What do you think?
Rate this book
Return to the Big Valley
The Brunstetters Return to a Unique Amish Setting for Three New Stories of Love
Journey back to an area of Pennsylvania that is home to three distinct Amish communities and meet three young women who face heartfelt disappointments in romance.
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Wilma Hostetler has been courted by Israel Zook for the last year, and he’s recently proposed marriage. But when his sister dies, leaving him to care for five young nephews who openly dislike Wilma, she has second thoughts of starting with a ready-made family and decides to call off the wedding. Can anything be done to restore the relationship, or will Israel seek another wife?
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is different from other Amish women in her love of hunting and the outdoors. Meeting Glen Swarey, who is working with the local fire department, seems to be a good match. But can Martha accept Glen’s thoughts of leaving the Amish faith, or will she walk away from a chance at love?
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
Alma Wengerd is a young widow who leaves her home in Kentucky to stay with friends in Pennsylvania. Soon she is speeding into a renewed romance with Elias Kurtz and raising the brows of the older church members. When Alma is waylaid by some unexpected news, could putting her happiness with Elias on hold be her only option?
Journey back to an area of Pennsylvania that is home to three distinct Amish communities and meet three young women who face heartfelt disappointments in romance.
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Wilma Hostetler has been courted by Israel Zook for the last year, and he’s recently proposed marriage. But when his sister dies, leaving him to care for five young nephews who openly dislike Wilma, she has second thoughts of starting with a ready-made family and decides to call off the wedding. Can anything be done to restore the relationship, or will Israel seek another wife?
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is different from other Amish women in her love of hunting and the outdoors. Meeting Glen Swarey, who is working with the local fire department, seems to be a good match. But can Martha accept Glen’s thoughts of leaving the Amish faith, or will she walk away from a chance at love?
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
Alma Wengerd is a young widow who leaves her home in Kentucky to stay with friends in Pennsylvania. Soon she is speeding into a renewed romance with Elias Kurtz and raising the brows of the older church members. When Alma is waylaid by some unexpected news, could putting her happiness with Elias on hold be her only option?
448 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2021
44 people are currently reading
2699 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 138 reviews
May 20, 2021
Three very nice Amish Romance novellas written by Wanda Brunstetter, Jean Brunstetter and Richelle Brunstetter. Each novella drew me in completely. The characters in each story had their own challenges . All had unpredictable twists and turns that kept me turning pages eager to see how the endings would turn out. These stories were well written and captivating to this reader.
Wilma's Wish by Wanda Brunstetter
This novella tugged at my heart. An Amish couple planning to be married have to put their wedding plans on hold when the boyfriend quite suddenly becomes a guardian to five rowdy and defiant nephews. The death of both parents made them orphans and their Uncle Isreal Zook is the only one who can take them in and give them a home. Because Wilma is Isreals fiance she feels she must watch the boys while Isreal works. The boys are disobedient and outright rude to Wilma. Try as she might she can do nothing to win the boys over. They just don't seem to like Wilma and claim they never will like her. If Wilma agrees to go ahead and marry Isreal what kind of life would she have trying to be a mother to five ungrateful boys? Is this how she wants to spend the rest of her life?
Martha's Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is somewhat of a tomboy. She's not into quilting or sewing or even cooking. She'd rather go hunting or fishing with her Dad any day than take part in a women's work frolic. Because of this Martha doesn't believe she will ever find an Amish man who would want to marry her. Then along comes Glen Swarey who is Amish but has one foot out in the English world. The two meet and Glen finds himself smitten with Martha. She loves the Amish faith but Glen wants to become a fireman. He's not really into going to church and is considered leaving the Amish for the English world. Glen and Martha court and have strong feelings for each other. But when Glen voices his opinion about jumping the fence Martha must decide if this is what she wants or should she stop seeing Glen?
Alma's Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
Alma Wingerd suddenly becomes a widow when her husband Michael dies from a fall. She wants to make changes in her life so a month after her husband's death she travels to Big Valley Pennsylvania to stay with friends. Alma had grown up in this community until her teenage years when her family moved to Kentucky to care for her aging grandparents. She plans to help her friend Leila Troyer in her card shop. There she meets an old friend she had known in school. Secretly Elais Kurtz and Alma had feelings for each other in their school years. They had never told each other how they felt for fear of rejection. Now after all these years they find they still have those same feelings for each other and this time they voice those feelings with each other. The problem is that Alma is a widow in grieving and she shouldn't be having these feelings for Elais when her late husband has only been dead for a month. Her Amish acquaintances would look down on her because it is expected that a widow should grieve her late husband for at least a year. Alma wrestles with feelings of guilt and wonders if she should return to Kentucky where she can separate herself from Elais.
I recommend this book to readers of Amish Fiction and fans of the writers. This book is a sequel to The Bridges of Big Valley. I read The Return to Big Valley out of order and still enjoyed the book. I feel that it can be read as a stand alone .
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you! A favorable review was not requested. All opinions expressed here are my own.
Wilma's Wish by Wanda Brunstetter
This novella tugged at my heart. An Amish couple planning to be married have to put their wedding plans on hold when the boyfriend quite suddenly becomes a guardian to five rowdy and defiant nephews. The death of both parents made them orphans and their Uncle Isreal Zook is the only one who can take them in and give them a home. Because Wilma is Isreals fiance she feels she must watch the boys while Isreal works. The boys are disobedient and outright rude to Wilma. Try as she might she can do nothing to win the boys over. They just don't seem to like Wilma and claim they never will like her. If Wilma agrees to go ahead and marry Isreal what kind of life would she have trying to be a mother to five ungrateful boys? Is this how she wants to spend the rest of her life?
Martha's Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is somewhat of a tomboy. She's not into quilting or sewing or even cooking. She'd rather go hunting or fishing with her Dad any day than take part in a women's work frolic. Because of this Martha doesn't believe she will ever find an Amish man who would want to marry her. Then along comes Glen Swarey who is Amish but has one foot out in the English world. The two meet and Glen finds himself smitten with Martha. She loves the Amish faith but Glen wants to become a fireman. He's not really into going to church and is considered leaving the Amish for the English world. Glen and Martha court and have strong feelings for each other. But when Glen voices his opinion about jumping the fence Martha must decide if this is what she wants or should she stop seeing Glen?
Alma's Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
Alma Wingerd suddenly becomes a widow when her husband Michael dies from a fall. She wants to make changes in her life so a month after her husband's death she travels to Big Valley Pennsylvania to stay with friends. Alma had grown up in this community until her teenage years when her family moved to Kentucky to care for her aging grandparents. She plans to help her friend Leila Troyer in her card shop. There she meets an old friend she had known in school. Secretly Elais Kurtz and Alma had feelings for each other in their school years. They had never told each other how they felt for fear of rejection. Now after all these years they find they still have those same feelings for each other and this time they voice those feelings with each other. The problem is that Alma is a widow in grieving and she shouldn't be having these feelings for Elais when her late husband has only been dead for a month. Her Amish acquaintances would look down on her because it is expected that a widow should grieve her late husband for at least a year. Alma wrestles with feelings of guilt and wonders if she should return to Kentucky where she can separate herself from Elais.
I recommend this book to readers of Amish Fiction and fans of the writers. This book is a sequel to The Bridges of Big Valley. I read The Return to Big Valley out of order and still enjoyed the book. I feel that it can be read as a stand alone .
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you! A favorable review was not requested. All opinions expressed here are my own.
March 16, 2023
The is a collection of three Amish Romance Short stories written by three different authors. The first book is Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter. I liked this story ok. I really did not loved how young Wilma acted, and I really did not like her mother's character. The next story in this collection is Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter. I have to say I really did not like this book. I felt the storyline was not developed enough. I think I would of liked this story if it was longer and more developed. I just felt this story was rush. The next story in this collection is Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter. This story was my favorite one of the three. I really enjoyed this story. The characters where great, and I felt for a short story it was really developed. I won a kindle edition of this book from a Goodreads Giveaway, but this review is my own opinion about this book.
May 30, 2021
Return to the Big Valley contains three Amish tales by Wanda E. Brunstetter, Jean Brunstetter, and Richelle Brunstetter. The stories are Wilma’s Wish, Martha’s Miracle, and Alma’s Acceptance. We are taken back to Big Valley, Pennsylvania which we visited in The Brides of Big Valley. Each story can be read as a standalone. I thought the stories were well-written with good life lessons. There is good dialogue and pacing as well. Each story gives us a different look at Amish life. They are heartwarming and realistic stories. I could understand Wilma’s hesitancy at suddenly becoming a mother to five mischievous boys who were making life difficult. It was definitely a situation where a person needed to step back and re-evaluate the situation. Martha Yoder is a unique Amish woman. She prefers to be outdoors, and Martha enjoys hunting and fishing. It is hard to find an Amish man who will accept her (who does not want her to change). I liked that we get to see an Amish woman in a non-traditional role. Alma becomes a widow after a year of marriage. Her friend suggests she visit her in Big Valley where she reunites with an old friend and someone she had developed feelings for as a teen. She wonders if it is too soon to find love again. I enjoyed all three tales that deal with grief, caring parents, romantic tension, relationship obstacles, love, and humor. We get to enjoy everyday life in the community. I appreciated the epilogues that nicely wrapped up each novella. Return to the Big Valley has three sweet Amish tales that are a relaxing way to spend an afternoon.
May 13, 2021
A collection of stories by Wanda, her daughter-in-law and her granddaughter. What a wonderful opportunity to share their love of writing as well as for the Amish.
The three stories demonstrates how GOD works in your life. HE is there during good times and bad.
The three stories were:
Wilma's Wish by Wanda Brunstetter
Martha's Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Alma's Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
The three main characters in each story must make a critical decision that will change their lives but their families as well. These decisions can not be made without prayer.
When you need to make a decision in life do you include prayer? This is a step that is the most important but frequently not done. GOD listens. He guides our steps.
I am never disappointed when I am reading a book by any Brunstetter. I am excited for Richelle as her story shows that she has a great future ahead of her.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
The three stories demonstrates how GOD works in your life. HE is there during good times and bad.
The three stories were:
Wilma's Wish by Wanda Brunstetter
Martha's Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Alma's Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
The three main characters in each story must make a critical decision that will change their lives but their families as well. These decisions can not be made without prayer.
When you need to make a decision in life do you include prayer? This is a step that is the most important but frequently not done. GOD listens. He guides our steps.
I am never disappointed when I am reading a book by any Brunstetter. I am excited for Richelle as her story shows that she has a great future ahead of her.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
Read
May 4, 2021Return to the Big Valley is a compilation of three stories by Wanda, Jean, and Richelle Brunstetter. Each were stand alone although they took place in the same community. I loved all three stories and finished this book in recored time. I honestly could not put it down once I started. All three stories were well written and the characters were easy to love. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys Amish or Inspirational fiction.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher and netgalley. All opinions are my own.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher and netgalley. All opinions are my own.
July 11, 2021
This is a collection of 3 novellas. I enjoyed that they were each pretty full novels and that I could fully invest in the characters and the stories.
The first novella was about Israel and Martha and this one was my favorite. It was such a sweet story and I loved the way that Israel and Martha cared for the 5 boys in the midst of such a hard time.
The next story was about Martha and Glenn. Martha was a little different because she enjoyed hunting and fishing. I liked that Glenn was interested in her for who she was.
The last story was about Alma and was probably my least favorite. She went to live with her friends after the loss of her husband. I did not really enjoy her character because everything has to be her way.
Thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book. The opinions are my own.
The first novella was about Israel and Martha and this one was my favorite. It was such a sweet story and I loved the way that Israel and Martha cared for the 5 boys in the midst of such a hard time.
The next story was about Martha and Glenn. Martha was a little different because she enjoyed hunting and fishing. I liked that Glenn was interested in her for who she was.
The last story was about Alma and was probably my least favorite. She went to live with her friends after the loss of her husband. I did not really enjoy her character because everything has to be her way.
Thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book. The opinions are my own.
Read
February 21, 2024Sometimes when you stay in a vacation rental there is a random book there and you start flipping through it and then it's large print and kind of fascinating and you read the whole thing! Am I the intended audience for three short romances about Amish women? Certainly not. Hopefully absolutely nobody associated with this book sees this review. I'm just writing this for me, a person who impulsively read a vacation house book! As an outsider, here are some takeaways:
- nearly every scene features characters either cooking, baking, or eating food. While they cook, bake, and eat the food, they talk about how good it will be/is! Each story features a recipe at the end! This is not an exaggeration: literally dozens of scenes of people eating together and commenting on how pleasant it is to eat together. In one story, they go to a fireman's benefit luncheon, eat a lot, and then head to a friend's house for snacks! In another, a couple eats a ton of pasta at a restaurant, then order dessert even though there's birthday cake at home, then go home to eat the birthday cake and also several more cakes! My college town had Amish people and we bought their pies and I can attest that it's all delicious.
- each story establishes its To Be Marrieds and then throws some mild conflict in there, but even the characters seem to know that Marriage Will Happen, followed immediately by babies (boppli in Pennsylvania Dutch, which is sprinkled throughout). Boppli!
- every story has a daughter living with her parents. At first, because the daughters are extremely responsible and dutiful and their hobbies include quilting, fishing, baking, sitting on the porch drinking lemonade, prayer, expressing gratitude, and working in the family store, I thought they were middle aged. Nope! They're 21. Then throughout each story, Mom lovingly meddles in their relationship, asks her husband to meddle, he refuses, then everything works out and the daughters are grateful for Mom.
