What do you think?
Rate this book
Here, Right Matters: An American Story
Retired U.S. Army Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman, who found himself at the center of a firestorm for his decision to report the infamous phone call that led to presidential impeachment, tells his own story for the first time. HERE, RIGHT MATTERS is a stirring account of Vindman's childhood as an immigrant growing up in New York City, his career in service of his new home on the battlefield and at the White House, and the decisions leading up to, and fallout surrounding, his exposure of President Trump's abuse of power.
0900, Thursday, July 25, 2019: President Trump called Ukraine's President Zelensky, supposedly to congratulate him on his recent victory. In the months that followed, the American public would only learn what happened on that call because Alexander Vindman felt duty-bound to report it up the chain of command: that the President of the United States had extorted a foreign ally to damage a political challenger at home. Vindman's actions and subsequent testimony before congress would lead to Trump's impeachment and affirm Vindman's belief that he had done the right thing in the face of intense pressure to stay silent. But it would come at an enormous cost, straining relationships with colleagues, superiors, and even his own father, and eventually end his decorated career in the US Army, by a Trump administration intent on retribution.
Here, Right Matters is Vindman's proud, passionate, and candid account of his family, his career, and the moment of truth he faced for his nation. As an immigrant, raised by a father who fled the Soviet Union in pursuit of a better life for his children, Vindman learned about respect for truth throughout his education and military service. As this memoir makes clear, his decision to speak up about the July 25th call was never a choice: it was Vindman's duty, as a naturalized citizen and member of the armed forces. In the wake of his testimony, he would endure furious partisan attacks on his record and his loyalty. But far louder was the extraordinary chorus of support from citizens who were collectively intent on reaffirming an abiding American commitment to integrity.
In the face of a sure-fire career derailment and public excoriation, Vindman heeded the lessons from the people and institutions who instilled in him the moral compass and the courage to act decisively. Like so many other American immigrant families, the Vindmans had to learn to build a life from scratch and take big risks to achieve important goals. Here, Right Matters is about the quiet heroes who keep us safe; but, above all, it is a call to arms for those who refuse to let America betray its true self.
0900, Thursday, July 25, 2019: President Trump called Ukraine's President Zelensky, supposedly to congratulate him on his recent victory. In the months that followed, the American public would only learn what happened on that call because Alexander Vindman felt duty-bound to report it up the chain of command: that the President of the United States had extorted a foreign ally to damage a political challenger at home. Vindman's actions and subsequent testimony before congress would lead to Trump's impeachment and affirm Vindman's belief that he had done the right thing in the face of intense pressure to stay silent. But it would come at an enormous cost, straining relationships with colleagues, superiors, and even his own father, and eventually end his decorated career in the US Army, by a Trump administration intent on retribution.
Here, Right Matters is Vindman's proud, passionate, and candid account of his family, his career, and the moment of truth he faced for his nation. As an immigrant, raised by a father who fled the Soviet Union in pursuit of a better life for his children, Vindman learned about respect for truth throughout his education and military service. As this memoir makes clear, his decision to speak up about the July 25th call was never a choice: it was Vindman's duty, as a naturalized citizen and member of the armed forces. In the wake of his testimony, he would endure furious partisan attacks on his record and his loyalty. But far louder was the extraordinary chorus of support from citizens who were collectively intent on reaffirming an abiding American commitment to integrity.
In the face of a sure-fire career derailment and public excoriation, Vindman heeded the lessons from the people and institutions who instilled in him the moral compass and the courage to act decisively. Like so many other American immigrant families, the Vindmans had to learn to build a life from scratch and take big risks to achieve important goals. Here, Right Matters is about the quiet heroes who keep us safe; but, above all, it is a call to arms for those who refuse to let America betray its true self.
256 pages, Hardcover
First published August 3, 2021
461 people are currently reading
2057 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 366 reviews
September 4, 2021
This memoir is well written, concise, relevant and important. This young man honors truth, duty and integrity in the face of onerous circumstances. He is an American hero. The tragedy is he had to be a hero when dozens of other people should have stepped up before, during and after he was forced into his crucible.
The book is a reliable memorandum of events of great historical importance.
He is a strong and principled person whose hard work has earned a great education and life experiences he cherishes. I predict we will not see the end of Alexander Vindman.
The book is a reliable memorandum of events of great historical importance.
He is a strong and principled person whose hard work has earned a great education and life experiences he cherishes. I predict we will not see the end of Alexander Vindman.
October 4, 2023
A memoir of an immigrant American, distinguished career soldier, faithful servant, and respectful son.
I learned a lot of new things about world politics and the Army from a book that was anything but “stuffy” or boring…and enjoyed it! I was also reminded how important it is to be sure of one’s own moral compass.
I learned a lot of new things about world politics and the Army from a book that was anything but “stuffy” or boring…and enjoyed it! I was also reminded how important it is to be sure of one’s own moral compass.
August 3, 2021
True American Hero
I read this book in record time. I couldn’t put the book down. I hope and pray we have learned and continue to learn what a true hero looks like. Alexander Vindman is a true hero.
I read this book in record time. I couldn’t put the book down. I hope and pray we have learned and continue to learn what a true hero looks like. Alexander Vindman is a true hero.
August 16, 2021
The United States is a country of immigrants. Except for Native Americans, all Americans have ancestors who came here from elsewhere - whether it was generations ago, or more recently.
Alexander Vindman’s immigrant experience is fairly recent. Perhaps that is why he truly appreciates all the opportunities that are available to U.S. citizens - opportunities that most of us take for granted.
In this honest and heartfelt autobiography, Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman tells his family’s story. It is one of family values, respect, hard work, determination, and courage. After a period of uncertainty, Alexander enlisted in the army with a goal of making military service his career. As his career expanded, he was offered a position on the National Security Agency staff as an expert on Eastern Europe and Russia.
In this capacity, he was one of a group of staff members who listened in on a phone call in July of 2019 that then President Trump was placing to newly elected President Zelensky of Ukraine. During this phone call, the staff in the room heard a highly unusual, disturbing and inappropriate request made by the President. This incident was so concerning that Lt. Colonel Vindman felt duty bound to report it up the chain of command.
This act of courage and truthfulness would incur the wrath, vindictiveness, and retribution of the President and those who followed his dictates. The people who knew what was said in the phone call were either too cowardly or too focused on their own careers to stand up for the United States’ leadership in international diplomacy and their oath to defend the Constitution of the United States.
This is a riveting book which sheds light on the inner workings of the United States government. It is a testament to the courage of a man who chose to stand up and speak out because, as Lt. Colonel Vindman so eloquently stated, “Here, Right Matters”.
Alexander Vindman’s immigrant experience is fairly recent. Perhaps that is why he truly appreciates all the opportunities that are available to U.S. citizens - opportunities that most of us take for granted.
In this honest and heartfelt autobiography, Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman tells his family’s story. It is one of family values, respect, hard work, determination, and courage. After a period of uncertainty, Alexander enlisted in the army with a goal of making military service his career. As his career expanded, he was offered a position on the National Security Agency staff as an expert on Eastern Europe and Russia.
In this capacity, he was one of a group of staff members who listened in on a phone call in July of 2019 that then President Trump was placing to newly elected President Zelensky of Ukraine. During this phone call, the staff in the room heard a highly unusual, disturbing and inappropriate request made by the President. This incident was so concerning that Lt. Colonel Vindman felt duty bound to report it up the chain of command.
This act of courage and truthfulness would incur the wrath, vindictiveness, and retribution of the President and those who followed his dictates. The people who knew what was said in the phone call were either too cowardly or too focused on their own careers to stand up for the United States’ leadership in international diplomacy and their oath to defend the Constitution of the United States.
This is a riveting book which sheds light on the inner workings of the United States government. It is a testament to the courage of a man who chose to stand up and speak out because, as Lt. Colonel Vindman so eloquently stated, “Here, Right Matters”.
March 21, 2022
I found this to be a most fascinating memoir. The Vindman family reveals several generations fleeing wars and persecution. The family is Russian/Ukrainian Jews. The story of his grandmother, fleeing Ukraine with her children from the Nazi invasion, showed the great strength of character of the family.
I find it shameful that this dedicated Army officer ends up losing a promising career just for doing his duty. He was obviously on track to the general ranks. Unfortunately, the country lost a talented, honest and dedicated officer with knowledge and expertise in an area that is turning out to be critical to the world now and in the future. The Army should have rewarded him instead of having him resign. From all the threats and harassments, he and his family have suffered, one must question just how different are we from the Russians who cannot speak truth to power. For all he has lost, I do hope he makes lots of money from this book.
I highly recommend this book and hope that people will examine their own values and honesty while reading it. I hope that Vindman will inspire others to join in holding unethical leaders, no matter the party or country, accountable for breaking their oaths to their people.
I read this as an audiobook downloaded from Audible. The book narration by Vindman and Jacques Ray was excellent.
I find it shameful that this dedicated Army officer ends up losing a promising career just for doing his duty. He was obviously on track to the general ranks. Unfortunately, the country lost a talented, honest and dedicated officer with knowledge and expertise in an area that is turning out to be critical to the world now and in the future. The Army should have rewarded him instead of having him resign. From all the threats and harassments, he and his family have suffered, one must question just how different are we from the Russians who cannot speak truth to power. For all he has lost, I do hope he makes lots of money from this book.
I highly recommend this book and hope that people will examine their own values and honesty while reading it. I hope that Vindman will inspire others to join in holding unethical leaders, no matter the party or country, accountable for breaking their oaths to their people.
I read this as an audiobook downloaded from Audible. The book narration by Vindman and Jacques Ray was excellent.
October 7, 2023
This book shames both the liars of the previous administration and the brass of the Army, who basically deserted this man for telling the truth. The expertise lost in the previous administration was appalling. The fact that he was unable to receive the Defense Senior Service Medal, something that he was entitled to, but the WH wouldn’t sign off on it, shows what petty, duplicitous men inhabited the last administration and what a shameful job the Republicans did in enabling the past president. Yes, “here, right matters”, but that so many institutions and individuals showed no character in the persecution of this man, is shameful. We are not the country we think we are, and we have a long way to go to become decent again.
December 16, 2021
My first impression of Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman when he was thrust on to the world's stage was that he was a man of character. He truly stood out to me and I was curious to find out more about him and motivated to read his book.
He writes in a way that is relatable, engaging and compelling. I enjoyed learning about his early life and his relationships with his family, in addition to his career in the U.S. Army and role on the White House's National Security Council.
Vindman writes about how his "father's determination and optimism" shaped who he is, and that due to the example his father set for him, he "learned how to do the right thing, even if it meant standing alone, and how to accept the consequences."
I enjoyed reading about Vindman's relationship with his wife, Rachel and how "she always pushes [him] to be better." It sounds like she truly wants what is best for him and is a wonderful source of support. He states that her "grit and courage" helped to sustain him.
Another source of support is his twin brother, Eugene, who he describes as being "an exterior manifestation of my quiet inner voice."
Vindman expresses empathy and understanding of human nature. He explains that "when things don't go the way we expect, we get into a muddle of anxiety, which leads to self-deterrence. Unable to game out the risks realistically, we fear taking any action at all. We can imagine a million things going wrong, and instead of figuring things out well enough to take some well-calculated risks, we become paralyzed."
I was impressed by his deep level of investment in his work and drive to understand what he describes as, "Russian hybrid warfare," by being on the ground at the Ukraine-Russian border on a regular basis to observe firsthand what was going on, rather than remaining at his desk and relying on other sources, or academic research. Vindman "thought [his] experience on the real issues, when clearly communicated, might help turn the tide of whatever catastrophe was being unleashed."
I found many insights throughout the book, and indications of his adaptability to circumstances such as, "You can't perfectly identify the context in which you'll best thrive. Indeed, you may find yourself in new ways if you go where you're needed."
Vindman testified against President Trump at his impeachment trial. It took courage and a sense of conviction that he was standing up for what was right. Vindman writes, "In 2019, when I saw that nobody else was stepping up, and it was time for me to take a stand about President Trump's wrongdoing, I felt a responsibility to those people we'd lost."
However, President Trump was acquitted by the Republican majority, and Vindman writes, "As expected, within forty-eight hours of his not-guilty verdict, President Trump fired both me and Eug." His career in government foreign policy was over and in time, he would discover that his career with the U.S. Army would be side-lined also, as a result of his testimony and subsequent conspicuous public profile. He writes, "The last place they wanted me now was in the U.S. policy for the critical danger zone of Russia, Ukraine, and eastern Europe. My hard-won experience would no longer play a role at all." He chose to retire from the U.S. Army, a decision fully supported by Rachel.
A final quote from Vindman: "I was certain, and I remain certain, that here, in the end, right matters."
He writes in a way that is relatable, engaging and compelling. I enjoyed learning about his early life and his relationships with his family, in addition to his career in the U.S. Army and role on the White House's National Security Council.
Vindman writes about how his "father's determination and optimism" shaped who he is, and that due to the example his father set for him, he "learned how to do the right thing, even if it meant standing alone, and how to accept the consequences."
I enjoyed reading about Vindman's relationship with his wife, Rachel and how "she always pushes [him] to be better." It sounds like she truly wants what is best for him and is a wonderful source of support. He states that her "grit and courage" helped to sustain him.
Another source of support is his twin brother, Eugene, who he describes as being "an exterior manifestation of my quiet inner voice."
Vindman expresses empathy and understanding of human nature. He explains that "when things don't go the way we expect, we get into a muddle of anxiety, which leads to self-deterrence. Unable to game out the risks realistically, we fear taking any action at all. We can imagine a million things going wrong, and instead of figuring things out well enough to take some well-calculated risks, we become paralyzed."
I was impressed by his deep level of investment in his work and drive to understand what he describes as, "Russian hybrid warfare," by being on the ground at the Ukraine-Russian border on a regular basis to observe firsthand what was going on, rather than remaining at his desk and relying on other sources, or academic research. Vindman "thought [his] experience on the real issues, when clearly communicated, might help turn the tide of whatever catastrophe was being unleashed."
I found many insights throughout the book, and indications of his adaptability to circumstances such as, "You can't perfectly identify the context in which you'll best thrive. Indeed, you may find yourself in new ways if you go where you're needed."
Vindman testified against President Trump at his impeachment trial. It took courage and a sense of conviction that he was standing up for what was right. Vindman writes, "In 2019, when I saw that nobody else was stepping up, and it was time for me to take a stand about President Trump's wrongdoing, I felt a responsibility to those people we'd lost."
However, President Trump was acquitted by the Republican majority, and Vindman writes, "As expected, within forty-eight hours of his not-guilty verdict, President Trump fired both me and Eug." His career in government foreign policy was over and in time, he would discover that his career with the U.S. Army would be side-lined also, as a result of his testimony and subsequent conspicuous public profile. He writes, "The last place they wanted me now was in the U.S. policy for the critical danger zone of Russia, Ukraine, and eastern Europe. My hard-won experience would no longer play a role at all." He chose to retire from the U.S. Army, a decision fully supported by Rachel.
A final quote from Vindman: "I was certain, and I remain certain, that here, in the end, right matters."
August 3, 2021
Starts with a bang in the midst of the phone call everyone wants to hear about. The next 6 chapters take a BIG step backwards…
Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman has a factual writing style. It’s easy to read, free from pretentiousness and kind of refreshing in a sea of self aggrandizing publications of late. He doesn’t try to be anything other than who he is - a soldier serving his country and upholding his sworn duty, whatever the cost. There isn’t any humor, lightheartedness or sarcasm; just facts and duty, as he sees it. That’s the character of the first part while he’s telling family history from Russia and Ukraine, his childhood, schooling, early military, marriage and foray into national service via the army eventually being assigned to the National Security Counsel.
Once Vindman reports the infamous phone call between Trump and Zelensky and begins the process of navigating his way thru the political labyrinth of D. C., there’s another voice being heard. Snippets of sound bites and snarky passages are nothing like what is written early on. There’s not a lot of it, but enough to be annoying.
Vindman speaks candidly about the whistleblower; no spoilers here, read the book. His life and those of his family members have been forever altered because of this experience. He’s gone back to school, sought new employment and found a passion for inspirational writing, which is how he closes the book. The Lt. Col. shares 6 lessons/guidelines he learned thru the experience. You can read them in the Epilogue but some you’ll have heard already.
If nothing else, Vindman is changed and he’s telling everyone about it📚
Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman has a factual writing style. It’s easy to read, free from pretentiousness and kind of refreshing in a sea of self aggrandizing publications of late. He doesn’t try to be anything other than who he is - a soldier serving his country and upholding his sworn duty, whatever the cost. There isn’t any humor, lightheartedness or sarcasm; just facts and duty, as he sees it. That’s the character of the first part while he’s telling family history from Russia and Ukraine, his childhood, schooling, early military, marriage and foray into national service via the army eventually being assigned to the National Security Counsel.
Once Vindman reports the infamous phone call between Trump and Zelensky and begins the process of navigating his way thru the political labyrinth of D. C., there’s another voice being heard. Snippets of sound bites and snarky passages are nothing like what is written early on. There’s not a lot of it, but enough to be annoying.
Vindman speaks candidly about the whistleblower; no spoilers here, read the book. His life and those of his family members have been forever altered because of this experience. He’s gone back to school, sought new employment and found a passion for inspirational writing, which is how he closes the book. The Lt. Col. shares 6 lessons/guidelines he learned thru the experience. You can read them in the Epilogue but some you’ll have heard already.
If nothing else, Vindman is changed and he’s telling everyone about it📚
August 10, 2021
This man is an American hero. Sometimes doing the right thing gets you punished. He stayed true to his oath to defend our country, and should have been rewarded. Eye-opening story. Couldn't put it down!
I love the double entendre of the title! If you read this book and still support the party of Donald Trump, you are not "right".
I love the double entendre of the title! If you read this book and still support the party of Donald Trump, you are not "right".
March 12, 2022
2.7⭐ * Updated- corrects spelling, punctuation, grammar*
Another memoir for the "Trumped" shelf. Alexander Vinman is the American military officer and security official who testified against Donald Trump at his first impeachment hearing. Vindman was listening in on Trump's "perfect call" to Ukraine's President Zelensky back in 2019, when he quickly realized something wasn't kosher. This is where the book begins, with it's detailed description of the White House situation room (the small one) where Vindman was monitoring the call. He pauses at that point and detours to his childhood, growing up as an immigrant kid in Brooklyn, his education and his military career, before getting back to Trump and the main event.
Like most memoirs it's calculated to show the picture it's author wants the public to see. Still, it seemed to me that Vindman does open himself up a bit sometimes, as when he described his argument with his father over testifying at the impeachment hearings. The older Vindman, a product of the Soviet system, is convinced nothing good will come of criticizing the boss. This of course led to Vindman's famous public reassurance at the hearings that nothing would happen to him because, "Here, right matters."
Things did happen to him of course and he spends some time complaining about that. I was unaware of his bitterness with the army, which he feels didn't properly defend him against Trump's vindictiveness and which put his upward career path on hold. He also settles the score with his enemies within the national security system. He makes no mention however of his lawsuit against the Trump officials he feels damaged his career. Again, the picture painted is selective in its details.
Speaking of details the book seemed to be lacking any new detail concerning his testimony in particular and in general on Trump's attitudes towards Russia and Ukraine. I can only assume Vindman was constrained by security agreements. Reading this as I was during the horrific Russian invasion of Ukraine, I was hoping for some deep insights into the background of the conflict but there wasn't a lot; again, I assume for security considerations. There was one observation that did stick out; Vindman was critical of the U.S.'s tendency to "self deter" in the face of Russian aggression in eastern Europe. He feels that will one day lead to potential dangerous escalation, as the Russians reach the redline the Americans will not tolerate being crossed. I have to think we may be witnessing that right now.
This isn't a bad book, though I found the style somewhat dry. I will admit I was disappointed at the lack of new insight and at Vindman's focus on self justification (although to be honest, what should one expect given how he was vilified by Trump's supporters, to the point of being called a traitor on Fox News). Recommended for people obsessed with Trump's malign influence on the United States 《 raises hand 》. -30-
Another memoir for the "Trumped" shelf. Alexander Vinman is the American military officer and security official who testified against Donald Trump at his first impeachment hearing. Vindman was listening in on Trump's "perfect call" to Ukraine's President Zelensky back in 2019, when he quickly realized something wasn't kosher. This is where the book begins, with it's detailed description of the White House situation room (the small one) where Vindman was monitoring the call. He pauses at that point and detours to his childhood, growing up as an immigrant kid in Brooklyn, his education and his military career, before getting back to Trump and the main event.
Like most memoirs it's calculated to show the picture it's author wants the public to see. Still, it seemed to me that Vindman does open himself up a bit sometimes, as when he described his argument with his father over testifying at the impeachment hearings. The older Vindman, a product of the Soviet system, is convinced nothing good will come of criticizing the boss. This of course led to Vindman's famous public reassurance at the hearings that nothing would happen to him because, "Here, right matters."
Things did happen to him of course and he spends some time complaining about that. I was unaware of his bitterness with the army, which he feels didn't properly defend him against Trump's vindictiveness and which put his upward career path on hold. He also settles the score with his enemies within the national security system. He makes no mention however of his lawsuit against the Trump officials he feels damaged his career. Again, the picture painted is selective in its details.
Speaking of details the book seemed to be lacking any new detail concerning his testimony in particular and in general on Trump's attitudes towards Russia and Ukraine. I can only assume Vindman was constrained by security agreements. Reading this as I was during the horrific Russian invasion of Ukraine, I was hoping for some deep insights into the background of the conflict but there wasn't a lot; again, I assume for security considerations. There was one observation that did stick out; Vindman was critical of the U.S.'s tendency to "self deter" in the face of Russian aggression in eastern Europe. He feels that will one day lead to potential dangerous escalation, as the Russians reach the redline the Americans will not tolerate being crossed. I have to think we may be witnessing that right now.
This isn't a bad book, though I found the style somewhat dry. I will admit I was disappointed at the lack of new insight and at Vindman's focus on self justification (although to be honest, what should one expect given how he was vilified by Trump's supporters, to the point of being called a traitor on Fox News). Recommended for people obsessed with Trump's malign influence on the United States 《 raises hand 》. -30-
August 6, 2021
I salute you sir.
Your guidance would be well advised to all members of our Congress. Too many members don't understand service for love of our Constitution. As a fellow retired officer I extend my hand in thanks for your outstanding service.
Your guidance would be well advised to all members of our Congress. Too many members don't understand service for love of our Constitution. As a fellow retired officer I extend my hand in thanks for your outstanding service.
August 9, 2021
A heroic tale from a man who truly loves this country, as proven by his honesty, courage, and sacrifice. Recommend.
August 8, 2021
Great book! Well written, engaging, and informative, with a very interesting immigrant story. Vindman describes how the lives, dreams, and support from his ancestors and current family, along with lessons from his childhood and long military career combined to lead to a single key ethical choice in his life and in the history of the United States. He also writes about what it's like when you think your life is well planned to go one way but you get caught up in events largely beyond your control that force you to embody your values in a way few of us are challenged to do, changing your life forever. Vindman writes that he wants to be someone his daughter can be proud of. As Kipling said,
" If you can bear to hear the truth you’ve spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools,
Or watch the things you gave your life to, broken,
And stoop and build ’em up with worn-out tools....", you will have succeeded. I think Vindman's done that, both with his book and with his life.
" If you can bear to hear the truth you’ve spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools,
Or watch the things you gave your life to, broken,
And stoop and build ’em up with worn-out tools....", you will have succeeded. I think Vindman's done that, both with his book and with his life.
August 7, 2021
Lt. Col. Vindman taught all of us what it means to be Real American, one who loves his/her country, and is willing to sacrifice so much in pursuit of the truth. He represents the best this country has to offer. It just makes me sick that his superior officers didn't have the guts to stand up to Trump, push for Lt. Col. Vindman's promotion to full Colonel, and didn't have his back when it was needed. But, in the end, he emerged stronger and more empowered to go to bigger and better things, always doing what's best for America.
August 29, 2021
Brilliant.
Once read this quote somewhere: “This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave.” Lt. Col. Vindman’s story is remarkable and gives hope that there are still good and brave people with a strong moral compass who will do the right thing. Courage and honor lifts us all up.
Once read this quote somewhere: “This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave.” Lt. Col. Vindman’s story is remarkable and gives hope that there are still good and brave people with a strong moral compass who will do the right thing. Courage and honor lifts us all up.
August 13, 2021
Riveting Account of a Dark Part of American History
All Americans should read this book. Easy to understand and follow the story. Would read it again! Thank you Alexander Vindman for your sacrifice.
All Americans should read this book. Easy to understand and follow the story. Would read it again! Thank you Alexander Vindman for your sacrifice.
August 9, 2021
I couldn't put this down. What a family story! Truly the American Dream. What he faced at the end of his exemplary military career is heartbreaking. Highly recommend!
August 15, 2021
Straightforward, inspiring account of Lt. Col. Vindman's life, with particular focus on the events that brought him into the public eye. Written in plain language with no pussyfooting around, and he's blunt about what he considers his own mistakes or misreadings of situations--he's not out to glorify himself, but simply to explain what happened and why he made difficult choices. How refreshing to read a book by someone with a true moral compass, rather than a million excuses for not doing the right thing. Vindman also readily shares credit with others who helped him, particularly his remarkable wife, Rachel. Their love story adds a lot of (unexpected) charm to the book. A good book to share with teens, if you have any in your household. Vindman has a lot to offer as a role model; I particularly admire his advice for what to do when your plans for your future suddenly go up in smoke.
August 11, 2021
An insider's view of history as it was being made.
In some ways, this reminds me of Tolkien. It reiterates the theme that the course of history may be changed by the deeds of ordinary people swept up in events beyond their control, as is seen in the Lord of the Rings. Col. Vindman was the right man, in the right place, at the right time, and did the right thing. Because of him it may turn out that this nation can turn back from path of corruption, decay, and ultimately decline, upon which Donald J. Trump would lead it.
In some ways, this reminds me of Tolkien. It reiterates the theme that the course of history may be changed by the deeds of ordinary people swept up in events beyond their control, as is seen in the Lord of the Rings. Col. Vindman was the right man, in the right place, at the right time, and did the right thing. Because of him it may turn out that this nation can turn back from path of corruption, decay, and ultimately decline, upon which Donald J. Trump would lead it.
September 12, 2021
Interesting story that I really appreciated because Vindman did what was right with little regard what it meant to him and his family.
The writing I felt was a little rough. At times I found it hard to follow, but he did get into what he knew well - the expectations of the military and the politics involved in Washington.
The writing I felt was a little rough. At times I found it hard to follow, but he did get into what he knew well - the expectations of the military and the politics involved in Washington.
September 30, 2021
Star rating is probably 4.5, not quite 5 of 5.
I don't often enjoy memoirs of living celebrities, politicians or others in the public eye. I might not have read this had not my book club chosen it. I'm glad they did. Vindman comes across as intelligent, confident yet sometimes self-deprecating, and most of all, a good citizen. After a brief chapter that takes us to the heart of why we know his name - THAT phone call - he gives us a summary of his life and the lessons learned that led him to the situation in which he found himself one morning in July, 2019.
Throughout his schooling and military career, he talks of his constant learning experiences at every step of the way. I admire a person who is a constant learner, no matter what life throws at him.
This book accomplishes several things, other than the obvious detailed report on President Trump's efforts to subvert the Constitution. It gives us a classic immigrant story - the Vindmans escaped Ukraine and the Soviet Union in 1979 - and the value of immigrants to our nation. It gives us a first-person view of the army training that most of us have never and will never experience. He gives us an excellent view of what goes on in analyzing foreign security threats and how they can affect our foreign policy. And finally, we get a first-person description of what it is like to testify before Congress. That's quite a life he has led.
His family, especially his twin brother and his wife, feature prominently and were a big part of who he is, why he felt compelled to report the phone call up the chain of command, and how he survived the threats and hate mail he received.
Quite a story, indeed, and worth reading.
I don't often enjoy memoirs of living celebrities, politicians or others in the public eye. I might not have read this had not my book club chosen it. I'm glad they did. Vindman comes across as intelligent, confident yet sometimes self-deprecating, and most of all, a good citizen. After a brief chapter that takes us to the heart of why we know his name - THAT phone call - he gives us a summary of his life and the lessons learned that led him to the situation in which he found himself one morning in July, 2019.
Throughout his schooling and military career, he talks of his constant learning experiences at every step of the way. I admire a person who is a constant learner, no matter what life throws at him.
This book accomplishes several things, other than the obvious detailed report on President Trump's efforts to subvert the Constitution. It gives us a classic immigrant story - the Vindmans escaped Ukraine and the Soviet Union in 1979 - and the value of immigrants to our nation. It gives us a first-person view of the army training that most of us have never and will never experience. He gives us an excellent view of what goes on in analyzing foreign security threats and how they can affect our foreign policy. And finally, we get a first-person description of what it is like to testify before Congress. That's quite a life he has led.
His family, especially his twin brother and his wife, feature prominently and were a big part of who he is, why he felt compelled to report the phone call up the chain of command, and how he survived the threats and hate mail he received.
Quite a story, indeed, and worth reading.
August 26, 2021
Alexander Vindman was satisfied with his career in the military. He felt fortunate that at his high level assignment at the National Security Council he could make a contribution to his country.
Vindman is this memoir relates his life story in way that gives the reader a perspective about his growth and commitment to his family and country.
His moral compass is tested when he witnesses the conversation between President Trump and the President of the Ukraine.
This is book by a resilient patriot.
Vindman is this memoir relates his life story in way that gives the reader a perspective about his growth and commitment to his family and country.
His moral compass is tested when he witnesses the conversation between President Trump and the President of the Ukraine.
This is book by a resilient patriot.
August 25, 2021
I wanted to like this, In fact I didn't hate it but some of wasn't just grabbing me and it sounded on occasion braggadocious (though I honestly don't think it was his intention, but critics will pound that to discredit him). I'd say my rating is more 3.5, however I would buy the book regardless to show my support for Lt. Colonel Vindman. He made a difficult choice to do the right and it cost him his military career. I'm glad I read it, I just can't give 5 stars. However for a first book, he could have done a lot worse...I'd be interested to see him expand on some of his experiences.
August 24, 2021
A touching book which gave a personal view of the life of a family of refugees from the Soviet Union and an interesting window into his experiences climbing the professional ladder in the U.S. military. It was interesting to read about his inside involvement in Washington and how he ended up testifying before Congress. He seems to be an optimistic, good-hearted person with a constant faith in the American system.
October 2, 2021
I have so much respect for this man! He and his family coming here as immigrants and succeeding as they all did; for LTC Vindman and his brother both to rise up into the upper echelons of American government is what our country was founded on, what we have fought for. LTC Vindman’s dedication to duty, his strong, unbending moral compass is something to admire. I only wish that there were more people like him in public service today.
August 12, 2021
I am not sure what I expected from this book. Quite frankly, I bought it to support Lt. Col. Vindman because he spoke up when speaking up was hard, dangerous even. What I didn't expect was that it would be so interesting. I read it in a day and found it thought-provoking and inspiring, even.
September 3, 2021
Excellent accounting of Vindman’s life and career in the military & foreign service. Inside accounts of his experience telling the truth about Trump’s attempt to undermine our constitution by leveraging Ukraine to help with his election. Very focused, inspiring and, in the end, hopeful!
August 15, 2021
I normally do not read and review current memoirs around the latest political controversy. That is because I have likely been following the details on various media and so a book would be redundant. There is also the problem of self-justification and immediacy clouding the perspective necessary to write a good account of a complex political situation. Mark Twain was generally right about the difficulties of autobiographies.
I made an exception for Vindman’s book. He was not your typical political hack trying to score off his last job before crashing in a catastrophe. Just read his book and that is apparent. Vindman’s story is more that of someone who found himself thrust into an ethical dilemma in which the safe options were not (and went against) the ethical choices. Many if not most of us do not find ourselves in a situation where the “right” course does not align with self-interest and is downright costly. The interesting question about such situations is what would we do? Would we do what is right? …or would be play it safe and not do what is right? … or perhaps we would do something wrong when faced with the situation. Alexander Vindman faced such a situation over the Presidential phone call with the Ukrainian president and decided to do the right thing. The rest, as they say, is history.
The first half of the book is his personal story, which I knew a little bit about. He uses it to set up his choices about becoming a whistle blower and testifying before Congress. The story generally works although you have to wonder a bit how he did not see more of what was headed his way. The remainder of the story discusses the testimony and its aftermath. It reads like a personal train wreck in slow motion but it was not surprising. If anything else had happened it would have been much less believable. He puts a personal development and character story, aided by a supportive family, on this and it generally rings true.
The book is well developed and reads easily. The account is believable. Vindman’s story is not over yet and I have no doubt we will hear more from him. …at least I hope so.
“Here, Right Matters: An American Story” is well worth reading.
I made an exception for Vindman’s book. He was not your typical political hack trying to score off his last job before crashing in a catastrophe. Just read his book and that is apparent. Vindman’s story is more that of someone who found himself thrust into an ethical dilemma in which the safe options were not (and went against) the ethical choices. Many if not most of us do not find ourselves in a situation where the “right” course does not align with self-interest and is downright costly. The interesting question about such situations is what would we do? Would we do what is right? …or would be play it safe and not do what is right? … or perhaps we would do something wrong when faced with the situation. Alexander Vindman faced such a situation over the Presidential phone call with the Ukrainian president and decided to do the right thing. The rest, as they say, is history.
The first half of the book is his personal story, which I knew a little bit about. He uses it to set up his choices about becoming a whistle blower and testifying before Congress. The story generally works although you have to wonder a bit how he did not see more of what was headed his way. The remainder of the story discusses the testimony and its aftermath. It reads like a personal train wreck in slow motion but it was not surprising. If anything else had happened it would have been much less believable. He puts a personal development and character story, aided by a supportive family, on this and it generally rings true.
The book is well developed and reads easily. The account is believable. Vindman’s story is not over yet and I have no doubt we will hear more from him. …at least I hope so.
“Here, Right Matters: An American Story” is well worth reading.
August 10, 2021
I am impressed with the devotion of service and creed, the discipline and commitment which today is extraordinary when surrounded by sycophants and divisionists. Alexander Vindman is intelligent and a brave soldier who defended his country with honour and compassion in defence of our constitution, rights & privileges. Alexander Vindman stepped up when he was needed and for those who perform, under enormous pressure and personal sacrifice, and do what is right despite the consequences? They should be our societies role models and be rewarded as heroes.
You are taken through an extraordinary life and career with all his mistakes and success and doubts as well as lessons. You see the maturity over years and the development of strategy he commanded. Most interesting to me was the explanation of how strategic decisions are made and how the system of military and government work.
Much more interesting and enjoyable than expected.
Thank you for your service RET lieutenant colonel Vindman.
You are taken through an extraordinary life and career with all his mistakes and success and doubts as well as lessons. You see the maturity over years and the development of strategy he commanded. Most interesting to me was the explanation of how strategic decisions are made and how the system of military and government work.
Much more interesting and enjoyable than expected.
Thank you for your service RET lieutenant colonel Vindman.
August 15, 2021
One of the best memoirs I have read. I like so many others found myself glued to the television watching this testimony. At the time all I could think was what a hero. I was so proud to have such an upstanding young man sitting there representing our military, doing the right thing in the face of such bad behavior by the commander-in-chief and the Republicans who supported him. Knowing the type of person in the White House, anyone could foresee what would be coming his way. What I did not foresee was that the Army specifically and the entire military community in general, would not stand up and defend one of their own who had behaved so admirably. This book was riveting, explaining the day-to-day of what he went through. I enjoyed the background explaining how he became the man he is. He is such a young man, so principled, intelligent, exemplifies "Here, Right Matters." I feel he still has a lot to offer and hopefully we have not seen the last of Col. Vindman.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 366 reviews