What do you think?
Rate this book
Silver Buckles: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
She staggered a great man. He was reeling. She was overwhelmed.
Fitzwilliam Darcy, standing irritably at the edge of the Meryton assembly, declines to dance with Elizabeth Bennet. In a mood of revulsion, he rejects her without concern of being overheard. Country pretensions are always in need of squashing, and what better way to make clear he would not partner anyone outside his party? However, when he looks over at her, she does not appear humbled at all. She is secretly laughing at him!
Elizabeth is perversely delighted to encounter such an outrageous snob as Mr. Darcy. When he approaches her with a stiff, graceless apology, she coolly brushes him off, believing that, like most annoyances, he will go away when properly snubbed. But no! The man then puts out his hand and, not wishing to create a scene, compels her to stand up with him.
They go through the steps of the dance mutually disdainful and intent upon wounding each other. But by the time the musicians end their tune, Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy have traded barbs with such accuracy, they are unaccountably amused and engaged. Will this most inconvenient flirtation drive them apart—or, like silver buckles, are they a matched pair?
Fitzwilliam Darcy, standing irritably at the edge of the Meryton assembly, declines to dance with Elizabeth Bennet. In a mood of revulsion, he rejects her without concern of being overheard. Country pretensions are always in need of squashing, and what better way to make clear he would not partner anyone outside his party? However, when he looks over at her, she does not appear humbled at all. She is secretly laughing at him!
Elizabeth is perversely delighted to encounter such an outrageous snob as Mr. Darcy. When he approaches her with a stiff, graceless apology, she coolly brushes him off, believing that, like most annoyances, he will go away when properly snubbed. But no! The man then puts out his hand and, not wishing to create a scene, compels her to stand up with him.
They go through the steps of the dance mutually disdainful and intent upon wounding each other. But by the time the musicians end their tune, Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy have traded barbs with such accuracy, they are unaccountably amused and engaged. Will this most inconvenient flirtation drive them apart—or, like silver buckles, are they a matched pair?
196 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 13, 2020
228 people are currently reading
254 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 174 reviews
October 20, 2020
5+ stars
I don't usually gush, but this is a gush-worthy novel. Not only does it make my personal "2020 Great Books" list, it ranks very high in my "All-Time Great JAFF" list. I absolutely adore it, and I know I'll be re-reading it periodically. What a brilliant debut novel Ms. Gibson has given us Austen lovers! (She's written other books, but I believe this is her first JAFF.)
The repartee between Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy fairly leaps off the pages in sparks - think of a young Katherine Hepburn and (a 28-year-old) Spencer Tracy. This starts immediately, at the Meryton assembly. Elizabeth wastes no time in pricking at Darcy's snooty attitude, he responds with intentionally exaggerated pomposity, and the two of them immediately recognize the other as a worthy sparring partner. The book is filled with their wonderfully intelligent banter.
As delightful as that is, there's much more. The plot is excellent, too. There are some tweaks to the backstory, but the changed interactions between Darcy and Elizabeth have a cascading effect that also affects the story's trajectory. For example, Elizabeth confesses to Darcy that her mother intends to send Jane to Netherfield on horseback when it's clearly going to rain, and he cleverly intervenes. Jane, not drenched through or feeling feverish, is mentally sharper and recognizes early on that Caroline Bingley and Louisa Hurst are NOT her friends. Although Darcy reluctantly leaves Hertfordshire and Elizabeth behind, her chiding leads him to deal with Mr. Wickham instead of leaving the villain unchecked in Meryton. Overall, the story that emerges is unpredictable, and the high quality of the writing fully engages the reader without resorting to high melodrama or excessive angst.
There's really no OOC behavior by ANY of Jane Austen's characters, but changes in circumstances create credible changes in their behavior. Elizabeth is at Longbourn without her favorite sister while Jane stays in London with the Gardiners, so Elizabeth seeks out Mary, who blossoms with the unusual attention. The two end up visiting Charlotte Collins in Kent together. Colonel Fitzwilliam has been squirreling away his army pay, knowing his family is on the brink of bankrupcy and not trusting fate to provide him with a wealthy heiress to marry. He looks forward to selling his commission and settling down - making him a more attractive marriage prospect. I particularly love Georgiana Darcy here; her shy personality remains intact though she challenges her brother's reluctance to pursue the only woman who's ever piqued his interest.
The unique events at Rosings are particularly noteworthy. Lady Catherine's interrogation leaves her thoroughly frustrated at Miss Bennet's refusal to be cowed. This courage in the face of Lady C's rudeness eventually ignites an all-out revolution against the obnoxious battleax.
The story is related alternately by Darcy and Elizabeth in first person. It sounds conversational yet still reasonably Regency-esque. Their reflections and manner of describing what happens exhibit the same sharp humor and intelligence as their conversations.
I can't praise this book highly enough. I was thoroughly charmed by it all: plot, characters, dialogue, and writing. Content is clean.
I don't usually gush, but this is a gush-worthy novel. Not only does it make my personal "2020 Great Books" list, it ranks very high in my "All-Time Great JAFF" list. I absolutely adore it, and I know I'll be re-reading it periodically. What a brilliant debut novel Ms. Gibson has given us Austen lovers! (She's written other books, but I believe this is her first JAFF.)
The repartee between Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy fairly leaps off the pages in sparks - think of a young Katherine Hepburn and (a 28-year-old) Spencer Tracy. This starts immediately, at the Meryton assembly. Elizabeth wastes no time in pricking at Darcy's snooty attitude, he responds with intentionally exaggerated pomposity, and the two of them immediately recognize the other as a worthy sparring partner. The book is filled with their wonderfully intelligent banter.
As delightful as that is, there's much more. The plot is excellent, too. There are some tweaks to the backstory, but the changed interactions between Darcy and Elizabeth have a cascading effect that also affects the story's trajectory. For example, Elizabeth confesses to Darcy that her mother intends to send Jane to Netherfield on horseback when it's clearly going to rain, and he cleverly intervenes. Jane, not drenched through or feeling feverish, is mentally sharper and recognizes early on that Caroline Bingley and Louisa Hurst are NOT her friends. Although Darcy reluctantly leaves Hertfordshire and Elizabeth behind, her chiding leads him to deal with Mr. Wickham instead of leaving the villain unchecked in Meryton. Overall, the story that emerges is unpredictable, and the high quality of the writing fully engages the reader without resorting to high melodrama or excessive angst.
There's really no OOC behavior by ANY of Jane Austen's characters, but changes in circumstances create credible changes in their behavior. Elizabeth is at Longbourn without her favorite sister while Jane stays in London with the Gardiners, so Elizabeth seeks out Mary, who blossoms with the unusual attention. The two end up visiting Charlotte Collins in Kent together. Colonel Fitzwilliam has been squirreling away his army pay, knowing his family is on the brink of bankrupcy and not trusting fate to provide him with a wealthy heiress to marry. He looks forward to selling his commission and settling down - making him a more attractive marriage prospect. I particularly love Georgiana Darcy here; her shy personality remains intact though she challenges her brother's reluctance to pursue the only woman who's ever piqued his interest.