- shocking twist: the grandmother/daughter/granddaughter team who wrote these stories aren't Amish! They're just admirers, despite being founders of the Amish fiction genre.
I could go on and on about this book. It is written more or less in the style and reading level of an educational story you read in middle school where everything is very logical. The only startling part is a bit in the third story where a grieving widow goes to stay with some friends and while she's there the book establishes that she's kind of a neat freak and she begins to tidy and reorganize her friend's house room by room, openly criticizing her friend (who has a boppli!) for being a slovenly housewife. This behavior escalates until one morning the friend wakes up to find the widow rifling through things in her own bathroom in her bedroom and they have a big fight. These characters generally lack interiority so it doesn't go anywhere but it was exciting!
- nearly every scene features characters either cooking, baking, or eating food. While they cook, bake, and eat the food, they talk about how good it will be/is! Each story features a recipe at the end! This is not an exaggeration: literally dozens of scenes of people eating together and commenting on how pleasant it is to eat together. In one story, they go to a fireman's benefit luncheon, eat a lot, and then head to a friend's house for snacks! In another, a couple eats a ton of pasta at a restaurant, then order dessert even though there's birthday cake at home, then go home to eat the birthday cake and also several more cakes! My college town had Amish people and we bought their pies and I can attest that it's all delicious.
- each story establishes its To Be Marrieds and then throws some mild conflict in there, but even the characters seem to know that Marriage Will Happen, followed immediately by babies (boppli in Pennsylvania Dutch, which is sprinkled throughout). Boppli!
- every story has a daughter living with her parents. At first, because the daughters are extremely responsible and dutiful and their hobbies include quilting, fishing, baking, sitting on the porch drinking lemonade, prayer, expressing gratitude, and working in the family store, I thought they were middle aged. Nope! They're 21. Then throughout each story, Mom lovingly meddles in their relationship, asks her husband to meddle, he refuses, then everything works out and the daughters are grateful for Mom.
- shocking twist: the grandmother/daughter/granddaughter team who wrote these stories aren't Amish! They're just admirers, despite being founders of the Amish fiction genre.
I could go on and on about this book. It is written more or less in the style and reading level of an educational story you read in middle school where everything is very logical. The only startling part is a bit in the third story where a grieving widow goes to stay with some friends and while she's there the book establishes that she's kind of a neat freak and she begins to tidy and reorganize her friend's house room by room, openly criticizing her friend (who has a boppli!) for being a slovenly housewife. This behavior escalates until one morning the friend wakes up to find the widow rifling through things in her own bathroom in her bedroom and they have a big fight. These characters generally lack interiority so it doesn't go anywhere but it was exciting!
May 22, 2021
The Return to the Big Valley by Wanda E. Brunstetter, Jean Brunstetter, and Richelle Brunstetter will be released, June 1, 2021, by Barbour Publishing, Inc.
This is a delightful collection of three stories in which three different women have to deal with romance in three very different ways.
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter is the story of Israel Zook and Wilma Hostetler. Israel and Wilma are planning to wed when Israel's sister is killed and he has to take custody of his five nephews. Will Wilma be able to adjust to this ready-made family?
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter is Martha Yoder's story. She is nothing like a normal Amish woman who, cooks, sews, and cleans for her family. Martha likes the outdoors. She would rather hunt or fish than anything. Glen Swarey seems to be a perfect match until Martha learns that Glen may not intend to stay Amish. Decisions have to be made. Will they or won't they be a couple?
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter is not your typical Amish romance. Alma Wengerd is a young widow who moved away from Big Valley several years ago and returns after her husband's untimely death. Her childhood best friend is Elias Kurtz, and he still lives in Big Valley. Can their friendship turn into more?
These authors have given us a 5-star, must-read collection of stories.
Thank you, Barbour Publishing, Inc. for allowing me to read an ARC of this book through NetGalley. The opinions stated here are my own and I was not required to give a positive review.
#TheReturntotheBigValley #NetGalley
This is a delightful collection of three stories in which three different women have to deal with romance in three very different ways.
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter is the story of Israel Zook and Wilma Hostetler. Israel and Wilma are planning to wed when Israel's sister is killed and he has to take custody of his five nephews. Will Wilma be able to adjust to this ready-made family?
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter is Martha Yoder's story. She is nothing like a normal Amish woman who, cooks, sews, and cleans for her family. Martha likes the outdoors. She would rather hunt or fish than anything. Glen Swarey seems to be a perfect match until Martha learns that Glen may not intend to stay Amish. Decisions have to be made. Will they or won't they be a couple?
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter is not your typical Amish romance. Alma Wengerd is a young widow who moved away from Big Valley several years ago and returns after her husband's untimely death. Her childhood best friend is Elias Kurtz, and he still lives in Big Valley. Can their friendship turn into more?
These authors have given us a 5-star, must-read collection of stories.
Thank you, Barbour Publishing, Inc. for allowing me to read an ARC of this book through NetGalley. The opinions stated here are my own and I was not required to give a positive review.
#TheReturntotheBigValley #NetGalley
June 30, 2021
This edition of three novellas by authors who all have the same last name, Brunstetter, is a sweet, relaxing read that showcases the manner that Amish folks live on a daily basis. The stories are not interconnected and can each be read as stand-alone novellas.
I believe my most enjoyable story of the three is that by Richelle Brunstetter who is a new author for me. I found the main character, Alma, an interesting individual who as a young widow handles her grief in unexpected ways.
For readers who enjoy stories about modern day folks who live their lives and faith more in line with people who lived in the 1700s, stories about the Amish most likely will be enjoyable. The Amish, though each community is somewhat different in their rules governing their way of life, shun the use of electricity, phones, cars and trucks. Their dress is distinct and sets them apart. They speak an old language, Pennsylvania Dutch, though they also speak English.
Stories about the Amish have words in Pennsylvania Dutch scattered through out which tends to lend authenticity. It does, though, sometimes confuse the reader.
The lead author in this set of three stories, Wanda E. Brunstetter, has been a much sought after author in the Christian fiction world of publishing for her gentle, lovely reads about the Amish.
I recommend this set of novellas as completely clean, gentle reads about flawed individuals facing storms of life and making life-changing decisions.
I received a complimentary copy to facilitate a review. Opinions are mine, alone and are freely given.
I believe my most enjoyable story of the three is that by Richelle Brunstetter who is a new author for me. I found the main character, Alma, an interesting individual who as a young widow handles her grief in unexpected ways.
For readers who enjoy stories about modern day folks who live their lives and faith more in line with people who lived in the 1700s, stories about the Amish most likely will be enjoyable. The Amish, though each community is somewhat different in their rules governing their way of life, shun the use of electricity, phones, cars and trucks. Their dress is distinct and sets them apart. They speak an old language, Pennsylvania Dutch, though they also speak English.
Stories about the Amish have words in Pennsylvania Dutch scattered through out which tends to lend authenticity. It does, though, sometimes confuse the reader.
The lead author in this set of three stories, Wanda E. Brunstetter, has been a much sought after author in the Christian fiction world of publishing for her gentle, lovely reads about the Amish.
I recommend this set of novellas as completely clean, gentle reads about flawed individuals facing storms of life and making life-changing decisions.
I received a complimentary copy to facilitate a review. Opinions are mine, alone and are freely given.
June 7, 2021
This book will be especially appealing to fans of Amish fiction. Authors Wanda E. Brunstetter, Jean Brunstetter, and Richelle Brunstetter have each written a sweet, inspiring story that is set in one of the three distinct Amish districts that make up the Pennsylvania area known as The Big Valley. Each novella has an intriguing plot with unique characters, and all three of them stress the importance of strong family ties, faith in God, and the ability to fully trust in His Plan for your life.
Wanda Brunstetter is certainly the veteran in this group of authors, and I do consider her story to be better defined, but Jean and Richelle Brunstetter definitely add their own unmistakable talents. Return to the Big Valley is an enjoyable read and I recommend it to all who enjoy Christian romance and Amish fiction.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. These are my own opinions.
Wanda Brunstetter is certainly the veteran in this group of authors, and I do consider her story to be better defined, but Jean and Richelle Brunstetter definitely add their own unmistakable talents. Return to the Big Valley is an enjoyable read and I recommend it to all who enjoy Christian romance and Amish fiction.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. These are my own opinions.
June 29, 2021
I am so happy that I had the chance to read The Return To The Big Valley. More specifically, Wanda Brunstetter’s Wilma’s Wish. Once again, Brunstetter has managed to create a beautiful, heart warming story that instantly captured me and made me fall in love with her characters!
Wanda Brunstetter takes us once again to the heart of the Amish country. She vividly portrays her characters and their homes, bringing them to life for the reader. You truly get to know Wilma, Israel, and the rascally nephews and become a part of their family. It was such a fun time!
That one was my favorite of the novellas, though, certainly, the others are beautifully written and filled with heart stealing characters, as well. This is one of my favorite Amish collections this year and I am looking forward to recommending this 4 star to read to all of my family and friends! Well done, ladies!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Author/Publisher and was under no obligation to post a review, positive or negative.*
Wanda Brunstetter takes us once again to the heart of the Amish country. She vividly portrays her characters and their homes, bringing them to life for the reader. You truly get to know Wilma, Israel, and the rascally nephews and become a part of their family. It was such a fun time!
That one was my favorite of the novellas, though, certainly, the others are beautifully written and filled with heart stealing characters, as well. This is one of my favorite Amish collections this year and I am looking forward to recommending this 4 star to read to all of my family and friends! Well done, ladies!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Author/Publisher and was under no obligation to post a review, positive or negative.*
May 17, 2021
Return to the Big Valley gave way to three romance stories by Wanda, Jean and Richelle Brunstetter in unique Amish communities with their buggies being a specific color instead of the usual black. The characters and decisions they faced were relatable in some ways but some were to unsettling. Each tale is easy to read and not connected to any of the other characters.
Wilma’s Wish found Wilma reconsidering her upcoming wedding to Israel. She cared for him but his five energentic nephews to care for caused undue strain. It was interesting to see how the author brought a second chance at romance through the boys.
Martha and Glen’s story in Martha’s Miracle involved more of the English world. Glen was fascinated with being a firefighter but Martha couldn’t leave her Amish faith.
Alma’s Acceptance found her back in her original Amish community and reconnecting with her first love Elias. The doubts and timing seemed wrong to be so attracted to him after years of separation.
Thank you to NetGalley for an early ARC and Barbour Publishers for a copy of this book without any obligation to write a positive review. I have shared my own opinion.
Wilma’s Wish found Wilma reconsidering her upcoming wedding to Israel. She cared for him but his five energentic nephews to care for caused undue strain. It was interesting to see how the author brought a second chance at romance through the boys.
Martha and Glen’s story in Martha’s Miracle involved more of the English world. Glen was fascinated with being a firefighter but Martha couldn’t leave her Amish faith.
Alma’s Acceptance found her back in her original Amish community and reconnecting with her first love Elias. The doubts and timing seemed wrong to be so attracted to him after years of separation.
Thank you to NetGalley for an early ARC and Barbour Publishers for a copy of this book without any obligation to write a positive review. I have shared my own opinion.
May 24, 2021
Heartwarming stories filled with family and love. I enjoyed each story. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
May 10, 2021
This book contain three stories each of which is unique and a sweet read taking place in Amish communities in the Pennsylvania hills. Each story is by a different author and all are enjoyable and make for a very entertaining book. I have enjoyed all of the Brunstetter stories, either from well-known author Wanda and her daughter-in-law and granddaughter. Their writing style is somewhat similar and so the stories blend well together as a book.
I enjoyed the book very much and although there is a previous book, which I have already read, it can be read as a stand-alone book. These Amish stories are about three different young women, each unique in their own way who have felt sorrows in previous relationships.
I received a copy of this book by NetGalley and Barbour Publishing. All thoughts are my own.
I enjoyed the book very much and although there is a previous book, which I have already read, it can be read as a stand-alone book. These Amish stories are about three different young women, each unique in their own way who have felt sorrows in previous relationships.
I received a copy of this book by NetGalley and Barbour Publishing. All thoughts are my own.
December 24, 2024
I'd give it a 3.5. The 3rd story was definitely the best. Overall, it's a nice quick read if you're looking for a somewhat complicated love story.
August 19, 2021
Three novellas by a grandmother, her daughter and her granddaughter. ABSOLUTELY skip the first by Wanda. This is the second writing that is fairly recent of hers and I could not finish either one. So many errors and poor unbelievable dialogue (see my highlight notes).
The daughter, Jean's, writing is SO much better. But the story just lays there. I never got engaged into the characters. Richelle's novella is by FAR the best of the three although the writer needs to remember that in dialogue she is writing how the Amish would talk. Not a modern Englisher person.
I won this set of novellas on Goodreads Giveaways and while a review was not required, it was requested. You might wonder why I even entered the giveaway since I find Wanda Brunstetter's latest writings unreadable. I entered because I had only found ONE that fit that category. I was in hope that was the previous Wanda book was a "one off". It wasn't.
The daughter, Jean's, writing is SO much better. But the story just lays there. I never got engaged into the characters. Richelle's novella is by FAR the best of the three although the writer needs to remember that in dialogue she is writing how the Amish would talk. Not a modern Englisher person.
I won this set of novellas on Goodreads Giveaways and while a review was not required, it was requested. You might wonder why I even entered the giveaway since I find Wanda Brunstetter's latest writings unreadable. I entered because I had only found ONE that fit that category. I was in hope that was the previous Wanda book was a "one off". It wasn't.
July 14, 2021
Three novels in one about 3 different women with completely different circumstances. Love and faith are like that. It challenges our faith and gives a reader a behind the scenes on what faith looks like in different circumstances. Sometimes you see yourself and other times a longing of faith in community. I always enjoy a good Amish romance from the Brunstetter family.
A special thank you to Barbour Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
A special thank you to Barbour Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
June 18, 2021
First, let me say that although these stories take place in the Big Valley, where we first went through The Brides of Big Valley, each story is a standalone.
All three Brunstetter authors wrote a story based in the yellow top community. I find it interesting, because so often we think all Amish communities are alike, but we learn here they aren’t. As well as unique communities, the characters in all three stories are also unique. An overnight mother of five. A woman who prefers hunting over quilting. A widow who is acting OCD as she deals with her pain. Well developed characters who grow as they trust God, I enjoyed seeing their maturing process.
What I noticed in this set of novellas is that all three authors have a similar writing style. Maybe a bit stiff for my preference but still well written. If you enjoy Amish fiction I recommend Return to the Big Valley.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.
All three Brunstetter authors wrote a story based in the yellow top community. I find it interesting, because so often we think all Amish communities are alike, but we learn here they aren’t. As well as unique communities, the characters in all three stories are also unique. An overnight mother of five. A woman who prefers hunting over quilting. A widow who is acting OCD as she deals with her pain. Well developed characters who grow as they trust God, I enjoyed seeing their maturing process.
What I noticed in this set of novellas is that all three authors have a similar writing style. Maybe a bit stiff for my preference but still well written. If you enjoy Amish fiction I recommend Return to the Big Valley.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.
September 12, 2022
Overall, I enjoyed this collection of 3 short stories. I liked how each of the stories mentioned, at least briefly, characters from the corresponding community stories in 'Brides of the Big Valley'. I also appreciated that each of the 3 main women characters learned how to trust God more fully in their lives.
Of the 3 stories, I think my favourite was the first one. Wilma and Israel's relationship felt very authentic, and the troubles they faced with his nephews and their initial dislike of Wilma were understandable. I liked how Deanna was able to offer good and godly counsel to Wilma as she faced a future she hadn't bargained on.
Of the 3 stories, I think my favourite was the first one. Wilma and Israel's relationship felt very authentic, and the troubles they faced with his nephews and their initial dislike of Wilma were understandable. I liked how Deanna was able to offer good and godly counsel to Wilma as she faced a future she hadn't bargained on.
December 24, 2021
I have loved Wanda Brunstetters books for years! Wilma’s Wish was another of many beautiful, moving books! I had a hard time getting through “Martha’s Miracle”, but then read “Alma’s Acceptance” by Wanda’s granddaughter, Richelle. Oh my! What wonderful writing!!! I couldn’t put it down until I finished it. Within the first chapter, I was totally captivated!!! Love love love
May 23, 2021
The Return to the Big Valley is your standard Amish genre fare. The stories are clean, wholesome and enjoyable to read if you like this type of writing.
Recommend.
Review written after downloading a galley from NetGalley.
Recommend.
Review written after downloading a galley from NetGalley.
June 20, 2021
3 Amish women who have faced disappointments and have gone on to thrive.
May 20, 2021
RETURN TO THE BIG VALLEY:
Wilma's Wish by Wanda Brunstetter
Martha's Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Alma's Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
One thing that all readers of Amish fiction know is that any book that is written by a Brunstetter is going to be wonderful! This is a delightful collaboration by Wanda, her daughter-in-law Jean, and Wanda's granddaughter Richelle. Each of these three women has a unique take on living the wholesome Amish life. You won't be disappointed with this book. Highly recommend.
Wilma wishes to be Israel Zook's wife more than anything, but when events beyond either of their's control occur, Wilma feels forced to make a difficult decision.
Martha knows deep in her heart and soul that she is meant to remain in the Amish faith and community. She is considered a "tomboy" type of girl, which is unusual in the Amish community. She can cook and clean, she'd just rather be off in the great outdoors, appreciating what God has designed for us to enjoy.
Alma is a newly widowed young woman who is suffering greatly after her beloved Michael was taken unexpectedly from her. A friend offers a place for her to come and visit to try to get her mind off of her loss.
Deeply faith-oriented, things that don't seem to have much focus in today's world, but loved, all the same.
#BarbourPublishing #barbourbooks #barbour was so kind to provide the complimentary copy of #returntothebigvalley I was under no obligation to post a review.
Wilma's Wish by Wanda Brunstetter
Martha's Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Alma's Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
One thing that all readers of Amish fiction know is that any book that is written by a Brunstetter is going to be wonderful! This is a delightful collaboration by Wanda, her daughter-in-law Jean, and Wanda's granddaughter Richelle. Each of these three women has a unique take on living the wholesome Amish life. You won't be disappointed with this book. Highly recommend.
Wilma wishes to be Israel Zook's wife more than anything, but when events beyond either of their's control occur, Wilma feels forced to make a difficult decision.
Martha knows deep in her heart and soul that she is meant to remain in the Amish faith and community. She is considered a "tomboy" type of girl, which is unusual in the Amish community. She can cook and clean, she'd just rather be off in the great outdoors, appreciating what God has designed for us to enjoy.
Alma is a newly widowed young woman who is suffering greatly after her beloved Michael was taken unexpectedly from her. A friend offers a place for her to come and visit to try to get her mind off of her loss.
Deeply faith-oriented, things that don't seem to have much focus in today's world, but loved, all the same.
#BarbourPublishing #barbourbooks #barbour was so kind to provide the complimentary copy of #returntothebigvalley I was under no obligation to post a review.
June 7, 2021
Return to Big Valley is a collection of three wonderful love stories written by Wanda Brunstetter, Jean Brunstetter, and Richelle Brunstetter. Each author has done a fantastic job telling their individual story with a unique writing style and fantastic characters. I enjoyed each individual story and wished that each story could continue on. I loved the titles for each story as well: Wilma's Wish by Wanda, Martha's Miracle by Jean, and Alma's Acceptance by Richelle. Each story has a way of drawing the reader into the story from the beginning. I look forward to more great stories written by these authors. I highly recommend this book to all those who love stories involving the Amish.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book through the publisher, Barbour Publishing, at the authors request. I, however, was not approached to post a favorable response just an honest one. All opinions are my own.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book through the publisher, Barbour Publishing, at the authors request. I, however, was not approached to post a favorable response just an honest one. All opinions are my own.
May 23, 2021
I've read other novella collections, as well as stories by Wanda E. Brunstetter, and I've always enjoyed them.
I love collections like this, as the stories are quick reads and easy to fit into a busy day. This was no exception. Each story stands on its own and features a young Amish couple facing difficult decisions, Their struggles (including relationship and lifestyle choices) are relatable. I enjoyed the first story ("Wilma's Wish") the most. I had the hardest time connecting with the characters in the final story ("Alma's Acceptance").
There is a prior book, but they don't have to be read in order to be enjoyed.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy, but I wasn't required to leave a positive review.
I love collections like this, as the stories are quick reads and easy to fit into a busy day. This was no exception. Each story stands on its own and features a young Amish couple facing difficult decisions, Their struggles (including relationship and lifestyle choices) are relatable. I enjoyed the first story ("Wilma's Wish") the most. I had the hardest time connecting with the characters in the final story ("Alma's Acceptance").
There is a prior book, but they don't have to be read in order to be enjoyed.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy, but I wasn't required to leave a positive review.
May 30, 2021
The Return to the Big Valley is a well written collection of three Amish novellas I enjoyed each selection. My thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for my advance ebook. This is my unbiased review.
July 22, 2021
This book has 3 different stories of Amish love stories. It was ok but nothing special.
June 1, 2021
Return to the Big Valley by Wanda E. Brunstetter,Jean Brunstetter,Richelle Brunstetter
The Brunstetters Return to a Unique Amish Setting for Three New Stories of Love
Journey back to an area of Pennsylvania that is home to three distinct Amish communities and meet three young women who face heartfelt disappointments in romance.
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Wilma Hostetler has been courted by Israel Zook for the last year, and he’s recently proposed marriage. But when his sister dies, leaving him to care for five young nephews who openly dislike Wilma, she has second thoughts of starting with a ready-made family and decides to call off the wedding. Can anything be done to restore the relationship, or will Israel seek another wife?
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is different from other Amish women in her love of hunting and the outdoors. Meeting Glen Swarey, who is working with the local fire department, seems to be a good match. But can Martha accept Glen’s thoughts of leaving the Amish faith, or will she walk away from a chance at love?
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
Alma Wengerd is a young widow who leaves her home in Kentucky to stay with friends in Pennsylvania. Soon she is speeding into a renewed romance with Elias Kurtz and raising the brows of the older church members. When Alma is waylaid by some unexpected news, could putting her happiness with Elias on hold be her only option?
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter
This is Wilma Hostetler and Israel Zook's story.
Reedsville, Pennsylvania
Whew! I can’t believe how warm it is already this morning.” Wilma Hostetler fanned her face with one of the quilted pot holders she’d brought to her friend Deanna Yoder’s quilt shop, along with several other items she had recently made. For the past year, Wilma had been bringing quilted items here on consignment. Trying to keep up with demand kept her busy at home.
“You’re right about the heat,” Deanna agreed. “And here it is only the last week of May. Just wait till summer hits and we have days with high humidity to go along with the sweltering heat.”
Wilma placed several table runners on a shelf. “I am thankful for all the trees in my parents’ yard that shade our home. Without those, as well as the cross-draft we get through our open windows, it would feel much worse.”
Lykens, Pennsylvania
Israel sat on the front porch of his sister’s home, waiting for the boys to come out of the house and trying to sort through his disconcerting thoughts. He didn’t know how he had survived the ordeal of his sister’s funeral or the several days after that, but for the sake of the boys, he’d managed to pull himself together and somehow muddled through.
Israel had been here for three weeks and would be taking the children home with him as soon as his driver arrived to pick them up.
The boys, especially Mark, age twelve, and Ethan, who was ten, had made it clear that they didn’t want to go and continued to say they could live in their parents’ home and take care of their younger brothers, Josh, Nate, and Micah. They obviously had no concept of how impossible that would be, and Israel had grown tired of trying to reason with them. Last night he’d gathered his sister’s sons together and told the older ones to pack their suitcases, while he assisted the younger boys with theirs.
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is different from other Amish women in her love of hunting and the outdoors. Meeting Glen Swarey, who is working with the local fire department, seems to be a good match. But can Martha accept Glen’s thoughts of leaving the Amish faith, or will she walk away from a chance at love?
This is Martha Yoder and Glen Swarey's story.
It was the first week of May and Martha Yoder's life had become busier than ever.
She flung back the sheets to make the bed in one of the guest rooms at the bed and breakfast her parents owned.
How long will the Robertsons be staying here?
Glen Swarey sat at one of the tables eating his lunch while looking over at a pretty young lady sitting with his friend Lori.
He'd attended the firehouse barbecue benefit today and his friend Kevin Presley had joined him.
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
This is Alma Wengerd and Elias Kurtz's story.
Nearly four weeks had passed since the graveside service and with the help of her family Alma had moved her possessions back to her childhood home.
Keeping busy helped Alma avoid thinking about her great loss.
While Alma appreciated the help of her parents and younger sister Makenzie it made her life more difficult in some ways.
Elias Alma bolted to him. Oh my goodness .
I can't believe it.
Embracing Elias brought back so many memories with him and her eyes prickled with tears.
I highly recommend.
Return to the Big Valley by Wanda E. Brunstetter,Jean Brunstetter,Richelle Brunstetter is a wonderful well written 5 star book.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review."
The Brunstetters Return to a Unique Amish Setting for Three New Stories of Love
Journey back to an area of Pennsylvania that is home to three distinct Amish communities and meet three young women who face heartfelt disappointments in romance.
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Wilma Hostetler has been courted by Israel Zook for the last year, and he’s recently proposed marriage. But when his sister dies, leaving him to care for five young nephews who openly dislike Wilma, she has second thoughts of starting with a ready-made family and decides to call off the wedding. Can anything be done to restore the relationship, or will Israel seek another wife?
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is different from other Amish women in her love of hunting and the outdoors. Meeting Glen Swarey, who is working with the local fire department, seems to be a good match. But can Martha accept Glen’s thoughts of leaving the Amish faith, or will she walk away from a chance at love?
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
Alma Wengerd is a young widow who leaves her home in Kentucky to stay with friends in Pennsylvania. Soon she is speeding into a renewed romance with Elias Kurtz and raising the brows of the older church members. When Alma is waylaid by some unexpected news, could putting her happiness with Elias on hold be her only option?
Wilma’s Wish by Wanda E. Brunstetter
This is Wilma Hostetler and Israel Zook's story.
Reedsville, Pennsylvania
Whew! I can’t believe how warm it is already this morning.” Wilma Hostetler fanned her face with one of the quilted pot holders she’d brought to her friend Deanna Yoder’s quilt shop, along with several other items she had recently made. For the past year, Wilma had been bringing quilted items here on consignment. Trying to keep up with demand kept her busy at home.
“You’re right about the heat,” Deanna agreed. “And here it is only the last week of May. Just wait till summer hits and we have days with high humidity to go along with the sweltering heat.”
Wilma placed several table runners on a shelf. “I am thankful for all the trees in my parents’ yard that shade our home. Without those, as well as the cross-draft we get through our open windows, it would feel much worse.”
Lykens, Pennsylvania
Israel sat on the front porch of his sister’s home, waiting for the boys to come out of the house and trying to sort through his disconcerting thoughts. He didn’t know how he had survived the ordeal of his sister’s funeral or the several days after that, but for the sake of the boys, he’d managed to pull himself together and somehow muddled through.
Israel had been here for three weeks and would be taking the children home with him as soon as his driver arrived to pick them up.
The boys, especially Mark, age twelve, and Ethan, who was ten, had made it clear that they didn’t want to go and continued to say they could live in their parents’ home and take care of their younger brothers, Josh, Nate, and Micah. They obviously had no concept of how impossible that would be, and Israel had grown tired of trying to reason with them. Last night he’d gathered his sister’s sons together and told the older ones to pack their suitcases, while he assisted the younger boys with theirs.
Martha’s Miracle by Jean Brunstetter
Martha Yoder is different from other Amish women in her love of hunting and the outdoors. Meeting Glen Swarey, who is working with the local fire department, seems to be a good match. But can Martha accept Glen’s thoughts of leaving the Amish faith, or will she walk away from a chance at love?
This is Martha Yoder and Glen Swarey's story.
It was the first week of May and Martha Yoder's life had become busier than ever.
She flung back the sheets to make the bed in one of the guest rooms at the bed and breakfast her parents owned.
How long will the Robertsons be staying here?
Glen Swarey sat at one of the tables eating his lunch while looking over at a pretty young lady sitting with his friend Lori.
He'd attended the firehouse barbecue benefit today and his friend Kevin Presley had joined him.
Alma’s Acceptance by Richelle Brunstetter
This is Alma Wengerd and Elias Kurtz's story.
Nearly four weeks had passed since the graveside service and with the help of her family Alma had moved her possessions back to her childhood home.
Keeping busy helped Alma avoid thinking about her great loss.
While Alma appreciated the help of her parents and younger sister Makenzie it made her life more difficult in some ways.
Elias Alma bolted to him. Oh my goodness .
I can't believe it.
Embracing Elias brought back so many memories with him and her eyes prickled with tears.
I highly recommend.
Return to the Big Valley by Wanda E. Brunstetter,Jean Brunstetter,Richelle Brunstetter is a wonderful well written 5 star book.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review."
July 30, 2021
It’s been a long time since I’ve read an Amish book, and I’m not quite sure why. I used to read a lot of them. I’ve just always been fascinated by the simple lifestyle and strong sense of community. So, when I won a copy of this one on Goodreads, I was excited to return the Amish culture.
Wilma’s Wish
Wilma’s Wish is about a young betrothed couple that find themselves with quite a burden on their hands. Israel’s sister passes away unexpectedly, leaving him with five rambunctious and unruly boys to raise. Wilma steps in right away to help, but finds the job a lot harder than she could ever anticipate. The boys are determined to get rid of her.
It’s a story that pulls on the heartstrings a bit but without going too heavy. The end was so sweet and definitely left a smile on my face. My only issue was that things seemed to be resolved a bit too quickly.
Martha’s Miracle
In Martha’s Miracle, Martha’s not your typical female in the Amish community. She’d much rather be fishing and hunting than sewing or baking. Unfortunately that meant that guys, while they might be attracted to her, never seemed to stick around long.
Then Glen Swarey enters the scene. He not only doesn’t mind that she fishes and hunts, he wants to do it with her. And he doesn’t care about what is typically required of an Amish woman, but he’s not so sure about joining the church. He’s very much considering going English. The problem with this is that Martha, while she may not be your typical Amish girl, is very sure that she wants to be Amish.
The problems arise when Glen tries to push Martha in the direction she’s made it clear she has no desire to go. But, there are some major issues coming Glen’s way that will definitely affect Glen’s heart.
I again didn’t love how quickly things wrapped up in this one, and I had one small issue with what influences Glen. But there were things I loved, like Martha’s short but powerful conversations with her father. Her father’s character isn’t a major one, but impactful enough to make me reflect on my own parenting.
In the end, it was another sweet story.
Alma’s Acceptance
Alma’s Acceptance is a love after loss story. Alma returns to the town she grew up in after losing her husband just a month prior. She had been forced to the leave the town several years earlier when her parents had to move to take care of an elderly grandparent.
Alma had loved her childhood best friend, Elias back then, but had never spoken up about it. And, he hadn’t either, though he had loved her, too. And her returning to the town brings a mixture of feelings for Alma. She’s struggling with the feelings of loss and the remaining love she still harbors for Elias.
They receive permission to court, but then Alma makes a discovery that would impact them both, and she decides it’s just not fair to put that on Elias. She decides for them both to end things without cluing Elias in.
I really appreciated that this book made me think and analyze my own thoughts and opinions on the topics in this book. It definitely encouraged me to refrain from passing judgments on others. But, it also solidified my opinion that it’s never okay to make a decision by yourself when it affects more than just you.
There are other interesting elements to this story. Alma’s overwhelming Type A personality creates some issues with her friend Leila that she’s staying with. And Leila and her husband Aden play a nice little role in the story and it’s conclusion.
In the end, it was another sweet story that I was glad I read. And it caused me to think and analyze my own thoughts. I love when a book can do that!
Overall, I enjoyed each short story even though I had some issues with them. It’s been so long since I’ve read an Amish book, and it was wonderful to return to the culture. And more importantly, these books challenged me to think about my own beliefs and opinions. I gave each individual story 4 stars, and therefore the book as a whole got 4.
Wilma’s Wish
Wilma’s Wish is about a young betrothed couple that find themselves with quite a burden on their hands. Israel’s sister passes away unexpectedly, leaving him with five rambunctious and unruly boys to raise. Wilma steps in right away to help, but finds the job a lot harder than she could ever anticipate. The boys are determined to get rid of her.
It’s a story that pulls on the heartstrings a bit but without going too heavy. The end was so sweet and definitely left a smile on my face. My only issue was that things seemed to be resolved a bit too quickly.
Martha’s Miracle
In Martha’s Miracle, Martha’s not your typical female in the Amish community. She’d much rather be fishing and hunting than sewing or baking. Unfortunately that meant that guys, while they might be attracted to her, never seemed to stick around long.
Then Glen Swarey enters the scene. He not only doesn’t mind that she fishes and hunts, he wants to do it with her. And he doesn’t care about what is typically required of an Amish woman, but he’s not so sure about joining the church. He’s very much considering going English. The problem with this is that Martha, while she may not be your typical Amish girl, is very sure that she wants to be Amish.
The problems arise when Glen tries to push Martha in the direction she’s made it clear she has no desire to go. But, there are some major issues coming Glen’s way that will definitely affect Glen’s heart.
I again didn’t love how quickly things wrapped up in this one, and I had one small issue with what influences Glen. But there were things I loved, like Martha’s short but powerful conversations with her father. Her father’s character isn’t a major one, but impactful enough to make me reflect on my own parenting.
In the end, it was another sweet story.
Alma’s Acceptance
Alma’s Acceptance is a love after loss story. Alma returns to the town she grew up in after losing her husband just a month prior. She had been forced to the leave the town several years earlier when her parents had to move to take care of an elderly grandparent.
Alma had loved her childhood best friend, Elias back then, but had never spoken up about it. And, he hadn’t either, though he had loved her, too. And her returning to the town brings a mixture of feelings for Alma. She’s struggling with the feelings of loss and the remaining love she still harbors for Elias.
They receive permission to court, but then Alma makes a discovery that would impact them both, and she decides it’s just not fair to put that on Elias. She decides for them both to end things without cluing Elias in.
I really appreciated that this book made me think and analyze my own thoughts and opinions on the topics in this book. It definitely encouraged me to refrain from passing judgments on others. But, it also solidified my opinion that it’s never okay to make a decision by yourself when it affects more than just you.
There are other interesting elements to this story. Alma’s overwhelming Type A personality creates some issues with her friend Leila that she’s staying with. And Leila and her husband Aden play a nice little role in the story and it’s conclusion.
In the end, it was another sweet story that I was glad I read. And it caused me to think and analyze my own thoughts. I love when a book can do that!
Overall, I enjoyed each short story even though I had some issues with them. It’s been so long since I’ve read an Amish book, and it was wonderful to return to the culture. And more importantly, these books challenged me to think about my own beliefs and opinions. I gave each individual story 4 stars, and therefore the book as a whole got 4.
May 29, 2021
Ms. Brunstetter along with other members of her family has written a delightful collection of three short stories.
Wilma's Wish
Wilma and Israel Zook have been courting for the last year and now with less than six months till their wedding, she can hardly wait. When Israel gets a call that his sister has died leaving five boys between the ages of three to twelve he has no choice but to go and get them. When he brings them home he realizes he must be responsible for them as they are his family.
Wilma although shocked had offered to help till he could find someone to watch the boys. The boys resent her and are afraid they might be looking at their new mother. When Wilma realizes after a few weeks, it is not going to work with this "ready-made family" she breaks up with Israel and calls off the wedding.
Both Wilma and Israel are unhappy but as of now Israel must protect the boys and that is his number one priority. As fate steps in something cause Wilma to try and help the boys once again on a temporary basis. This time things seem to be different and she wonders if she made a mistake calling off the wedding.
Martha's Miracle
Martha Yoder is certainly not like any of the other Amish women love to hunt and fish and be outdoors. She enjoys spending time outside rather than quilting or things that most Amish women do. Although she has dated before none of the gentlemen are looking for a wife who is interested in things other than the house, cooking, and family.
Glen Swarey meets her at the local firehouse barbecue benefit. They seem to hit it off and enjoy the outdoors and each other's company. After a short time he asks to court her and she agrees. She is not happy about him working in the Fire Department as it is a dangerous job and he also wants her to leave the Amish faith and join the English.
After much thought and with a heavy heart, Martha breaks it off and says she does not want to become English and will remain Amish and stick with her faith. Both are not happy about the decision but that seems what is best.
Several weeks later an unfortunate accident occurs and Glen has to rethink his life, values, and his faith. Will he give up the thought of being English and possibly have another chance with Martha? That is a decision they both will have to make.
Alma's Acceptance
Alma has become a widow after being married less than one year. She loved Michael and is having a hard time adjusting to life without him. Her friend Leila who she met with her husband on vacation suggests she come back to visit in Pennsylvania where the family was from.
Alma was not happy when her parents had to move to be with her sick grandparents in Kentucky. Her parents agree it might be just the change she needs and encourage her to go. After some thought, she agrees.
While staying with the Troyer's she meets up with Elias an old friend. She had known him since they were children and as she got older she had developed feelings for him. Since he never seemed interested in her in the same way, so when they moved to Kentucky she forgot about him.
Now it seems when she sees him again, both of them have changed as he is interested in her and she is feeling the same, more than just friends. They are together for a few weeks and want to court her. Although she realizes she feels the same she is not sure it is a good idea as it is not even a year since her husband has passed. Elias is willing to wait but they decide to leave it up to the church. Life seems to be going well until she gets some unexpected news which changes everything and she breaks up with Elias. Will they be able to work
Wilma's Wish
Wilma and Israel Zook have been courting for the last year and now with less than six months till their wedding, she can hardly wait. When Israel gets a call that his sister has died leaving five boys between the ages of three to twelve he has no choice but to go and get them. When he brings them home he realizes he must be responsible for them as they are his family.
Wilma although shocked had offered to help till he could find someone to watch the boys. The boys resent her and are afraid they might be looking at their new mother. When Wilma realizes after a few weeks, it is not going to work with this "ready-made family" she breaks up with Israel and calls off the wedding.
Both Wilma and Israel are unhappy but as of now Israel must protect the boys and that is his number one priority. As fate steps in something cause Wilma to try and help the boys once again on a temporary basis. This time things seem to be different and she wonders if she made a mistake calling off the wedding.
Martha's Miracle
Martha Yoder is certainly not like any of the other Amish women love to hunt and fish and be outdoors. She enjoys spending time outside rather than quilting or things that most Amish women do. Although she has dated before none of the gentlemen are looking for a wife who is interested in things other than the house, cooking, and family.
Glen Swarey meets her at the local firehouse barbecue benefit. They seem to hit it off and enjoy the outdoors and each other's company. After a short time he asks to court her and she agrees. She is not happy about him working in the Fire Department as it is a dangerous job and he also wants her to leave the Amish faith and join the English.
After much thought and with a heavy heart, Martha breaks it off and says she does not want to become English and will remain Amish and stick with her faith. Both are not happy about the decision but that seems what is best.
Several weeks later an unfortunate accident occurs and Glen has to rethink his life, values, and his faith. Will he give up the thought of being English and possibly have another chance with Martha? That is a decision they both will have to make.
Alma's Acceptance
Alma has become a widow after being married less than one year. She loved Michael and is having a hard time adjusting to life without him. Her friend Leila who she met with her husband on vacation suggests she come back to visit in Pennsylvania where the family was from.
Alma was not happy when her parents had to move to be with her sick grandparents in Kentucky. Her parents agree it might be just the change she needs and encourage her to go. After some thought, she agrees.
While staying with the Troyer's she meets up with Elias an old friend. She had known him since they were children and as she got older she had developed feelings for him. Since he never seemed interested in her in the same way, so when they moved to Kentucky she forgot about him.
Now it seems when she sees him again, both of them have changed as he is interested in her and she is feeling the same, more than just friends. They are together for a few weeks and want to court her. Although she realizes she feels the same she is not sure it is a good idea as it is not even a year since her husband has passed. Elias is willing to wait but they decide to leave it up to the church. Life seems to be going well until she gets some unexpected news which changes everything and she breaks up with Elias. Will they be able to work
Displaying 1 - 30 of 138 reviews