A Beautiful Allegorical Love Story With a Viking Twist
Ylva, the so-called Wolf Queen and leader of a Viking clan, was raised by wolves. More wondrous still, she has a remarkable gift—she can see the light and darkness in the hearts of men. Rohan, prince and heir to the Four Realms, doesn’t believe in light and dark, in good and evil. But a threat is rising in the north. An evil priestess and a great dragon are raising an army of the undead and threatening to infect the land with darkness. Ylva and Rohan must join forces to defeat the great evil…and will fall in love on the way. But their victory will come at a steep price.
To start off, good things. The Viking setting is well-rendered, Ylva’s wolf buddies are awesome, and the fantasy elements—Light and Dark, the dragon, wolves with spiritual sight, clans and kingdoms—all feel coherent and well-developed. The in-world theology is fairly simple, but resonant, and makes sense within the story’s context.
I should also say…WOW, Tabitha Caplinger has deep insight into the spiritual importance of emotions, and personal relationship with Christ. The protagonist Ylva’s relationship with the novel’s obvious Christ-figure, Elior, is heartwarming, inspiring, and a beautiful portrait of what a close relationship with Jesus looks like. Ylva also demonstrates Christlike love and faith in her relationship with Rohan. And Caplinger, by training a youth pastor, has sprinkled her novel with on-point quotes about the Christian walk and “guarding one’s heart” that leave me wanting to attack the book with a highlighter and write things down for future study.
Now for the not-so-great things.
The Wolf Queen works very well as an allegory of spiritual warfare, the life of Jesus, and trusting one’s heart to God, but as a story, it honestly fell flat for me.
Ylva’s character is just a little too perfect, which is a good thing and a bad thing. A good thing because her purity of heart, and the thought process by which she puts to rest her doubts every time they come up, are a good role model for readers to follow. How I wish I could live my Christian life with as much self-control, purity, and joy as Ylva follows the Light! But it’s a bad thing in that it makes her character hard to relate to and robs the plot of urgency. Ylva doesn’t really grow. She doesn’t have to. Her doubts and struggles are never serious and are typically resolved within the paragraph they come up in. She’s admirable for sure, but not the kind of protagonist whose journey is going to keep me flipping the pages late into the night.
Rohan, who struggles with doubt and grows into faith by the novel’s end, is a somewhat more realistic character. But I have read more compelling characters who struggle with doubt (Stephen Howards’ characters come to mind), and even Rohan’s arc didn’t really grab me. Other characters felt rather flat as well. An exception was Elior, who was an absolute delight to read—gentle, patient, selfless, noble, not to mention funny! Caplinger clearly loves Jesus, and that love shines through the pages of the novel.
For such a short novel, it took a long time for me to read. It’s just not all that compelling and was a bit of a chore to get through to be brutally honest. Mostly this is the protagonist’s flat character arc, but some of it is the plot. For all the blackened zombie warriors, battle scenes, an evil immortal priestess, and a dragon (!)…I just didn’t feel as much urgency as I could have. The writing style isn’t fantastic, either. The prose is basic, and Caplinger does a lot of telling rather than showing, which does not help with the lack of connection to the characters. And the allegory is so obvious that it sometimes overwhelms the story.
But what a lovely allegory it is! The relationships between Ylva and Rohan, and especially Ylva and Elior, were beautiful, a fine example of Christlike love in action. And that ending…despite my complaints of not connecting to the characters, the novel’s finale, and the hard choices they had to make, had me all emotional. So…even though I didn’t love this novel as a story, I would definitely read it again for the rich spiritual insight it offers.
Artistic value: 2/5
Moral value (general): 5/5
Moral value (Christian): 5/5
Entertainment: 2.5/5
Naomi’s Choice: 4/5