Trinity Baird’s hope for independence is tenuous, especially when her family has the final say—and the power to lock her away In her third Rainy Lake historical drama, Mary Casanova takes us back to pristine and rugged northern Minnesota. It’s 1922, women have won the right to vote, and Trinity Baird is of age. But at 21, and after nearly two years at Oak Hills Asylum, she returns to her family’s island summer home with her self-confidence in tatters and her mind seared by haunting memories. Her parents are oblivious to what they have put her through and instead watch their daughter for the least sign of defiance. Trinity struggles to be the “respectable” young woman her parents (especially her mother) demand, so that she can return to her independent life studying art and painting in Paris. She never wants to go back to Oak Hills, where they “treat” hysterical , i.e., unconventional, young women. With enough talent and ambition to be accepted into the Sorbonne, Trinity had hoped she would be well on her way as an artist by now. On the island, she returns to what sustains painting. While her love for this beautiful place is deep and abiding, the few months ahead present a near-impossible recover the strong sense of self she’s nearly lost during her time away, while holding off her powerful family’s efforts to coerce her into submission. When her parents arrive on Baird Island, her father brings along a promising young architect to help with plans to build new guest cabins. Trinity suspects her parents are trying to introduce yet another marriage prospect. Or might she have found an ally? Informed by historical figures, by the burgeoning growth of women’s rights in the early twentieth century, and the complicated issue of mental illness and how “difficult” women were silenced, Waterfall offers a compelling story of an inspired, ambitious, and soulful young woman’s fight to find her way.
Mary Casanova is an award-winning children's author of novels and picture books. Many of her books stem from her life on the Minnesota-Canadian border; yet some of her stories have taken her as far away as France, Norway, and Belize for research. Whatever the setting for her books, Casanova writes stories that matter--and stories that kids can't put down.
Her book awards include: American Library Association "Notable," Aesop Accolades by the American Folklore Society, Parents' Choice "Gold" Award, Booklist Editor Choice, and two Minnesota Book Awards. Her books frequently land on state children's choice book master lists across the country. "The greatest reward for me," Casanova states, "is when a young reader tells me she or he loves one of my books. For me, it's all about communicating writer-to-reader through a character and story."
Casanova grew up in a family of ten children in St. Paul, Minnesota. In a bustling camp-like atmosphere, Casanova found that writing became her voice. "Words are my paintbrush," she explains, "my way of exploring the world around me."
Now, with 19 books published and many more under contract and forthcoming, she divides her time between writing and traveling. Nationally and internationally, at schools and conferences, Casanova shares her love of writing and reading with children and adults.
Her newest novel, The Klipfish Code, makes use of Mary's on-site research in Norway. The story explores an important facet of Norwegian history through the experiences of Marit, a 12-year-old Norwegian girl who finds a way to fight against the 5-year Nazi occupation of Norway. Marit and her brother Lars are separated from their parents (who are working for the Resistance) and sent to live on an island with their gruff grandfather and school teacher aunt. During the course of the story, Marit's aunt is one of the Norwegian school teachers that gets sent to a concentration camp for refusing to integrate Nazi propaganda into her classroom. With potential danger waiting every turn, Marit finds a way to help the Resistance and eventually reunite her family.
Mary's series, Dog Watch (Simon and Schuster) is based on her northern Minnesota village where dogs are allowed to roam free—as long as they don't get in trouble. If they get in trouble, they earn a sticker on their page at the village clerk's office; too many stickers and a trouble-making dog must remain at home. "I never know where the next story will come from. It’s a delight when the stories come right from this corner of the world I call home." She makes her home in a 100-year old house on Rainy Lake with her husband, Charles, and their three "above average" dogs and spends free time with their horses, Jay and Midnight.
Whenever I find myself being the first to rate and review a book on GR, there is a certain responsibility or at least a desire to be kind. And so I’ll try, but don’t hold me to it… The area where Minnesota and Canada meet doesn’t initially sound like an ideal vacation land. But then again where there is a will water, there is a way and so, apparently, the tiny islands around the lake there provide a lovely place to visit during the inevitably brief summers. This book takes place in 1922 on one such island owned by the esteemed Baird family. Their youngest daughter, Trinity, a spirited young woman with artistic ambitions returns to their yearly vacation abode following an 18 months involuntary confinement in a loony bin for…well, being spirited. An absolutely intolerable thing for a well to do conservative family like Bairds. But now she’s back, as spirited as ever, possibly more so, but also more in control of it, minding the fact that she depends completely on the financial support of her family if she is to pursue her studies and dreams. And so she’ll patiently contend with her witch of a mother and her racist miser of a dad, who is actually the nice one in the family, and her recently (gasp) divorced alcoholic sister for a summer of fun and soul searching. There might even be an opportunity for romance with the young man employed by her father’s company. But most importantly, it’ll be the summer Trinity figures out her family and her future. So in a way it’s a coming of age story. Young woman follows her rebellious spirit, overcomes the constrictive binds of her family and finds the courage/finances to follow her dreams. Obstacles are overcome and triumph is arrived at, but…but…the execution of it all does leave a lot to be desired. I’ve never read or even heard of the author, it appears she has made a career of writing for children (with some exceptions, featuring this book and its two predecessors all set in the same area) and it really shows in the maturity of the writing. Which is to say that while there is nothing child oriented per se about the book, the plainness of its plotting, the quaint sentimentality and the easy morality of it all reads very much like a sort of instructive tale for young readers. And in the end it’s all wrapped up with a pretty bow and delivered on a sort of easy resolution platter you’d expect from a prime time non premium tv network show or maybe a Lifetime movie production. It’s all very…nice. So if you’re willing to trade in moral complexity and narrative excellence for nice, this is your book. Otherwise, it’s kind of frustrating. It tries to go to dark places, but Polyannas right out of them each and every time. It isn’t Trinity herself (who is meant to be brave and ambitious and intelligent), she’s just written that way. She wants to be relevant and courageous and shine the light on the appalling social injustices of her time, but the writer is determined to make her into a neat after school special. It’s all terribly well meant and sincere, but too tonally quaint for its themes, basically a heavy metal key lime pie of a book. Seemingly targeted to the ladies of a certain age who watch daytime television and occasionally swoon at Outlander. The lovers of historical fiction delivered softly, in an easily digestible and morally unambiguous manner. Turns out (from the afterword) that the author is from the area and is quite taken with it, having done a bunch of research that leads her to put out these books inspired by real people. In fact, the book features some real life characters and some thinly disguised ones. The main protagonist is inspired by a real person, it is her photo on the cover, fiction (such as it is) imitating life. Not sure what they’d think about being fictionalized thusly, but then again, it is a form of immortality after all. But in the end, in the adorably nifty, unrealistically perfectly resolved end, there isn’t much here to recommend. It’s a decent book, it’s a nice book in so many ways, but it isn’t wildly original or exciting and it kind of seems the plot was consistently at odds with the execution and, lamentably, the latter won out. The entire thing just seemed too much like a kids book written for adults. It did read quickly and had some decent dramatic family moments, so there’s that. But nice and quaint just aren't the qualities I'm after in my historical, or otherwise, fiction. Thanks Netgalley.
Another 1920’s era novel that continues on with the people in and around Rainy Lake, MN. It is a really well told story of a wealthy but “broken “ family, who start to come to terms with their independent youngest daughter, Trinity, and their struggle to control her. After an upsetting relationship disappointment ( in the last book, Frozen) her parents had her put in an institution, where she experienced horrible treatment and witnessed unspeakable situations. She is released to her family and feels like she has to “walk on eggshells”, for fear of being “put away” again. She meets a young man , an architect, Max, brought to the family home by her father for the summer as an intern of sorts. While they are fond of each other, she’s very careful that nothing romantic occurs, as she fears her parents will be furious. Then, the architect, all of a sudden leaves and she finds out that her bigoted father, has sent him away because he discovered that Max was Jewish! Trinity’s sister returns after a divorce and brings along a female companion, who it becomes clear is in a romantic relationship with her sister. The mother has become dependent on laudanum due to her instability and can’t seem to function with or without it. Suffice it to say, there are a lot of subplots and the book is good!
Frozen is my favorite book of the series, but I did enjoy this novel about Trinity and the ways society handled mental health issues in the early 1900s. Mary Casanova does a great job of giving you a feel for the history of Rainy Lake and the Minnesota Canada border along with issues of the time such as preserving wilderness, racism and class.
A waterfall is a relationship based on topography. The erosional energy of water creates a channel through which water moves by gravitational necessity. A sudden decline in topography results in a waterfall. Falling water produces energy. In addition to sightseers, a waterfall may draw entrepreneurs who understand that this power can be harnessed to propel industrial production.
Judged by the standards of her wealthy parents, Trinity Baird is a too spirited for her own good. An artist, she’s talented enough for the Sorbonne. A young woman with sexual desires, she has a long-term attraction to proto-environmentalist Victor Guttenberg. After making an overt play for him, and being roundly rejected, her emotional reaction causes her parents to commit her to the St. Peter Asylum. Set in 1922, the book examines conditions at the asylum, especially as pertaining to female inmates.
As the novel Waterfall opens, Trinity has been released from St. Peter, and will be spending the summer on a family-owned island on the northern border of Minnesota. She is, in a real sense, on probation. If she behaves herself, she returns to Paris and continued study at the Sorbonne. If she shows signs of instability, her parents have the power to have her recommitted.
Covering the span of a summer, we see a parallel between a dammed waterfall and Trinity’s present-moment life. She sees herself as trapped, being financially at the mercy of her parents (studying at the Sorbonne is not cheap). The central question of the book explores the power dynamic between Trinity and her mother, as well as Trinity’s growing sense of herself as an independent woman capable of self-determination.
Trinity’s strength is tested as she faces a fire, a storm, a boat crash, her sister’s alcoholism, her mother’s laudanum addiction, her parents’ anti-Semitism, her father’s cruelty to impoverished Natives, her attraction to a young architect, and her ongoing longing for Victor. In the process she meets author Sinclair Lewis who promises to buy a painting from her, which would finance her studies.
Mary Casanova, with 39 published books to her credit, is familiar with the landscape she evocatively portrays in Waterfall, her first adult novel. This is the third of a series of interconnected books, each of which focuses on a different main character. Trinity Baird is loosely based on Virginia Roberts the historical figure who graces the book jacket.. I would suggest that readers begin by turning to the last few pages of the book where fictional versus historical aspects are spelled out.
If you enjoy an exquisitely drawn natural setting, have an interest in the social mores of the 1920s and the issues of women then and now, pick up a copy of Waterfall. It is a compelling read and will provide an excellent springboard for book group discussion.
Mary Casanova is the author of thirty-nine books -- most of which have been written for young readers. Waterfall is her third adult novel set on Rainy Lake in northern Minnesota. Waterfall is the story of Trinity Baird who has recently returned to the family's summer home after nearly two years at Oak Hills Asylum, where she was committed for hysteria. The year is 1922, women have just gotten the vote, and Trinity is a young woman struggling to assert her independence in a society that defines respectable women within the narrow confines of marriage and motherhood. Trinity is a gifted artist and wishes to continue her studies in Paris, a privilege afforded only through her family's wealth and generosity. Walking a fine line between pleasing her family and living an authentic life, Trinity gradually grows strong enough to speak her truth.
Mary Casanova shines a dim light upon the early treatment of mental illness, the infantilization of women in the early twentieth century, and drug addiction in the privileged class. Though heavy subjects, the novel treats all these things with a light hand, so readers who prefer their historical fiction to be unburdened by the darker aspects of the early twentieth century, should still find WATERFALL appealing. The story of resilience and resistance as told through Trinity’s experience may also appeal to teen readers.
This is Lin Salisbury with Superior Reviews. Read all my reviews and listen to my author interviews on my blog at www.superiorreads.blog.
Stepping away from her children's writing, Mary Casanova has written an historical trilogy, this being the last of the three. With a restrained use of creative license, she takes us to the early part of the 1900s on the Minnesota boarder with Canada. With skill she uses her characters, based on historical figures, and the place on the edge of the massive Rainy Lake to shine a light on the life and times of the people who lived there.
She deftly included reference to prohibition, sexism, antisemitism, classism, and mental health "treatment" to build her story of self-discovery.
I loved the picture in this last novel of the way the wealthy privileged folks of the time interacted within the wilderness setting. The contrast of riches and the plain wonders of the wild northern woods was clearly structured and held my interest. In addition to this portrayal of the privileged, she brings forward key characters from the first two novels in a continuing story for those who have read all three. Her afterward explains the fact inside the fiction complete with photos of historical figures like Ernest Oberholtzer, and Upton Sinclair.
Waterfall has the potential to be a great book. It has an intriguing premise about a young woman’s isolation in an asylum, and what happens when her parents agree to her release during a summer pilgrimage to their Minnesota lake home. It is set in a lovely and richly described lake area. It has more than a few dramatic interludes that prompt an accelerated reading pace. It is nicely written. Waterfall is also populated with interesting characters, but populated is the right word. Waterfall feels crowded. Too many characters pass through the book without much connectedness to one another. Even the playful puppy in the book wanders around without much interaction between the residents and visitors to the islands. This lack of cohesion makes Waterfall read more like a collection of short stories than a complete novel. While it is never boring or tedious, it also never grabbed me or pulled me in. Like a waterfall, it sparkles and shines in places as it moves to the end, but it doesn’t leave anything behind.
Thanks to Netgalley for an advance copy in exchange for this honest review.
Waterfall by Mary Casanova takes us to the northern border of Minnesota during the 1920s. Our main character, Trinity, is spending the summer on a private island owned by her wealthy family. An artists, Trinity has recently been released from an asylum. Her parents committed her there after she had an emotional reaction to being rejected by a man. Her behavior isn't seemly... it is what they called hysterical. And that is all it took to lock women away. Now Trinity is desperate to return to the Sorbonne, but will her parents ever allow that to happen? They have all the power, and could easily have her recommitted.
Trinity feels trapped on the island. This is a book about power dynamics, family, and female independence. It is a story that exposes all the ways women have been suppressed, and how power is used to keep them compliant. Trinity must be sweet, nice and feminine, or she will lose everything, including her freedom.
Don't miss the author's note at the end.
Thank you @UMinnPress for the #gifted copy of this thought-provoking novel. I enjoyed it!
Mary Casanova tackled a topic not often discussed in her third Rainy Lake historical drama. Tiffany Baird was sent to an asylum by her parents for behavior unbefitting her station--but quite normal for a young woman with an artistic temperament testing her wings in her late adolescence. It grates on our 2021 sensibilities to read how complicated issues of mental illness and difficult women were so easily silenced. Set in 1922 as the Roaring Twenties were taking off, and women had won the vote, the author paints a scene all too real of how a promising young women could be derailed so easily.
Fortunately, Tiffany gains her self-confidence and wins allies in time to find her own way out of the morass that well could have been her un-doing.
I so thoroughly enjoyed this book! Living on a lake in Northern MN, as I do, may be part of what endeared me to the backdrop of this early 20th century work of historical fiction. I could find myself in different pieces of Trinity’s world, even if sometimes I couldn’t relate to her adventurous spirit, she made me want to break out of my comfort zone and yell, “listen to me dammit! See me!” Her affluent families “values” gave me fits, while the other cast of characters made me smile and nod in acknowledgement of the way things were in this time and place. I found myself looking up facts surrounding this area and other places mentioned in Minnesota…historical fiction, if written well will do that to you:)
If you like a fast-paced historical novel rife with issues that resonate today, you’ll enjoy Waterfall, set in northern Minnesota near the Canadian border. This plot includes racism, religious bias, mental health taboos, the power of the wealthy, environmental issues, rebelliousness of the younger generation, homosexuality, promiscuity, sibling rivalry, parental rejection, humane treatment of domestic and wild animals, artistic rejection, and adult failure to keep a potentially life-changing promise. Even with all these issues, which propel the story forward, Waterfall provides a pleasant diversion to the 1920s that will keep you turning pages.
The third book set on the northern Minnesota border. The first being Frozen and the second Ice-Out. Each deals with a different main character. This one focuses on Trinity, the youngest daughter of Major Baird, owner of an island retreat on Rainy Lake. The book deals with involuntary committal to an asylum, drug and alcohol addiction, abuse and racism in the 1920's. The book doesn't focus on the issues or provide judgment, it just lays out the facts of how life was. Quick pacing and a light touch make for a quick read, even with the difficult topics.
Well written, thoughtful historical fiction, northwoods Minnesota, a coming of age in the 1920's story. Touches on issues a young woman growing up in a wealthy family may have questioned then like women's rights,Semitism, lynching, mental illness. Turns out that the story is inspired by real people in the Boundary Waters area during the 20's, names and stories aren't necessarily accurate, not were they meant to be.
I read Frozen by Mary Casanova a few years ago and remembered enjoying it. This book pics up right where that book left off with the wealthy Baird family, summering on a remote island in Rainy Lake, northern Minnesota during the early 1920s.
I have to say, this is a pretty slow-paced book with a strong cast of rich, arrogant, and incredibly unlikable characters.This book was very well researched, the history and scenic descriptions were wonderful, but I found it pretty boring overall.
I really enjoyed this book. It was an easy read yet kept my attention. It certainly explores a lot of aspects of mental illness and is a great reminder that everyone has their "demons" they are fighting. A lot of family dynamics at play. It also highlights how far we have come from the 1920's in women's rights and mental health care.
I really liked the perspective from a woman in that timeline. How the author came full circle with the family. The family dynamics and the mother daughter relationship. The description of the northern Minnesota setting was my favorite part. Enjoyable read with a new perspective of the time and women’s history what so many endured.
I loved this! I’m not usually much of an historical fiction reader, but I enjoyed the setting (I spent summers growing up at family’s resort and Baird Island reminded me so much of that) and Trinity was such a lovely, strong, likeable character.
I love novels where I "know" the characters and Waterfall knocks it out of the park. Burgeoning women's rights, mental illness (real and perceived), hidden drug addiction, thwarted ambition and multiple other topics are touched on. Terrific writing. This book was received from Goodreads.
MN author, publisher and setting at northern Rainy Lake. I liked this gutsy, open minded & determined protagonist, ahead of her time in 1922, who challenges her family & social class expectations & biases.
A very nice, sincere story of a wealthy young woman in the 1920s. After being institutionalized for two years for “hysteria,” she is staying with her parents on their private island on Rainy Lake at the Minnesota/Canadian border. Several heavy themes are introduced but never fully explored.
Trinity and life after living in Oak Hills Asylum for two years is a compelling story of her finding herself again as she spends her summer at Braid Island. Mary Casanova has such a gift of storytelling. This is a beautiful story of reclaiming one’s self and surviving to reach one’s goals.
I loved this third book depicting life in the 1920’s in Northern Michigan. I could continue reading more like this from the author. Frozen and Ice-Out were great reads too, so glad I stumbled upon Mary Casanova!
1920s Minnesota takes place on Rainey Lake with flash back to the St. Peter Hospital in southern MN. Wealthy family from Iowa summers in MN. Interesting insight as to how women’s rights were nonexistent.
Read in two days while on a solo canoe trip! Interesting historical fiction with realistic, likable protagonist. Would read her other historical Rainy Lake fiction.
I won this as an ARC on Goodreads. It was an enjoyable read for me. Historic Fiction is my favorite! I am also a nature enthusiast, so I loved all the wildlife that the author described, along with the Minnesota/Canadian border landscape. The main character in this novel is named Trinity. This had a personal attraction for me, since my oldest granddaughter is also named Trinity. Strong and fearless just like the character. Independence and free thinking wasn’t usually considered a good trait for women in the 1920s, which is the time frame for this book.