What do you think?
Rate this book
The Derwent Chronicles #3
Until We Can Forgive
They survived the Great War, but will life ever be the same?
Spring 1919: WW1 is over and a fragile peace has descended over the country. Now living in Cambridge with husband Edmond, Amy Derwent is settling into her new life as wife and mother to little Beth. But the shadow of the Great War looms large, particularly as the injuries Edmond sustained at Ypres still take their toll on him today.
Edmond’s cousin, Vicky, has now grown into a fine young woman, eager to help her country. Throwing off her privileged background to train as a nurse, she spends her days tending to the many soldiers still suffering the after-effects of their time on the battlefield.
Meeting Maxim Duclos, a young Frenchman who has arrived in Larchbury, fills her heart with joy - but when it is discovered that Maxim may be hiding the truth about his past, Vicky is faced with an impossible choice. Follow her heart’s desire and risk her family’s disapproval or keep her family – but deny herself the chance of true love?
The war may be over, but Edmond, Amy and Vicky must all face a new battle, finding their own peace in a country wounded by loss.
Spring 1919: WW1 is over and a fragile peace has descended over the country. Now living in Cambridge with husband Edmond, Amy Derwent is settling into her new life as wife and mother to little Beth. But the shadow of the Great War looms large, particularly as the injuries Edmond sustained at Ypres still take their toll on him today.
Edmond’s cousin, Vicky, has now grown into a fine young woman, eager to help her country. Throwing off her privileged background to train as a nurse, she spends her days tending to the many soldiers still suffering the after-effects of their time on the battlefield.
Meeting Maxim Duclos, a young Frenchman who has arrived in Larchbury, fills her heart with joy - but when it is discovered that Maxim may be hiding the truth about his past, Vicky is faced with an impossible choice. Follow her heart’s desire and risk her family’s disapproval or keep her family – but deny herself the chance of true love?
The war may be over, but Edmond, Amy and Vicky must all face a new battle, finding their own peace in a country wounded by loss.
ebook
Published October 28, 2020
1 person is currently reading
30 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews
June 19, 2021
Really dragged my feet with this one, it took me ages to read. I was determined not to give up but found it a difficult and frustrating read, the main reason is that it's part of a series and I hadn't previously read the other books. Most times this happens it doesn't seem to matter because the story recaps past events and characters, but this wasn't the case. So I would say that this book didn't work for me as a stand alone, I might have had a different opinion if I had read the other books. Found the story to be very upper class.
October 25, 2020
I am excited to be taking part in the #BlogTour for Rosemary Goodacre's final installment in the Derwent Chronicles Trilogy UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE.
After reading the first two books in quick succession I was excited to discover the final part of the trilogy UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE so soon after and couldn't wait to find out how things played out for the young Derwent couple. Rosemary loved my reviews for the first two but sadly she passed away just two weeks ago and did not live to see her last book published. I was deeply saddened to hear of Rosemary's passing as her books are just so easy to read and immerse yourself into the era. She will be missed by many in the literary community as well as her fans.
1919: Picking up from where the previous book "Until the War is Over" left off, the story begins with Amy and Edmond finally able to settle into their new home in Cambridge with baby Beth whilst Edmond studies at the university nearby. After being wounded during the war, Edmond has taken a long time recovering and even then he still tires easily, what with having part of his lung removed as a result of his injuries. As Amy was a VAD nurse during the war, her abilities have always been needed at one time or another caring, more recently nursing Edmond's mother during the Spanish flu. But now that her mother-in-law has recovered, Amy is finally able to join Edmond in Cambridge having been separated for many months after first her surgery to repair her broken ankle and then caring for Ma.
Amy's friend Florence has now married her cousin James and Lavinia and Charles are also about to enjoy a lavish wedding at her home in Alderbank. Edmond's sister Beatrice is still seeing her American beau, Caleb, much to her mother's chagrin as he is but a Warrant Officer and not someone of a higher rank and class which is far more desired for a lady such as Beatrice was raised to be. Edmond's cousin Vicky,who had been a frequent visitor to The Beeches over the years, as the daughter of Ma's brother, is now a young woman and pursuing a career as a nurse...training in nearby Wealden.
Although the war has been over for a year, James was still with the army as a medical orderly and awaiting his discharge papers, whilst Caleb was sent to the Rhineland to oversee the occupation and the peace treaty with Germany. Despite the end of hostilities, tensions are still rife regarding Germans and the horrors they inflicted on Britain and her Allies. Whilst some thought it was time to put the tensions behind them, to forgive and move on, many refused to entertain such notions.
When young Maxim Dulcos arrives with Edmond's older brother Peter from Europe as his guest, Vicky notices the young Frenchman immediately. The two begin a tentative courtship stealing moments between their respective jobs. As a chef, Maxim desires to live and work in England so the local vicar finds him lodgings with Miss Miller who lives next door to Amy's parents and work in the local inn as a chef.
But when there are whispers about Maxim's true identity going around in Larchbury village, questions arise as to what he may be hiding. And Vicky then finds herself faced with an impossible choice - to follow her heart or risk her family disapproval?
Following on from the previous book, UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE takes place between 1919 and 1921 as the country moves into a new decade with new ideas and a far different world than before. Rosemary has done a wonderful job of continuing the story of Amy and Edmond and their respective families as if I had come straight from the previous book without taking a breath. Whilst the struggles and worries are real, there is a real sense of moving on without complaint.
