us going, when we finally get to it, does not really hang together or make a lot of sense. I was left with the feeling: “I came all the way here for this?”
And not to nitpick, but near the beginning there’s a pretty huge historical inaccuracy. Evelyn turns to a friend and says about some people she doesn’t like: “Well you know what they say: ‘Keep your friends close …’” Unfortunately, that quote “Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer,” originated with “The Godfather, Part II,” which came out in 1974, and thus could not have been what they were saying in the 1930s or 40’s.
All in all, “An Unlikely Spy” was very disappointing.
January 9, 2021
I was very hopeful for this book. It has many of the concepts I find intriguing- World War II, spies, female lead. The thought of a lower class female working her way up to being a spy of all things during a war was a great plot idea. I felt like the plot of the story did not meet my expectations. Multiple times it felt rushed and like key details were missing. I wish the author had gone into more details with examples of the protagonist's dealings with the groups she was infiltrating. I appreciate the effort the author put into writing the story and her research into these types of events. It was clear she spent time looking up these details to make the story believable. It is the start to a great novel for sure. With a few more events demonstrating how the lead has to transform herself to do her job and the events she takes part in the story would be excellent. Despite my not as high rating, I do feel the author wrote well and allowed me to see and feel right along with with characters. Being able to see her battle with herself about how these acts as a spy made her feel was a new perspective and thought process I had not considered. Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity for this ARC.
November 20, 2020
Female spies during WWII have always intrigued me. How they could so easily become someone else yet maintaining the compassion needed for people of interest to trust them. That’s why I couldn’t wait to read this book but...I was really disappointed. It was a struggle for me to get through. It read very slow and just wasn’t gripping in the way that you want a book about spies to be.
Evelyn is a young English woman who gets a job with the war office. She quickly proves herself to be of value to the MI5 and quietly infiltrates a group of Russians, eager to overthrow the government. Despite the pleas of her superior, Evelyn takes things one step too far and gets herself into trouble.
I so wanted to enjoy this book and I am grateful to the author and NetGalley for allowing me to read it early. I did learn more about women’s roles during WWII which is always my main goal of reading WWII fiction.
Evelyn is a young English woman who gets a job with the war office. She quickly proves herself to be of value to the MI5 and quietly infiltrates a group of Russians, eager to overthrow the government. Despite the pleas of her superior, Evelyn takes things one step too far and gets herself into trouble.
I so wanted to enjoy this book and I am grateful to the author and NetGalley for allowing me to read it early. I did learn more about women’s roles during WWII which is always my main goal of reading WWII fiction.
December 20, 2020
That cover grabbed me and the gorgeously written narrative kept me rapt ‘til the end. Yes, this is another WWII novel with spies but its execution and well developed characters elevate it. What does it cost the soul to be a good spy? Read on!
4 of 5 Stars
Pub Date 01 Jun 2021
#AnUnlikelySpy #NetGalley
Thanks to the author, Ecco, and NetGalley for the review copy. Opinions are mine.
4 of 5 Stars
Pub Date 01 Jun 2021
#AnUnlikelySpy #NetGalley
Thanks to the author, Ecco, and NetGalley for the review copy. Opinions are mine.
February 28, 2021
Just what I needed to pull me out of my reading slump ... a well written, compelling historical fiction with great characters and a good dose of intrigue.
January 13, 2023
It's only when Evelyn is in prison that she realises that unlike the people of influence also imprisoned on charges of violating the official secrets act to incite treason they will have a short sentence but she will not. Even with all her work for MI5, her infiltration into the Lion Society no one came to her aid, no one stood up for her as a witness that she was innocent of the charges of attempted murder. Rather, she reflects that however much she had remade herself into being accepted into the upper echelons of British Society she still remained to them as the middle class girl from Lewes. The Wesleys were of British high society of button manufacturers and with the pending war looked to gain even more wealth, buttons needed for service uniforms of all sorts. Sally Wesley, a bit of an outcast herself befriends Evelyn at Somerville College, Oxford where Evelyn had through scholarship gained a place to further her education. However she soon discovers that with her distinct county accent of Lewes Sussex. (YouTube recording of such an accent is very interesting) and after a lot of teasing and abuse realises that she must reinvent herself and through her friendship with Sally she is able to achieve this. Still, the disparities remain even when she starts work in a rather menial position with poor pay. At the Wesley's she manages to speak to Sally's father who out of all the family admires Evelyn the most and looks to getting work for her with the War office. After sometime her work bores her and she pushes for a position into the thick of MI5. It all goes well until she discovers a Wesley family member, Julia, previously married to a German, is the head of the Lion Society. It all heads down hill for Evelyn. After her release, she starts to remake herself again, meets a man who finally gets her to let go of her secrets and her past.
March 2, 2021
What an edge of the seat read, I was so worried for Evelyn and worried by Evelyn...I found this absolutely page turning! I loved the character of Evelyn, I could so relate to her and could completely see her journey. The idea of a scholarship student being a perfect candidate for a spy is so clever. She was so well practiced in imitating the behaviour of others. I loved her parents, they were so well drawn. I had no idea there were any nazi sympathisers at the start of ww2, I’ve never even thought about that ‘phoney war’ period. I was so engrossed in the storyline. It was so well done, the writing is beautiful. I loved it, can’t wait for the next Rebecca Stratford novel!!
Read
May 28, 2021AN UNLIKELY SPY is a deep psychological portrait of a woman on the brink, a powerful examination of the choices we make — and as gripping a World War II thriller as you’re likely to read this year.
Read our full review here:
https://booktrib.com/2021/05/28/in-an...
Read our full review here:
https://booktrib.com/2021/05/28/in-an...
November 10, 2025
Loved!!!! We meet our main girl Evelyn in post WWII London. She’s on a date and is suddenly caught off guard after she runs into someone from her past. It then flashes to the beginning of the war and we follow her as she joins war work, gets recruited by the OSS and works as a spy. In the post war chapters we know she’s running from something that happened during the war. Flew through this!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 397 reviews