This first new book on Bishop Seabury in more than a decade, One, Catholic, and Samuel Seabury and the Early Episcopal Church is a fascinating story of the first bishop in the Episcopal church.
In 1783, Seabury was chosen by the clergy of Connecticut to seek ordination to the episcopate in England. After a year of negotiation, Seabury found it impossible to obtain Episcopal orders from the Church of England because, as an American citizen, he could not swear allegiance to the crown. He then turned to the non-juring bishops of the Episcopal church in Scotland and was ordained on November 14, 1784. As part of his negotiation with the Scottish bishops Seabury agreed to incorporate the Communion Service from the Scottish Prayer Book into a new American Prayer Book, thereby establishing a pivotal component in American Anglican Liturgy. When he returned to America, he was recognized as the first Bishop of Connecticut.
Using Seabury's persona and thought as central themes, distinguished historian and Bishop of Bethlehem (PA) Paul Marshall argues that liturgy cannot be understood simply by studying texts, and so he explores the complex personalities, motivations, loyalties and prejudices that went into the formation of the Episcopal church and the creation of its liturgy. (300 pp Paperback, includes CD-ROM appendix.)
A fantastic resource about an important situation in church history. While the study is thorough and engaging, the book represents some serious inside denominational baseball. Moreover, Marshall fails to provide an engaging, organized narrative with which to interpret events. He did not flesh out the full story of the Anglican experience in early America, at least for the beginning scholar. Previous context will allow the reader to fully appreciate this work. Nevertheless, Marshall remains a vibrant writer, especially adept at characterization.