As with both the previous two books "Until We Meet Again" and "Until the War is Over" , UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE is a fitting ending to the trilogy bringing closure to each of the stories as well as giving hope and promise for the future. It was refreshing to see Beatrice, particularly, morph into a much more likeable character than the spoilt ornament she was at the beginning. Her character was the most surprising and refreshing to see her grow from the world for which she was brought up in to the one she now inhabits. Seeing the attitudes of people change over the course of the trilogy has been exhilarating as we see how friendships and relationships overcome their differences.
Although UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE is the third and final installment of this wonderful trilogy, it can easily be read as a standalone as previous important incidents that had taken place in the previous two books are referred to in enough detail so as to not confuse the reader. However, I do recommend reading them all from the beginning as it is such a wonderful journey back in time and a delightful and engaging read.
My only regret is that there will be no more, since Rosemary's passing just two weeks ago. But while the world has lost an engaging storyteller, at least her stories will live on in her memory.
Perfect for fans of wartime fiction, particularly World War One.
I would like to thank #RosemaryGoodacre, #NetGalley, #RachelsRandomResources and #HeraBooks for an ARC of #UntilWeCanForgive in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
After reading the first two books in quick succession I was excited to discover the final part of the trilogy UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE so soon after and couldn't wait to find out how things played out for the young Derwent couple. Rosemary loved my reviews for the first two but sadly she passed away just two weeks ago and did not live to see her last book published. I was deeply saddened to hear of Rosemary's passing as her books are just so easy to read and immerse yourself into the era. She will be missed by many in the literary community as well as her fans.
1919: Picking up from where the previous book "Until the War is Over" left off, the story begins with Amy and Edmond finally able to settle into their new home in Cambridge with baby Beth whilst Edmond studies at the university nearby. After being wounded during the war, Edmond has taken a long time recovering and even then he still tires easily, what with having part of his lung removed as a result of his injuries. As Amy was a VAD nurse during the war, her abilities have always been needed at one time or another caring, more recently nursing Edmond's mother during the Spanish flu. But now that her mother-in-law has recovered, Amy is finally able to join Edmond in Cambridge having been separated for many months after first her surgery to repair her broken ankle and then caring for Ma.
Amy's friend Florence has now married her cousin James and Lavinia and Charles are also about to enjoy a lavish wedding at her home in Alderbank. Edmond's sister Beatrice is still seeing her American beau, Caleb, much to her mother's chagrin as he is but a Warrant Officer and not someone of a higher rank and class which is far more desired for a lady such as Beatrice was raised to be. Edmond's cousin Vicky,who had been a frequent visitor to The Beeches over the years, as the daughter of Ma's brother, is now a young woman and pursuing a career as a nurse...training in nearby Wealden.
Although the war has been over for a year, James was still with the army as a medical orderly and awaiting his discharge papers, whilst Caleb was sent to the Rhineland to oversee the occupation and the peace treaty with Germany. Despite the end of hostilities, tensions are still rife regarding Germans and the horrors they inflicted on Britain and her Allies. Whilst some thought it was time to put the tensions behind them, to forgive and move on, many refused to entertain such notions.
When young Maxim Dulcos arrives with Edmond's older brother Peter from Europe as his guest, Vicky notices the young Frenchman immediately. The two begin a tentative courtship stealing moments between their respective jobs. As a chef, Maxim desires to live and work in England so the local vicar finds him lodgings with Miss Miller who lives next door to Amy's parents and work in the local inn as a chef.
But when there are whispers about Maxim's true identity going around in Larchbury village, questions arise as to what he may be hiding. And Vicky then finds herself faced with an impossible choice - to follow her heart or risk her family disapproval?
Following on from the previous book, UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE takes place between 1919 and 1921 as the country moves into a new decade with new ideas and a far different world than before. Rosemary has done a wonderful job of continuing the story of Amy and Edmond and their respective families as if I had come straight from the previous book without taking a breath. Whilst the struggles and worries are real, there is a real sense of moving on without complaint.
As with both the previous two books "Until We Meet Again" and "Until the War is Over" , UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE is a fitting ending to the trilogy bringing closure to each of the stories as well as giving hope and promise for the future. It was refreshing to see Beatrice, particularly, morph into a much more likeable character than the spoilt ornament she was at the beginning. Her character was the most surprising and refreshing to see her grow from the world for which she was brought up in to the one she now inhabits. Seeing the attitudes of people change over the course of the trilogy has been exhilarating as we see how friendships and relationships overcome their differences.
Although UNTIL WE CAN FORGIVE is the third and final installment of this wonderful trilogy, it can easily be read as a standalone as previous important incidents that had taken place in the previous two books are referred to in enough detail so as to not confuse the reader. However, I do recommend reading them all from the beginning as it is such a wonderful journey back in time and a delightful and engaging read.
My only regret is that there will be no more, since Rosemary's passing just two weeks ago. But while the world has lost an engaging storyteller, at least her stories will live on in her memory.
Perfect for fans of wartime fiction, particularly World War One.
I would like to thank #RosemaryGoodacre, #NetGalley, #RachelsRandomResources and #HeraBooks for an ARC of #UntilWeCanForgive in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
October 30, 2020
I have been a fan of Rosemary's work ever since I was lucky enough to be offered the chance to review her debut novel 'Until We Meet Again' when it was released in October 2019. That was the first book in 'The Derwent Chronicles' trilogy. The third instalment is called 'Until We Can Forgive' and it was released in October 2020. It's another cracking and compelling read, which I thoroughly enjoyed but more about that in a bit.
I was drawn into 'Until We Can Forgive' from the moment I clapped eyes on the cover and as soon as I saw Rosemary's name, I just knew that I would have to read it as soon as I could. I had thoroughly enjoyed the previous books in the series and I had to know how the story concluded and how that impacted on some of the characters. I grabbed a cup of tea, grabbed my copy of the book and settled down for a right good read. I found that I just couldn't put the book down for very long at all. I was so wrapped up in the story that I couldn't bear to be parted from the book for any length of time, so the book literally travelled everywhere with me. I began reading the book on a dark and wet morning and I finished reading the book mid afternoon of the same day, which is pretty good going for me.
'Until We Can Forgive' is superbly written but then I thought that to be true of Rosemary's previous books too. She had a way of grabbing your attention at the start and then drawing you into the story. Rosemary clearly did a lot of research into the First World War and this shines through in her books. As well as being a book geek, I am a history nerd with a particular focus on the First and Second World Wars so I already knew a fair bit about them. Rosemary used such vivid and realistic descriptions that she gave me a real sense of what it must have been like to live through the First World War. I never knew my grandparents and great grandparents so reading books such as Rosemary's gives me a greater appreciation of what they had to go through. I really felt as though I was part of the story and I kept feeling as though I wanted to jump inside the pages of the book to sort certain characters out and to give them what for. I know this is a fictional book but I find that if I enjoy a book as much as I enjoyed reading 'Until We Can Forgive', then I tend to 'live' the story as if it were real.
In short, I thoroughly enjoyed reading 'Until We Can Forgive'. It's a fitting end to what is a fantastic trilogy. I will certainly be recommending this trilogy to other readers. The score on the Ginger Book Geek board is a very well deserved 5* out of 5*.
(PS) The eagle eyed among you may have noticed that I have referred to Rosemary in the past tense. Sadly Rosemary passed away suddenly and unexpectedly following a recent short illness. I was never lucky enough to be able to meet Rosemary in person but we were in touch on social media. Rosemary was a lovely lady and my heart goes out to her family and friends at this sad time. x
I was drawn into 'Until We Can Forgive' from the moment I clapped eyes on the cover and as soon as I saw Rosemary's name, I just knew that I would have to read it as soon as I could. I had thoroughly enjoyed the previous books in the series and I had to know how the story concluded and how that impacted on some of the characters. I grabbed a cup of tea, grabbed my copy of the book and settled down for a right good read. I found that I just couldn't put the book down for very long at all. I was so wrapped up in the story that I couldn't bear to be parted from the book for any length of time, so the book literally travelled everywhere with me. I began reading the book on a dark and wet morning and I finished reading the book mid afternoon of the same day, which is pretty good going for me.
'Until We Can Forgive' is superbly written but then I thought that to be true of Rosemary's previous books too. She had a way of grabbing your attention at the start and then drawing you into the story. Rosemary clearly did a lot of research into the First World War and this shines through in her books. As well as being a book geek, I am a history nerd with a particular focus on the First and Second World Wars so I already knew a fair bit about them. Rosemary used such vivid and realistic descriptions that she gave me a real sense of what it must have been like to live through the First World War. I never knew my grandparents and great grandparents so reading books such as Rosemary's gives me a greater appreciation of what they had to go through. I really felt as though I was part of the story and I kept feeling as though I wanted to jump inside the pages of the book to sort certain characters out and to give them what for. I know this is a fictional book but I find that if I enjoy a book as much as I enjoyed reading 'Until We Can Forgive', then I tend to 'live' the story as if it were real.
In short, I thoroughly enjoyed reading 'Until We Can Forgive'. It's a fitting end to what is a fantastic trilogy. I will certainly be recommending this trilogy to other readers. The score on the Ginger Book Geek board is a very well deserved 5* out of 5*.
(PS) The eagle eyed among you may have noticed that I have referred to Rosemary in the past tense. Sadly Rosemary passed away suddenly and unexpectedly following a recent short illness. I was never lucky enough to be able to meet Rosemary in person but we were in touch on social media. Rosemary was a lovely lady and my heart goes out to her family and friends at this sad time. x
December 13, 2020
I've been so lucky to have read the previous two novels in this trilogy; Until We Meet Again and Until the War is Over - I highly recommend you grab yourself copies of these.
Edmond and Amy Derwent are our central characters, and they are characters that we have now followed through three novels. We have followed their relationship from when it was just a fleeting glance, all the way through to their marriage and the birth of their beautiful daughter Beth. I love a book series that allow me to become invested in characters, and Rosemarie Goodacre provides us with this opportunity beautifully.
Until We Can Forgive focuses on the time following the end of WWI - most families have suffered losses, and the Spanish Flu pandemic is finally abating. War injuries are impacting many lives, but despite these many obstacles families are working hard to rebuild their lives whilst establishing their new normal.
Edmond and Amy's friends and family have all been affected in some way by the war. Vicky, Edmonds cousin, was too young to really have had any involvement in the war effort. However, seeing her friends and family playing their part has inspired her future. Despite her privileged upbringing, she is keen to assist in the rebuilding of her country. Inspired by Amy and the hundreds of other women who assisted their injured men, both on the front and at home, she is adamant that she wants to train and work as a nurse. When she meets Maxim, a young Frenchman, she discovers a love that she could never have anticipated existing. As we all know though, the road to love is never smooth...
I have loved following Edmond, Amy, their family and friends. Larchbury was hit by much tragedy during the Great War as many small communities were, but seeing them come out of the other side has been wonderful to follow. The community spirit is so evident, and there seemed to be very much a 'can do' attitude. Clearly worries for the future remained, but hope is very clearly depicted in Rosemarie's writing. I am more than happy to recommend this novel to you all (although I do recommend you reading all three novels in the series) - I love reading wartime fiction, I love the hopefulness that existed even in the face of adversity. Rosemary Goodacre has given us an excellent example of such writing.
This is a bittersweet review. Very sadly, Rosemarie Goodacre passed away a few short weeks ago. I am however honoured to have been a part of the blog tour for her final novel, and would like to thank Rachel at Rachel's Random Resources and Hera Books for inviting me to be a part of it, and for providing me with a copy of the novel. My review is all my own, honest opinions.
Edmond and Amy Derwent are our central characters, and they are characters that we have now followed through three novels. We have followed their relationship from when it was just a fleeting glance, all the way through to their marriage and the birth of their beautiful daughter Beth. I love a book series that allow me to become invested in characters, and Rosemarie Goodacre provides us with this opportunity beautifully.
Until We Can Forgive focuses on the time following the end of WWI - most families have suffered losses, and the Spanish Flu pandemic is finally abating. War injuries are impacting many lives, but despite these many obstacles families are working hard to rebuild their lives whilst establishing their new normal.
Edmond and Amy's friends and family have all been affected in some way by the war. Vicky, Edmonds cousin, was too young to really have had any involvement in the war effort. However, seeing her friends and family playing their part has inspired her future. Despite her privileged upbringing, she is keen to assist in the rebuilding of her country. Inspired by Amy and the hundreds of other women who assisted their injured men, both on the front and at home, she is adamant that she wants to train and work as a nurse. When she meets Maxim, a young Frenchman, she discovers a love that she could never have anticipated existing. As we all know though, the road to love is never smooth...
I have loved following Edmond, Amy, their family and friends. Larchbury was hit by much tragedy during the Great War as many small communities were, but seeing them come out of the other side has been wonderful to follow. The community spirit is so evident, and there seemed to be very much a 'can do' attitude. Clearly worries for the future remained, but hope is very clearly depicted in Rosemarie's writing. I am more than happy to recommend this novel to you all (although I do recommend you reading all three novels in the series) - I love reading wartime fiction, I love the hopefulness that existed even in the face of adversity. Rosemary Goodacre has given us an excellent example of such writing.
This is a bittersweet review. Very sadly, Rosemarie Goodacre passed away a few short weeks ago. I am however honoured to have been a part of the blog tour for her final novel, and would like to thank Rachel at Rachel's Random Resources and Hera Books for inviting me to be a part of it, and for providing me with a copy of the novel. My review is all my own, honest opinions.
November 26, 2020
Until We Can Forgive, the third book in the Derwent Chronicles trilogy, follows straight on from Until The War is Over, and we are back with Amy, Edmond and their daughter Beth who are settling into life in Cambridge. Edmond is at university, studying for his future, despite still recovering from his injuries sustained in Ypres, while Amy is delighted her little family are finally able to be together.
The gentle language of this book perfectly fits with the period it is written about, portraying life in Britain as it enters the 1920’s. The war is over, but things will never be the same as they were before and lots of young men are still commissioned, working away in France or Germany. Back in Larchbury, where Edmond and Beth grew up, many families are grieving the loss of a son and there is divided opinion on the Germans. While some feel there needs to be peace between nations, others can’t bring themselves to forgive and foreigners are treated with suspicion. When a young French chef arrives, his accent and foreign ways make some uneasy, but with a few friends and a growing fondness for Edmond’s cousin Vicky, he does his best to settle in, until a scandal about his past comes to light. The villagers are quick to decide his fate, jumping to their own conclusions with little understanding of the facts.
The young people we have been following throughout the trilogy are doing their best to settle into the new period. There are weddings, babies and choices to be made that pre-war would have been unthinkable. Daughters falling in love and being determined to follow their heart rather than the social protocol they have been brought up with. Married women who have experienced the independence of working, now wanting more than just being a housewife and mother. It is not always easy for the older generation to understand.
Their war is over, but they still find themselves in difficult situations, facing loss, grief and tough decisions. I really enjoyed getting a glimpse into life at this time as we followed their journeys, including an emotional visit to a cemetery in France.
If you enjoy historical fiction, do give this trilogy a go.
The gentle language of this book perfectly fits with the period it is written about, portraying life in Britain as it enters the 1920’s. The war is over, but things will never be the same as they were before and lots of young men are still commissioned, working away in France or Germany. Back in Larchbury, where Edmond and Beth grew up, many families are grieving the loss of a son and there is divided opinion on the Germans. While some feel there needs to be peace between nations, others can’t bring themselves to forgive and foreigners are treated with suspicion. When a young French chef arrives, his accent and foreign ways make some uneasy, but with a few friends and a growing fondness for Edmond’s cousin Vicky, he does his best to settle in, until a scandal about his past comes to light. The villagers are quick to decide his fate, jumping to their own conclusions with little understanding of the facts.
The young people we have been following throughout the trilogy are doing their best to settle into the new period. There are weddings, babies and choices to be made that pre-war would have been unthinkable. Daughters falling in love and being determined to follow their heart rather than the social protocol they have been brought up with. Married women who have experienced the independence of working, now wanting more than just being a housewife and mother. It is not always easy for the older generation to understand.
Their war is over, but they still find themselves in difficult situations, facing loss, grief and tough decisions. I really enjoyed getting a glimpse into life at this time as we followed their journeys, including an emotional visit to a cemetery in France.
If you enjoy historical fiction, do give this trilogy a go.
October 16, 2020
This is the third book in The Derwent Chronicles and continues the story of the characters from the previous books. Because this is an ongoing story I am going to say it would be better to read the books in order, but they also do work as stand-alone.
This is set just after the end of World War I, some men have returned home, some are still in Europe and of course, there are those that will never return. The author does such a wonderful job of depicting life as people try to look forward, to new starts and also to peace. For families to return to some sort of normality and daily routine.
While this book doesn't have the danger of the War there are still plenty of other things going on in everyday life that add drama, tension and also danger. Everyone has lost someone and feelings over the repatriation of the fallen is mentioned along with Poppy Day, the building of the Cenotaph and also the troops that remain in occupied Germany.
While some have been discharged due to injuries there are still those who are enlisted. Each one has there own problems whether it is coming to terms with living a civilian life or wanting to be back home with loved ones. There is still animosity towards Germany and also a wariness with the Americans, the country wants to get back to how things were but with so much change there has to be compromise.
The author has done a wonderful job of continuing the story of Amy and her husband Edmond and those that cross their paths. There is a real sense of wanting to get on and not to complain, worry or moan as things are still fresh from the years during the war. As I mentioned, this has a different backdrop but there are still struggles and worries.
A wonderful next instalment in this saga that sees how opinions of family and friends can make things difficult, how friendships and relationships can overcome differences. It is one for those who love historical fiction, sagas and family life. A wonderful read that had me hooked and One I would definitely recommend.
This is set just after the end of World War I, some men have returned home, some are still in Europe and of course, there are those that will never return. The author does such a wonderful job of depicting life as people try to look forward, to new starts and also to peace. For families to return to some sort of normality and daily routine.
While this book doesn't have the danger of the War there are still plenty of other things going on in everyday life that add drama, tension and also danger. Everyone has lost someone and feelings over the repatriation of the fallen is mentioned along with Poppy Day, the building of the Cenotaph and also the troops that remain in occupied Germany.
While some have been discharged due to injuries there are still those who are enlisted. Each one has there own problems whether it is coming to terms with living a civilian life or wanting to be back home with loved ones. There is still animosity towards Germany and also a wariness with the Americans, the country wants to get back to how things were but with so much change there has to be compromise.
The author has done a wonderful job of continuing the story of Amy and her husband Edmond and those that cross their paths. There is a real sense of wanting to get on and not to complain, worry or moan as things are still fresh from the years during the war. As I mentioned, this has a different backdrop but there are still struggles and worries.
A wonderful next instalment in this saga that sees how opinions of family and friends can make things difficult, how friendships and relationships can overcome differences. It is one for those who love historical fiction, sagas and family life. A wonderful read that had me hooked and One I would definitely recommend.
November 2, 2020
This isn’t the first novel I have read of Rosemary Goodacre and I have loved all the previous one, just like I enjoyed this one.
Sadly, Rosemary Goodacre passed away earlier in October. We’re honouring her memory with her last book and blog tour, finishing off the trilogy that she leaves as a legacy.
It broke my heart when I learned this news, but it got me thinking about the amazing stories she have left us to remember her.
Something me and my younger brother have in common is that we like to learn about history. Yes, I love to read, and he’s not that into it. But every time I buy a National Geographic magazine about any of the World Wars, he asks me to read it. So I would like to think that, if he was more open about fictional books, and not just small articles, he may enjoyed Rosemary Goodacre’s Saga.
That’s the power of her words and stories, they take us to a time period full of emotions and tell us the story of characters that could have been our ancestors.
In “Until We Can Forgive” we pick up from were we left in the previous book, following a group of characters, Amy and Edmond, Vicky, Maxim… It’s was like being in the middle of them, being a part of the family (blood related and friends). I touched my heart each page, reading about the dreams, goals and accomplishments. About the obstacles and about the love between each other.
Overall, I loved it. And I can’t recommend it enough. If you want to go on an emotional journey through that era, this series is definitely for you.
[I want to thank Rachel, at Rachel’s Random Resources, and Rosemary Goodacre and Hera Books for the eCopy of this book and for allowing me to join in the fun and being a part of the blog tour with my honest review of the book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.]
Sadly, Rosemary Goodacre passed away earlier in October. We’re honouring her memory with her last book and blog tour, finishing off the trilogy that she leaves as a legacy.
It broke my heart when I learned this news, but it got me thinking about the amazing stories she have left us to remember her.
Something me and my younger brother have in common is that we like to learn about history. Yes, I love to read, and he’s not that into it. But every time I buy a National Geographic magazine about any of the World Wars, he asks me to read it. So I would like to think that, if he was more open about fictional books, and not just small articles, he may enjoyed Rosemary Goodacre’s Saga.
That’s the power of her words and stories, they take us to a time period full of emotions and tell us the story of characters that could have been our ancestors.
In “Until We Can Forgive” we pick up from were we left in the previous book, following a group of characters, Amy and Edmond, Vicky, Maxim… It’s was like being in the middle of them, being a part of the family (blood related and friends). I touched my heart each page, reading about the dreams, goals and accomplishments. About the obstacles and about the love between each other.
Overall, I loved it. And I can’t recommend it enough. If you want to go on an emotional journey through that era, this series is definitely for you.
[I want to thank Rachel, at Rachel’s Random Resources, and Rosemary Goodacre and Hera Books for the eCopy of this book and for allowing me to join in the fun and being a part of the blog tour with my honest review of the book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.]
October 12, 2020
Until We Can Forgive is the third book in a historical fiction series set around the First World War. The book follows the years after the Great War, and it shows the characters wanting to move on after the everlasting impact the war had on their lives. There is that question of being able to forgive, a theme that runs strongly throughout the novel, and with the memories of the previous four years still raw in their minds, for most, it appears this is impossible.
The war brought about change, and this was evident in the story as it showed the characters trying to adjust. I experienced a wave of emotions when reading the book, and all I wanted was for everything to work out for the characters who deserved it. As is life, not everyone can forgive.
Although I have not read the previous two novels, I still felt I could connect with the characters and knew them well from the beginning. I was introduced to quite a few characters in the earlier chapters and sensed there was more to them, that if I had read the previous two books, I would have known. However, I remained engaged with the story; I had my suspicions about one character, another I did not like, and others that I cared about what happened to them. I felt a deep connection between the characters that had fought together or worked together during the war.
There were discussions about a few incidents that had taken place in the previous books, that had me curious; this did not distract from the storyline, the book stood well on its own. I remained involved and wanting to know more about the earlier years that I now intend to read the previous two novels.
The book is well-researched, the author knows her history, and I felt a real sense of the era.
I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys World War One fiction, and I look forward to reading the earlier two novels, and more from this author.
The war brought about change, and this was evident in the story as it showed the characters trying to adjust. I experienced a wave of emotions when reading the book, and all I wanted was for everything to work out for the characters who deserved it. As is life, not everyone can forgive.
Although I have not read the previous two novels, I still felt I could connect with the characters and knew them well from the beginning. I was introduced to quite a few characters in the earlier chapters and sensed there was more to them, that if I had read the previous two books, I would have known. However, I remained engaged with the story; I had my suspicions about one character, another I did not like, and others that I cared about what happened to them. I felt a deep connection between the characters that had fought together or worked together during the war.
There were discussions about a few incidents that had taken place in the previous books, that had me curious; this did not distract from the storyline, the book stood well on its own. I remained involved and wanting to know more about the earlier years that I now intend to read the previous two novels.
The book is well-researched, the author knows her history, and I felt a real sense of the era.
I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys World War One fiction, and I look forward to reading the earlier two novels, and more from this author.
October 30, 2020
Until We Can Forgive by Rosemary Goodacre is a light-hearted account of the several years after World War I. This particular story takes place in England amongst upper middle class young adults who are marrying and have babies. There is a particular hatred here for anything German after the losses suffered in the war. These people are all very proper, not written to have any depth, not appearing to feel deeply, although I am sure they do. The characters in this book are all pretty superficial. Amy is married to Edmond who damaged his lungs during the war. He has returned to England to take up his studies at university. Amy is at home with their daughter, Beth. They had been married when both of them were at war, she as a nurse. Edmond is not fully recovered, so Amy worries. The other characters in this book are friends and family, all living their lives.
Maybe this is the English stiff upper lip. It was ad oddly distant telling of a very emotional time. The story takes place over several years and is pretty much a slice of life novel Weddings, babies, miscarriages, a trip to Europe to visit the grave of Amy's brother who died there, et al. Everything seems to turn out for this people. It is kind of a surreal feeling to read this book, which has no depth. The characterizations are shallow, with very little time spent delving into them. This is the third book in the series, so obviously someone loves it. It is a peek into the lives of returning soldiers as well as those left behind.
I was invited to read a free ARC of Until We Can Forgive by Netgalley. All opinions and interpretations contained herein are solely my own. #netgalley #untilwecanforgive
Maybe this is the English stiff upper lip. It was ad oddly distant telling of a very emotional time. The story takes place over several years and is pretty much a slice of life novel Weddings, babies, miscarriages, a trip to Europe to visit the grave of Amy's brother who died there, et al. Everything seems to turn out for this people. It is kind of a surreal feeling to read this book, which has no depth. The characterizations are shallow, with very little time spent delving into them. This is the third book in the series, so obviously someone loves it. It is a peek into the lives of returning soldiers as well as those left behind.
I was invited to read a free ARC of Until We Can Forgive by Netgalley. All opinions and interpretations contained herein are solely my own. #netgalley #untilwecanforgive
October 30, 2020
I have read many books set in the First World War and very much enjoyed the first two books in this engaging trilogy, but this third instalment is a little different. What was life like once the war was over? Young men returning injured, many not returning at all, a shortage of men of marriageable age, women finding new skills and freedom and going out to work for the first time, and suspicions about all things German. A nicely presented snapshot of a period of great change, but also a chance for readers to find out what happened to Amy, Edmond and all the other characters from the earlier books. An enjoyable and hopeful end to their story, although sadly there can be no more after the very sudden and unexpected death of the author. RIP Rosemary.
November 2, 2020
Until We Can Forgive by Rosemary Goodacre
I must gush on the beauty of the book cover. This was the reason why I signed up for this book blog tour.
The writing style of the author is nice. It is so easy to read and understand.
The plot is interesting too.
This is the first book by the author I am reading and she did a good job.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are mine.
I must gush on the beauty of the book cover. This was the reason why I signed up for this book blog tour.
The writing style of the author is nice. It is so easy to read and understand.
The plot is interesting too.
This is the first book by the author I am reading and she did a good job.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are mine.
June 23, 2021
This is what I believe to be a beautiful end to this trilogy, it moves through a longer duration to the other two books in this series, but maintains the story line of the families involved in the books.
Another amazing aspect of this book is the ending, as it does leaving you wanting more, but not on a cliffhanger. I definitely recommend this to anyone who loves reading or the series to anyone who wants to get into reading!
Another amazing aspect of this book is the ending, as it does leaving you wanting more, but not on a cliffhanger. I definitely recommend this to anyone who loves reading or the series to anyone who wants to get into reading!
October 29, 2020
This third novel in The Derwent Chronicles sees Edmund and Amy, who have courted, married and survived the war in the previous two novels, begin to build a life in post-war Cambridge. Despite their best efforts to forge a hopeful new life and begin to build bridges with their recent enemy, the people of their acquaintance seem less willing to move forward into a lasting peace.
Rosemary Goodacre writes with clear knowledge of, and enthusiasm for, the post-WW1 period, and the book has obviously been thoroughly researched, allowing us to be drawn completely into Edmund and Amy’s world. The social and class norms of the day may seem foreign to us now, but you get a great sense of the battles that the couple have had to fight to be together, being as they are of a different class.
The examination of attitudes towards the Germans in this book is really interesting – you can well imagine that many who had lost loved ones may feel that harsh sanctions would be fully deserved and that it would be impossible to forgive, while some characters put forward the view that it is more important to forge new friendships and move forward in the spirit of forgiveness. We all know how it turned out in the end, but it is interesting to see both viewpoints put forward here.
While reading this book I was informed that, sadly, Rosemary Goodacre had recently passed away. It is incredibly sad that Rosemary’s clear love of this period in history and love of writing will not be brought to bear on any future novels. The three books in the Derwent Chronicles are a fitting legacy.
Rosemary Goodacre writes with clear knowledge of, and enthusiasm for, the post-WW1 period, and the book has obviously been thoroughly researched, allowing us to be drawn completely into Edmund and Amy’s world. The social and class norms of the day may seem foreign to us now, but you get a great sense of the battles that the couple have had to fight to be together, being as they are of a different class.
The examination of attitudes towards the Germans in this book is really interesting – you can well imagine that many who had lost loved ones may feel that harsh sanctions would be fully deserved and that it would be impossible to forgive, while some characters put forward the view that it is more important to forge new friendships and move forward in the spirit of forgiveness. We all know how it turned out in the end, but it is interesting to see both viewpoints put forward here.
While reading this book I was informed that, sadly, Rosemary Goodacre had recently passed away. It is incredibly sad that Rosemary’s clear love of this period in history and love of writing will not be brought to bear on any future novels. The three books in the Derwent Chronicles are a fitting legacy.
May 23, 2021
Having so enjoyed the first two books in the Derwent Chronicles, I couldn't wait to get hold of this one so I could read it.
A thoroughly enjoyable trilogy; I was so sad to learn of the author's death, meaning that there are no more to look forward to :(
A thoroughly enjoyable trilogy; I was so sad to learn of the author's death, meaning that there are no more to look forward to :(
January 1, 2021
Review to come! So sad to hear of this author's passing. I enjoyed her books and am saddened at the news of her death.
December 1, 2023
What a fantastic story of determination and love
March 18, 2025
This doesn't often happen but I'm afraid I've given this one the elbow. I found it a bit dull and it didn't keep me interested. I read almost one third before I decided to call it a day. Sorry!
October 28, 2020
Until We Can Forgive is the final book in the Derwent Chronicles trilogy by the late Rosemary Goodacre. Sadly the author passed away before this book was published. She was a lovely woman, a very talented author and she will be sorely missed. Reading this book knowing that Rosemary had passed away made it an even more emotional read for me, and knowing this review will be the last one I do for one of her books brings tears to my eyes. May she rest in peace, and may I do her last book justice with my review.
Although a part of a trilogy Until We Can Forgive can be read as a standalone. Major events that happened in the first two books are mentioned and explained enough in this book that you aren't left wondering what you have missed. That said, having read the previous books I had more of an insight into what the characters were like and what they had been through. I would recommend that you read the other books, 'Until the War is Over' and 'Until We Meet Again' first.
The previous books were set during World War 1. We were introduced to Edmond and Amy and their families and we read about their parts in the war, and how it affected them. This book tells us about their lives after the war is over.
Amy is loving being a mother to her daughter, Beth, and of course, being married to Edmond. She worries about him because he is trying to carry on with making a career for himself despite the injuries he sustained during the war. Those injuries nearly saw him die and he has been left weak since his recovery.
Beatrice, Edmond's sister finds herself falling for Caleb, an American. He is still enlisted in the army and is part of the military that is helping to settle things in Europe in the aftermath of the war. They don't see each other often, and Beatrice wonders if there could be a future for them. Surely he won't want to stay in England, but just as surely she would not want to move to America.
Vicky, Edmond's cousin decides she wants to work as a nurse and begins her training. Her love interest is Maxim Duclos, a French man and friend of Peter (Edmond's brother) who has come to England to find work and to get away from the anger that is still very much present in his homeland since the war. He has secrets, ones that could put pay to any chance Vicky and he has for a relationship.
Amy's friends Florence and Lavinia have found love with James and Charles respectively and it is a pleasure to read about their happiness.
Does everybody from the previous books have a happy ever after, absolutely not, but those that don't are those that don't deserve one! Reading of their comeuppance was wonderful especially as it was a long time coming. Rosemary really rounded off this trilogy perfectly. We see our favourite people find their loves, but we also see how there are many trials and tribulations still to deal with even though the war is over. There are some very emotional scenes that made me cry, but for the most part, this was an uplifting story showing how one family and the people closest to it managed their lives before, during and after the war.
This has been a wonderful trilogy that I am sure to read again. I couldn't help but get involved in the fictional lives of its characters especially as their stories take place during a time that was very real, World War 1. There was plenty of factual information given about what life was like then to make me realise just how much work and research the author put into writing these books. They will be her legacy and that is a lovely thought.
Although a part of a trilogy Until We Can Forgive can be read as a standalone. Major events that happened in the first two books are mentioned and explained enough in this book that you aren't left wondering what you have missed. That said, having read the previous books I had more of an insight into what the characters were like and what they had been through. I would recommend that you read the other books, 'Until the War is Over' and 'Until We Meet Again' first.
The previous books were set during World War 1. We were introduced to Edmond and Amy and their families and we read about their parts in the war, and how it affected them. This book tells us about their lives after the war is over.
Amy is loving being a mother to her daughter, Beth, and of course, being married to Edmond. She worries about him because he is trying to carry on with making a career for himself despite the injuries he sustained during the war. Those injuries nearly saw him die and he has been left weak since his recovery.
Beatrice, Edmond's sister finds herself falling for Caleb, an American. He is still enlisted in the army and is part of the military that is helping to settle things in Europe in the aftermath of the war. They don't see each other often, and Beatrice wonders if there could be a future for them. Surely he won't want to stay in England, but just as surely she would not want to move to America.
Vicky, Edmond's cousin decides she wants to work as a nurse and begins her training. Her love interest is Maxim Duclos, a French man and friend of Peter (Edmond's brother) who has come to England to find work and to get away from the anger that is still very much present in his homeland since the war. He has secrets, ones that could put pay to any chance Vicky and he has for a relationship.
Amy's friends Florence and Lavinia have found love with James and Charles respectively and it is a pleasure to read about their happiness.
Does everybody from the previous books have a happy ever after, absolutely not, but those that don't are those that don't deserve one! Reading of their comeuppance was wonderful especially as it was a long time coming. Rosemary really rounded off this trilogy perfectly. We see our favourite people find their loves, but we also see how there are many trials and tribulations still to deal with even though the war is over. There are some very emotional scenes that made me cry, but for the most part, this was an uplifting story showing how one family and the people closest to it managed their lives before, during and after the war.
This has been a wonderful trilogy that I am sure to read again. I couldn't help but get involved in the fictional lives of its characters especially as their stories take place during a time that was very real, World War 1. There was plenty of factual information given about what life was like then to make me realise just how much work and research the author put into writing these books. They will be her legacy and that is a lovely thought.
December 21, 2020
Picking up the pieces after war…
Now that WW 1 is over, people are starting to get their lives back on track. For Amy Derwent it means that she can start enjoying her new life as a wife and mother. This little family is now living in Cambridge, but the demons of the War are still looming around the corner, especially to Edmond, as the injuries he sustained are still taking their toll on him.
Edmond’s cousin Vicky is using her skills as a nurse to tend the soldiers who are still suffering after their time on the battlefield. When she meets Maxim Duclos, a Frenchman, she starts to feel what love is. But Maxim is carrying secrets of his past, Vicky has to make a difficult decision.
With the war just over, what can be forgiven? And will finding your own peace possible when the scars of the war run so deep?
I found this a beautiful but also realistic story to read. It shows how people are struggling getting their lives back on track after one of the hardest periods. There is no sugar-coating, making is sound like war is over, it’s all happiness and love now. No, this book tells us that the end of the war is discovering that life as we once knew, is a far away dream.
Amy and Edmond are a wonderful couple to read about. They had their share of problems yet they are making the best of their lives together. Their love is something so palpable and sweet. And even if Edmond is still having a hard time, they stick together and are there for each other, no matter what.
I found Vicky and Maxim’s story bittersweet. I was happy when these two persons found love with each other. Yet it’s rather quickly obvious that Maxim is having a secret. I had my suspicions, and I was sorry when I found out I was right.
But the author instead of making it about someone running away for his terrible past, she changed it in something admirable. This was not only a story about life after war, but also about forgiveness and seeing there is more one side of a story. There are people like Amy, Edmond, Vicky and even more, ready to forgive past mistakes and just think about their future. And I think it’s a strong message. Lingering in the past and keep holding a grudge is not the best of ideas. It keeps you in the past and you cannot move forward. It’s not a quick read, you need to take your time to let all the emotions get in. And even if it’s a part of a series, it can be perfectly read as a standalone, just like I did. But of course, having a background would be nice, so I know for sure that I will read the previous parts too!
Now that WW 1 is over, people are starting to get their lives back on track. For Amy Derwent it means that she can start enjoying her new life as a wife and mother. This little family is now living in Cambridge, but the demons of the War are still looming around the corner, especially to Edmond, as the injuries he sustained are still taking their toll on him.
Edmond’s cousin Vicky is using her skills as a nurse to tend the soldiers who are still suffering after their time on the battlefield. When she meets Maxim Duclos, a Frenchman, she starts to feel what love is. But Maxim is carrying secrets of his past, Vicky has to make a difficult decision.
With the war just over, what can be forgiven? And will finding your own peace possible when the scars of the war run so deep?
I found this a beautiful but also realistic story to read. It shows how people are struggling getting their lives back on track after one of the hardest periods. There is no sugar-coating, making is sound like war is over, it’s all happiness and love now. No, this book tells us that the end of the war is discovering that life as we once knew, is a far away dream.
Amy and Edmond are a wonderful couple to read about. They had their share of problems yet they are making the best of their lives together. Their love is something so palpable and sweet. And even if Edmond is still having a hard time, they stick together and are there for each other, no matter what.
I found Vicky and Maxim’s story bittersweet. I was happy when these two persons found love with each other. Yet it’s rather quickly obvious that Maxim is having a secret. I had my suspicions, and I was sorry when I found out I was right.
But the author instead of making it about someone running away for his terrible past, she changed it in something admirable. This was not only a story about life after war, but also about forgiveness and seeing there is more one side of a story. There are people like Amy, Edmond, Vicky and even more, ready to forgive past mistakes and just think about their future. And I think it’s a strong message. Lingering in the past and keep holding a grudge is not the best of ideas. It keeps you in the past and you cannot move forward. It’s not a quick read, you need to take your time to let all the emotions get in. And even if it’s a part of a series, it can be perfectly read as a standalone, just like I did. But of course, having a background would be nice, so I know for sure that I will read the previous parts too!
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews