Intriguing Irish Fantasy With Likeable Characters, A Rich World, and Troubling Disability Representation
Lexi Danu, an 18-year-old girl who is scarred and blind in one eye, has spent her life on the run from a mysterious government organization. When she finally settles down to start college, she meets two other disabled young adults--Connor, a bouncy goofball in a wheelchair who becomes her fast friend, and Killian, a quiet young man who loves nature and takes an intense interest in her. Connor, Killian, and Lexi, it turns out, share a magical secret: they are the last of the Tuatha de Danaan or Celestials, a race of superhumans out of Celtic mythology. When forces of evil invade and kidnap Connor, Lexi is spirited away to Domnaill castle in Ireland, where she learns about her magic heritage, falls in love with Killian, and becomes embroiled in a war between good and evil with the fate of humanity in the balance.
The characters here are actually quite good, with distinctive personalities, good dialogue, and high likeability, even if they do follow some of the basic YA tropes. Lexi is a feisty, bright young lady with a snarky narrative voice, and Killian is a sweetheart with a tragic backstory and a kind, protective nature. Their relationship is healthy, passionate but sweet (and with a lot more *tension* than is typical in Christian YA), and there is no love triangle (yay!). I actually ... really enjoyed the romance parts, which is a bit unusual for me. (there is a scene involving chocolate brownies that is priceless. If you know, you know). Connor, while he is onscreen, is an absolute joy, and a loyal bird-shifter and a kelpie with attitude round out the cast.
(Speaking of romance and tension...the tension is great. There is one pretty intense kissing scene that, while certainly not offending me in any way--there's much worse in secular YA, believe me--it pushed the boundaries of what is acceptable in Christian YA fantasy. Lexi wraps her legs around Killian's waist, they kiss A LOT, Lexi thinks vaguely about wanting to be closer and go further, and they make a specific remark about not going further as it's just a first date. So, self-control prevails, but it is a bit intense. Just putting it out there for the more sensitive as I've found some Christian readers are *really* sensitive about this kind of thing).
The Irish mythological element is also absolutely fascinating. I don't think I've seen Irish folklore explored in a YA fantasy before, or at least, not this thoroughly. The Celestials possess elemental powers--water for Lexi, earth for Killian, and you'll have to find out for Connor...which are beautifully done--and actually tie in nicely to the romance too. The Tuatha de Danaan myths are intriguing. Killian's past ties in with the myths, and it is mysterious and lovely. The Irish setting is gorgeous. The kelpie...that kelpie...he's great :) Honestly one of the biggest draws of this novel, for me, was the unique Irish element. I do feel the author's attempt to integrate her mythology into the Christian worldview felt a bit awkward--she could have left out references to the Creator and Eden and it would have been just fine as a clean, non-Christian fantasy. But on the whole, I am definitely curious to learn more about the world, its myth, and its magic.
So, here's what I didn't like about this novel. There are a few grammar and spelling errors. Connor needed more screentime and his character transformation at the end felt very...drastic with little explanation. I'd have liked to see Connors or Killian's POV. But those are small beans.
The big one...The disability representation. Lexi and her friends, as I mentioned, are disabled at the beginning of the novel. I signed on to ARC-read this based on a blurb about this being an Irish-inspired story with disabled characters...but as soon as Lexi reached the castle, she was magically disability-free and beautiful, so I felt a bit cheated. Apparently, the Celestials are only disabled in the human world. What? And the explanation does. not. help. Celestials are "cursed" to be like the "weakest mortals" when in the mortal realm...which apparently means disabled people are cursed and weak? Huh? Yeah, as a self-identified disabled person (Autism/Anxiety/Depression) with several physically disabled, mentally ill, and/or Autistic friends, I didn't care for that. And that explanation comes from a character who is literally a FATHER FIGURE to two of the disabled characters...like couldn't he at least have thrown in a remark about how the beings who cursed the Celestials were totally wrong in their thinking because disabled people are actually crazy strong? I'm really surprised that an editor or sensitivity reader didn't catch that. I guess this is what happens with small Christian presses...no requirement for sensitivity reads. The author herself identifies as disabled, so I'm willing to forgive this, but, I'm honestly kinda shocked. Look...I'm not trying to be some kind of super-woke warrior here. I'm not saying it's a bad book and should be cancelled. It's a pretty good book and I'd actually recommend it if it sounds like your thing. It's just a me-thing, okay? It rubbed me the wrong way, but that's only my opinion and I certainly don't expect anyone else to share it.
For me, what it comes down to is, are there better books I could be reading? And my answer is, yes, yes there are, even within the Christian/clean/indie scene. Sara Ella's Coral has some lovely mental health representation (she used a professional psychiatrist and sensitivity readers. It shows). Mary Weber also does good work with disability and racial representation. Hannah Heath, a disabled author, writes Christian adventure fantasy and ALL of her characters have disabilities, both physical and psychological, that are significant but don't define them. So...I could preorder the sequel to Tempest. And I've half a mind to do so, to be perfectly honest. There was a lot to like here. But there are authors who are just as good who do their disability representation better, and I'd honestly rather read them.
In spite of all that criticism, though, I will freely admit that I am of half a mind to go ahead and preorder the sequel. I really loved the Irish element, and that ending was quite the cliffhanger. My feelings about this book are definitely...complicated.