An Imperfect Christmas is a Christmas-themed novel by British author, Tanya Jean Russell. Just as accountant Maggie Green, on temporary leave, is heading back to Honeyford to help out with the family accounting business and attend her sister’s wedding, she receives some concerning health news. Then she loses her prestigious London job. Then her sophisticated boyfriend, Rupert drops her. As if returning to her childhood home, and the likely presence of the man who rejected her in her teens, isn’t stressful enough.
Nathan Parker is back in Honeyford for good. He’s bought the Old Barn up on Castle Hill and is converting it into a home and carpentry workshop. He wishes he’d been able to tell Maggie about his plans for their favourite place, but he will first have to repair the friendship he fractured in their teens; he wishes there could be more between them, but it seems that now Maggie is dating his London-based brother, Dean.
At Frederick and Green, Uncle Walter offers her a partnership in the business; her sister and niece desperately want her to stay close, and neighbours, and friends, everyone in the village is so welcoming; and after some misunderstandings are cleared up, Nathan vows he will be there for her, come what may.
But everybody leaves: can she trust Nathan not to leave her like last time? And is it fair to land him with her potential illness? Maybe she’d be better off in London with a high-power job and Rupert and his coffee machine…
This is very much a tale of people making assumptions, not communicating, injured pride and running away to lick wounds. Maggie is a bit too proud and precious to completely endear herself to the reader, being stubborn and unforgiving for longer than necessary; when it finally comes, the showdown with Rupert is excellent, though.
The Parker family are enjoyable, although Nathan might just be too good to be true; little Evie is a delight, and Dean and Grandma Agnes are fun. While the main protagonist is a little frustrating, this is ultimately a sweet romance.
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Sapere Books