What do you think?
Rate this book
Siren Island #5
Too Good to Be True
When the oracle predicted that Mirra would need to be rescued…Mirra is shocked to find the premonition unfold literally. When Silas Somerborne races to save the day, and rescues Mirra from certain death, she knows immediately that he’s the one she’s been waiting for. And yet, no matter how hard she tries, Silas pushes Mirra away.
Silas has spent his life escaping notice by living on the fringes of society where hard work and keeping his head down is all he knows. He’s content with his life as it is, and Silas certainly doesn’t need a bombshell beauty like Mirra to intrude. As far as he’s concerned, women could disrupt the course of even the most seaworthy sailor.
When danger comes to Siren Island, Silas must do his best to quell the threat and keep Mirra safe. However, is Silas actually the one who has needed rescuing all along?
Silas has spent his life escaping notice by living on the fringes of society where hard work and keeping his head down is all he knows. He’s content with his life as it is, and Silas certainly doesn’t need a bombshell beauty like Mirra to intrude. As far as he’s concerned, women could disrupt the course of even the most seaworthy sailor.
When danger comes to Siren Island, Silas must do his best to quell the threat and keep Mirra safe. However, is Silas actually the one who has needed rescuing all along?
272 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 5, 2021
1495 people are currently reading
443 people want to read
About the author
Tricia O'Malley
77 books2,402 followersAs an award winning NY Times, USA Today, and WSJ bestselling author, Tricia O’Malley’s infectious joy in writing romance with an added dash of the magical has touched hearts around the world. With over three million books read, O’Malley’s stories have been translated into several languages and enjoy a devoted following. Tricia O’Malley is a native of Wisconsin, and departed the wintry tundra for warmer locales five years ago. She now lives in the Caribbean with her handsome Scotsman.
An avid scuba diver, Tricia spends much of her time underwater dreaming up new stories while photographing the beautiful sea life. Tricia loves fun vacation reads, believes in mermaids, and has a serious travel addiction. She discovers her inspiration on the go – and you’ll find her books set in beautiful settings with characters who deserve a happily-ever-after.
To see some of her underwater or island life photos visit her on Facebook, Instagram, or join her mailing list at www.triciaomalley.com
An avid scuba diver, Tricia spends much of her time underwater dreaming up new stories while photographing the beautiful sea life. Tricia loves fun vacation reads, believes in mermaids, and has a serious travel addiction. She discovers her inspiration on the go – and you’ll find her books set in beautiful settings with characters who deserve a happily-ever-after.
To see some of her underwater or island life photos visit her on Facebook, Instagram, or join her mailing list at www.triciaomalley.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews
February 8, 2022
This one was a little bit of a heart breaker for me. Not because there isn't an HEA because there is one; but because of Ms. O'Malley's descriptive writing of Silas. I loved visiting Siren Island again and visiting with Jolie, Mirra, Irma and Prince. I would love to meet Prince one day. Romance, family, a little suspense and magic made this one hard to put down.
April 7, 2022
Mirra has a premonition of danger and the premonition turns out to be true.
She gets caught by a fishing trawler when trying to release some dolphins.
Siles is a Marine enforcement officer and a loner.
Tiles helps Mirra escape the fishermen and saves her life as she was caught in the net and left to drown.
Siules and MIrra have an instant attraction but Silas is used to being on his own and feels he doesn't deserve a beauty like Mirra.
But Silas must learn about family and people having his back when danger comes to the island.
Fun romance and adventure!
She gets caught by a fishing trawler when trying to release some dolphins.
Siles is a Marine enforcement officer and a loner.
Tiles helps Mirra escape the fishermen and saves her life as she was caught in the net and left to drown.
Siules and MIrra have an instant attraction but Silas is used to being on his own and feels he doesn't deserve a beauty like Mirra.
But Silas must learn about family and people having his back when danger comes to the island.
Fun romance and adventure!
November 16, 2022
Too Good To zBe True(The Siren Island Trilogy)
I couldn’t put this book down! It was amazing! It was like I was there with the characters! I can’t get over the imagination Tricia O’Malley has, it is TrueType amazing! I know I use that word a lot ,but I don’t know how describe it any other way!
I couldn’t put this book down! It was amazing! It was like I was there with the characters! I can’t get over the imagination Tricia O’Malley has, it is TrueType amazing! I know I use that word a lot ,but I don’t know how describe it any other way!
May 31, 2021
Loved the ending!!
June 23, 2021
I could not put it down it was so good!
April 22, 2021
Too Good to Be True. Silas saves Mirra’s life, but can he accept what she is and the gift she offers when his life is threatened? Tricia O’Malley’s latest tale about the magical folk of Siren Island puts her characters in danger as drug smugglers try to gain a foothold. This dialogue driven story introduces a perceptive canine named Splash and lets series fans spend some more time with the all knowing island character, Prince. This is a book that begs to be read in one sitting. Highly recommend.
October 27, 2024
WELL THIS WAS SWEET, IF IT HAD BEEN MORE EXPLICIT, I WOULD HAVE RATED THIS 5 STARS - NO QUESTIONS ASKED. While I was smut-binging the entire weekend, it was wonderful to end it with an emotionally invested story. Of course, on a scale of 5, the intimacy and emotional level was a 3 for me. Nevertheless, I had a few snickering moments.
I have a healthy respect for women (not maneaters) who aren't afraid to approach a man - make the first move - because I sure as hell can't. Luckily, Mirra while persistent, knew her boundaries and didn't PESTER the man to the point where he would quit and run.
MIRRA was a lover. The type who had too much to give, maybe a little too nosey sometimes. I can even see her being a tree hugger if the situation calls for it, which explains how she was rescued by Silas when she got trapped in an illegal fishing net. This was slightly "fated lovers", so Mirra knew Silas was THE ONE for her, thus she pursued the hell out of him. Those moments were funny at times, the man was like a deer in headlights, not knowing what just hit him. 😂😂 I would have enjoyed watching this on film.
SILAS might as well have been an orphan, being the atypical story of a white trash kid, he learned early on to fend and survive on his own. Naturally, he doesn't trust easy, and life without commitments was easier. He never expected Mirra to crash into his life and uproot his quiet, peaceful and staid life. Needless to say, the man seemed desperate for a manual on how to navigate and deal with a bubbly and caring woman like Mirra...in fact, her entire family was a new species to him, the poor guy.
THE BEST PAST OF THE STORY?!! SPARKS, Silas's dog. It made me miss my own pet who passed away a year ago due to health complications. You can always trust a man who knows how to care for his pet.
OVERALL this was wholesome, though the ending was rather rushed or fast for my taste. I felt like the author never really delved into Silas getting to know Mirra more as a mermaid, so that was dissatisfying. Wasn't this a mermaid story? Where was the swashbuckling? I would have loved to see the calm after the storm, but throughout the story I felt Mirra and Silas never had a moment to just BE together.
I have a healthy respect for women (not maneaters) who aren't afraid to approach a man - make the first move - because I sure as hell can't. Luckily, Mirra while persistent, knew her boundaries and didn't PESTER the man to the point where he would quit and run.
MIRRA was a lover. The type who had too much to give, maybe a little too nosey sometimes. I can even see her being a tree hugger if the situation calls for it, which explains how she was rescued by Silas when she got trapped in an illegal fishing net. This was slightly "fated lovers", so Mirra knew Silas was THE ONE for her, thus she pursued the hell out of him. Those moments were funny at times, the man was like a deer in headlights, not knowing what just hit him. 😂😂 I would have enjoyed watching this on film.
SILAS might as well have been an orphan, being the atypical story of a white trash kid, he learned early on to fend and survive on his own. Naturally, he doesn't trust easy, and life without commitments was easier. He never expected Mirra to crash into his life and uproot his quiet, peaceful and staid life. Needless to say, the man seemed desperate for a manual on how to navigate and deal with a bubbly and caring woman like Mirra...in fact, her entire family was a new species to him, the poor guy.
THE BEST PAST OF THE STORY?!! SPARKS, Silas's dog. It made me miss my own pet who passed away a year ago due to health complications. You can always trust a man who knows how to care for his pet.
OVERALL this was wholesome, though the ending was rather rushed or fast for my taste. I felt like the author never really delved into Silas getting to know Mirra more as a mermaid, so that was dissatisfying. Wasn't this a mermaid story? Where was the swashbuckling? I would have loved to see the calm after the storm, but throughout the story I felt Mirra and Silas never had a moment to just BE together.
