What do you think?
Rate this book
Albert O. Hirschman: An Intellectual Biography
Winner, 2023 Best Book Award, Italian Association for the History of Economic Thought
One of the most original social scientists of the twentieth century, Albert O. Hirschman led an uncommonly dramatic life. After fleeing Nazi Germany as a youth, he fought in the Spanish Civil War, took part in antifascist activities in Italy, and organized an underground rescue operation in Marseille through which more than 2,000 people, including Marc Chagall, Arthur Koestler, and Hannah Arendt, escaped Europe. Hirschman moved across topics, methodologies, and disciplinary boundaries as fluidly as he did among countries and languages. His work is marked by a deep suspicion of all-encompassing theories, valuing instead doubt and a sensitivity to contingencies and unexpected consequences.
In this intellectual biography, the economic historian Michele Alacevich explores the development and trajectory of Hirschman’s characteristic approach to social-scientific questions. He traces the many strands of Hirschman’s thought and their place in his multifaceted body of work, considering their limitations as well as their strengths. Alacevich puts Hirschman’s ideas into context, following his participation in the major intellectual and political debates of his times. He examines Hirschman’s pioneering work in development studies and his analyses of social change, the history of capitalism, and the workings of democracy alongside his activities in the postwar reconstruction of Europe and economic development in Latin America. A compelling intellectual portrait of a profoundly distinctive thinker, this book also reflects on Hirschman’s legacy and lasting influence.
One of the most original social scientists of the twentieth century, Albert O. Hirschman led an uncommonly dramatic life. After fleeing Nazi Germany as a youth, he fought in the Spanish Civil War, took part in antifascist activities in Italy, and organized an underground rescue operation in Marseille through which more than 2,000 people, including Marc Chagall, Arthur Koestler, and Hannah Arendt, escaped Europe. Hirschman moved across topics, methodologies, and disciplinary boundaries as fluidly as he did among countries and languages. His work is marked by a deep suspicion of all-encompassing theories, valuing instead doubt and a sensitivity to contingencies and unexpected consequences.
In this intellectual biography, the economic historian Michele Alacevich explores the development and trajectory of Hirschman’s characteristic approach to social-scientific questions. He traces the many strands of Hirschman’s thought and their place in his multifaceted body of work, considering their limitations as well as their strengths. Alacevich puts Hirschman’s ideas into context, following his participation in the major intellectual and political debates of his times. He examines Hirschman’s pioneering work in development studies and his analyses of social change, the history of capitalism, and the workings of democracy alongside his activities in the postwar reconstruction of Europe and economic development in Latin America. A compelling intellectual portrait of a profoundly distinctive thinker, this book also reflects on Hirschman’s legacy and lasting influence.
352 pages, Hardcover
Published April 6, 2021
9 people are currently reading
109 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
June 4, 2023
A few years ago, I had already read the incredible story of Hirschman's life, which I reviewed here:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
The Netflix series "Transatlantic" (which recounts his participation in a network that set up an escape route for Jews fleeing the Nazis) reminded me that his intellectual biography had already been on my "to read" list for a few years as well.
Alacevinch's book should not be seen as a substitute for Adelman's, but as a complement to it. As the title correctly emphasizes, the focus here is on the works of Hirschmand, and the author refers systematically to Adelman's book for the other aspects of his life.
Alacevich's book fills an important gap, and is an excellent introduction to the thoughts of an economist who also turned out to be that rare species, an all round social scientist. The book is at its best when it discusses Hirschman's own ideas.
However, I have mixed feelings about the discussion of the reactions to Hirshman's work . To Alacevich's credit, he faced a bit of a unsolvable dillemma here. If he had expanded the sections discussing other scholars' criticisms of Hirshman, the book would have become very long.
By keeping these discussions concise, it would be hard for the non-specialised reader to understand what exactly the criticisms were about. Alacevich chose a middle group and ended up with a result that is both tedious and too dense, especially when discussing Hirschman's latter work. This has cost the book a 4th star.
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
The Netflix series "Transatlantic" (which recounts his participation in a network that set up an escape route for Jews fleeing the Nazis) reminded me that his intellectual biography had already been on my "to read" list for a few years as well.
Alacevinch's book should not be seen as a substitute for Adelman's, but as a complement to it. As the title correctly emphasizes, the focus here is on the works of Hirschmand, and the author refers systematically to Adelman's book for the other aspects of his life.
Alacevich's book fills an important gap, and is an excellent introduction to the thoughts of an economist who also turned out to be that rare species, an all round social scientist. The book is at its best when it discusses Hirschman's own ideas.
However, I have mixed feelings about the discussion of the reactions to Hirshman's work . To Alacevich's credit, he faced a bit of a unsolvable dillemma here. If he had expanded the sections discussing other scholars' criticisms of Hirshman, the book would have become very long.
By keeping these discussions concise, it would be hard for the non-specialised reader to understand what exactly the criticisms were about. Alacevich chose a middle group and ended up with a result that is both tedious and too dense, especially when discussing Hirschman's latter work. This has cost the book a 4th star.
March 2, 2023
Found the descriptions of his inter-disciplinary approach and theorizing based on limited data very intriguing. And how that theorizing was critiqued in his time but helped shape varied social science disciplines over time.
February 5, 2022
I like this one much more than the other more popular Hirschman biography. This one is about the work Hirschman did, and was more of what I was looking for in the Adelman biography.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews