I powered through all 7 of these books, which kept me intrigued for a little over a week. They are very complex until you figure out the action really doesn't change too much from book to book. The faces and names vary, as there are new villains within each book, but the action is repetitive and a bit redundant. This is not to say they aren't interesting and fast paced. But there are the same challenges, settings, missions, oaths, contracts, promises and humiliations spread out over the entire (to date) series. Thomas Blackstone comes close to death dozens of times but each time he manages to survive and the baddies suffer loss of limb and ultimately, life. Over and over again.
I thought I had made it to the end of the series only to find there is at least one, possibly two more to get through.
I can't do it.
It seems there are vast swathes of material that are lifted as paragraphs in situ, cut and pasted to describe the armor, the weapons, the archery skills, the famous English Yew bows used by every single archer in these stories. The fighters eat pottage. I know what that is, and I must say it's a bit disgusting. Almost every scene that describes encampment also has it's share of pottage being warmed over the embers of a dying fire. And on that same subject of repetition, I must have seen the same phrases used dozens of times to describe the talismans, the tactics, the will of God and protection of Goddess, page after page, and book after book. After reading the same descriptions so often, I lost a great deal of interest in how they each concluded. You can smell each intrigue a few chapters into each tale. Along with the pottage, they begin to lose their flavor after a while.
The hero/protagonist is Thomas Blackstone, originally an archer who was serving the English King Edward in the leading battle of the series, the famous battle on French soil at Cre`cy in 1350's France. Following that stunning battle, Blackstone is dragged from the field to the young Prince Edward (3) also known as the Black Prince. Blackstone is knighted for his service and for saving the life of the young Prince. That starts their rocky relationship for the next 20+ years. Critically injured, and surviving only by luck and sheer stubborn inner strength, Blackstone eventually recovers only to find he will never again be able to draw his bow and continue the fight as he intended. So he becomes a soldier committed to horse and foot warrior engagements. He fights in every subsequent battle, names of which are recorded in history with terrifying regularity. For purposes of my review I don't think I need to recount each one, only to stress that no matter his injuries, the spirit continues to rally and he survives each and every battle ever mounted. But eventually his luck is challenged and seems to run out. A series of personal misfortunes and tragedies takes a great toll on the young warrior and for a time, he vanishes from sight and falls far from his comrades and their everyday struggles between warring factions and over disputes that kill more than they actually resolve conflicts. Rescued eventually from his self induced stupor and tragic life circumstances, Blackstone returns to the field as the Black Prince's right hand warrior and eventually the King's Master of War. Life surges on for Blackstone and his itinerant troops. He becomes rather a mercenary as well, selling his sword for gold or plunder, buying his freedom one skirmish at a time. Those never end, BTW. One fight is another before one book ends and the next begins.
As the series spins out, Blackstone takes on more tasks involving the politics of the Prince Edward (3), who rather enlists him and his faithful followers to seek ever more determined and diabolical mercenaries and brigands as the nation of France is plunged deeper into chaos and closer to civil war. Kings and princes do not fight as do common men. That point is highlighted repeatedly. Blackstone takes their battles on as his own and overwhelms and overcomes all takers as the stakes grow ever more complex and demand constant armed response to the differences between countries and kings. Almost like the GOP and Democrats, except todays political differences don't use physical swords or daggers, just poisonous editorials and social media as weapons of choice. In our world, there are only corrupt politicians, greed and power. In the world of Thomas Blackstone, there is just vicious fighting and death everywhere.
So, the battles rage and the blood flows rich and rank in the streets, the fields, the mountainous crags and the hidden valleys. The land is unforgiving and yet brutally beautiful, but death lurks at every pass and in every alley.
By book seven, Shadow of the Hawk, I had about my fill of the series. I thought I could move on to another author, another series or another genre. And then I see there is book 8 and possibly book 9.
Sorry, but my interest has declined and I am weary of Thomas Blackstone, no matter who he is fighting for or what demons he may have to face.
I think I did pretty well, for a series that doesn't change very much from book to book. This would have been an insurmountable task to plow through had it been contained in just one or two volumes, but I just can't keep going, 400+ pages at a time, no matter how much I like the characters, the history and the events of the time period.
Maybe I will return to pick up where I left off, but for now I really need a break from the agony of horses dying, the clash of swords and the spilling of blood on battlefields long dead to one world and not developed by our current world, and scarcely remembered by readers today.
This series is absorbing, but because I finally found it a little bit drawn out and over the top for historical dramedy, I am giving it a rest and moving on to something of a more modern age to read. If you like historical reenactment, this series is well worth your time, but be prepared to be overwhelmed at some point in time and possibly, as did I, find yourself needing something a bit more on the current list of books to provide entertainment and history, all at once.
I would note to the author that the series is very well done, but some of the typos and grammatical errors cry out for improved editing and proofreading.
All in all, 4/5.