With a cover like that, how could I not want to pick this one up! Tarnished Empire ended up being total unexpected. I expected this to be mafia captive, hostile enemies to lovers - but this story took me totally off guard. Instead this is more like Romeo and Juliet meets the Blue Lagoon.
The plot starts out like a familiar mafia treat- Alaric, head of his family’s mafia/arms dealing is out for revenge against the man he believes killed his father. But from there, Ava totally delivers a fresh and unique take- a story I didn’t expect. He’s recently delivered a real hit to his enemy’s business, so much so that the enemy’s daughter, Phoenix, a daughter that Alaric knows nothing about, decides to sidling up to Alaric in hopes of gathering intel on him to report back to her father. Of course, that scheme is short lived, and once she’s discovered she finds herself at the mercy of her father’s enemy….and of Alaric’s enemies as well. Which leaves her and Alaric in a unique situation- enemies who have to somehow work together to survive a situation I (or they) never expected.
Alaric is delicious- a strong, dominant, alpha hero with a giant soft heart buried under all his stoic responsibility and hard edge bravado. Not only do we get some sweetness and vulnerability from him, but he’s surprisingly resourceful and clever. His protective nature and passionate emotions had me swooning,and of the two main character, he’s definitely the one who grew and evolved more. HIs characterization felt both consistent and more steadily progressed- which had me really invest in him, not to mention in love.
There is a lot to like about Phoenix- she’s strong willed, loyal, compassionate, and fighter- all things I love in a push-pull heroine. She’s true to her namesake. But, even so, she took a minute for me to warm up to. At times she’s almost too obstinate - a bit foolhardy- which made me respect her a bit less.Her gullible belief she could so easily trick Alaric was so misguided it was comedic, and she stubbornly puts herself in danger repeatedly. Although, I like when Alaric rescues her (swoon), but I couldn’t really get into her until Ava gives us her vulnerability- we see her soft side, learn a bit more about why she’s admirable, resilient but frustratingly stubborn. Eventually, I grew to love her- I just needed some time.
The pacing of this story had me stalling in a few places- we had an interesting and foreboding beginning and then what felt like a lot of exposition to get to the unexpected forced cohabitation, and then we get so deeply into the ins and outs of that existence that the relational elements very slow. I’m glad I pushed through- once these two start to authentically connect and once you figure out just what kind of story this is going to be, I really enjoyed it. There are twists a plenty- just when I thought I’d figured out the plot something else would change direction- and that did keep me engaged. While I found the beginning a bit slow, the end had a lot of moving pieces that wrapped up just a smidge too quickly - I felt like I needed to explore the “real world” functioning of their relationship a smidge more, plus there was so much drama unfolding I would have loved to linger a bit more. The twists were so interesting and amazing (some I expected, others not), but the quick revelations and resolutions I think shortchanged their epicness slightly.
I loved the danger and action elements, and the chemistry was both sexy and then ultimately sweet. I definitely really bought into this story once these two finally connected emotionally, and I definitely appreciate Ava’s unique approach to forced cohabitation/enemies to lovers- not only did it surprise me but it feels fresh, not only to mafia romance but just romance in general. Overall, an entertaining and unique read.