October 12, 2025
Mira
Silas Somerborne
Mirra is saved by Silas as she finished saving some dolphins. When Mirra sees Silas she immediately knows he’s the one she has been waiting for. Silas just keeps pushing her away, he’s always had to depend on himself and has spent his life trying to keep his head down and working hard. Silas has a dog named Splash that he has as his best friend. He likes his Captain at work and plays dominoes with some of the island people. Silas has never known love and Mirra wants to help him. Then trouble comes to the island and Silas tries to keep Mirra safe as well as take care of the threat. This is very good, fast reading book. Mirra is very loving, family oriented and wants to only heal Silas and be his partner. Silas has to learn to accept help and understand his feelings as they change toward Mirra and people in general. I would definitely read more books by this author and this series.
Silas Somerborne
Mirra is saved by Silas as she finished saving some dolphins. When Mirra sees Silas she immediately knows he’s the one she has been waiting for. Silas just keeps pushing her away, he’s always had to depend on himself and has spent his life trying to keep his head down and working hard. Silas has a dog named Splash that he has as his best friend. He likes his Captain at work and plays dominoes with some of the island people. Silas has never known love and Mirra wants to help him. Then trouble comes to the island and Silas tries to keep Mirra safe as well as take care of the threat. This is very good, fast reading book. Mirra is very loving, family oriented and wants to only heal Silas and be his partner. Silas has to learn to accept help and understand his feelings as they change toward Mirra and people in general. I would definitely read more books by this author and this series.
May 10, 2025
Mirra and Silas were great protagonists. She loving him right off the bat , knowing that he's the one as soon as she sees him. Silas, a loner fights her and her family every step of the way. Her mother and sister are of course mermaids as well although only half mermaid, half human. The husband and father was a full blooded merman. But he's dead and gone and their mother is all on her own except for her daughters, Jolee and Mirra. And the mermaid community and friends on land. But she's still lonely.
Irma, the mother still feels grief over the loss of her loving husband. And in the next book, it promises a new long. I will be looking for that next book 6, " A Good Soul .
I really enjoyed this audio version and would listen to more. The characters were easily portrayed by Amy Landon. And I also enjoyed the supporting characters too !
A great Fairytail, pun intended !
Irma, the mother still feels grief over the loss of her loving husband. And in the next book, it promises a new long. I will be looking for that next book 6, " A Good Soul .
I really enjoyed this audio version and would listen to more. The characters were easily portrayed by Amy Landon. And I also enjoyed the supporting characters too !
A great Fairytail, pun intended !
July 3, 2024
Another Great Escape to Siren Island
Mirra, a mermaid, learned from the Oracle that she would be saved by the man she is destined to love, and then she would save him. When she's trapped in a cable while saving dolphins from a fishing net, Silas, a sailor and Marine Enforcement officer, saves her. She tries to repay him, but he refuses to accept her gifts and pushes her away.
My favorite part of this book is the mystery element introduced by Silas' fight against drug traffickers and a traitor within his team. During this, Mirra stays close to protect him. They both learn to love and appreciate all that entails as they save one another, and the reassurances Mirra gives Silas are beautiful!
I highly recommend this series!!
Mirra, a mermaid, learned from the Oracle that she would be saved by the man she is destined to love, and then she would save him. When she's trapped in a cable while saving dolphins from a fishing net, Silas, a sailor and Marine Enforcement officer, saves her. She tries to repay him, but he refuses to accept her gifts and pushes her away.
My favorite part of this book is the mystery element introduced by Silas' fight against drug traffickers and a traitor within his team. During this, Mirra stays close to protect him. They both learn to love and appreciate all that entails as they save one another, and the reassurances Mirra gives Silas are beautiful!
I highly recommend this series!!
May 5, 2021
Another home run
I first read Ms O'Malley when I started her Grace Cove novels. I quickly moved on to her other series and was thrilled when she wrote the first Siren Island book. How can you go wrong with beautiful mermaids finding their true love on a Caribbean Island. This book is just another jewel (an aquamarine in fact) in Ms. O' Malley's crown. Can't wait for Irma's book next. Please hurry~
I first read Ms O'Malley when I started her Grace Cove novels. I quickly moved on to her other series and was thrilled when she wrote the first Siren Island book. How can you go wrong with beautiful mermaids finding their true love on a Caribbean Island. This book is just another jewel (an aquamarine in fact) in Ms. O' Malley's crown. Can't wait for Irma's book next. Please hurry~
May 12, 2021
Loved it
A story of love, souls, friends, family, action and romance what more can you ask for. Silas rescued Mira and she rescues him right back. Mira shows him how to love and accept love and hope. She teaches him that love and family is something that is good. Friends and family help each other because of love and it is a good thing. Strong characters can’t wait for Irma story.
A story of love, souls, friends, family, action and romance what more can you ask for. Silas rescued Mira and she rescues him right back. Mira shows him how to love and accept love and hope. She teaches him that love and family is something that is good. Friends and family help each other because of love and it is a good thing. Strong characters can’t wait for Irma story.
May 21, 2021
Fabulous
This is the word for this amazing and delightful book! Tricia O'Malley is a magician with the written word. The Siren Island series is great and reading these books make you feel like you are part of the family of the island. I'm sure you will fall in love with Tricia"s books just like I did. Any and all of her books are magical and heartwarming. You won't want to miss them!!
This is the word for this amazing and delightful book! Tricia O'Malley is a magician with the written word. The Siren Island series is great and reading these books make you feel like you are part of the family of the island. I'm sure you will fall in love with Tricia"s books just like I did. Any and all of her books are magical and heartwarming. You won't want to miss them!!
July 6, 2021
Too good to be true book 5
I enjoyed this sisters story More than book 4. It has more adventure and action plus romanace To keep the reader interested.Just 1 correction needs to be made.The night he gets shot has a new moon Which keeps her hidden in the water because there's no light . Yet when she takes him into the cave There is a sliver of light coming in from above from the moon.
I enjoyed this sisters story More than book 4. It has more adventure and action plus romanace To keep the reader interested.Just 1 correction needs to be made.The night he gets shot has a new moon Which keeps her hidden in the water because there's no light . Yet when she takes him into the cave There is a sliver of light coming in from above from the moon.
February 27, 2023
Mirra has got to be my favorite! I adored her personality through out all the other books. I'm so glad that her book ended as happily as the others. I had a few fears there for a while. I just hoped Silas could see how amazing Mirra is. And he deserved to be happy and loved. Took him long enough, but he didn't waste time when he finally realized it! I can't wait for the next book. I'm looking forward to seeing Irma finding her happy ending! She has helped everyone else find theirs.
May 9, 2021
Oh, how I love Siren Island! I love it when you can't put a book down. Magical realism takes you away to a life you can only dream of.
We are back for Mirra's story in Too Good to Be True. It's a story about breaking down barriers, accepting and learning to love, finding family and finally living, instead of just surviving.
I'm very much looking forward to Irma's story in book 6. 🧜🏼♀️💗
We are back for Mirra's story in Too Good to Be True. It's a story about breaking down barriers, accepting and learning to love, finding family and finally living, instead of just surviving.
I'm very much looking forward to Irma's story in book 6. 🧜🏼♀️💗
May 25, 2021
I truly couldn't put this down if I want to
I love the characters and the way they are portrayed. I love the story surrounding these characters and the backstory for all of them. It truly make me want to believe there truly are mermaids living amongst us. Thank you Tricia for making me a believer.
I love the characters and the way they are portrayed. I love the story surrounding these characters and the backstory for all of them. It truly make me want to believe there truly are mermaids living amongst us. Thank you Tricia for making me a believer.
August 14, 2021
Love meant to be
What a lovely tale. Poor Salad didn't know how love d
Could both save him and set him free! Mirra is the love he never knew he waited for even though he wore her likeness in the tattoo he acquired so many years past. They finally found each other and eventually realized they were supposed to be together forever.
What a lovely tale. Poor Salad didn't know how love d
Could both save him and set him free! Mirra is the love he never knew he waited for even though he wore her likeness in the tattoo he acquired so many years past. They finally found each other and eventually realized they were supposed to be together forever.
February 18, 2022
Beautiful and soft hearted Mirra finds the man she believes is her one and only, just as her sister Jolie did in the previous book. Even Splash (the dog) knows his person and this beautiful mermaid are meant to be together - now if she can just convince her true love to take a chance on love - not always an easy task.
Fun series!
Fun series!
February 25, 2023
True love conquers all !
I would recommend this to all romantics. It was lovely. Tricia really put love into every word that told these stories. She tells them as though she was there as the stories unfolded. She made me feel that I was there with them as they lived their lives, found happiness, and found true love.
I would recommend this to all romantics. It was lovely. Tricia really put love into every word that told these stories. She tells them as though she was there as the stories unfolded. She made me feel that I was there with them as they lived their lives, found happiness, and found true love.
July 7, 2023
Best of the siren island series
I loved this book and the characters in it ! I was totally engrossed with the storyline! This book makes me yearn to live on an island and feel the ocean breeze and the sand beneath my feet! I read this book in one sitting,it was so good. Tricia O'Malley creates magic in her books and for that I am thankful!
I loved this book and the characters in it ! I was totally engrossed with the storyline! This book makes me yearn to live on an island and feel the ocean breeze and the sand beneath my feet! I read this book in one sitting,it was so good. Tricia O'Malley creates magic in her books and for that I am thankful!
May 6, 2021
Wonderful
I love Tricia O’Malley’s books I have read everyone of hers. This one is about love ,patience and breaking down walls. It has drama and suspense and is hard to put down. I loved it and am looking forward to the next one
I love Tricia O’Malley’s books I have read everyone of hers. This one is about love ,patience and breaking down walls. It has drama and suspense and is hard to put down. I loved it and am looking forward to the next one
May 7, 2021
Amazing
I have been waiting to read this book, it was absolutely perfect, Silas and Mirri was perfect for each other, I can’t wait for the book about Irma to come out, oh please hurry with it
I have been waiting to read this book, it was absolutely perfect, Silas and Mirri was perfect for each other, I can’t wait for the book about Irma to come out, oh please hurry with it
May 9, 2021
Amazing as always.
I can always trust Tricia O’Malley to create a world where love lives and hope springs eternal. Where friends and family are celebrated. Her stories are always so compelling and the characters that she creates are so special that you just can’t put it down. Thank you for another wonderful book.
I can always trust Tricia O’Malley to create a world where love lives and hope springs eternal. Where friends and family are celebrated. Her stories are always so compelling and the characters that she creates are so special that you just can’t put it down. Thank you for another wonderful book.
May 9, 2021
Love the mermaids
Mirra is so kind hearted. She loves strong and hard. Silas didn't have a great childhood and had to learn to take care of himself. It took awhile for Mirra to get thru to him. It was a really great book.
Mirra is so kind hearted. She loves strong and hard. Silas didn't have a great childhood and had to learn to take care of himself. It took awhile for Mirra to get thru to him. It was a really great book.
May 11, 2021
Slow beginning, beautifully developed story
Wonderful story. 5th in Siren Island series. Love story about a mermaid and a troubled sailor. Highly recommend this book and others in series.
Wonderful story. 5th in Siren Island series. Love story about a mermaid and a troubled sailor. Highly recommend this book and others in series.
May 11, 2021
This series is just so fun with all the mermaids and magic. Mirra is such a sweet soul and she is perfect for poor Silas who breaks my heart throughout this book. Looking forward to Irma's story next.
May 14, 2021
Could not put this one down!
Absolutely love all Trisha's books. However, I literally read this book beginning to end today!
Captivating from the first sentence. Anxiously awaiting book 6. Which of course I have pre-ordered.
Thanks Trisha for another awesome book!!!!
Absolutely love all Trisha's books. However, I literally read this book beginning to end today!
Captivating from the first sentence. Anxiously awaiting book 6. Which of course I have pre-ordered.
Thanks Trisha for another awesome book!!!!
May 15, 2021
This is a very nice continuation of the Siren Island series and an enjoyable book to read. If you are looking for a romantic story with likable characters and gorgeous scenery, sit back and let yourself be carried away!
May 19, 2021
Delightful and intriguing!
A soft hearted strong woman and a hard headed and hearted man make for a modern clash of the titans island style. Throw in a lovable "Splash ", some dolphins and those cunning mermaids and you have yourself a hit.
A soft hearted strong woman and a hard headed and hearted man make for a modern clash of the titans island style. Throw in a lovable "Splash ", some dolphins and those cunning mermaids and you have yourself a hit.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews