I'm reviewing this series in one go because I pretty much inhaled it over the first 3 weeks of September during Level 4 lockdown and I honestly can't remember which things happened in which books.
I do know that, despite the fact that I loved the worldbuilding and overall series story arc of the Trellis family building their circle (and the various ways that the paranormal and psychic stuff shows up in the series), my favourite book was actually #1, which had VERY little paranormal going on at all. But there was just something about Matty and Jake that felt... better developed and more relatable than any of the other characters from later books.
(Also, the opening scene was freaking hilarious and had me continuously laughing out loud from the second or third paragraph. And I really, really loved the sweariness and the diversity of the characters)
I also quite enjoyed Adrian and Lucy's book (partly because anger being used constructively is a trope I really love, and Adrian's journey to accepting himself is an interesting one).
After that, I won't lie, the books blur, and my memory of them is more of a single story that takes four books to tell, where the individual romances and book-level plots take a back seat to the series arc. It kept me reading, but I don't think I'd say I enjoyed the later books as much as the first two.
In particular, the Noah/Luke/Talise thing SERIOUSLY annoyed me - probably because it hit all my "FFS would the three of you just sit down and have an honest conversation like grown-ass adults for five minutes?" triggers. Also, I don't know what it was about the Sam/Addy stuff that just didn't work for me from the start... I think Sam may be one of those characters who makes a good supporting character in someone else's book (he was great in Jake and Matty's story), but doesn't quite work for me when he's the star of the show, which is the case in Books 3 and 4.
All up, I did enjoy the series: it was EXACTLY the kind of light, mindless escapism I needed and wanted throughout Level 4 lockdown, and I'm definitely planning on reading the spinoff series at some point, although I need a bit of a change of pace before I do. I feel like if I stepped back and tried to analyse the books in more depth, I'd find a heap of things to critique, but I really don't want to - I'm happy to just enjoy them for what they were: a chance to escape to a warm, comfy , safe world where people care about each other, have each others' backs, and actually use their powers to make the world a better place.