The unique events at Rosings are particularly noteworthy. Lady Catherine's interrogation leaves her thoroughly frustrated at Miss Bennet's refusal to be cowed. This courage in the face of Lady C's rudeness eventually ignites an all-out revolution against the obnoxious battleax.
The story is related alternately by Darcy and Elizabeth in first person. It sounds conversational yet still reasonably Regency-esque. Their reflections and manner of describing what happens exhibit the same sharp humor and intelligence as their conversations.
I can't praise this book highly enough. I was thoroughly charmed by it all: plot, characters, dialogue, and writing. Content is clean.
September 11, 2025
Banter: an exchange of light, playful, teasing remarks; good-natured raillery.
The best part of “Silver Buckles” has to be the interactions between Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy: clever, bold and quick on both parts. I would recommend the book on this alone.
Elizabeth doesn’t confine her cleverness to just Mr. Darcy. She also is pro-active in “the conversation” with the Rev. Collins. How can she have a problem with her mother if she doesn’t receive a proposal?
Quote from the book (Mr. Bennet): “I am disappointed. I had a handy rejoinder prepared for your mother when you refused to marry the man and she insisted I make you change your mind.” He paused. “Would you like to hear it?”
The author creates great word pictures throughout the story. For example: Mama set about preparing for a wedding that was months away with all the serenity of a Bedlamite in mental crisis.
And: And so, in the fashion of ducks on parade, Mr. Collins struck out with a long line of us behind as we made our pilgrimage to the great house for the purpose of bowing and curtseying to Mr. Darcy’s sister.
Loved it!
Repartee: a quick witty reply; a conversation filled with such replies
The best part of “Silver Buckles” has to be the interactions between Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy: clever, bold and quick on both parts. I would recommend the book on this alone.
Elizabeth doesn’t confine her cleverness to just Mr. Darcy. She also is pro-active in “the conversation” with the Rev. Collins. How can she have a problem with her mother if she doesn’t receive a proposal?
Quote from the book (Mr. Bennet): “I am disappointed. I had a handy rejoinder prepared for your mother when you refused to marry the man and she insisted I make you change your mind.” He paused. “Would you like to hear it?”
The author creates great word pictures throughout the story. For example: Mama set about preparing for a wedding that was months away with all the serenity of a Bedlamite in mental crisis.
And: And so, in the fashion of ducks on parade, Mr. Collins struck out with a long line of us behind as we made our pilgrimage to the great house for the purpose of bowing and curtseying to Mr. Darcy’s sister.
Loved it!
Repartee: a quick witty reply; a conversation filled with such replies
June 2, 2021
Just when I start to think P&P is a tapped out genre a new book comes along that renews my hope and restores my faith. This is such a book!
It's dead clever. it is a tale of less Pride and Less Prejudice and lots of banter. Witty banter like you got in the 1930s comedies like the Thin Man series or the 1980s TV show Moonlighting or the 1970s The lady vanishes - with Cybil Sheppard
To truly enjoy this book you have to recognize the different between banter and sarcasm - do try to keep up.
It departs from canon quickly when at the Assembly Mr. Darcy does indeed dance with Miss Elizabeth and is quite taken with her - although not the rest of her family.
The book is related from the view points of both Darcy and Lizzy but isn't repetitive (aspiring authors please take note) Further it is clearly marked as to who's opinion we are reading (ditto)
Darcy is in love with Lizzy but bound by convention to deny him desires to please his family. We get a brilliant Georgiana, a lovely Mary, and an absolutely adorable Darcy - eventually.
I loved this book like a fat cat loves lasagna.
It's dead clever. it is a tale of less Pride and Less Prejudice and lots of banter. Witty banter like you got in the 1930s comedies like the Thin Man series or the 1980s TV show Moonlighting or the 1970s The lady vanishes - with Cybil Sheppard
To truly enjoy this book you have to recognize the different between banter and sarcasm - do try to keep up.
It departs from canon quickly when at the Assembly Mr. Darcy does indeed dance with Miss Elizabeth and is quite taken with her - although not the rest of her family.
The book is related from the view points of both Darcy and Lizzy but isn't repetitive (aspiring authors please take note) Further it is clearly marked as to who's opinion we are reading (ditto)
Darcy is in love with Lizzy but bound by convention to deny him desires to please his family. We get a brilliant Georgiana, a lovely Mary, and an absolutely adorable Darcy - eventually.
I loved this book like a fat cat loves lasagna.
October 30, 2020
“with all the serenity of a Bedlamite in mental crisis.” Quote from the book
Rating: steamy: MA: no graphic sex, but adult themes. Angst level: low-to-medium: You know there is that time frame where Darcy is Darcy and duty and all get in his way. Then we have Lizzy knowing her place in society and all that. However, once they get their act together… this was simply an excellent... excellent story. That is the only words I can think of for this work by Grace Gibson. OMG! I loved this D&E and the writing was… OK-sue-me… most excellent. The word choices were so unique and fresh it just made me smile. I think I hurt my face I smiled so much.
This was so much fun. I followed Grace on the blog tour and had to read it. I grabbed it through the KU Program and read it in one sitting. I simply CNPID. I highly recommend this for the BEST witty Elizabeth and Darcy that I’ve read in a while. In many cases, Elizabeth’s wit can come across as cruel, sharp, and even biting. However, in this instance, it was a delight to read and her actions with and reactions to Darcy were just what he needed even though he didn’t realize it. For them to enjoy their verbal swordplay, quips, snark, and just plain snappy repartee were so enjoyable to read. I laughed out loud so many times as I read through the scenes with ODC. From the very first chapter, the reader is engaged and drawn into the fun with all the excitement and expectation that this is something different. Even Darcy with Mrs. Bennet was a hoot. You don’t usually see that. He was so smart at times and then so dense I wanted to shake him. Georgiana and, of course, our dear Colonel were just the icing on the cake. I loved them. Then our Elizabeth took on Lady Catherine in her own throne room [to the horror of her cousin Collins] it was the best scene ever… EVER. I don’t think our dear Lady will ever be the same.
We had the most delightful letters back and forth between Elizabeth and her father, Elizabeth and Darcy, and Darcy and Elizabeth. These were so entertaining. The steam worthy scenes between our dear couple were hilarious, sexy as heck, delicious, romantic as all get out, and just plain fun to read. Man, I love this guy. I think my heart skipped a beat a few times as I read his declarations. Maybe I need to drop that extra cup of coffee.
10-24-20: I followed the author’s blog tour and, after reading a few excerpts, borrowed this through the KU program with no expectations of a review. The views and opinions expressed are my own. Later, I received a copy from Meryton Press, and read it again. I couldn’t help myself… I love this story and highly recommend it for those who enjoy snarky D&E swordplay. This was the best.
Rating: steamy: MA: no graphic sex, but adult themes. Angst level: low-to-medium: You know there is that time frame where Darcy is Darcy and duty and all get in his way. Then we have Lizzy knowing her place in society and all that. However, once they get their act together… this was simply an excellent... excellent story. That is the only words I can think of for this work by Grace Gibson. OMG! I loved this D&E and the writing was… OK-sue-me… most excellent. The word choices were so unique and fresh it just made me smile. I think I hurt my face I smiled so much.
This was so much fun. I followed Grace on the blog tour and had to read it. I grabbed it through the KU Program and read it in one sitting. I simply CNPID. I highly recommend this for the BEST witty Elizabeth and Darcy that I’ve read in a while. In many cases, Elizabeth’s wit can come across as cruel, sharp, and even biting. However, in this instance, it was a delight to read and her actions with and reactions to Darcy were just what he needed even though he didn’t realize it. For them to enjoy their verbal swordplay, quips, snark, and just plain snappy repartee were so enjoyable to read. I laughed out loud so many times as I read through the scenes with ODC. From the very first chapter, the reader is engaged and drawn into the fun with all the excitement and expectation that this is something different. Even Darcy with Mrs. Bennet was a hoot. You don’t usually see that. He was so smart at times and then so dense I wanted to shake him. Georgiana and, of course, our dear Colonel were just the icing on the cake. I loved them. Then our Elizabeth took on Lady Catherine in her own throne room [to the horror of her cousin Collins] it was the best scene ever… EVER. I don’t think our dear Lady will ever be the same.
We had the most delightful letters back and forth between Elizabeth and her father, Elizabeth and Darcy, and Darcy and Elizabeth. These were so entertaining. The steam worthy scenes between our dear couple were hilarious, sexy as heck, delicious, romantic as all get out, and just plain fun to read. Man, I love this guy. I think my heart skipped a beat a few times as I read his declarations. Maybe I need to drop that extra cup of coffee.
10-24-20: I followed the author’s blog tour and, after reading a few excerpts, borrowed this through the KU program with no expectations of a review. The views and opinions expressed are my own. Later, I received a copy from Meryton Press, and read it again. I couldn’t help myself… I love this story and highly recommend it for those who enjoy snarky D&E swordplay. This was the best.
October 30, 2020
I just read many of the other reviews...all 5 stars or 5+ stars and have to say I do so agree. I loved the banter, the barbs, the rejoinders between Darcy and Elizabeth. They are so clever, so on-the-mark. And it goes on and on. They are so quick to "call-a-spade-a spade" with each other. There is no beating around the bush as Elizabeth points out that she knows he cannot marry her and lists the reasons on her own. The chapters bear "Darcy's story" and "Elizabeth's story" titles so there is no confusion as to who is saying what or their opinions.
In this story after Darcy is overheard insulting Elizabeth at the Meryton Assembly he realizes such and goes to her immediately with an apology and an offer to dance. She is not in a position to refuse as those around them have seen his hand being offered to her and probably overheard his apology as well. She has accepted his apology but goes on to remark about his obvious attitude about the company. Neither one is satisfied to say a word and leave it at that. No, in this story they delve into motives and background and learn to know each other well. There is no Hunsford proposal although there is a big blow-up at Rosings after which Elizabeth and Mary (who have become close with each other when Jane stays in London) have to make plans to leave for home a.s.a.p.
Jane and Bingley do not marry and that is a side story. Wickham does not elope with Lydia as Darcy has acted early in this story to make sure that man's character and his crimes come to light and are dealt with. The Colonel's family has a serious problem within the family and their pressure upon Darcy to marry a woman of status and wealth has more to do with how it will affect their own particular problem.
I am not going to go into more details as other reviews have each gone to great lengths to give a complete and detailed synopsis.
This author is one to follow. She made reading the times between Darcy and Elizabeth so much fun...clever conversations...well done. I highly recommend this story. I won a copy during the blog tour raffles.
In this story after Darcy is overheard insulting Elizabeth at the Meryton Assembly he realizes such and goes to her immediately with an apology and an offer to dance. She is not in a position to refuse as those around them have seen his hand being offered to her and probably overheard his apology as well. She has accepted his apology but goes on to remark about his obvious attitude about the company. Neither one is satisfied to say a word and leave it at that. No, in this story they delve into motives and background and learn to know each other well. There is no Hunsford proposal although there is a big blow-up at Rosings after which Elizabeth and Mary (who have become close with each other when Jane stays in London) have to make plans to leave for home a.s.a.p.
Jane and Bingley do not marry and that is a side story. Wickham does not elope with Lydia as Darcy has acted early in this story to make sure that man's character and his crimes come to light and are dealt with. The Colonel's family has a serious problem within the family and their pressure upon Darcy to marry a woman of status and wealth has more to do with how it will affect their own particular problem.
I am not going to go into more details as other reviews have each gone to great lengths to give a complete and detailed synopsis.
This author is one to follow. She made reading the times between Darcy and Elizabeth so much fun...clever conversations...well done. I highly recommend this story. I won a copy during the blog tour raffles.
June 7, 2021
Audiobook Re-Read Review Update
A sassy session on the dance floor starts this Pride and Prejudice variation off with the kind of snappy dialogue that had this reader laughing from the first page. Silver Buckles has the reader appreciating Austen's classic in a refreshing, standout variation with just a simple tweak to each character.
This Darcy is less taciturn and is caught up in the sizzling connection from the beginning letting it see him into the assembly dance line with the very female he just insulted and who gives back as good as she gets. As a result, Elizabeth is exposed to a Darcy whose arrogance is tempered by many other facets to his character and she can view him, if not with complete approbation, at least curiosity which alters how she views the consecutive events including Wickham's serpent tongue and the advent of Mr. Collin's arrival and the Bingley departure.
At the same time, Darcy, too, is less severe on the Bennets as a whole- though yes, he wouldn't go so far as to get cozy with them- and more interested in altering his flawed behavior toward others much sooner and this leaves him stymied by duty to family or love until his sister and cousin decide to keep him from making a hash of his chance at happiness.
Both narrators were splendid choices to voice Darcy and Elizabeth's alternating narration. I've enjoyed Stevie Zimmerman several times and was well pleased with my first listen to Neil Roy McFarlane. Both gave the characters such depth and I loved the additional nuances to the story.
All around, Silver Buckles was a lighter, engaging historical romcom. There is conflict, but there is humor as well. It was an easy and entertaining listen and easily leaving me smiling over the romance pair and other moments quite often. Those who enjoy their Austen light and a good Regency Romp should definitely give this one a go.
A sassy session on the dance floor starts this Pride and Prejudice variation off with the kind of snappy dialogue that had this reader laughing from the first page. Silver Buckles has the reader appreciating Austen's classic in a refreshing, standout variation with just a simple tweak to each character.
This Darcy is less taciturn and is caught up in the sizzling connection from the beginning letting it see him into the assembly dance line with the very female he just insulted and who gives back as good as she gets. As a result, Elizabeth is exposed to a Darcy whose arrogance is tempered by many other facets to his character and she can view him, if not with complete approbation, at least curiosity which alters how she views the consecutive events including Wickham's serpent tongue and the advent of Mr. Collin's arrival and the Bingley departure.
At the same time, Darcy, too, is less severe on the Bennets as a whole- though yes, he wouldn't go so far as to get cozy with them- and more interested in altering his flawed behavior toward others much sooner and this leaves him stymied by duty to family or love until his sister and cousin decide to keep him from making a hash of his chance at happiness.
Both narrators were splendid choices to voice Darcy and Elizabeth's alternating narration. I've enjoyed Stevie Zimmerman several times and was well pleased with my first listen to Neil Roy McFarlane. Both gave the characters such depth and I loved the additional nuances to the story.
All around, Silver Buckles was a lighter, engaging historical romcom. There is conflict, but there is humor as well. It was an easy and entertaining listen and easily leaving me smiling over the romance pair and other moments quite often. Those who enjoy their Austen light and a good Regency Romp should definitely give this one a go.
December 8, 2025
A Dialogue Lover’s Delight
Oh, what a playful read! Such fun! Darcy and Elizabeth are delightful as they engage in a story full of delicious banter. Angst free, this book is such a pleasure to read. I hated to see it end. I adored this Elizabeth and Darcy. Highly recommend! I look forward to more from this author.
March 16-17, 2021 Audiobook
Excellent narration by Stevie Zimmerman and Neil Roy McFarlane. Having both a female and male reading adds a wonderful element to the performance. Well done!
First read via Kindle Unlimited, I have now purchased both the ebook and audiobook for my permanent respective libraries.
August 31, 2022 - Audiobook, second listen.
May 1, 2024 - Audiobook, third listen. I still adore this book. Neil Roy McFarlane is my ideal Mr. Darcy voice, especially when he is teasing.
Oh, what a playful read! Such fun! Darcy and Elizabeth are delightful as they engage in a story full of delicious banter. Angst free, this book is such a pleasure to read. I hated to see it end. I adored this Elizabeth and Darcy. Highly recommend! I look forward to more from this author.
March 16-17, 2021 Audiobook
Excellent narration by Stevie Zimmerman and Neil Roy McFarlane. Having both a female and male reading adds a wonderful element to the performance. Well done!
First read via Kindle Unlimited, I have now purchased both the ebook and audiobook for my permanent respective libraries.
August 31, 2022 - Audiobook, second listen.
May 1, 2024 - Audiobook, third listen. I still adore this book. Neil Roy McFarlane is my ideal Mr. Darcy voice, especially when he is teasing.
November 3, 2020
I can't do better writing a review than some others so I will not attempt much. I will only say this one is definitely on the re-read list!
January 6, 2021
5 Star ++++
"I stood at the edge of a bacchanal." (quote from the book)
What can I say that others have not said before me in their reviews of this Pride & Prejudice 'what if'. I will just say, that this is more than witty banter between our beloved couple. This is more than clever tweaking of events that alter certain circumstances. This is an insightful and brilliant introspection of Jane's beloved characters. I was completely enamoured and highly entertained!
"We had just rounded the corner of the room where my mother loudly held court. I sensed we were to take the buttons off our foils and fence in earnest now." (quote from the book)
Yes, it was very much like a fencing match, all parry, riposte, feint and lunge...all graceful and quick. I just loved being in the heads of Darcy and Elizabeth. Their thoughts, opinions, words and actions came flying off the page to enthrall me. It was magical, funny and at times poignant. There are so, so, many wonderful verses that I wrote down while reading so I could use them in this review. Heaven forbid I mark up this beautiful book...I do so adore the cover (back and front)! But I digress. Choosing which ones to use has been very difficult as I loved them all!
"The tone I meant to use was the roar of a bull on the charge. I was close to snorting when I arrived and stormed into the parlor where sat my woman, my betrayer, my love." (quote from the book)
There is so much to love in this engaging story and I can only encourage you to read it. I was thrilled to have received it as my Austenesque Jolabokaflod book. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!
November 23, 2022
The audiobook production of this is fantastic! A little over 5 hours, it was perfect for listening while working. I loved the 2 voices taking each POV of ODC.
Charming story, Elizabeth was cute, but Darcy was awesome!
Charming story, Elizabeth was cute, but Darcy was awesome!
October 17, 2020
Delightful changes from canon
Lizzy is saucy and argumentative. Darcy is arrogant and officious. Darcy learns early he is arrogant and tries to change, early. Lizzy will not back down to the tall, intelligent, bossy Darcy . They argue their way through the story. Lizzy fears losing herself and Darcy fears his reputation if they marry. Luckily Darcy doesn’t want Lizzy to change...much and Lizzy comes to trust Darcy .
I really enjoyed the story. 👍🏻
Lizzy is saucy and argumentative. Darcy is arrogant and officious. Darcy learns early he is arrogant and tries to change, early. Lizzy will not back down to the tall, intelligent, bossy Darcy . They argue their way through the story. Lizzy fears losing herself and Darcy fears his reputation if they marry. Luckily Darcy doesn’t want Lizzy to change...much and Lizzy comes to trust Darcy .
I really enjoyed the story. 👍🏻
November 5, 2021
What If Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s First Encounter Included Some Flirting?
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Source: Gift from Publisher
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
THE PREMISE: Compelled to apologize for his ungenerous insult at the Meryton Assembly, Mr. Darcy ends up asking Elizabeth Bennet to dance. And after thoroughly enjoying a dance full of verbal swordplay and cheeky facetiousness, Mr. Darcy is delighted to continue flirting with Elizabeth throughout his stay in Meryton although the game he is playing poses some dangers…
WHAT I LOVED:
- Wit and Dialogue: I greatly enjoyed the rapid-fire quick-wit and playful exchanges displayed by both Darcy and Elizabeth – it was akin to the flaring tempers and fast banter of Katharine Hepburn and Cary Grant in many of their movies. Grace Gibson brilliantly emulates the wonderful combination of intelligence, sharp humor, and silliness with the dialogue between these characters.
- Openness: With Darcy and Elizabeth engaging in more conversations and actively seeking each other out there was a refreshing level of openness between these characters. I loved how Mr. Darcy was always quick to notice Elizabeth’s feelings and often urged her to confide in him. And I heartily approve of his actions and all the times he listened or came to the rescue. I especially enjoyed how he interacted with and handled various members of Elizabeth’s and his own family.
- New Developments: Because of this slight change in Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s first impression of each other, it caused some new ripple effects that were so very diverting to explore. Grace Gibson found some interesting and plausible new avenues to travel in this story. I thought Jane’s storyline to be very inline with her character and I especially loved the evolution with Mary Bennet that was implemented. In addition, there were also some delightful new twists with Colonel Fitzwilliam, and I wouldn’t have minded seeing some more page time devoted to his progression through these developments.
- Dual POVs: Not only does Grace Gibson masterfully write sharp and droll dialogue between her characters, she tells the story seamlessly from their individual perspectives. I greatly enjoyed seeing the alternating points-of-view and being privy to the inner thoughts, reflections, and reactions of both Darcy and Elizabeth during this tale.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Slight Quibbles: There was just a moment or two where I sort’ve felt Mr. Darcy’s outbursts and exclaiming “barks” felt out of character, but who is to say that this reserved man would not behave in such a way when provoked beyond reason. In addition, this Elizabeth felt a little overawed/concerned with money matters, but perhaps the author intentionally wanted to portray a more practical and pragmatic Elizabeth Bennet.
CONCLUSION: What a fantastic debut novel that adeptly captures Jane Austen’s satirical voice and demonstrates what happens when Darcy and Elizabeth begin with slightly better impressions! I loved seeing this depiction of Darcy and Elizabeth in a “they drive me crazy, but I love ’em” relationship! And I cannot wait to read Grace Gibson’s newest release Reckless, Headstrong Girl.
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Source: Gift from Publisher
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
THE PREMISE: Compelled to apologize for his ungenerous insult at the Meryton Assembly, Mr. Darcy ends up asking Elizabeth Bennet to dance. And after thoroughly enjoying a dance full of verbal swordplay and cheeky facetiousness, Mr. Darcy is delighted to continue flirting with Elizabeth throughout his stay in Meryton although the game he is playing poses some dangers…
WHAT I LOVED:
- Wit and Dialogue: I greatly enjoyed the rapid-fire quick-wit and playful exchanges displayed by both Darcy and Elizabeth – it was akin to the flaring tempers and fast banter of Katharine Hepburn and Cary Grant in many of their movies. Grace Gibson brilliantly emulates the wonderful combination of intelligence, sharp humor, and silliness with the dialogue between these characters.
- Openness: With Darcy and Elizabeth engaging in more conversations and actively seeking each other out there was a refreshing level of openness between these characters. I loved how Mr. Darcy was always quick to notice Elizabeth’s feelings and often urged her to confide in him. And I heartily approve of his actions and all the times he listened or came to the rescue. I especially enjoyed how he interacted with and handled various members of Elizabeth’s and his own family.
- New Developments: Because of this slight change in Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s first impression of each other, it caused some new ripple effects that were so very diverting to explore. Grace Gibson found some interesting and plausible new avenues to travel in this story. I thought Jane’s storyline to be very inline with her character and I especially loved the evolution with Mary Bennet that was implemented. In addition, there were also some delightful new twists with Colonel Fitzwilliam, and I wouldn’t have minded seeing some more page time devoted to his progression through these developments.
- Dual POVs: Not only does Grace Gibson masterfully write sharp and droll dialogue between her characters, she tells the story seamlessly from their individual perspectives. I greatly enjoyed seeing the alternating points-of-view and being privy to the inner thoughts, reflections, and reactions of both Darcy and Elizabeth during this tale.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Slight Quibbles: There was just a moment or two where I sort’ve felt Mr. Darcy’s outbursts and exclaiming “barks” felt out of character, but who is to say that this reserved man would not behave in such a way when provoked beyond reason. In addition, this Elizabeth felt a little overawed/concerned with money matters, but perhaps the author intentionally wanted to portray a more practical and pragmatic Elizabeth Bennet.
CONCLUSION: What a fantastic debut novel that adeptly captures Jane Austen’s satirical voice and demonstrates what happens when Darcy and Elizabeth begin with slightly better impressions! I loved seeing this depiction of Darcy and Elizabeth in a “they drive me crazy, but I love ’em” relationship! And I cannot wait to read Grace Gibson’s newest release Reckless, Headstrong Girl.
Austenesque Reviews
October 28, 2020
Utterly delightful!
A cleverly written book with delightful, witty banter.
Loved the development of our dear couple's relationship which was fraught with less adversity than canon and had an earlier resolution.
Heartily recommend!
Rated: chaste.
A cleverly written book with delightful, witty banter.
Loved the development of our dear couple's relationship which was fraught with less adversity than canon and had an earlier resolution.
Heartily recommend!
Rated: chaste.
November 29, 2020
This is such a great book... right from the start the tone is set for an epic battle of wits between our dear couple. The story is written in the first person and switches perspective between Darcy and Elizabeth. Its such good fun and is essentially how things would be if these two said exactly what they wanted to to each other. Its witty, sarcastic and full of banter and we can see Darcy has been captured by the 'longbourn vixen' from the very first meeting at the Merston assembly. There are some changes to the plot line - Mary and Jane get different outcomes but I really liked them.
I read this in one sitting. It's really different but refreshingly so. The tone and language of the time remains and so it feels very authentic. We have a few occasions where propriety is thrown out the window but honestly, i didn't care! It was great to see a passionate Darcy - one who laughs and pokes fun. We get to see Elizabeth at full force- saying exactly what she thinks - when she's being witty and when she's being vulnerable. They squabble a lot but its a great way of getting these two to honestly exchange their views.
I'd definately recommend this - its fantastic!
I read this in one sitting. It's really different but refreshingly so. The tone and language of the time remains and so it feels very authentic. We have a few occasions where propriety is thrown out the window but honestly, i didn't care! It was great to see a passionate Darcy - one who laughs and pokes fun. We get to see Elizabeth at full force- saying exactly what she thinks - when she's being witty and when she's being vulnerable. They squabble a lot but its a great way of getting these two to honestly exchange their views.
I'd definately recommend this - its fantastic!
November 2, 2020
Avid Reader
I truly enjoyed Elizabeth and Darcy bringing each other to their needs. I am glad that Jane married Dr. Robert Bromley. After Darcy and Elizabeth had four children, Caroline and Bingley were still single. Mary married the Colonel after she nursed him back to health. Darcy also knew how to handle Mr. and Mrs. Bennet!
I truly enjoyed Elizabeth and Darcy bringing each other to their needs. I am glad that Jane married Dr. Robert Bromley. After Darcy and Elizabeth had four children, Caroline and Bingley were still single. Mary married the Colonel after she nursed him back to health. Darcy also knew how to handle Mr. and Mrs. Bennet!
December 24, 2025
In this Pride & Prejudice variation Darcy insults Elizabeth at the Meryton Assembly, but her response intrigues him enough to ask for a dance. The resulting conversation changes their response to each other. But can this result in happy ending for anyone.
An entertaining well-written variation with likeable pairings, just a pity there was not more of other pairings.
An entertaining well-written variation with likeable pairings, just a pity there was not more of other pairings.
July 22, 2021
4,5 rounded up to 5
Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
What if Mr. Darcy realizes his mistake in offending Elizabeth at the Meryton Assembly and decides to offer an apology? And what if they do dance together and start off on more friendly terms ?
In Silver Buckles the story is relatively simple, and because of that, it is refreshingly interesting. There aren’t unnecessary misunderstandings or farfetched changes in the story. Silver Buckles is a low angst novel that places our beloved characters in drawing room and uses a vibrant writing to make the story progress.
What I loved the most about this book were the flirtation and the dialogues between Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy. Many authors mention repeatedly how witty Elizabeth is and how Mr. Darcy and she are equals in terms of intelligence, but Grace Gibson didn’t mention that, she showed it to us, which proves her quality as a writer. The playfulness and vivacity of Elizabeth and Darcy’s dialogues kept me interested in the story until the last page because I always wanted to know what they would say to one another next, and this definitely sold the book to me.
Another aspect I loved about this book is Elizabeth’s relationship with Mary. The middle daughter is one of my favourites and I always believed that if her sisters would pay her more attention she would prove to be great company. Grace Gibson proved this by having Elizabeth help Mary develop into an adoring lady, and I adored it!
Jane Bennet is another character whose plotline will surprise some readers, and I confess that once more I loved the outcome she had. Col. Fitzwilliam and Georgiana were two other secondary characters I enjoyed, and who filled their job as supporters of the story.
Grace Gibson penned a story that is simple yet catching and where some of the characters are refreshingly different, but where Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth stay very true to themselves. For me this was the most important, I love to see some differences in the secondary characters because that makes the story more interesting and unpredictable, but I cannot bear to have different Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s. Grace Gibson did just that.
Summing up, Silver Buckles is an extremely well written book where the author shows the reader what is happening and reveals the characters personalities by having them behave in a certain manner instead of just telling all of these things. For me this is a sign of a quality book and I highly recommend it.
Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
What if Mr. Darcy realizes his mistake in offending Elizabeth at the Meryton Assembly and decides to offer an apology? And what if they do dance together and start off on more friendly terms ?
In Silver Buckles the story is relatively simple, and because of that, it is refreshingly interesting. There aren’t unnecessary misunderstandings or farfetched changes in the story. Silver Buckles is a low angst novel that places our beloved characters in drawing room and uses a vibrant writing to make the story progress.
What I loved the most about this book were the flirtation and the dialogues between Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy. Many authors mention repeatedly how witty Elizabeth is and how Mr. Darcy and she are equals in terms of intelligence, but Grace Gibson didn’t mention that, she showed it to us, which proves her quality as a writer. The playfulness and vivacity of Elizabeth and Darcy’s dialogues kept me interested in the story until the last page because I always wanted to know what they would say to one another next, and this definitely sold the book to me.
Another aspect I loved about this book is Elizabeth’s relationship with Mary. The middle daughter is one of my favourites and I always believed that if her sisters would pay her more attention she would prove to be great company. Grace Gibson proved this by having Elizabeth help Mary develop into an adoring lady, and I adored it!
Jane Bennet is another character whose plotline will surprise some readers, and I confess that once more I loved the outcome she had. Col. Fitzwilliam and Georgiana were two other secondary characters I enjoyed, and who filled their job as supporters of the story.
Grace Gibson penned a story that is simple yet catching and where some of the characters are refreshingly different, but where Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth stay very true to themselves. For me this was the most important, I love to see some differences in the secondary characters because that makes the story more interesting and unpredictable, but I cannot bear to have different Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s. Grace Gibson did just that.
Summing up, Silver Buckles is an extremely well written book where the author shows the reader what is happening and reveals the characters personalities by having them behave in a certain manner instead of just telling all of these things. For me this is a sign of a quality book and I highly recommend it.
January 1, 2021
I selected this book as my Austenesque Jolabokaflod book for 2020 and I'm so pleased with my choice! Grace Gibson is a gifted writer--what an amazing novella for a first book.
This is not to say it's perfect. But the praiseworthy features overwhelm the flaws so greatly, it's easy to forget the latter. No matter, there were far fewer flaws than in the vast majority of books I read by seasoned authors. I'll expound on them before getting into the gifts Gibson has given us in this book.
Editing was professional, but missed a few non-Regency (scan, wax poetic, paisley) and American (gotten) words and anachronistic situations that the editors may not be familiar with.
The action slowed following the disagreement between the protagonists, as if the section was filler time between scenes the author had well-drafted. Perhaps the pace issue was partly because of the loss of the easy banter between the lead characters, and the subsequent deadpan humour. Even the sections where plenty was going on were moderate in terms of action, giving this author a decided voice regarding how she played out the remainder of her tale. Nothing is wrong with the latter, it is merely a lesser seen take on writing, not often seen in action-packed JAFF, and I can name the excellent writers who also use this style. It's careful in its execution, and full of dry wit.
The humour in this book is almost another character, it's such a rich portion of what we know. Each protagonist is somewhat self-deprecating at times, in a charming way. Of course, we love this couple, so we eat up every moment of caustic banter between the two of them, and this book delivers quite a lot of that sort of energy. It's a book full of posturing and manners, much like Austen, but different.
Language was used intelligently with no desire to overwhelm the reader with difficult words, and those words carved out scenes with brilliant intensity. Once again, the intelligent humour raises its head.
The cover is beyond beautiful. It's why I wanted a hard copy of this book where I mostly get my books on Kindle. If there were a competition among JAFF covers for best of 2020, this would make the first rungs of the top 10 for sure, along with others by Janet Taylor.
I do hope Grace Gibson has more books to bring to us. Her eloquence and deadpan style bring a fresh voice to the romance of Elizabeth and Darcy, one that makes it realistic and unique.
Disclaimer: I am a JAFF author, and some might say that because of this I should not write reviews of JAFF books. However, I was a reader first, and my reviews are all honest and impartial.
This is not to say it's perfect. But the praiseworthy features overwhelm the flaws so greatly, it's easy to forget the latter. No matter, there were far fewer flaws than in the vast majority of books I read by seasoned authors. I'll expound on them before getting into the gifts Gibson has given us in this book.
Editing was professional, but missed a few non-Regency (scan, wax poetic, paisley) and American (gotten) words and anachronistic situations that the editors may not be familiar with.
The action slowed following the disagreement between the protagonists, as if the section was filler time between scenes the author had well-drafted. Perhaps the pace issue was partly because of the loss of the easy banter between the lead characters, and the subsequent deadpan humour. Even the sections where plenty was going on were moderate in terms of action, giving this author a decided voice regarding how she played out the remainder of her tale. Nothing is wrong with the latter, it is merely a lesser seen take on writing, not often seen in action-packed JAFF, and I can name the excellent writers who also use this style. It's careful in its execution, and full of dry wit.
The humour in this book is almost another character, it's such a rich portion of what we know. Each protagonist is somewhat self-deprecating at times, in a charming way. Of course, we love this couple, so we eat up every moment of caustic banter between the two of them, and this book delivers quite a lot of that sort of energy. It's a book full of posturing and manners, much like Austen, but different.
Language was used intelligently with no desire to overwhelm the reader with difficult words, and those words carved out scenes with brilliant intensity. Once again, the intelligent humour raises its head.
The cover is beyond beautiful. It's why I wanted a hard copy of this book where I mostly get my books on Kindle. If there were a competition among JAFF covers for best of 2020, this would make the first rungs of the top 10 for sure, along with others by Janet Taylor.
I do hope Grace Gibson has more books to bring to us. Her eloquence and deadpan style bring a fresh voice to the romance of Elizabeth and Darcy, one that makes it realistic and unique.
Disclaimer: I am a JAFF author, and some might say that because of this I should not write reviews of JAFF books. However, I was a reader first, and my reviews are all honest and impartial.
December 7, 2020
Our couple didn't seem like familiar to me.
April 23, 2021
A very entertaining beginning with undeniably witty writing, but the chemistry fizzles soon thereafter as the characters regress. As there isn't much of a plot to speak of, the last third is rendered dreadfully boring.
Synopsis:
We open at the beginning- the Meryton Assembly- where Darcy deems Lizzy not tolerable and Lizzy hears him, but we deviate when Darcy realizes his snub has been heard. He immediately apologizes and asks for a dance.
Thus began the most charming scene in the entire novel; an intoxicating give and take of dry sardonic wit as they danced.
Darcy is utterly charming; he relaxes with Lizzy and we see the teasing flirty potential that 'Pride and Prejudice' Darcy was restrained in, for fear of flirting and raising expectations.
By the end of the set they were fast friends.
This was an awesome scene but the fact is that it felt like a climax, since never again did the novel rouse such interest. Perhaps because it was so damned perfect, I can't credit it. I will note Lizzy grew more insecure and lame and Darcy became less resolved and never again so daring.
I understand falling in love can make us weak and unsure and perhaps the author wanted to convey that, but what is Lizzy without her courage that rises with every attempt to intimidate it?
Who is Darcy if not a resolute man who makes his own destiny?
They were shells of themselves by the end; charms diminished and their chemistry but a fizzling ember.
Darcy, even with a better understanding of Lizzy, still ditches her and Netherfield
Darcy has this big scare when he arrives at Rosings and circumstances lead him to temporarily believe Lizzy married Mr Collins. In that moment he is filled with regret and an epiphany dawns on him; He would have inevitably offered for Lizzy!
He rages into the parsonage and soon ascertains she is indeed still Miss Bennet, and all the resolve that the epiphany and his passion engendered? Poof! He backtracks! Regression of characters is a constant in this work.
Darcy goes back to not offering for her until the Colonel and Georgie intervene & beg him to consider it. It still is Lizzy who confesses her feelings first, well after when they are in London.
Lame. Not my Darcy.
My Darcy is his own man, and once he is decided he declares himself not leaving room for uncertainty. This Darcy was weak and I heartily disliked him and Lizzy who became insecure and scared of his consequence and wealth.
What I enjoyed:
Lizzy 'waving the red cape' to 'distract the bull' (so to speak) of Lady Catherine’s antagonizing of Georgiana
The banter is undeniably intellectually witty;
“Well,” he admitted, “I believe Mr. Hurst is a saint. He is forever in their company, yet he bears up regardless.”
“I see the saint is taking Communion now,” I replied with a twinkling laugh. As one, we turned to watch him at the refreshments table, drinking down the contents of a glass in one gulp and reaching for a second.”
What Displeased Me:
Darcy! I really disliked him! He didn't seem passionate to me, he grated my nerves! He clearly didn't inherit any of the 'family jewels', for Georgiana has the big balls. She has to implore him to marry Lizzy, unconcerned of her own marriage prospects! Is that what we want? Weedy lovers whose little sisters must beg them to date us? Is that the fantasy? Is this what it has come to?
My boredom progressed in tandem with the story, it only goes progressively downhill from the stellar debut scene
Verdict:
It was ok, I didn't feel Darcy was swoon worthy, I actually really disliked him. The banter between ODC was clever but seemed at times to rely heavily on mean spirited commentary on others, so Darcy and Lizzy both came off as snobby intellectuals. I didn't feel invested in their relationship, perhaps lack of chemistry, and grew bored of them and the story. I wouldn't re read.
A story unfortunately can't be a string of well delivered zingers and punch lines; it needs a plot, it requires character growth and a driving force. This is what Silver Buckles lacked.
October 16, 2020
Perfect
An absolutely perfect little variation inspired by Jane Austen’s classic novel Pride and Prejudice. I thoroughly enjoyed this story just wish it had been longer
An absolutely perfect little variation inspired by Jane Austen’s classic novel Pride and Prejudice. I thoroughly enjoyed this story just wish it had been longer
December 24, 2024
3,5 Stars.
It‘s a relisten. The first time I rated 5 Stars though..
Now, I liked Darcy and Elizabeth‘s banter and sweet moments etc.. but did it felt like he would ever in his lifetime act on them? NO.
He would kind of lead her on. And yet he was not my least favorite character because he still had some sense but Elizabeth certainly was my least favorite to the point that I facepalmed myself and cried out at work.
Starting ‚fights‘ with Darcy because of his wealth or because he bought something? Girl, you were not yet married, he didn’t need to ask you if he is allowed to buy something. 🤦♀️
I think she was supposed to be written as an independent woman but this was too much. If your betrothed comes with a sensible plan for everything than how about agreeing instead of all the time picking a fight?
Well, I did however loved Mary!! It was refreshing that she had a major role.
Bingley and Jane not ending up together is perfect 😁 Thank you Ms Gibson!!
It was well written and still enjoyable though. I listened to the audiobook.
Stevie Zimmerman was as always brilliant.
Neil Roy McFarlane was good but unfortunately not my favorite.
EDIT: I totally forgot to mention that Jane had a spine and sense! I loved it!!
It‘s a relisten. The first time I rated 5 Stars though..
Now, I liked Darcy and Elizabeth‘s banter and sweet moments etc.. but did it felt like he would ever in his lifetime act on them? NO.
He would kind of lead her on. And yet he was not my least favorite character because he still had some sense but Elizabeth certainly was my least favorite to the point that I facepalmed myself and cried out at work.
Starting ‚fights‘ with Darcy because of his wealth or because he bought something? Girl, you were not yet married, he didn’t need to ask you if he is allowed to buy something. 🤦♀️
I think she was supposed to be written as an independent woman but this was too much. If your betrothed comes with a sensible plan for everything than how about agreeing instead of all the time picking a fight?
Well, I did however loved Mary!! It was refreshing that she had a major role.
Bingley and Jane not ending up together is perfect 😁 Thank you Ms Gibson!!
It was well written and still enjoyable though. I listened to the audiobook.
Stevie Zimmerman was as always brilliant.
Neil Roy McFarlane was good but unfortunately not my favorite.
EDIT: I totally forgot to mention that Jane had a spine and sense! I loved it!!
December 15, 2021
I felt thoroughly snarked at by this book, so snappish!
November 4, 2020
Fabulous! Please, Ms Gibson, write another JAFF book!
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and was only disappointed that it ended. For once, Darcy and Elizabeth interact with each other in an honest way, and their intelligent banter is priceless. It's so refreshing to read a book written by a clever and intelligent author, and one who does justice to the disparate but complementary personalities of ODC. In a most satisfying twist on the original, Darcy and Elizabeth realize quite early on that they like each other, in spite of being polar opposites, and decide to explore their suspicions that they just might be a good match.
The road to resolution is fraught with uncertainty, and the usual concerns about societal status, but it's marvelous the way they meet the challenge head on, sometimes almost resorting to a shouting match to overcome an issue of vulnerability. This is a wonderful Darcy, who quickly learns how to reach a woman with Elizabeth's hang-ups. Elizabeth, too, is wonderful, and much more temperate and open to Darcy's clever corrections. She, too, comes to realize the power she possesses to affect Darcy for the better, but never loses her awe of his superior standing in society.
The story begins with the infamous insult at the assembly, and the fun starts right there and seldom let's up. The change in their initial encounter profoundly affects almost everything. The impacts of the usual villains, Wickham, Caroline Bingley, Lady Catherine, are all diluted because of the strange bond that Elizabeth and Darcy have at the very start. Communication is the key, and unlike the usual beating around the bush because of propriety, they both insist on an open dialogue when the world gets in the way. It's so satisfying!
Many of the characters take a different trajectory than the original P&P, and it's perfectly fine. Mary Bennett has a more prominent presence, as does Georgiana Darcy, and they're both lovely. Colonel Fitzwilliam seems less manic, more introspective, and just a great guy. Jane Bennett is more decisive and sure about what she wants. In general, some of the characters are less exaggerated than in the original P&P, and it's a welcome change.
I really hope to hear more from this author in the near future. The book is well written and well edited. The humor is sublime. I recommend it highly.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and was only disappointed that it ended. For once, Darcy and Elizabeth interact with each other in an honest way, and their intelligent banter is priceless. It's so refreshing to read a book written by a clever and intelligent author, and one who does justice to the disparate but complementary personalities of ODC. In a most satisfying twist on the original, Darcy and Elizabeth realize quite early on that they like each other, in spite of being polar opposites, and decide to explore their suspicions that they just might be a good match.
The road to resolution is fraught with uncertainty, and the usual concerns about societal status, but it's marvelous the way they meet the challenge head on, sometimes almost resorting to a shouting match to overcome an issue of vulnerability. This is a wonderful Darcy, who quickly learns how to reach a woman with Elizabeth's hang-ups. Elizabeth, too, is wonderful, and much more temperate and open to Darcy's clever corrections. She, too, comes to realize the power she possesses to affect Darcy for the better, but never loses her awe of his superior standing in society.
The story begins with the infamous insult at the assembly, and the fun starts right there and seldom let's up. The change in their initial encounter profoundly affects almost everything. The impacts of the usual villains, Wickham, Caroline Bingley, Lady Catherine, are all diluted because of the strange bond that Elizabeth and Darcy have at the very start. Communication is the key, and unlike the usual beating around the bush because of propriety, they both insist on an open dialogue when the world gets in the way. It's so satisfying!
Many of the characters take a different trajectory than the original P&P, and it's perfectly fine. Mary Bennett has a more prominent presence, as does Georgiana Darcy, and they're both lovely. Colonel Fitzwilliam seems less manic, more introspective, and just a great guy. Jane Bennett is more decisive and sure about what she wants. In general, some of the characters are less exaggerated than in the original P&P, and it's a welcome change.
I really hope to hear more from this author in the near future. The book is well written and well edited. The humor is sublime. I recommend it highly.
November 22, 2020
An instant classic! Fabulous!
I would give this delightful book ten stars, if I could. Beautifully written, witty and hilarious, romantic and simply “unputdownable”. I want to read it again and again. A real breath of fresh air in the genre, finding the beauty in the simple story of our favorite couple falling in love. Darcy and Elizabeth are at their very best here, with some of the most wonderful dialogue and delicious sparring I have read in hundreds of variations. If fantastical plots, angst and wild characters are your preference, you won’t find them here. However, if you want to lose yourself for a few hours in lovely romance and laughter as Darcy and Elizabeth find their way to happily ever after, look no further than this gem of a story. I eagerly await the author’s next.
I would give this delightful book ten stars, if I could. Beautifully written, witty and hilarious, romantic and simply “unputdownable”. I want to read it again and again. A real breath of fresh air in the genre, finding the beauty in the simple story of our favorite couple falling in love. Darcy and Elizabeth are at their very best here, with some of the most wonderful dialogue and delicious sparring I have read in hundreds of variations. If fantastical plots, angst and wild characters are your preference, you won’t find them here. However, if you want to lose yourself for a few hours in lovely romance and laughter as Darcy and Elizabeth find their way to happily ever after, look no further than this gem of a story. I eagerly await the author’s next.
December 3, 2020
Absolutely excellent!
This comes so close to being the most perfect book I have ever read. And it's about Elizabeth and Darcy, which only adds to its excellence.
The banter between Elizabeth and Darcy was very entertaining. As they got to know each other, their conversations were revealing and vital to moving the story along. I had to keep looking at the cover to convince myself that it was not written by Jane Austen. If you like variations, I highly recommend this book. The changes from canon were made for a specific purpose.
I sincerely hope the author received adequate recognition for her efforts, you know, awards and such. I will remember this story with great fondness.
5
This comes so close to being the most perfect book I have ever read. And it's about Elizabeth and Darcy, which only adds to its excellence.
The banter between Elizabeth and Darcy was very entertaining. As they got to know each other, their conversations were revealing and vital to moving the story along. I had to keep looking at the cover to convince myself that it was not written by Jane Austen. If you like variations, I highly recommend this book. The changes from canon were made for a specific purpose.
I sincerely hope the author received adequate recognition for her efforts, you know, awards and such. I will remember this story with great fondness.
5
December 6, 2020
If you are going to read a P&P "what if", read this one. It was excellent. One of the best I have ever read in all my years of reading JAFF. I can not say enough good things about the writing, the characterization, the tone, the wit and humour - it's all amazing. I loved how Jane's story was handled, and Mary's. Very nicely done. I said in my updates that this book as one of the best opening hooks I've ever read. I highly recommend this story!!!
October 21, 2020
I bumped this book up my reading list after resding the reveiws of it.
I have to say I was not at all dissapointed. It is well written good story fun to read couple of giggles along the way.
Read it you will not be sorry you did.
It's fabulous.
I have to say I was not at all dissapointed. It is well written good story fun to read couple of giggles along the way.
Read it you will not be sorry you did.
It's fabulous.
October 22, 2020
Tremendous Acheivement
Read all the other reviews of five stars only - I'm terribly short on time and creative writing skills at the moment - So, for a genuine visitation with the characters Jane Austen created, READ THIS BOOK. It is great.
Read all the other reviews of five stars only - I'm terribly short on time and creative writing skills at the moment - So, for a genuine visitation with the characters Jane Austen created, READ THIS BOOK. It is great.
July 16, 2021
Just a quick note to say this one goes on my favorites list both for reading and listening. I have done both and own both book and audible. Lovely, lovely story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 174 reviews